Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone thinks I'm being mean.

121 replies

Sheranovermytoes · 26/06/2023 14:49

We have three churches in our Parish one main church and two smaller ones. P is a lifelong wheelchair user 68 years old with no mobility. He uses a wheelchair that he can push a very short distance probably just down a corridor. Now has bad Arthritis so finds it very painful. P lives alone and has carers throughout the day and pays for this so lots of his money is spent on care ( this is relevant). P comes in an Uber to church every week to one of the smaller churches this is the church that myself and my husband attend. We assist him from his transport into place at church and then back into the taxi after. P is part of the church council ( not sure fully what it is called) and meetings were moved to the larger church as P could wheel himself over. We are not on the council but now P is struggling to wheel himself over. I wheeled him to a social event at the church about two weeks ago ( I didn't attend) as its a couple of miles from my house and came to collect P to wheel him back home however while I'm happy to help when I can I can't commit to being the default person full time work and two kids.

P is very heavy and now to large for his wheelchair. Myself and husband work full time and can't be around on demand.
The council members are older and although they have tried to wheel P over just can't do it. P misses out on an active church life and will sometimes attend luncheon club which I will push him too if and when I'm available.

There is a council meeting tonight and he has rung my house 8 times in the last hour. He says he has no money to pay any more carers, P is extremely heavy, I'm healthy and struggle the church council members can't push him and now he has got stroppy with me because I can't take him over. I'm not even on the council.

I'm going from feeling angry that I'm trying and still he is being rude to feeling sorry about how difficult it must be.
It seems like no good deed goes unpunished.
People at the bigger church had now started ringing me whenever he wants wheeling somewhere!

OP posts:
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/06/2023 11:30

So a church full of people, a council meeting full of people, and you're the only one who is kind enough to help him out?

They're taking the utter piss. I don't think you're mean to say that as much as you appreciate he needs help, it simply cannot all fall to you (if you're happy to help out at all that is). Having to drive to push him across the road is simply insane, when there's a whole group of people any one of which could literally walk over the road and push him back!

windowof · 27/06/2023 11:05

It seems to me that this is a combination of a few things.
@Sheranovermytoes you're right, his attitude will be based on frustration at himself and his situation. It is understandable though this does not mean it is your responsibility in any way. You don't deserve to be treated like that by anyone.
You say he lives just along and over from the church. So presumably there'll be other parishioners who pass his house on the way and could help, even on a rota basis.
I am Catholic so not sure how it would work in your church but, if it were one of our parishioners struggling to attend I know we would speak with Father and go from there. He would then know who to speak to in order to arrange a suitable way of accommodating everyone. Is this something you can do maybe? Presuming in your church it would be your vicar you speak with? (Apologies if wrong terminology) It's worth starting there and be clear that while you have compassion for P you cannot continue doing the drop off/pick up as it's no longer feasible.
Hope you get something sorted and for what it's worth you sound like a really caring, kind parishioner.

JenniferBarkley · 27/06/2023 10:53

You're doing so much OP.

I think you need to have a frank chat with him tbh, and explain the demands on your time. Tell him you wish you could do more to help him, but you simply can't.

DelurkingLawyer · 27/06/2023 10:44

Sheranovermytoes · 27/06/2023 10:09

@inappropriateraspberry no sorry maybe didn't explain well. He lives across the road from the main church and sort of a little up the road probably about a three minute walk at the most. I live two miles away near our church which is the village hall. We share with other organisations so can't have the meetings there anyway. The church is very accessible level access and even surface. He was able to wheel himself over but now can't due to arthritis and weight gain.
I have to drive two miles to essentially push him across the road then he wants me to come back at the end of the meeting to push him home. I certainly couldn't manage 2 miles. I'd be superwoman🦸‍♀️

This is even more bonkers than I’d previously thought. You are being expected to drive TWO MILES to wheel him up the street to a church meeting? And then drive there again to wheel him back at the end of the meeting???? Sorry but fuck that.

Another common feature of CF stories which is loud and clear here is other people “volunteering” your services so they don’t have to put themselves out. Everyone’s very good at finding someone who is younger/female/socialised to say yes. Then the enablers pat themselves on the back for their own non existent contribution, or castigate the victim for being a massive meanie if she says no.

Say no, OP, and don’t invent a back injury. Don’t provide any excuse. You’ll just get people policing you every time they see you unloading shopping from your car, or constantly asking if you are “better” yet.

CattyCone · 27/06/2023 10:42

Sheranovermytoes · 27/06/2023 10:09

@inappropriateraspberry no sorry maybe didn't explain well. He lives across the road from the main church and sort of a little up the road probably about a three minute walk at the most. I live two miles away near our church which is the village hall. We share with other organisations so can't have the meetings there anyway. The church is very accessible level access and even surface. He was able to wheel himself over but now can't due to arthritis and weight gain.
I have to drive two miles to essentially push him across the road then he wants me to come back at the end of the meeting to push him home. I certainly couldn't manage 2 miles. I'd be superwoman🦸‍♀️

Why is it you specifically being asked? That's ridiculous.

Surely some other parishioners live nearer to him. I think refer this to the church council/vicar to make enquiries. He's not your sole responsibility.

Pansypotter123 · 27/06/2023 10:37

Have you spoken to those Vicar, PCC Secretary and Church Wardens to explain your position and to let them know you can no longer sustain this support?

Superdupes · 27/06/2023 10:25

It's time to either put a complete stop to this or be clear that you can only take him from his transport into church. Also change your mobile phone number and don't give it to anyone who has hassled you.

You sound like a saint but now you are just being taken advantage of.

Dryinginthesea · 27/06/2023 10:19

They need to look at moving the meeting a back to the smaller church, not doing the meetings face to face and having a few people dial in from the other two smaller churches, getting him an Uber to the meetings or finding another alternative. You are going to hurt yourself doing this

EmpressaurusOfCats · 27/06/2023 10:13

And yet it’s reasonable for other people on the council not to want to take turns driving him? No. That definitely doesn’t work.

Sheranovermytoes · 27/06/2023 10:09

@inappropriateraspberry no sorry maybe didn't explain well. He lives across the road from the main church and sort of a little up the road probably about a three minute walk at the most. I live two miles away near our church which is the village hall. We share with other organisations so can't have the meetings there anyway. The church is very accessible level access and even surface. He was able to wheel himself over but now can't due to arthritis and weight gain.
I have to drive two miles to essentially push him across the road then he wants me to come back at the end of the meeting to push him home. I certainly couldn't manage 2 miles. I'd be superwoman🦸‍♀️

OP posts:
Sheranovermytoes · 27/06/2023 10:00

He is always in his chair when we get there and has carers in for short periods of the day. He doesn't have Internet or have any awareness of how to use it either and lives on the ground floor of his house. It's tiny but could fit people in there.
I have a VERY good awareness of his needs as I work for a different council in moving and handling. He can be hoisted with one person and chooses to sit in his wheelchair rather than a comfy chair as he can move a short distance. I can see how frustrating it must be for him.
My user name comes from an incident where his carer inadvertently push him over my toe.

OP posts:
Sheranovermytoes · 27/06/2023 09:45

He is contacting on our landline and it was he himself who told me he was hurt. It was in his stroppy moment!

OP posts:
EsmeSusanOgg · 27/06/2023 09:30

NotOnYourNellies · 27/06/2023 09:07

I'd be pissed off at whoever told me he was upset. They have no right to guilt you into anything
Speak to P and be honest, being disabled does not give anyone the right to infringe unfairly on others. I must be so hard for him but not at the expense of your family time, your health and your good will
Bat it back to the church and don't answer his calls for a while

Not surprised though. There are a lot of holier than thou people on church councils who think it is everyone else's duty to give up time they do not have to help run things... Whilst they take all the credit because they attend a semi-regular chin wag session 'on the council'..

EsmeSusanOgg · 27/06/2023 09:28

Could the big church not arrange for P to join council meetings remotely?

EllaRaines · 27/06/2023 09:24

Sorry for missing words! You get the gist! ^

EllaRaines · 27/06/2023 09:24

Usually I would just be blunt and say no but in this circumstance I can see this causing problems for you it just with him but with other church members and even the church itself.

Therefore I would invent a minor back injury that GP that prevents you from pushing a gigantic bloke around in a manual wheelchair.

No further discussion.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/06/2023 09:17

Ad hoc support is only really helpful short term, I’d want to help him gain independence

Another very important point, in that "help" isn't necessarily effective if it stops real, longer term solutions being put in place

The other caveat about approaching church members is that you don't get stuck with "Can you just do it until ...", with promises of others stepping in which don't materialise
It's very easy for them to appear "grateful" when you're falling into line, but if you stop it quickly becomes clear whether it was real gratitude or simply manipulation

inappropriateraspberry · 27/06/2023 09:16

I can't believe you're pushing a very overweight man in his 60s 2 miles in a wheelchair!

Caramellois · 27/06/2023 09:13

End this before you are the one in a wheelchair. Your primary responsibility is to your children and husband and not the ungrateful fat one in a wheelchair. I think the venue of the Council meeting might have to change - either to a more accessible venue or by teams or maybe he gives up his seat on the council. This is not your responsibility.

poppitypop1 · 27/06/2023 09:12

Yanbu. It is fine you have helped out as and when you can. Just because he has difficulties, his needs don't trump yours. Tbh I'd be thinking about stepping back entirely given his reaction/expectations/entitlement.

NotOnYourNellies · 27/06/2023 09:07

I'd be pissed off at whoever told me he was upset. They have no right to guilt you into anything
Speak to P and be honest, being disabled does not give anyone the right to infringe unfairly on others. I must be so hard for him but not at the expense of your family time, your health and your good will
Bat it back to the church and don't answer his calls for a while

Lougle · 27/06/2023 09:03

He could buy a power pack for his current wheelchair, which would aid the person pushing, or he could get an electric wheelchair that can be guided by a supporter.

He can't demand that you become his unpaid carer.

Nevermind31 · 27/06/2023 08:52

Sheranovermytoes · 26/06/2023 18:13

Sorry I forgot to add he has tried an electrical scooter but needs hoisting so can't get on for that reason.Powered wheelchair is dangerous too due to poor hand eye coordination else that would be a good plan. He is apparently personally hurt because I can't take him over. I feel so awful for him 😞

He is being manipulative. Tell him and the church council that you tried your best, and you are personally hurt that you are taken for granted and being harassed when you say No. You care for your children, and work full time, and your health is suffering - you can’t do it anymore.

i would just say No because of the manipulative nature - just don’t be available (having said that - maybe speak to a church council member and let them know that you cannot do that anymore and your physical and mental health and your family is struggling).

IvySquirrel · 27/06/2023 08:44

In our church we have a pastoral care team of volunteers plus the church administrator and minister who share information on these sort of situations, work out the best way to help and refer to safeguarding/social services etc if need be. This means the burden never falls on individuals.
You need to speak to whoever is in charge - minister/elders/church wardens/safeguarding officer/pastoral assistant- and get something more structured in place. Otherwise it will only get worse over time.

DelurkingLawyer · 27/06/2023 08:21

OP, this is no different from one of the legions of CFs who say “if you don’t give me a lift to work I have to catch 3 buses and it takes an hour” or “if you don’t give me a lift to our mutual hobby I can’t do the hobby boo hoo” or “if you don’t mind my kids every day after school I have to change my work shifts.” Exactly the same pattern of gratefulness being replaced by entitlement, and original requests that didn’t put you to much trouble turning into demands that you do things that are very inconvenient for you.

Forget the disability. It doesn’t matter whether you are being put upon and taken advantage of because the person is disabled or because they don’t have a car. This is a CF who has had a lot of help from you in facilitating their personal/social life who has gone way over the line. They all try to guilt trip you - that’s how CFs work. Say no.