Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to raise my child speaking German?

82 replies

BlauBlau · 26/06/2023 13:43

So my family originally came from Germany, it was one of my grandparents who came from there. My grandparent spoke the language, but after emigrating, gradually forgot how to speak German.

I did German at school to GCSE level, and got an A*. So my German is conversational, but very basic (i.e: I speak German about as well as a 2 year old).

My monolingual toddler is over a year ahead in their English, so that's going well. Should I just swap to speaking German to them 100% of the time? Any music or TV I show them is in German.

How would I find other (probably much more fluent XD) German speaking families, so my little one could have playdates with German-speaking chilldren? I worry that, if it's only me speaking German to them, they won't be interested in speaking German.

OP posts:
Muffit · 26/06/2023 17:18

You should find other german speakers.Possibly a student or aupair who can speak to your child in german.

Or just wait until your child can learn at school and get them to do a school exchange as long as they learn at school uni age, they can still learn a language pretty well.If they go to germany and immerse themselves in the language.

I wouldn't speak the bad german to them, this means they would learn your language mistakes.

EssexMan55 · 26/06/2023 17:12

helpfulperson · 26/06/2023 15:07

So how does most of Europe end up with children fluent in English by the age of 12? Do there parents speak to them in it even if it isn't their first language?

They don't?I think this is a myth - I lived in France and went to a social group where most of the people were working class. Very few of them spoke fluent English, a few more could struggle with broken English and many spoke little to none.

I also asked a German colleague how come his English was so good - he learnt it when on a placement overseas at university.

MargotBamborough · 26/06/2023 16:40

Havanananana · 26/06/2023 16:36

And even then, most of Europe is nowhere near fluent in English even by adulthood, let alone at the age of 12.

But in some countries a large percentage of the children can manage to hold a conversation in English by the age of 12, even if they are not fluent, and they are often very keen to do so. From my own experience, the Scandinavian countries, Netherlands, Austria, Germany - all places where English is taught from an early age, where English-language music, films and computer games are popular and where it is considered the norm to be able to speak English - and a requirement for many jobs in adulthood.

In some countries, yes. Not most of Europe though.

And they tend to be countries where basically nobody outside of their country speaks their language, so speaking English as a lingua franca is necessary.

Havanananana · 26/06/2023 16:36

And even then, most of Europe is nowhere near fluent in English even by adulthood, let alone at the age of 12.

But in some countries a large percentage of the children can manage to hold a conversation in English by the age of 12, even if they are not fluent, and they are often very keen to do so. From my own experience, the Scandinavian countries, Netherlands, Austria, Germany - all places where English is taught from an early age, where English-language music, films and computer games are popular and where it is considered the norm to be able to speak English - and a requirement for many jobs in adulthood.

Anoooshka · 26/06/2023 16:35

My dad is a native German speaker and used to use a few German phrases with us at home. Just little things, like 'dinner is ready', 'it's time to go', 'goodnight' etc. Not much, but when I learnt German at school I'd already got used to the sound of the language, which definitely helped.

I lived in Germany for a few years when my DS was little, and he went to a German primary school for 3 years. We then kept up his German by using an online tutor, and then he went to a private German school in the US for a few years. Now that he's a teen, he goes to German Saturday school in the US and has German friends here (teen speak!). He's also going to be taking a German course at high school next year.

It's really difficult to raise a bilingual child if you don't speak the language and it takes a lot of effort (and money) to keep up their language skills. Someone I know managed to raise French-speaking kids even though they didn't speak French and they lived in the US. They employed a French-speaking nanny, went on holiday to France every year, put their kids in after-school French language classes, etc.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 26/06/2023 16:32

I think you are approaching this in the wrong way. Take the focus off being bilingual and instead focus on exposure to the language and encouraging an interest in the language and, as your child gets older, holidays there, TV, radio etc.

My DS is 12 and has been learning French at school for 1 year. He really, really likes it. So, we have switched his radio over to a french station, he subscribes to a French magazine, he has changed his Xbox settings into French, he subscribes to French slow news (great site!) and this summer is travelling solo to France for a two week immersion camp.

He obviously isn't bilingual but that isn't the aim, it's more about encouraging the love of the language and giving him a platform to take things further when he is older if he wants to - A-level, study overseas, living and working in France etc.

FernGully43 · 26/06/2023 16:14

You could give it a shot but it will be difficult. My son is being raised bilingual (German / English), and we live in Germany. His dad is German and only speaks German to him (very involved dad but works full time) DS understands everything and occasionally speaks it but his English is far superior as he's with me all the time (he's only 3). He prefers to speak English even with his dad and speaks it to the other children despite nursery twice a week fully in German. So give it a shot - I even think introducing a language young will at least let them hear different sounds, different flow and they'll pick something up. Just don't expect them to become fluent without a native German around all the time / or not living in a German speaking country!

Bratwurst123 · 26/06/2023 16:13

DH and I are native German speakers but have lived in the UK for 20 years. We speak German to our children but find when we go to Germany that our language is "out of date". We realise when we go to Germany that the way our children speak is not like the local children. My French is also at first year university level but no way good enough to raise a bilingual child.

Your idea is lovely but in practice I'm afraid I don't think it will work as you won't have sufficient breadth of vocabulary, the right accent and intonation etc. Try to introduce an interest in German culture which will hopefully encourage them to learn the language. For example we celebrate St Nikolas Day and we do "Laternenumzug" which they find great fun.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 26/06/2023 16:12

helpfulperson · 26/06/2023 15:07

So how does most of Europe end up with children fluent in English by the age of 12? Do there parents speak to them in it even if it isn't their first language?

They don't. I went on several foreign exchanges from age 11 and not one single person was even close to being fluent in English!

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 26/06/2023 16:10

In the nicest way possible - you're not fluent in German yourself, so how on earth are you going to speak it (and teach it) to your toddler?

A toddler will very quickly want to know a lot more than you're capable of teaching them which is just going to lead to frustration and tantrums (and not just from your toddler Grin)

If you try and teach someone a language when you don't speak it properly yourself, you're just going to confuse them - and you'll potentially teach them the wrong things which is only going to cause even more confusion down the line.

I know that sounds negative but I speak from experience - my mum tried to teach me French when I was little but she was raised in a French-speaking country that wasn't France and so she didn't teach me proper French - so when I went to school and took French lessons, I was really confused by the fact that what I thought I knew was suddenly wrong and being corrected.

By all means get him a tutor or maybe a German-speaking babysitter or nanny, but I really think you'll cause more problems than you'll solve if you try and teach him yourself given that you're not even close to fluent.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 26/06/2023 16:10

We used to live in Germany when we kids and so many German neighbours had children whose English speaking was helped along enormously by singing along to and hearing popular music.

David Hasselhoff was a teacher and he didn't even know it Grin showing my age

StamppotAndGravy · 26/06/2023 16:02

helpfulperson · 26/06/2023 15:07

So how does most of Europe end up with children fluent in English by the age of 12? Do there parents speak to them in it even if it isn't their first language?

In the Netherlands they start English class at school at 6 multiple times per week and watch most YouTube in English. They learn it at the same as Dutch. Most signs are bilingual in the cities so you learn to read both at the same time. They're still not technically bilingual though and often find it hard work, but are very good in English. English ability also improves with improved socioeconomic conditions. Immigrant kids don't tend to have such good English because they're trying to learn both English and Dutch at the same time.

JaneyGee · 26/06/2023 15:52

I'm so envious of your child. I would have loved to have been taught a second language in childhood, especially something like German or Russian or Italian. Beyond a certain age it definitely gets harder.

PastTheGin · 26/06/2023 15:51

Smallinthesmoke · 26/06/2023 15:08

You will quickly find that conversations with toddlers are WAY beyond GCSE level. They will ask questions where answers require a big vocabulary (and sometimes some complex philosophical or scientific concepts too!)
I recommend lots of holidays in Germany. Enjoy!

This in spades! We lived in a French speaking country for a few years and I vividly remember my ds, aged around 4, explaining to me that I, in fact, did NOT speak French as I could not help him label a pirate ship, after a previous similar failure at naming lots of different creepy crawlies😂
I thought I was pretty fluent but would never have attempted to raise the kids in French as I lacked the everyday ease and child specific vocab.

BlauBlau · 26/06/2023 15:42

Thank you all for the advice :) , I am very new to all of this. I will find a tutor, and look out for other people locally who speak German who my little one can spend time around.

@ApplesInTheSunshine @TheSnowyOwl @Nordicrain I know my toddler is 13 months ahead in expressive language because they were formally assessed on the Mullen Scale of Early Learning by a professional. I would never have known otherwise.

OP posts:
sonjadog · 26/06/2023 15:41

As someone who is bilingual and who works professionally with multilingualism, I would have to say that it isn't possible to raise a bilingual child on a GCSE German. What you can definitely do, however, is raise your child's awareness of the language and make other languages and cultures interesting and fun. Get German children's TV in your home, go on holidays there, go to German events in your local area, order up some fun children's books. If your child is interested in languages, they are more likely to want to learn them later.

If you still want your child to be bilingual, then a German speaking nanny and enrolling them in a German speaking school would probably make them fluent, if not bilingual. Or move to Germany for some years.

RecklessBlackberries · 26/06/2023 15:33

When I was a teacher in a school with a huge number of parents who didn't speak English well, we always always always asked them to speak their native language at home rather than English.

Most of language learning is the subconscious acquisition of grammatical structure and what "feels right". And at the stage children are at (where they're still subconsciously absorbing the basic concept of adjectives, nouns, adverbs etc), hearing native level Language X will help them in other languages too.

Hearing a native level of any language is what they need, and will give them a foundation for future language learning. Only hearing an error-riddled or non-fluent version of a language is going to set them back in every language.

MargotBamborough · 26/06/2023 15:31

GrassWillBeGreener · 26/06/2023 15:24

You've had lots of good advice above, hope you can find groups to go to in order for you both to gain more language skills. I was always rather jealous of families near me who were in a position to bring their children up bilingually. (Having said that, DS has just done German A level and really threw himself into mastering it as far as he could these last 2 years. And one of his university offers could involve a year abroad which he'd seek to do in a German speaking city to improve it further).

If you're really lucky you might find that you can access bilingual schooling. I know a few families that use the Europa school in Oxfordshire which has French, German and Spanish streams.

My mum was a French teacher so she had a degree in French and had spent several years living in France. My dad wanted her to speak French to us at home but she didn't because she thought it would be unnatural.

She did help us with our homework, encouraged us to do French GCSE and A-level, sent us on French exchanges and took us on frequent holidays to France.

I ended up living in France and married to a French man, which was how I eventually became bilingual.

I think she made the right call.

I am now having to stop her from trying to speak French to my kids though!

MargotBamborough · 26/06/2023 15:25

I went to a family wedding in Poland and most of the Polish side had little to no English, but quite a few of them spoke decent Russian or German.

MargotBamborough · 26/06/2023 15:24

Hoppinggreen · 26/06/2023 15:19

They probably start learning it at school/kindergarten from 3 or 4

And even then, most of Europe is nowhere near fluent in English even by adulthood, let alone at the age of 12.

In France most people in well paid professional jobs need to have a good level of English which is why it is a compulsory subject all through school and on most if not all university courses.

The average French adult will speak more English than the average English adult speaks French, but most are far from fluent, and this is the same in most European countries.

I get the impression that most teenagers and adults are reasonably fluent in English in Scandinavia and the Netherlands, and to a lesser extent in Germany.

GrassWillBeGreener · 26/06/2023 15:24

You've had lots of good advice above, hope you can find groups to go to in order for you both to gain more language skills. I was always rather jealous of families near me who were in a position to bring their children up bilingually. (Having said that, DS has just done German A level and really threw himself into mastering it as far as he could these last 2 years. And one of his university offers could involve a year abroad which he'd seek to do in a German speaking city to improve it further).

If you're really lucky you might find that you can access bilingual schooling. I know a few families that use the Europa school in Oxfordshire which has French, German and Spanish streams.

LondonPapa · 26/06/2023 15:21

I'm raising my DD to be bilingual in English and Russian. The difference is that my DP and I are fluent, her native in Russian so it works. We use 1 parent, 1 language as well as having Russian media, family and friends. When DD is older, she will have Russian tuition too.

Now, at GCSE level in German, you're likely to be A1/A2 or threshold B1 depending on how active you have been with German to date. With this in mind, I wouldn't recommend that you try and do it the way you intend to.

I have a colleague at work who wants to ensure greater language learning in a non-native environment. The way they're doing it is to have private tuition and frequent trips to the target language country. They also have lots of materials (books, magazines, visual and audio media) available in the TL. They've had moderate success but they are literally in the TL country once a month for weekends.

In your case, you should look at private German tuition and frequent trips to Austria, Germany and Switzerland alongside native German speaker friends/playgroups (if available and only once you're at a suitable level to communicate yourself). Ensure you have plenty of easily accessible material available for your DC and work on your own German too.

Do not attempt to switch your life into 100% German. You should not confuse your DC. Stick to English.

Hoppinggreen · 26/06/2023 15:19

helpfulperson · 26/06/2023 15:07

So how does most of Europe end up with children fluent in English by the age of 12? Do there parents speak to them in it even if it isn't their first language?

They probably start learning it at school/kindergarten from 3 or 4

Maddy70 · 26/06/2023 15:18

Even if you are only GCSE level. That's a great base for a child to start.

Hoppinggreen · 26/06/2023 15:17

DHs first language is German and my 2 speak very little, just enough to say please and thank you etc and order in a restaurant. Unless you are using a language regularly at home the chances of your child speaking it well are pretty minimal .
However, they love Germany and enjoy visiting etc and are proud of their heritage (even if they get called Nazis regularly at school), they even have dual nationality.
Teach your child to love their heritage but don’t force a language on them that you don’t even speak yourself