Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Cardiff is essentially an English city?

84 replies

hirwaun · 26/06/2023 14:25

Despite changes over recent years to "welshify" Cardiff... to me, it essentially feels like an English city. Barely any different to Bristol over the channel.

If you look at surnames of people living there, and exclude those who have moved more recently from other parts of Wales... the vast majority of families have roots in England.

Culturally Cardiff feels very different to other bits of Wales, even those 5 miles into the valleys feel so much more Welsh.

The Cardiff accent is mainly an english accent, especially in the nicer areas and the older generation sound almost RP.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
latetothefisting · 27/06/2023 19:07

wavingtreetops · 27/06/2023 15:51

I think I know what you mean. I lived in Edinburgh for twenty years and it was, I think, the most ‘English’ part of Scotland in that there were a lot of English people living there, hear English accents a lot, most Scottish accents are not terribly strong there. Probably due to it being a university town, and a great place to live, so lots of people stay in after studying.

Cardiff is nothing like Bristol though. Bristol is way superior. Cardiff is more like a town than a city, and not a particularly large or busy town at that. It doesn’t have the volume of people, diversity, culture or activities or wealth to rival Bristol or most other major English or Scottish cities.

in terms of culture and activities, I mean, I don't think bristol has a parliament, government, opera, or any particularly big arenas/stadium? (I know one is being built).
Literally in the last few weeks Beyonce, Coldplay and Harry Styles have played arena tours in Cardiff (along with lots of smaller bands)...again don't think any of them played Bristol!
Don't think Bristol has ever hosted the 6 nations or anything similar...

in terms of diversity, Cardiff was slightly more ethnically diverse than bristol as of the last census.

Not sure how you'd categorise wealth in terms of a city?

They both have things going for them, but although smaller Cardiff is obviously going to have more going on simply because it's the capital of a country, whereas bristol is just one of many english cities.

Not to say I don't like both, Bristol has a lot more history, for example (Cardiff was pretty much a village up until the industrial revolution). The airport is much bigger/better. It also has a lot more hills!

SemperIdem · 27/06/2023 18:12

Yabu

Piggywaspushed · 27/06/2023 16:12

wavingtreetops · 27/06/2023 15:51

I think I know what you mean. I lived in Edinburgh for twenty years and it was, I think, the most ‘English’ part of Scotland in that there were a lot of English people living there, hear English accents a lot, most Scottish accents are not terribly strong there. Probably due to it being a university town, and a great place to live, so lots of people stay in after studying.

Cardiff is nothing like Bristol though. Bristol is way superior. Cardiff is more like a town than a city, and not a particularly large or busy town at that. It doesn’t have the volume of people, diversity, culture or activities or wealth to rival Bristol or most other major English or Scottish cities.

Yeah, but I don't think anyone in Scotland would disagree about Edinburgh. The whole of Wales disagrees about Cardiff!

wavingtreetops · 27/06/2023 16:10

EmmaPaella · 27/06/2023 16:01

Cardiff is friendlier though (generally).

Yes Cardiff is friendly, that's true. Even on the last train on the Valley line at night, people are absolutely rat-arsed but still really friendly! Never any bother!

EmmaPaella · 27/06/2023 16:01

wavingtreetops · 27/06/2023 15:51

I think I know what you mean. I lived in Edinburgh for twenty years and it was, I think, the most ‘English’ part of Scotland in that there were a lot of English people living there, hear English accents a lot, most Scottish accents are not terribly strong there. Probably due to it being a university town, and a great place to live, so lots of people stay in after studying.

Cardiff is nothing like Bristol though. Bristol is way superior. Cardiff is more like a town than a city, and not a particularly large or busy town at that. It doesn’t have the volume of people, diversity, culture or activities or wealth to rival Bristol or most other major English or Scottish cities.

Cardiff is friendlier though (generally).

wavingtreetops · 27/06/2023 15:51

I think I know what you mean. I lived in Edinburgh for twenty years and it was, I think, the most ‘English’ part of Scotland in that there were a lot of English people living there, hear English accents a lot, most Scottish accents are not terribly strong there. Probably due to it being a university town, and a great place to live, so lots of people stay in after studying.

Cardiff is nothing like Bristol though. Bristol is way superior. Cardiff is more like a town than a city, and not a particularly large or busy town at that. It doesn’t have the volume of people, diversity, culture or activities or wealth to rival Bristol or most other major English or Scottish cities.

CasperGutman · 27/06/2023 15:35

I'm very confused as to what your point is here.

You relate an experience of some (rude, or at least thoughtless) people making you feel that your kids somehow don't fully belong in Cardiff because you're not "Welsh enough". And from this you conclude that in fact Cardiff is not "Welsh enough" but really just an English city in Wales?

I can't see the logic, TBH.

For what it's worth, as an English parent living in Cardiff I've found it a very welcoming - and Welsh - city. But like any city it is a collage of overlapping communities. Many of the people I know in Cardiff I have met through my children's Welsh medium school, and they definitely don't have those in England!

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 27/06/2023 15:00

The valleys are more than 5 miles from Cardiff. It’s 10
miles to Pontypridd and 5 miles north is still in Cardiff county.

Cardiff is probably the only place in Wales where you can drive for 20 minutes and still be in town.

that’s because they’ve fucked it with pedestrianisation and out of sync traffic lights. Took me 35 mins to get from Park Place to the train station car park some months ago.

Abhannmor · 27/06/2023 14:50

I'm not really qualified to say , being Irish and all. But I've spent a lot of time in Wales and to me Cardiff seems a lot more Welsh than Pembrokeshire. Haverfordwest seems quite Middle England . Whereas I actually heard a good bit of Welsh spoken in Cardiff.

This charge is often levelled at Dublin by English people. Could be Bristol or Newcastle , just vastly more expensive etc. I think capitalism makes everything look a bit homogeneous . Same shops , same clothes , same beer 🍻

Topseyt123 · 27/06/2023 14:41

So you think that the capital city of Wales is English rather than Welsh??

Interesting take on it, but I doubt many will agree with you and I don't. Of course Cardiff is Welsh.

The xenophobic remarks towards your child are not on though, and I should think that few would seek to defend that.

BluebellPinkBell · 27/06/2023 14:31

Out of interest @hirwaun how could it be any more Welsh in your eyes?
Should everyone be speaking Welsh, wearing the traditional costume or what?
It’s very Welsh. There are bilingual signs everywhere, symbols of Wales such as the flag, red dragons and daffodils everywhere, Cardiff Castle, the stadium, the rugby, the Senedd. You couldn’t get more Welsh than all of that.

Hoppinggreen · 27/06/2023 14:26

It’s in Wales so it’s a Welsh city isn’t it?

LaBefana · 27/06/2023 14:21

Vettrianofan · 27/06/2023 14:16

You could also argue Edinburgh is an English city as no one originally from Edinburgh can afford property there for half of England moving there from down south - still untrue though🤷

We seriously though of selling up in Bristol (3 bed terrace) and going to Edinburgh when Scottish independence and EU membership seemed possible ('Come on up!' said Nicola). We would still do very nicely out of such a move.

Vettrianofan · 27/06/2023 14:16

You could also argue Edinburgh is an English city as no one originally from Edinburgh can afford property there for half of England moving there from down south - still untrue though🤷

Askil · 27/06/2023 14:13

LaBefana · 26/06/2023 14:45

Also people in Cardiff are generally so much more friendly than many Bristolians.

THIS! hands down. I love CardiffSmile.

Hobnobswantshernameback · 27/06/2023 13:08

Probably one of the stupidest things I've ever read on mumsnet
And the competition is stiff
Er mwyn dyn 🙄

Ffaldiri · 26/06/2023 19:55

IamaBluebird · 26/06/2023 18:32

Cardiff do not actually get battered everywhere we go, hope this helps Greenadventurine .

🤣 bendigedig!

Whippetlovely · 26/06/2023 19:51

Ive only visited once but I didn’t feel Cardiff have a particularly Welsh feeling when I went there it was like any city, very multicultural. I’ve been to rural parts of Wales and people spoke mostly Welsh but you wouldn’t expect a city to have the same feel as a rural area. I wouldn’t say it’s like Bristol though , Bristol is very much a student town kind of a chilled feel and not a lot to do there imo, Cardiff is much better.

Stickybackplasticbear · 26/06/2023 19:39

Oooft. Prepare to get ya arse handed to you. No.

DdraigGoch · 26/06/2023 19:36

I bet you wouldn't dare tell a Glaswegian that Glasgow is basically an English city because some English folk live there!

I saw an interesting graphic the other day that suggested that the Glaswegian had more genetically in common with an Englishman than a North Walian does with a South Walian.

Valour · 26/06/2023 19:36

Oh give over OP. It's a city in Wales, so it's Welsh. Just because a randomer was rude to you, it doesn't mean the city was geographically and culturally moved. That's your ego talking right there.

Cardiff, like many cities, has a wonderful melting pot culture with many languages and traditions with roots all over the world. It doesn't make it any less Welsh. You don't have to prove your lineage before you consider yourself a Welsh person.

luckylavender · 26/06/2023 19:31

hirwaun · 26/06/2023 14:25

Despite changes over recent years to "welshify" Cardiff... to me, it essentially feels like an English city. Barely any different to Bristol over the channel.

If you look at surnames of people living there, and exclude those who have moved more recently from other parts of Wales... the vast majority of families have roots in England.

Culturally Cardiff feels very different to other bits of Wales, even those 5 miles into the valleys feel so much more Welsh.

The Cardiff accent is mainly an english accent, especially in the nicer areas and the older generation sound almost RP.

Ridiculous post

NoSquirrels · 26/06/2023 19:30

I reckon you're confusing urban with English.
Yes!

NoSquirrels · 26/06/2023 19:29

I’m interested in your thought processes, OP! Someone at school with a (rudely) heightened sense of Welsh identity called your child ‘English’ as an insult, and from
this you concluded that Cardiff is basically English anyway? Rather than thinking, Welsh people are fiercely protective of being Welsh and Cardiff is the nation’s capital?

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 26/06/2023 19:22

@hirwaun I'm in Swansea, and Cardiff feels much more Welsh than Swansea does. It has the stadium, and the Senedd, and it's just feels Welshier. The accent to me is much more Welsh as well. I'm English, though I've lived in Wales for 30 odd years, since I was 7, and I feel a lot more like an outsider in Cardiff than Swansea.

I reckon you're confusing urban with English. Welsh cities are tiny in comparison to their English counterparts. Cardiff and Swansea and miniscule in comparison to London and Birmingham, and as a result even the cities in Wales are quite rural.

I'm 5 minutes drive from the city centre. I've also got a hill with horses and cows outside my back window. I'm also unlikely to pop into town without bumping into at least two people I know, because it's just not that big a city.

Cardiff is probably the only place in Wales where you can drive for 20 minutes and still be in town. It's also the only place in Wales where you can go on a night out and not bump into someone from work. That doesn't make it English, it just makes it big (comparatively)