Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Uncovering family secrets how did you deal ?

32 replies

ManorHall7 · 26/06/2023 15:42

MIL passed away at Christmas, FIL died 20 years ago. I have been helping SIL clear the house. DH hasn't been able to cope until now receiving counselling and also with pressurised job.

Today we found two adoption certificates which suggest MIL had a child adopted. SIL shell shocked and according to MIL history her and FIL were together but child has different surname. This was in early 60s so I think common practice perhaps for out of wedlock children.

I was astounded but have tried to be supportive, DH doesn't know and I haven't told him I think it needs to come from SIL. SIL is trying to obtain copy of birth certificate.

They don't have any other family to ask any questions. How on earth do you support them ??

These documents weren't hidden away so SIL thinks MIL meant them to be found. It was a sudden hospital admission and death but traumatic for them both to watch her die for a week.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ManorHall7 · 28/06/2023 12:07

user1492757084 · 27/06/2023 10:23

You could ask authorities exactly what the certificates mean.
It must be a shock but it always was .. and now you know.
It will be theraputic to understand the circumstances etc.
Your poor MIL keeping an important secret.

I think a shock for them they are handling well I have suggested getting someone to look at the documents

OP posts:
ManorHall7 · 27/06/2023 14:15

Begonne · 27/06/2023 10:18

Slowly and gently is the only advice I’d have.

Grief is a minefield and losing a parent, even as an adult is completely disorienting.

Having questions occur to you that you cannot ask, is very common. This is just one specific thing that will take that focus. And they will probably have to pick it over from different angles over a period of time. There isn’t any single way to handle it, or straightforward solution.

All you can really do is be a kind listener. And at times, you might have to cut that back a bit for your own sake.

It’s a tough situation.

Thank you. They have applied for a birth certificate and will go from there it's a bit of a minefield for them but they don't know currently the route they wish to take.

I am just letting them chat if they want to etc

I grew up in long term Foster care and my parents never wanted to know me , they both died. Very difficult for them as they cannot ask questions and i know how that feels

OP posts:
dearJayne · 27/06/2023 10:28

That's sort of how I found out I was adopted.

No one died was very poorly and in hospital and family member asked for death certificate because they thought what they had was what my gran had died of so off I went looking for them and that's how I found out I was adopted.

user1492757084 · 27/06/2023 10:23

You could ask authorities exactly what the certificates mean.
It must be a shock but it always was .. and now you know.
It will be theraputic to understand the circumstances etc.
Your poor MIL keeping an important secret.

Ladyoftheknight · 27/06/2023 10:23

I found out both my paternal grandparents were adopted, and they didn't know. Both were born to young parents who couldn't keep them (not married, family didn't approve it seems), then adopted by well off couples who couldn't have their own children. Weirdly their birth surnames are similar, and both birth mothers have the same name! Won't say as outing but surnames are as similar as White and Wright. Both adoptive parents didn't tell them, they died without knowing.

It was a lot for me to process as I was only doing some slight digging into our history, then had to tell my Dad and his siblings. They then found the birth parents had gone on to have more children, and they now join us at family gatherings. It was a big shock to us all and really changed a lot.

MySugarBabyLove · 27/06/2023 10:22

I would advise your DH to take some time to think about this before deciding what they want to do.

Contrary to what the likes of long lost families would have us believe, finding an adopted relative rarely has the happy ending these types of programmes wish to portray, and indeed I have read accounts even from the people who have been reunited via long lost family who have now distanced themselves due to toxic relationships and having nothing in common.

You need more than blood to be a sibling, just because they share DNA doesn’t mean they’ll click or even get on at all.

And the adopted sibling may simply not want to know, I know at least two adopted children (now adults) who have no desire to meet their biological families. Their adoptive parents are their family, and they’re happy with that.

I think often it depends on the kind of childhood and upbringing they had whether they decide to pursue things.

I don’t know whether there are sources where your DH could leave his details in case the sibling wants to make contact, but the contact absolutely should come from the sibling and not from your dh or your SIL.

Begonne · 27/06/2023 10:18

Slowly and gently is the only advice I’d have.

Grief is a minefield and losing a parent, even as an adult is completely disorienting.

Having questions occur to you that you cannot ask, is very common. This is just one specific thing that will take that focus. And they will probably have to pick it over from different angles over a period of time. There isn’t any single way to handle it, or straightforward solution.

All you can really do is be a kind listener. And at times, you might have to cut that back a bit for your own sake.

It’s a tough situation.

ladyofshertonabbas · 27/06/2023 10:11

The UK Adult adoptee movement might be able to advise where you can get support and guidance.

what would you like to do? Ancestry dna might connect you to the adopted sibling. (I’m adopted, just did it and have found my family.)

maybe it’s helpful to get some context on how hard it was for pregnant mothers at that time, they had no choice or information, some not even knowing how babies are made.

YeOldeTrout · 27/06/2023 10:06

I discovered an adopted away relative (half-uncle?) in 2019 via Ancestry.com genetic test match. I don't know why he was even on Ancestry because he resolutely did not want to know us. Comms via his step-daughter. Insisted that I should tell our shared family not to contact him (that's the whole family who didn't know he existed, and I wasn't going to upset them by telling them). His existence has been shared with a few but > 80% still don't know. I strongly advised that he make his profile unfindable on Anc.com.

He never made his profile private on Ancestry, so whole family (dozens of people) may yet find him.

People are weird. I don't regret reaching out but am sad he's so unfriendly.

TheDogthatDug · 27/06/2023 09:47

DH's friend discovered he had a half brother when their DM died, she had mentioned nothing about it when she was alive. They get along really well apparently. He (and us) still don't understand why she didn't say anything to him when alive. Families eh?

GulesMeansRed · 27/06/2023 09:47

HappiDaze · 27/06/2023 01:15

You can try Ancestry or 23andme abs if the sibling has done the same they can be traced that way

That’s very true and many people have found adopted siblings in this way.

i would though always advise to HANG FIRE and give it a good few months to sink in. Adoption counsellors can help your DH and his sister decide if they do want to try to find this full or half sibling, or not. It is probably very unlikely that the sibling themselves has done an Ancestry dna test, so then you’re into building fsmily trees and understanding Centimorgans. There are professional genealogists and enthusiastic amateurs who can help.

but don’t rush into it, I’d always advise at least 6 months to let the dust settle.

Laughingravy · 27/06/2023 09:37

When my Gran and Grandad live in Australia they'd left some paperwork with us. This was kept in the Desk - repository for all important family papers. Being nosy kids myself and my brother both had a rummage in there from time to time and both independently discovered my Gran had divorced in the thirties, married Grandad and soon had Dad. As kids we thought little of it. But when Dad eventually found the same paperwork he realised the dates were quite close. Dad being Dad got Mum to write to Gran to check. There never was any doubt really Dad is a spit for Grandad.
And it was decades later in a chance conversation that brother and I found we had both known. Neither he nor I have ever spoken to Dad about it. No real surprise, he married his partner and didn't tell us. We only found out when they had a big argument and she rang to tell me - just to spite him - three years after they married.
I would have liked to talk to Gran about the challenge of getting a divorce in the thirties - we are not a wealthy family. But she was as tight lipped as Dad about such things.

Nookable · 27/06/2023 09:35

Caramellois · 27/06/2023 08:52

You don't have to have the sibling to have done the same. If you get a familial match, you can reconstruct the family tree based on the person you did match with. It really irks me when people post about things they know nothing about.

That would only work if its the adopted person trying to do the tracing.

If you're trying to find an adopted person it would only work if the adopted sibling has had their own children who have taken a test. Everyone else that they're legally related to through adoption is not a genetic relative so wouldn't show as a match.

confusedlots · 27/06/2023 09:18

Theunamedcat · 27/06/2023 09:02

We had a different situation we all knew but he didn't he just thought we were his foster family being kind and keeping in touch so when they told him moms dying he said he was sorry and didn't intrude on "our" grief he was angry and upset when he found out but he has made peace with it (i hope) his father's family should have told him we all assumed they had! We still meet up for family get togethers

What did you all know?

Theunamedcat · 27/06/2023 09:02

We had a different situation we all knew but he didn't he just thought we were his foster family being kind and keeping in touch so when they told him moms dying he said he was sorry and didn't intrude on "our" grief he was angry and upset when he found out but he has made peace with it (i hope) his father's family should have told him we all assumed they had! We still meet up for family get togethers

VDisappointing · 27/06/2023 08:53

If your s'n'law really wants to find this child/adult she could do a sample with ancestry DNA and help trace family history. My parents stumbled across a grandchild this way - she's coming over for Christmas this year.

Caramellois · 27/06/2023 08:52

HappiDaze · 27/06/2023 01:15

You can try Ancestry or 23andme abs if the sibling has done the same they can be traced that way

You don't have to have the sibling to have done the same. If you get a familial match, you can reconstruct the family tree based on the person you did match with. It really irks me when people post about things they know nothing about.

ElsieMc · 27/06/2023 08:38

I am adopted. I did try to contact my birth mother in my thirties, but she did not want to know. I did try many years later to contact my half sister, she was shocked at first but told me she had not spoken to our mother for 30 years. She also did not want to know.

It is always up to the individual but sometimes you can set yourself up for more rejection and upset. I also have a half brother but have decided not to go there. You have to remember that after the initial shock that there is no shared history between the siblings and this does make a difference.

When I watch Long Lost Families, I do sometimes wonder how many unhappy stories they have. Just a cautionary tale for you here op.

whumpthereitis · 27/06/2023 08:22

For some people, finding this out about a parent is earthshaking, and and they can either want to find out more or leave it alone entirely. For others, it’s momentarily shocking before they accept it and move on without giving it any further consideration.

There’s no ‘right way’ to react and respond, and all the majority may act in one way, it doesn’t mean the individual in question will. Just let your DH take the lead, and don’t put any expectations on him in regards to what you think he should be feeling and/or doing.

ManorHall7 · 27/06/2023 07:42

FarmGirl78 · 27/06/2023 05:34

Totally agree. They might not know they're adopted, but would totally love siblings. They might not want to have traced their parents but knowing they went on to be happily married and together many years might be something they'd find comfort in. They might know they're adopted but respectfully be waiting to trace their birth parents until their own parents have passed on. Please don't NOT trace them based on the fact they haven't already.

This is my thought but obviously it is up to DH and SIL. There isn't much on ancestry. It comes up with a different surname for mothers maiden name

OP posts:
FarmGirl78 · 27/06/2023 05:34

ManorHall7 · 27/06/2023 05:22

We don't know anything about whether they tried contacting and despite what you have said research suggests otherwise re contact

Totally agree. They might not know they're adopted, but would totally love siblings. They might not want to have traced their parents but knowing they went on to be happily married and together many years might be something they'd find comfort in. They might know they're adopted but respectfully be waiting to trace their birth parents until their own parents have passed on. Please don't NOT trace them based on the fact they haven't already.

ManorHall7 · 27/06/2023 05:22

starrynight21 · 27/06/2023 03:15

Digging around to try to find information would probably not be successful, adoption papers were sealed in those days. The adopted person has had 60 years to find their birth family if they wanted to , so you can assume that they don't want to know .

Personally I'd leave it to your DH and SIL , it's a big thing to come to terms with .

We don't know anything about whether they tried contacting and despite what you have said research suggests otherwise re contact

OP posts:
ManorHall7 · 27/06/2023 05:20

starrynight21 · 27/06/2023 03:15

Digging around to try to find information would probably not be successful, adoption papers were sealed in those days. The adopted person has had 60 years to find their birth family if they wanted to , so you can assume that they don't want to know .

Personally I'd leave it to your DH and SIL , it's a big thing to come to terms with .

I have left it to them. But DH hasn't been coping well since MIL passed has been better past month and was concerned this would set him back.

As i am helping sort the house etc too. They have no other family and SIL has been leaning heavily on me for support throughout as her DH is not good

OP posts:
Nicecow · 27/06/2023 03:18

Gosh how shocking. My friend was clearing out her dads things, and it turned out he had lived in another country and had a whole family before them, 4 or 5 kids I think. He had just abandoned them. I wonder why she never told anyone

starrynight21 · 27/06/2023 03:15

Digging around to try to find information would probably not be successful, adoption papers were sealed in those days. The adopted person has had 60 years to find their birth family if they wanted to , so you can assume that they don't want to know .

Personally I'd leave it to your DH and SIL , it's a big thing to come to terms with .