Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not stop DS disturbing DH when he is wfh?

510 replies

Mintelderflower · 26/06/2023 13:07

DH wfh for three days - Monday, Wednesday and Thursday. He is supposed to be at the office Tuesdays and Fridays but often decides to switch days around last minute.

DS attends nursery for three days a week and I have changed these days to accommodate the days Dh is supposed to be in the office because DS is a bit of a nightmare and keeps wanting to play in the room DH is working from and climbing on DH lap, wanting to go out on the bikes (this is also where the bikes are kept.) When he is taken away he throws massive tantrums (he is 2) and also keeps gravitating back. It’s really tricky. Normally DS days in nursery have to be my work days but currently on maternity leave.

I think I need to say very honestly to DH that I’m not going to keep intervening. If he makes the choice not to go to the office on that day then he isn’t going to get much work done. I don’t want to be an arse about this but I sort of feel I’ve done everything I reasonably can to avoid this issue and now it’s on DH.

OP posts:
SeemsPointless · 26/06/2023 20:25

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 26/06/2023 20:13

Agreed - so much over analysing on this thread and in that ridiculously long post in particular. For now, DH needs to go into the office when DS isn't at nursery. Things will no doubt change in the future, maybe even in a few weeks but I don't think DS is at the stage of logical reasoning yet.

That's fucking rude @ChateauxNeufDePoop - and unnecessary.

My "ridiculously long post" was long because I was making suggestions that OP might want to try such as visual aids, and a visual diary. It was long because I was genuinely trying to help.

Also, I'm autistic and have ADHD myself so I struggle with being concise, and I struggle with communication. Maybe think twice about the reason some people communicate the way they do before throwing out nasty and spiteful comments.

SeemsPointless · 26/06/2023 20:23

SouthLondonMum22 · 26/06/2023 20:08

She isn't asking him to go into the office 5 days a week though. She is only asking for 2 days a week to help make things easier and after she has rearranged for DS to be in nursery for his usual 3 WFH days.

I don't think that's unreasonable at all.

Completely agree that would be easier but that's not what's happening and OP hasn't explained explicitly why the days change (unless I missed it although I did read all her comments).

But that's not really the point though. The point is that there are no boundaries in place and the child is just being allowed to bounce in. Two-year-olds want to do lots of things which aren't appropriate - and they get told no.

I find it absolutely mad that a 2 yr old's feelings are dictating whether a parent can WFH. If the parent was trying to WFH in the middle of the living room then fair enough, but it's a garden office for heaven's sake.

There might be times when flexibility is needed - especially after the OP gives birth. If DS hasn't learnt by then that Daddy can't be interrupted while he's at work, things will be even harder. It's worth putting in the effort now because you never know when you might need that flexibility - especially with a new baby about to arrive.

I think that @OhFGSwhatTFnow had a good idea though. At weekends, they can swap and DH can deal with DS with the OP being in the locked room/behind closed door having some quiet time. There's no reason they can't share the load - and actually, after the birth, it might be useful for the OP to be able to rest without DS insisting on getting what they want.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 26/06/2023 20:13

SouthLondonMum22 · 26/06/2023 20:08

She isn't asking him to go into the office 5 days a week though. She is only asking for 2 days a week to help make things easier and after she has rearranged for DS to be in nursery for his usual 3 WFH days.

I don't think that's unreasonable at all.

Agreed - so much over analysing on this thread and in that ridiculously long post in particular. For now, DH needs to go into the office when DS isn't at nursery. Things will no doubt change in the future, maybe even in a few weeks but I don't think DS is at the stage of logical reasoning yet.

SouthLondonMum22 · 26/06/2023 20:08

SeemsPointless · 26/06/2023 19:55

I don't think children should be shushed in their own home, or made to feel as if they have to be quiet. They should be able to play in their garden in exactly the same way as they would if DH was at work.

If DS can do all of that and DH isn't getting stroppy about noise - the OP suggests that he's absolutely fine about it - then I don't see why DH can't work from home. The person who is WFH should have to adapt around the people who are living there and don't have the right to insist on certain working conditions being met. But I don't think asking the child not to go into a garden office is an unreasonable request.

Literally the only thing in the way of the DH being able to WFH is a child who won't accept being told "no". Their lifestyle isn't being curtailed, they are free to go around the whole house and garden playing however they want - apart from one room.

What if someone was ill? What if one parent worked nights? The child would have to learn that sometimes the answer is no.

I know MN likes to pile onto men disproportionately - and in fairness, it's often with good reason. I'm not a man, btw, but I don't like the ways things aren't always even handed. If there was a woman on here saying that she preferred to WFH and that her DH refused to stop their child from busting into the room, posters would be queuing up to criticise the man for not being able to parent the child. There's no way posters would be agreeing that the woman had to leave the house.

Why should someone - of either sex - HAVE to go into the office just because it's impossible to teach a 2 yr old that Mummy/Daddy is at work and therefore unavailable? It's a ludicrous concept. There are lots of reasons why WFH might be preferable and in this modern day and age, it's not unreasonable to want to WFH.

Also, with another baby on the way, now seems like the ideal time to teach the toddler that sometimes you can't always get what you want right away. OP is going to need support from her DH after she gives birth, and that might mean explaining to DS that they can't go to Mummy right now.

Honestly, I'm not unsympathetic and I get that it's much easier to shoo DH off to work at the office. But having an extra pair of hands in the house as an emergency back-up could be useful when there's another small baby in the mix. I've suggested methods above that could help ease the learning period - and I've been through this myself with SEN twins so I know it's painful at first. But if both parents stick to the routine, and the aids are used every time, the child will quickly adapt.

When I took my DS to nursery for the first time he cried his eyes out. And he did on the second day, and the third. It took a while but he learnt that he could have fun while I wasn't there, and that I'd always come back for him. It's exactly the same principle.

She isn't asking him to go into the office 5 days a week though. She is only asking for 2 days a week to help make things easier and after she has rearranged for DS to be in nursery for his usual 3 WFH days.

I don't think that's unreasonable at all.

bussteward · 26/06/2023 20:06

Unless I’ve missed something OP is setting boundaries and saying “No”, and that’s causing the tantrums, and she is parenting through those, but it’s tough for all sorts of reasons, so her AIBU? is should she stop saying no so DH is impacted. Which makes all the “just say no (no!)” Zammo-style advice irrelevant.

1stTimeMummy2021 · 26/06/2023 20:06

@Mintelderflower As the saying goes, you have a DH problem. Either DH goes into the office or DS goes into nursery, it's unfair for you to keep having to deal with this issue. I have a DH who works at home and I understand how appealing that is to a toddler.

thehonscupboard · 26/06/2023 19:59

This has struck a chord with me as am in similar situation to you with a toddler/wfh situation except already have had the baby and it is a joint decision that DH stays home 4/5 days because alternative is a 3 hour round commute and I would rather have him at home for that time rather than on a train. Also he makes us both food while I traipse around pushing buggy to get both DCs to sleep so we can have a bit of adult time (staring at tv and a v. quick nap if we're lucky).

What has helped lots is that DH now does a morning 'shift' 6am-8am alone with DC1 so they have some good quality 1-1 time before he starts work. There are still multiple attempts to break into the room he's working in (sometimes successful). Before being heavily pregnant/stuck breastfeeding newborn I would attempt to police this. Now I just let DC go for it and it's DH's fault if he's not successfully barricaded the door.

I was left with a very upset toddler every time DH came into the room for a coffee (often), or went to the toilet, as he would stop for a couple of minutes of Disney Dad routine before disappearing. It really wound me up but stupidly I didn't say anything for ages, just got quietly infuriated until I snapped at DH, who now sneaks in and out, mostly unseen. So that, combined with 1-1 morning time has really helped.

I don't know if this would help with you given your layout, it sounds like sneaking in and out would be difficult. For us it was definitely the cameo appearances throughout the day that made things worse, rather than being hidden away in a room.

He also always comes for one quick cuddle when DC1 wakes up from nap, with a 'I have to go back to work now but when I'm finished we'll do X Y or Z together' then sticks to that promise, and always finishes at the same time. I think the routine helps.

KingOfThieves · 26/06/2023 19:58

I would not do that personally…. Me and my OH work from home frequently. We make it work and support each other and juggle the kids because that’s what we do

SnackSizeRaisin · 26/06/2023 19:58

ProudThrilledHappy · 26/06/2023 17:42

Your DH does need to help with this but you need to have a conversation with him explaining the problem.

The issue is your DS is seeing Daddy and not understanding why he cant spend time with him, so you need to give him a set routine of Daddy contact. For example, Dad says I am working from now until x time, here is a timer (buy a digital beeping timer) and when it beeps dad will come out and spend time with you.

If you knock on dads door before then he wont be able to see you because he will have to catch up on what he missed. Then set toddler a task to do- here is a colouring book and I would like you to colour in a page really nicely for me to see, when the timer goes off and it is our time together.

Unfortunately 2 is too young for that kind of thing. 3.5 or older it could work. 2 year olds cannot reason in that way and can't colour nicely either.

OhFGSwhatTFnow · 26/06/2023 19:56

Perhaps this weekend you could you lock yourself in the garden office with a flask of iced tea and a book and see how DH gets on with entertaining DS and stopping him interrupting you.

Might just give him some perspective.

Clearly, for now at least, he needs to stick to WFH on the days DS is in nursery. He gets to work uninterrupted, DS isn't distressed at lack of access to his dad, and you aren't being driven crazy with completely understandable toddler wobblies.

Not only that - you will need those three days a week when you're recovering from a C-section with a newborn - you can't have abject chaos going on five days a week then and if you change the routine beforehand you're less likely to have to deal with DS having a negative reaction to the new arrival as well.

SeemsPointless · 26/06/2023 19:55

NobdieTheNob · 26/06/2023 19:34

sometimes you do need to tell your child "no" and they need to learn that they can't always get what they want

I agree with this 1000%. But not in this case. A home is a home. It isn't a workplace, other than out of necessity. There is no necessity here. Home is the place where you can be yourself and do your own thing. Home is not a place where a child should be shushed and kept out. It's also not a place where the person looking after the small child should feel forced out, or forced to 'discipline' a toddler who is being a normal toddler.

Any nanny will tell you that it's a sodding nightmare to have parents around the house when they are on duty.

I don't think children should be shushed in their own home, or made to feel as if they have to be quiet. They should be able to play in their garden in exactly the same way as they would if DH was at work.

If DS can do all of that and DH isn't getting stroppy about noise - the OP suggests that he's absolutely fine about it - then I don't see why DH can't work from home. The person who is WFH should have to adapt around the people who are living there and don't have the right to insist on certain working conditions being met. But I don't think asking the child not to go into a garden office is an unreasonable request.

Literally the only thing in the way of the DH being able to WFH is a child who won't accept being told "no". Their lifestyle isn't being curtailed, they are free to go around the whole house and garden playing however they want - apart from one room.

What if someone was ill? What if one parent worked nights? The child would have to learn that sometimes the answer is no.

I know MN likes to pile onto men disproportionately - and in fairness, it's often with good reason. I'm not a man, btw, but I don't like the ways things aren't always even handed. If there was a woman on here saying that she preferred to WFH and that her DH refused to stop their child from busting into the room, posters would be queuing up to criticise the man for not being able to parent the child. There's no way posters would be agreeing that the woman had to leave the house.

Why should someone - of either sex - HAVE to go into the office just because it's impossible to teach a 2 yr old that Mummy/Daddy is at work and therefore unavailable? It's a ludicrous concept. There are lots of reasons why WFH might be preferable and in this modern day and age, it's not unreasonable to want to WFH.

Also, with another baby on the way, now seems like the ideal time to teach the toddler that sometimes you can't always get what you want right away. OP is going to need support from her DH after she gives birth, and that might mean explaining to DS that they can't go to Mummy right now.

Honestly, I'm not unsympathetic and I get that it's much easier to shoo DH off to work at the office. But having an extra pair of hands in the house as an emergency back-up could be useful when there's another small baby in the mix. I've suggested methods above that could help ease the learning period - and I've been through this myself with SEN twins so I know it's painful at first. But if both parents stick to the routine, and the aids are used every time, the child will quickly adapt.

When I took my DS to nursery for the first time he cried his eyes out. And he did on the second day, and the third. It took a while but he learnt that he could have fun while I wasn't there, and that I'd always come back for him. It's exactly the same principle.

Mintelderflower · 26/06/2023 19:55

There is no need to have DH move upstairs. All that means is DS has a tantrum because he cannot go upstairs rather than because he cannot go into the annexe.

Boundaries are important when raising children, but they also have to be reasonable boundaries. Expecting a six month old baby to walk themselves and barking ‘she needs boundaries! You can’t always carry her!’ would be absolute madness.

DS does not in understand. I don’t care if your toddler would have, or if your toddler didn’t at first and now does because you patiently explained, because your toddler is not my toddler.

And as much as boundaries are important they are not the only thing that is important. Compassion and flexibility and responding to needs also are important. It is extremely hot and muggy here at the moment. DS is old enough to sense a big change coming and not old enough to really understand it and that’s coming out in all sorts of strange ways. He’s been trotting into nursery quite happily since he was ten months but suddenly started to become hysterical when I approached. Then it stopped as soon as it started. Then he started being difficult at bath time when this was never previously an issue. Now, it’s these big BIG tantrums. All signs that his world is being disturbed.

Life has to go on. He does have to go to nursery or I can’t work. He does have to have a bath. He can’t disturb his dad at work - but where I can make adjustments I do. All I’m asking for is the same in reverse.

OP posts:
Nimblesandbimbles · 26/06/2023 19:47

The responses on here are so annoying! OP my DD was like your DS at that age. Let me tell you, all these posters ranting on about boundaries, no means no etc- they would honestly have no idea how to cope with a less compliant child. I know because I’ve seen people try their brilliant ‘parenting strategies’ on my DD. Guess what? It didn’t work. All two year olds are different!!!

GeekyThings · 26/06/2023 19:44

Mintelderflower · 26/06/2023 18:44

@MysteryBelle that’s not fair … I have. I’ve said thank you, numerous times, and agreed with you that I need to address this with Dh.

@GeekyThings so I have already explained the wifi upstairs just isn’t good enough for DH to work there and even so I’m not sure there is a discernible difference between DS having a tantrum because he can’t go in an annexe and DS having a tantrum because he can’t go upstairs.

But I am lost with your ‘why not put him in full time childcare.’ Because the whole point of me working PT is supposed to be so DS isn’t in FT childcare. I am undecided what I’ll do when my maternity leave ends but in any case, I certainly don’t think forking out for FT childcare at a point where my income is about to drastically nosedive is wise. I think it would also have a detrimental effect on DS behaviour, given that I think some of the causes for it are probably worry.

I am genuinely grateful for those who have been supportive, it is hard not to answer personal comments.

My WiFi upstairs wasn't good, but I fixed it - working from home you usually need better internet. You can usually claim some if the money back, you spouse get your husband to check what he can claim on from HMRC and his workplace.

I think the problem with the situation as described is that if you decide to not go back after taking a huge salary hit from maternity (I'm guessing that's what you're indicating from your comment?) is that you'll be entirely reliant upon your husband's wages for the family. It's your choice to make, but I would say that it means it's more important, especially heading into likely recession again as we are, that his job is prioritised, he'll have to keep it, and he'll have to try and work his way up.

Which means he'll be needing less toddler interruptions rather than more! And I truly mean that, from experience - I've seen more than one person over the last few years not get promoted because of too many distractions at home, including children; I've even seen a couple get warnings about their employment status over it! So I don't think letting a screaming child go into where he's working more just to make a point is looking at the bigger, long-term picture!

In the end, if it is on him to deal with, and if he's anything like me, then your son may end up going into daycare full-time anyway - I was not about to give up my job that kept a roof over my head to keep my kids out of daycare. Nor would I deal with less favourable T&C's in order to keep my kids out of daycare - if I went into the office more now, my employer would just take away my long-term right to work at home, so I'd be shooting myself in the foot 5 years down the line.

Also - daycare is fantastic is this country, why wouldn't I want that for my kids anyway? They better at teaching kids the basics than I am, they're trained professionals at it. My kids thrived, and I can honestly say there's no way I would have been as successful doing things like potty training or teaching them some self-control on my own. And I'm a pretty good parent! I'm just also not going to kid myself that I'm Mary Poppins 😂

AnneElliott · 26/06/2023 19:43

YANBU op. Your DH should just go I to the office when the toddler is at home. Why are people expecting a 2 year old to understand and respond when the adult bloke doesn't feel the need to change his wfh days!

Curseofthenation · 26/06/2023 19:36

My two year old is fine with my DH working from home BUT I still think YANBU. You need to give your DH a warning that you will no longer be stopping DS from entering the room and therefore it will no longer be a suitable work environment. That way you've been reasonable to give him the heads up.

Fuck his comfort and wants. You're heavily pregnant with an energetic toddler to grapple with. Family comes first and the home is a home first and foremost when a perfectly good office is available elsewhere.

NobdieTheNob · 26/06/2023 19:34

sometimes you do need to tell your child "no" and they need to learn that they can't always get what they want

I agree with this 1000%. But not in this case. A home is a home. It isn't a workplace, other than out of necessity. There is no necessity here. Home is the place where you can be yourself and do your own thing. Home is not a place where a child should be shushed and kept out. It's also not a place where the person looking after the small child should feel forced out, or forced to 'discipline' a toddler who is being a normal toddler.

Any nanny will tell you that it's a sodding nightmare to have parents around the house when they are on duty.

Cleethorpes · 26/06/2023 19:33

You can't have a parent be unable to be in their own house because their child has a tantrum! I'm sure this is a very difficult time as you're so pregnant but it will pass.

MysteryBelle · 26/06/2023 19:30

Abracadabra12345 · 26/06/2023 19:16

I love this! And yes. Sometimes you have to be that blunt and that honest

Hilarious, I love this too.

You’ve got to speak up, op. The days of women silently toiling at the grindstone but inwardly seething because it’s their ‘lot in life’ are well and truly OVER.

SeemsPointless · 26/06/2023 19:29

There are benefits to WFH - less time commuting, more time with the family, less expense etc. I know MN as a general rule frowns upon WFH but some people really do prefer it.

I do think that there are some things which are unreasonable - for example, expecting a SAHP and/or child to creep around their home and not make a noise. If you choose to WFH, then the noise is something that you have to suck up - or else go into the office.

But disruptions? No. I think it's entirely reasonable to expect the OP to tell her DS no, and ride out the consequences. Two-year-olds aren't renowned for their reasonable approach or logic, so he's bound to be a bit upset. But he will learn that when the door is locked/closed, Daddy is working and not available.

Have you considered putting a sign on the door? That could make it easier for DS to identify/learn that Daddy is working and therefore not available? Visual aids really do help children learn and I know a closed door is a visual sign but I think a proper pictorial aid might help your DS learn.

I'm trying to avoid using the B-word here OP because honestly, I've been there and I know it's hard. But sometimes you do need to tell your child "no" and they need to learn that they can't always get what they want.

What would you do if your DS saw your Tesco shopping being delivered and there was a big bag of sweets that he wanted to eat? If he kicked and screamed because he wanted the sweets, would you give them to him just to calm him down? Pretty sure you wouldn't - and this is the same principle.

I don't think it's reasonable to force the OP's DH to go to the office because OP isn't willing to teach her child that the answer is no. As your DS gets older, and especially when there's another baby in the house, that flexibility re working patterns might be bloody useful.

Another thing - when you say that Daddy isn't available, does your DS know what to expect? Because 2-year-olds tend to think in absolute terms - "daddy has gone forever!!!" Have you considered doing a visual diary for him? If your DS can see when his daddy will reappear, it will reduce his anxiety.

I promise you OP, I'm not trying to have a go. I've got SEN twins and I've been on both sides of the WFH coin - both the parent who doesn't want to be interrupted, and the one trying to keep the DC away from the one working! So I really do appreciate the difficulty for everyone. You should be free to use your home and garden how you want without having to keep the noise down so as long as your DH isn't trying to insist on that, I think it's fair enough for him to WFH.

**Obvs as I have SEN DC, some of the things I've suggested above come from "my world" of parenting DC who have communication difficulties. But many SEN techniques work well with neurotypical DC too, especially when they're very young. Happy to expend on anything if it would help!

Charley50 · 26/06/2023 19:26

I've only read your posts OP. I think your DH needs to go to the office (not garden office!) as arranged. It's not fair on you or DS. I don't understand why your DH doesnt understand your POV. Is the home office fully soundproofed or something?

And yes you can't reason with 2 year olds, or maybe some you can, but some really tantrum a lot and it is a waiting game till they grow out of it in some ways.

Shinyandnew1 · 26/06/2023 19:25

There’s no need for DH to go back into the office full time. He just needs to WFH the days he agreed to. The ones when DS is at nursery.

Sirzy · 26/06/2023 19:23

LolaSmiles · 26/06/2023 19:12

It's simple.

DH's standard WFH days are on days when DC is in nursery.

OP said later in the thread she suspects that his changes in days are due to the office having him in on his usual WFH days (fairly standard to swap your WFH days with hybrid working rather than going in the office extra days).

On the days DH WFH when the DC is at home, he has a WFH space where a 2 year old isn't given free run of the house to let themselves in (which means that there's no having to remove the 2 year old from climbing on him), but he also has to accept he needs to schedule time in his day to see his DC over tea breaks and coffee breaks. This helps OP because she can say to DC that Daddy will come and see them at a certain point.

As a parenting team they both teach their child that there's times when Mummy/Daddy will be in the house and not be available (eg WFH for either of them, Mummy needing rest when recovering from birth, Mummy being with baby and needing quiet etc)

Exactly!

NobdieTheNob · 26/06/2023 19:18

Yellowrosesmakemehappy · 26/06/2023 13:09

Sounds like DH needs to move rooms
in the home?

Sounds like DH needs to go back to the office full time.

OP, it's bollocks that your toddler just needs "more boundaries". He is a toddler, behaving like a toddler, and what you have is an endless source of frustration.

People who are suggesting you should put him in full time childcare are batshit. The one who should be out of the house and off the premises is the one who is trying to turn their family home into a workplace.

It is not possible to WFH effectively with small children around. And the needs of the small child trump those of the adult who could perfectly easily work off the premises. I'd say the needs of the person looking after the small child trump the needs of the "WFH" adult, too.

Heronwatcher · 26/06/2023 19:17

I say this as someone in a house with very thick walls/ difficult angles who has got the WiFi to work- and my sister has 2 separate systems one for each end of the house- so I’d definitely look into that.