Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to raise my child speaking German?

82 replies

BlauBlau · 26/06/2023 13:43

So my family originally came from Germany, it was one of my grandparents who came from there. My grandparent spoke the language, but after emigrating, gradually forgot how to speak German.

I did German at school to GCSE level, and got an A*. So my German is conversational, but very basic (i.e: I speak German about as well as a 2 year old).

My monolingual toddler is over a year ahead in their English, so that's going well. Should I just swap to speaking German to them 100% of the time? Any music or TV I show them is in German.

How would I find other (probably much more fluent XD) German speaking families, so my little one could have playdates with German-speaking chilldren? I worry that, if it's only me speaking German to them, they won't be interested in speaking German.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
swimminglessonadvice · 19/09/2023 19:19

I got an A* at GCSE literally think I can say where is the station please 😂

on a serious note I speak my ‘mother tongue’ but because I was brought up with a Grandparent who didn’t speak English. In addition my parents brought up my brother and spoke English and our mother tongue, his language skills are much much weaker than mine. You need one fluent speaker who only speaks that language to them and never speaks English.

onlytherain · 19/09/2023 19:15

I don't know if this is an option at all, but have you considered sending your child to a German nursery? At the German school in Richmond, for instance, there are quite a few parents who don't speak German at all or only very basic German. Only 1/3 of the children at the German school are German children from Germany. 2/3 are international (including families in which no-one is German) or dual heritage families living in the UK.

So1invictus · 27/06/2023 10:10

Most of Europe doesn't have kids aged 12 anywhere near fluency.
At 14 EU students are expected to be at a B1 (pre-intermediate) level of English, all other things being equal and factoring in individual L1 interference/national language programmes etc. By 18 they are expected to be a decent B2 (good intermediate/upper) level.

Neither of which = fluency.

Some learners find English easier due to their own language crossovers. I'd put the Dutch in top position.

@BlauBlau by all means encourage an interest in German with your child. You can certainly teach them the basics with your level which would hopefully foster an interest and willingness to continue.

As others have said, they won't ever be bilingual, but very very few people truly are.

I'm in Italy, and I'd say my daughter is almost bilingual. But it's rarely as simple as following OPOL and giving the child exposure. There will always be contexts in which one language has dominance over the other. (my daughter is now at university in the UK and initially had issues with writing essays etc, not because of "language" per se, but because of tone, register, Syntax etc)

Friends here in the sand situation as us, one Italian parent, one British, have a totally non bilingual daughter. In their case the Dad is British and works away. The child never had enough exposure to English in her early years.

But, as I said, languages are great, so absolutely nothing wrong with helping a child have an interest, especially when there's a cultural family background which will help foster what's known as the affective dimension.

Good luck!

IDontWantToBeAPie · 27/06/2023 09:59

helpfulperson · 26/06/2023 15:07

So how does most of Europe end up with children fluent in English by the age of 12? Do there parents speak to them in it even if it isn't their first language?

... they're taught English at school intensively

endofthelinefinally · 27/06/2023 09:56

I think it is great to raise your children with 2 languages. It is a real advantage in life. They find it easier to learn more languages later.
My dc were brought up with 2 languages. Now one has 3 and the other has 5.

Natsku · 27/06/2023 09:51

helpfulperson · 26/06/2023 15:07

So how does most of Europe end up with children fluent in English by the age of 12? Do there parents speak to them in it even if it isn't their first language?

By age 12 is an exaggeration even in parts of Europe that have very high English ability levels. I live in Finland where they do learn English very well and many are pretty near fluent by the time they finish school but DD is 12 and only one of her friends speaks English well enough to have a conversation with me, and that's probably because her dad is an English teacher.
But they learn from school, TV (TV is only dubbed for very small children here, unlike in some parts of Europe where TV is dubbed even for adult programmes) and the internet and books.

OP, its best for parents to speak their native language to their children but exposing your child to German in other ways like playgroups, saturday schools, cartoons and music is good, even if they don't seem to pick up anything the early exposure will help them if they try to learn the language later on in life.

youaintmymother · 26/06/2023 22:34

Mariposista

Everyone is being very negative OP. It’s a lovely idea to share your heritage with your child. Take the focus off him being bilingual and work on exposing him to German.

This. My mum is German and we speak in English, but I still have family in Germany and 'feel' German. It's a really important part of my identity and I want it to be the same for my DC.

Anyone questioning the importance of language to self should read this article published just today/yesterday:
https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20230608-what-happens-when-you-cant-speak-your-parents-native-language

My comprehension is good through hearing German throughout my childhood, but, although I studied to degree level, I don't feel fluent enough to raise my DC bilingual. I gave up trying to talk to my DC only in German because it felt completely unnatural and I didn't have the language ability to talk to them as a mum rather than a teacher.

However... it doesn't matter how much they hear - being exposed to the language will make a difference. You should try to share everything you know!

Good morning/night
What would you like to eat/drink/do?
Please/thank you
Yes/no
Colours
Objects

Simple books:
https://www.dk.com/uk/book/9780241491416-german-for-everyone-junior-5-words-a-day/

https://usborne.com/gb/books/browse-by-category/foreign-languages/german

Nursery rhymes:
https://youtube.com/@SingKinderlieder

My DC love this channel:
https://youtube.com/@kika

This website has other fab ideas:
https://www.fluentin3months.com/german-for-kids/

Lastly, as PP have mentioned. There is nothing that makes it easier to learn a language than visiting the country and conversing with real people. This will also keep your family connected to their heritage.

Good luck OP!

Randomiser13 · 26/06/2023 20:46

From what I've read for a child to learn a language fluently they need to be exposed to it for their 30% of the time (ie of all the time that they come into contact with any language I think).

I am from Germany originally and tried to raise my kids bilingually. Till my older one joined school we almost always spoke in German and she was as fluent in German as she was in english. Now we don't speak that often in German anymore and she's forgotten a lot of it. She still understands most of it but her active vocabulary is much smaller and her grammar isn't great. The younger one hears even less German and only knows a few words. So it does take quite a bit of exposure. Apparently about 30% (of the time that they are exposed to language) to learn a language. I also used to read a lot of German books to DD and I think that actually helped a lot.

I think, books more than Tv Shows or music, would help to teach your kids as they are more interactive. You can point to things to make.clear what is meant or do voices or enact stuff to help with understanding. Reading German books to.your kids would also improve your German.

Alternatively, when your DC is older you could put them in German classes or both of you could learn German together even

I do think it's doable actually. Good luck.

BlauBlau · 26/06/2023 18:45

@justrude this thread has been really helpful. My little one has been spared my awful GCSE German 😂, it'll be tuition and spending time with people we know who speak German

OP posts:
justrude · 26/06/2023 18:43

The other things here is lots of posters are talking about bilingualism, but perhaps OP wants her child to be comfortable around German as a second language, which is entirely different.

CurlewKate · 26/06/2023 18:28

You can't raise a bilingual child unless you are bilingual. And how do you know your toddler is a year ahead in English? A year ahead of what?

IneedanewTV · 26/06/2023 18:27

helpfulperson · 26/06/2023 15:07

So how does most of Europe end up with children fluent in English by the age of 12? Do there parents speak to them in it even if it isn't their first language?

Films and music is mostly in English language. Influence of the USA.

newtb · 26/06/2023 18:27

As for the pp saying about language changing, they have a point.
My uncle was nicknamed Padre in the RAF as hé never swore. One day he was muttering je m'en fous, I don't give a fuck. I told him off and he was quite indignant and fetched his CM2 dictionary out from the 1930s. I countered with my kindle dictionary in French from 2012. He was quite shocked and said he'd have to tell his cousin Liliane as they both said it all the time. Then for the whole of the rest of the day, he went around muttering je m'en fous under his breath.

InvincibleInvisibility · 26/06/2023 18:23

My DC are fully bilingual French/English. And it takes a LOT of work and commitment.

French = we live in France, DH is French, they go to French school.

English = me. I speak 95% of the time with them in English (the other % is when their friends are round/Im asking them exactly what happened in school/ discussing their homework....). They spend all school holidays at least partly with English family in England.

Films, TV and books are a mixture of languages. But I was careful to expose them to both when younger. Now we tend to go with whatever the original language of film/book is (so Indiana Jones can NOT be watched in French! ).

Having a 9 and 12 year old its important for me to
A) understand everything my DC are saying (I'm bilingual too). I have previously had to teach my parents all the French swear words my kids weren't allowed to use / I pick up when one is being mean to the other even in French

B) be able to speak naturally to my kids. I want to say things like "silly billy" and call them "darling" not call them "ma puce". I wanted (and did) to sing them "my" nursey rhymes from my childhood not foreign ones.

Lastly, you can expose your DC to languages all you like but it takes a LOT of rigor to make them use that language daily. If its not used it gets lost.

We never bothered with English language playgroups etc cos whenever we met English speaking families in France the DC were bilingual....and all played together in French regardless what adults told them to do...

newtb · 26/06/2023 18:15

Goethe Institut may have German language activities for children like alliance Française and Institut français used to.

justrude · 26/06/2023 18:14

We are a bilingual household, but we speak mostly English at home and school, activities etc is in the second language. The children are learning German at school as well.

Language is picked up socially from a young age so you singing, reading to him will be much more helpful than watching tv shows in German. Or chatting in German with others.

I would find myself some German speaking friends in your area. Improve your German, and practice, practice, practice.

Alaimo · 26/06/2023 18:14

StamppotAndGravy · 26/06/2023 16:02

In the Netherlands they start English class at school at 6 multiple times per week and watch most YouTube in English. They learn it at the same as Dutch. Most signs are bilingual in the cities so you learn to read both at the same time. They're still not technically bilingual though and often find it hard work, but are very good in English. English ability also improves with improved socioeconomic conditions. Immigrant kids don't tend to have such good English because they're trying to learn both English and Dutch at the same time.

That's very much dependent on the primary school though. It's still only a small proportion of primary schools in the Netherlands (around 20% I think) that teach English in reception/Y1. Lots of schools only teach English in the last two years of primary, which is compulsory. There are also a few studies from the Netherlands that show that kids who started learning English in Y1 don't actually master the language any better by the time they leave school than those who only had English classes in the last two years of school.

LysHastighed · 26/06/2023 18:06

My kids are growing up trilingual but we are native speakers in the languages we speak to them in. It still takes a long time.
I am bilingual in German myself but owing to ‘one person one language’ I had to choose not to speak it to the kids.
Based on that, I would have the following observations:

  • Your toddler already has a mother tongue. Don’t take that away!
  • As others have said, your German is far from being at a level to pass it on, but even if it were, would it be the language of your heart or of your authentic self? That’s the language your child needs to hear from you, with all the little features of your speech that only you have.
  • You can become an excellent model for your child of learning a language in a lesson based way. Get someone to come and teach you both. Modelling learning is also a great thing to pass on.
NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/06/2023 18:05

A lot of nationalities have schools at the weekend precisely so their children are around others of the same origin and share cultural capital when their parents may be losing their fluency (if they had it in the first place). There are definitely German Schools like that (used to be one held at one of my previous workplaces), just as there is Greek School, Polish School and Chinese School.

It's worth googling for somewhere within travelling distance.

ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 26/06/2023 17:59

Surely you must be having a laugh 😂

SchoolShenanigans · 26/06/2023 17:52

I agree with others. If you talk like a German 2 year old, you're not much use as a teacher.

GrumpyPanda · 26/06/2023 17:50

Lots of good advice by posters OP. Just to add, if you're London-based you could look to enroll DS in the local Deutsche Schule starting age 3 or so. It's a fully certified German curriculum graduating with a combination of IB and German Abitur. They'll be teaching mostly in German with some classes in English and pupils will be a mixture of expat and local families.

Not sure if there's any other schools around that do bilingual teaching. It's increasingly common in Germany, several of my nieces and nephews have/are attending the mixed German and French language programme at their local gymnasium, with some subjects taught entirely in French, but I haven't heard of this approach catching on in the UK.

SomersetBrie · 26/06/2023 17:31

I lived in Germany for a few years and my German is well beyond GCSE.
I could not even begin to teach it to a toddler.
Are you planning for them to learn nouns or speak to them in sentences?
Will you just do this when you are alone or would you do it at mixed gatherings?

Hiring a tutor and learning with your toddler might help. And lots of visits to Germany.

saoirse31 · 26/06/2023 17:23

You should go back to lessons improving your German abd send your child to German school. Absolutely. Speaking more than one language is hugely beneficial for children. Go for it!!!

Muffit · 26/06/2023 17:20

Just wanted to say I learnt german at age 30 and I am quite fluent understand nearly everything.I can write quite well as well now.So it is possible as an adult.Everyone can tell I am not a native speaker, though.I do make grammar mistakes.