Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is my manager being cruel?

194 replies

Thistulipisblooming · 26/06/2023 12:42

I am 34, and work in a public sector. I’ve been in my job over 2 years and I’ve never taken a day off sick (not that it matters if I had)

My grandma has cancer and is now at end of life and coming towards her last days. I don’t have any annual leave to spend with her so I put in a request for special leave (which we get 2/3 weeks full paid). My grandma is also technically my mum, which makes this more complicated. My mum walked out when I was 3 and my grandma took over- I see her as my mum, she is my mum. She raised me.

So I spoke to my manager about this special leave and she said “oh it’s reserved for close living relatives, such as partner, children and mum and dad” so I explained that yes, my grandmother technically is my mum.

and she has refused the leave on the grounds that, as my grandma isn’t biologically my mum that it would be frowned upon as others have had to take it unpaid or on sick for their grandparents.

So now I will have to take it as sick, but unfortunately this is only statutory which won’t go far and she said should I put on your sick leave register now that you’re depressed? As she didn’t know what to put it under as I am not technically sick.

I want to take it to HR possibly but not sure if my emotions are getting the better of me so WIBU to request this leave?

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/06/2023 17:42

Something that might be useful is to look at both the employee policy AND the school admissions policy - the reason for the latter is that it will often define 'parent' - and if that includes grandparent or other relative/kinship/fostering/adoption/SGO (as it should), then it's a further reason for HR to confirm that a grandparent in a parenting role is absolutely included as a close relative.

DeliciouslyDecadent · 26/06/2023 17:40

I work in private education and our leave is September to August

This makes no sense @Thistulipisblooming

I worked in independent schools.

An indie school is not 'a public sector' organisation.

Leave is Sept to August? What do you mean?

Indie school terms in the UK are early Sept to the first week of July (they usually finish term around the 5th July.)

Are you a teacher?

I'm sorry about your Gran but the person to approach is the Head teacher. Has she said you can't have time off?

Lacucuracha · 26/06/2023 17:38

This is cruel. When my brother died my boss said to me to take 2 weeks off and asked me if I needed more time.

My brother and I weren't even that close as he loved abroad, but I was all over the place trying to support my mum, her flight, her visa etc.

Terloz · 26/06/2023 17:36

Is it possible that you put your line manager on the spot and they replied too quickly without appreciating the nuances? Or that your explanation wasn’t clear enough? If either is possible I would re approach the manager and say something like ‘I’m not sure I explained clearly but I was brought up by my grandmother from a toddler. I have no mother. She was my only carer. I feel unable to work whilst she is ill’. This might give the manager a second chance to rethink what may have been a snap response. If not, definitely speak to HR.

lieselotte · 26/06/2023 17:34

loislovesstewie · 26/06/2023 17:28

I'm not unsympathetic but if you start having exceptions then there is no policy. I agree that the OP needs to contact HR but more in the hope that another solution can't be found.

Of course there is, you use common sense. In this case the OP's GM is in the position of her mother.

No policy is going to cover every situation.

Blanketpolicy · 26/06/2023 17:31

Quveas · 26/06/2023 16:44

Just to clarify, because we now have a load of false information being peddled:

  • the OP does not work in the public sector
  • the manager has said that the OP can have all the leave she wants - unpaid or SSP. She has not been denied leave, she has been denied PAID leave.
  • She has been denied paid leave because she does not meet the employers eligibility criteria. An appeal higher may result in discretion being used somewhere up the ladder, but managers who follow the rules are not being cruel, they are doing their job. If managers randomly apply the rules whenever and wherever they like then they are (a) not rules, and (b) lead to unfair and discriminatory treatment.

Someone can be sympathetic and still not able to act in accordance with what you want.

Party agree.

But it would be a pretty crap, ineffectual manager that didn't raise it up the organisation, to HR and exhaust all possibilities to fight for the team member to get the paid leave, then when all avenues were exhausted try some more and let the team member know what they were trying to do for them.

loislovesstewie · 26/06/2023 17:28

I'm not unsympathetic but if you start having exceptions then there is no policy. I agree that the OP needs to contact HR but more in the hope that another solution can't be found.

EasilyDistractable · 26/06/2023 17:25

Your manager might be technically correct, like others have said.
But where is the humanity? There have to be exceptions. The inability to view individual circumstances is not healthy. Or normal. But BE AWARE that HR are there to protect your employer, not your.
You MUST go to your employee union.

SouperWoman · 26/06/2023 17:20

Sorry for your troubles @Thistulipisblooming Flowers
But your manager is not being cruel. HR rules tend to be inflexible because any variation can undermine them ie set a precedent that other staff can use to flex even more. Your manager has outlined a way you can do the important thing - which is visit your DGM - that is within the rules and will not create an awkward exception that may cause issues for the employer in the future. It’s not a lack of empathy - it’s just the reality of management.

I hope you find peace in your time with your GM.

Fink · 26/06/2023 17:11

I agree with the pp who pointed out that your use of the word 'technically' might have confused your manager. If you were talking about someone who was technically your mother, the implication would be that she wasn't a real mother figure to you but just happened to have birthed you. In that case your manager would be less likely to be sympathetic to your request. If you appeal to HR, I would get rid of the word and make it clearer that your grandmother raised you in the place of any parental contact. Use the words kinship carer or foster mother, not technically.

Fandabedodgy · 26/06/2023 17:08

Absolutely take this to HR

Sorry about your grandmother.

Quz · 26/06/2023 16:55

I don't know how "just taking in" children works in the UK, but in the US, without legal guardianship your grandmother would not be able to register you for school or take you for medical treatment (among other things). Are you sure your grandmother didn't have legal guardianship of you? (You were only three; it's not something you would have been aware of at the time.) Because based on some of the other responses, if she did, she qualifies as a close relative in this case. Or...Did she receive any form of benefit because she was taking care of you, and would that prove that she was recognized as your legal guardian?

DarkDarkNight · 26/06/2023 16:55

Please don't encourage people to get signed off sick. That is never the answer and horrendously unfair to colleagues and the business left holding their workload.

What difference does it make if the staff member is absent on special leave or sick? They’re still not there. The policy isn’t fair (or at least the way it’s being implemented) to the OP who was raised by her grandparent. I’m the kind of person who drags myself in when I feel terrible, but the older I get the more I am realising we as a workforce shouldn’t give too much of ourselves to a company who would never do the same for us.

TiaraBoo · 26/06/2023 16:53

I’d tell HR your grandmother has been your legal guardian since you were 3 years old. She is your mum. You don’t get a certificate crossing out your mums name to show HR. And you certainly don’t get one as an adult to show your manager. An explanation is usually enough.

Blanca87 · 26/06/2023 16:53

Your gran was your informal kinship carer and she should be seen as such. Which country do you live in?

Worriedmama82 · 26/06/2023 16:52

GoldfincTart · 26/06/2023 15:34

Clearly, as some of the managers posting here have made plain, it's not possible in a lot of places to take three weeks paid leave in any kind of compassionate-leave circumstance. I think someone in the public sector has stated that their organisation allows only a maximum of 3 days, whatever the situation.

So please tell me, everyone here who's so insistent that the OP is being treated cruelly by being denied three-weeks paid leave, where do you work? I'd love to know so I can advise younger members of my family where to set their career sights.

I’m not saying she should get 3 wks leave but some element of consideration that this is a parental figure. I’m self employed so could take leave but wouldn’t be paid for it and therefore not viable!

lavagal · 26/06/2023 16:51

Outrageous. Speak to HR

I'd seriously reconsider my role and worth in a company if they treated me that way

loislovesstewie · 26/06/2023 16:50

Agreed to the late 2 posters.

DarkDarkNight · 26/06/2023 16:50

I’m sorry about your grandma. This is heartless of your boss and in these circumstances I would t think twice about getting signed off. You can try going to HR first but if you get no luck don’t think twice.

Makemyday99 · 26/06/2023 16:49

Quveas · 26/06/2023 16:44

Just to clarify, because we now have a load of false information being peddled:

  • the OP does not work in the public sector
  • the manager has said that the OP can have all the leave she wants - unpaid or SSP. She has not been denied leave, she has been denied PAID leave.
  • She has been denied paid leave because she does not meet the employers eligibility criteria. An appeal higher may result in discretion being used somewhere up the ladder, but managers who follow the rules are not being cruel, they are doing their job. If managers randomly apply the rules whenever and wherever they like then they are (a) not rules, and (b) lead to unfair and discriminatory treatment.

Someone can be sympathetic and still not able to act in accordance with what you want.

Well said, people struggle to get their heads around the concept that fair treatment doesn’t necessarily give them what they want but is fair for the workforce as a whole. I don’t know any company that gives 3 weeks paid leave on compassionate grounds it just doesn’t happen

GuinnessBird · 26/06/2023 16:48

This thread is bullshit.

Quveas · 26/06/2023 16:44

Just to clarify, because we now have a load of false information being peddled:

  • the OP does not work in the public sector
  • the manager has said that the OP can have all the leave she wants - unpaid or SSP. She has not been denied leave, she has been denied PAID leave.
  • She has been denied paid leave because she does not meet the employers eligibility criteria. An appeal higher may result in discretion being used somewhere up the ladder, but managers who follow the rules are not being cruel, they are doing their job. If managers randomly apply the rules whenever and wherever they like then they are (a) not rules, and (b) lead to unfair and discriminatory treatment.

Someone can be sympathetic and still not able to act in accordance with what you want.

loislovesstewie · 26/06/2023 16:40

An adoptive parent is viewed, legally, as exactly the same as a biological parent.

AlyssumandHelianthus · 26/06/2023 16:39

This is cruel. Would she say the same of an adoptive parent?

Maria1982 · 26/06/2023 16:34

Maddy70 · 26/06/2023 12:56

Go and see your doctor and signed off with stress that can't be refused

But she shouldn’t have to! This is why companies have compassionate /special leave available

if she takes sick leave she will be financially worse off, and will have taken sick leave so it will be on her record if she has future episodes of sick leave

Swipe left for the next trending thread