Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is my manager being cruel?

194 replies

Thistulipisblooming · 26/06/2023 12:42

I am 34, and work in a public sector. I’ve been in my job over 2 years and I’ve never taken a day off sick (not that it matters if I had)

My grandma has cancer and is now at end of life and coming towards her last days. I don’t have any annual leave to spend with her so I put in a request for special leave (which we get 2/3 weeks full paid). My grandma is also technically my mum, which makes this more complicated. My mum walked out when I was 3 and my grandma took over- I see her as my mum, she is my mum. She raised me.

So I spoke to my manager about this special leave and she said “oh it’s reserved for close living relatives, such as partner, children and mum and dad” so I explained that yes, my grandmother technically is my mum.

and she has refused the leave on the grounds that, as my grandma isn’t biologically my mum that it would be frowned upon as others have had to take it unpaid or on sick for their grandparents.

So now I will have to take it as sick, but unfortunately this is only statutory which won’t go far and she said should I put on your sick leave register now that you’re depressed? As she didn’t know what to put it under as I am not technically sick.

I want to take it to HR possibly but not sure if my emotions are getting the better of me so WIBU to request this leave?

OP posts:
SparklyJumpsuit · 26/06/2023 19:50

Ours wouldn't allow it either. But I agree it's a shitty policy.

We can take up to two weeks (every 2 years) paid carer's leave though - which you would be able to use in these circs.

So check for other relevant policies. I know 2 weeks isn't much but it helps.

Quveas · 26/06/2023 19:45

DeliciouslyDecadent · 26/06/2023 19:14

PLEASE READ THE OP'S POSTS (THERE ARE ONLY TWO.)

SHE DOES NOT WORK IN THE NHS !!!

SHE WORKS IN AN INDEPENDENT SCHOOL.

THERE IS NO LINE MANAGER.

THE PERSON WHO WILL MAKE THIS DECISION IS THE HEAD TEACHER

PLEASE STOP SHOUTING!
You are wrong, there is a line manager - OPs first post says her manager refused. That's the definition of a line manager. You can't say that the Head Teacher will make the decision - if this is the governors rule then it will be them. Head Teachers don't necessarily make the rules, especially in a private school.

Elsewhere you asked how I knew she had other leave offered. Neuter she said so. The line manager only refused leave with full pay - not any other leave, and they specifically advised the OP to take sick leave.

As for those saying how cruel this is, I'm sorry but her grandmother is alive. She isn't bereaved. She's asking for 2 - 3 weeks fully paid leave ( which may extend to an unspecified further period of leave) before she loses her grandmother, and that's before. Then there will be more leave. This isn't about whether she should be allowed to have leave - it's been allowed, and even if it hasn't, she could take sick leave. As she was advised to.

Maybe everyone here, whether private or public sector, have employers who allow lengthy fully paid leave outside normal sick leave or annual leave. If that's the case, please post who you work for so everyone can get a job with these ( incredibly generous) employers.

DeliciouslyDecadent · 26/06/2023 19:14

PLEASE READ THE OP'S POSTS (THERE ARE ONLY TWO.)

SHE DOES NOT WORK IN THE NHS !!!

SHE WORKS IN AN INDEPENDENT SCHOOL.

THERE IS NO LINE MANAGER.

THE PERSON WHO WILL MAKE THIS DECISION IS THE HEAD TEACHER

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 26/06/2023 18:40

I think the manager has made an error by not pushing it up the ladder but some of the stick they are getting (especially after the correction that the OP does not work in the public sector) is harsh.

Channellingsophistication · 26/06/2023 18:36

I don’t think the manager is cruel. I think they are just sticking to the policy. However there is a special circumstance here and some discretion should be used. Perhaps there is a compromise what if they paid you some paid leave and the rest unpaid?

RichardMarxisinnocent · 26/06/2023 18:30

morelippy · 26/06/2023 13:04

Nhs organisations have big blanket police's and there's little room for manoeuvre within them. Why is it only stat sick pay if you've been there 2 years?

I'd advise a staff member to take sick leave. If it means a sickness trigger then don't worry.. it can be worked round if your manager has either half a brain or a bit of heart. HR wouldn't support any sort of disciplinary in those circumstance

There is definitely room for manoeuvre and for manager's discretion in the special leave policy at the NHS Trust I work at. The max amount of leave allowed in total is fixed, but the relationships compassionate leave is allowed for is at the manager's discretion. As a manager I'd definitely allow it for a grandparent who raised the person.

Mary28 · 26/06/2023 18:25

Take it to HR. This happened to a colleague of mine when her grandfather died. Her mom was a single mom and she lived with her granddad too so he was basically her dad. Our manager was horrible about it and she went higher and got sorted. Not nice to have to step out and do that when you're grieving though.
I'm very sorry for your loss.

Emotionalsupportviper · 26/06/2023 18:23

If you get nowhere with HR, are you in a union? They may be able to help.

I'm so sorry about your grandma's illness. You must be in bits.

deydododatdodontdeydo · 26/06/2023 18:15

Quveas · 26/06/2023 16:44

Just to clarify, because we now have a load of false information being peddled:

  • the OP does not work in the public sector
  • the manager has said that the OP can have all the leave she wants - unpaid or SSP. She has not been denied leave, she has been denied PAID leave.
  • She has been denied paid leave because she does not meet the employers eligibility criteria. An appeal higher may result in discretion being used somewhere up the ladder, but managers who follow the rules are not being cruel, they are doing their job. If managers randomly apply the rules whenever and wherever they like then they are (a) not rules, and (b) lead to unfair and discriminatory treatment.

Someone can be sympathetic and still not able to act in accordance with what you want.

This is the most sensible post on this thread.
Imagine if the rest of the colleagues found out she'd been granted it for her grandmother - they'd want the same.
In my opinion, discretion should be to allow as mother, on the understanding she wouldn't then take the same for her actual mother.

lanthanum · 26/06/2023 18:10

I suspect if you did a straw poll of colleagues, they would say that your grandma counts as close enough, and would not see it as unfair. Your manager needs to stop hiding behind "other people might complain" and make a reasonable decision. (Hopefully HR will override...)

Okaaaay · 26/06/2023 18:08

She sounds junior, or out of touch. I would support a colleague fully and facilitate this time. I probably wouldn’t have done that 10 years ago when more junior (I would have been more concerned about being equitable amongst staff). I would write to your manager asking them to reconsider and then escalate if they say no. Dear manager, I’ve had time to reflect on our conversation and would invite you to reconsider the option to facilitate compassionate leave to allow me to be with my dying grandma. My grandma has been my legal guardian since xxxxx and continue with a brief context and a final request to reconsider. If she says no, then escalate.

Couldyounot · 26/06/2023 18:07

Your manager is a cunt. HR all the way.

Doggymummar · 26/06/2023 18:05

Absolutely talk to HR I would have no qualms in approving special leave or compassionate leave. There are many types of families these days, she needs to be less rigid

loislovesstewie · 26/06/2023 17:58

I'm a former public sector worker. We had policy and legislation to cover what we did, because without policy etc each individual worker would do exactly what they thought best. Policy is there to prevent that so there is consistency, anything that was out of the ordinary was still dealt with within the policy but by a panel of senior officers. And there was still some guidance. The point I made earlier was that the manager here is keeping to the policy as she must. If the OP thinks there might be extenuating circumstances she puts it in writing and asks HR if there is any leeway or other way.

DeflatedAgain · 26/06/2023 17:58

That's insane. I would absolutely speak with HR.

Just because she's not your biological mother that doesn't take away the fact she was your legal guardian and your beloved grandmother.

FFS.

anyolddinosaur · 26/06/2023 17:57

Whatever the nature of your employment they have a special leave provision for close relatives. This is your only close relative (you havent mentioned a father). It's discriminatory to refuse. Other people would get this leave for their mothers, you wont -you should be able to do so for your grandmother.

Go over her head if you can.

storminamooncup · 26/06/2023 17:56

OP I don't know if anyone has said yet, but cancer is a disability and discrimination by association with a disabled person is illegal. You should complain to HR and say this. Also say that your grandmother raised you. Are you in a union? If you're public sector there should be a union so you can join it and speak to them. Even if you are a new member, I'm sure they can at least advise you.

MoonSea · 26/06/2023 17:56

fuckip · 26/06/2023 12:53

She's not necessarily being cruel by sticking to the rules but she's not being especially caring or helpful either. Yes talk to HR and see what you can arrange.

Of course she is being cruel.

Makemyday99 · 26/06/2023 17:51

All the advice telling her to just get signed off/just say she was your legal guardian (lie effectively) are the reason businesses need strict policies in place, to stop employees taking the P

bingbangbongding · 26/06/2023 17:48

Outrageous. Go over his/her head.

justasking111 · 26/06/2023 17:48

Thistulipisblooming · 26/06/2023 13:53

I work in private education and our leave is September to August.

it was never anything legal, my mum just upped and left and my grandma took me and my older siblings on as her own. She never formally adopted me or anything- I haven’t seen my biological mum since I was 3. Not a peep.

I'd tell them that she is you legal guardian. Did she get family allowance etc for you all, did school send her school report etc??

FloofCloud · 26/06/2023 17:46

Did you explain you wouldn't be asking for any time off for your mum as she left you aged 3? Your manager is being horrible under these circumstances she's actually your mum, just not biological, would she refuse someone who was brought up by foster parent or adopted parent? ... unlikely!
Go to HR or your managers manager if you need to

So sorry about your grandma

DeliciouslyDecadent · 26/06/2023 17:46

@Thistulipisblooming What is your role at work?

You are working in an independent school. So you could be a TA, a teacher, catering asst, admin, or other roles.

As it's days to the end of term, can you not be allowed some compassionate leave of a few days?

I know that many schools have an HR dept but TBH I'd go to the Head with your case.

I don't know what posts @Quveas has read because they make several points that aren't in your posts. Paid leave or unpaid leave? Where is that mentioned?
All OP has said is it's 'statutory leave' and her manager has to account for it by 'pretending' she is depressed.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/06/2023 17:43

DeliciouslyDecadent · 26/06/2023 17:40

I work in private education and our leave is September to August

This makes no sense @Thistulipisblooming

I worked in independent schools.

An indie school is not 'a public sector' organisation.

Leave is Sept to August? What do you mean?

Indie school terms in the UK are early Sept to the first week of July (they usually finish term around the 5th July.)

Are you a teacher?

I'm sorry about your Gran but the person to approach is the Head teacher. Has she said you can't have time off?

It makes perfect sense. The financial and leave years are aligned with the academic year. It's the same with Academies.

Monotonously · 26/06/2023 17:42

Thistulipisblooming · 26/06/2023 13:53

I work in private education and our leave is September to August.

it was never anything legal, my mum just upped and left and my grandma took me and my older siblings on as her own. She never formally adopted me or anything- I haven’t seen my biological mum since I was 3. Not a peep.

Please don't listen to this public sector manager alone saying they can't offer discretion. Sometimes if people bother to discuss things with HR, they'd know there may be leeway to permit you this leave. As a public sector manager I know that discretion is there in this case. Please go to HR and state she has been your legal guardian since you were 3.

Obviously sticking to policy is important for fairness but if you're a valued member of staff going through this, it's enough to tip you over the edge mentally and/or leave. She has been your mother all of these years. HR should take that into consideration. You can always discuss it with ACAS too. If not, your work may offer you the same amount of time unpaid.

Failing that, you may be impacted by this whole thing with work as well as your grandma so hugely that now or at a time of bereavement you need to get signed off if need be. Look after your mental health and get that time you will not get back. In my opinion, you only have one of her, one of yourself but you will find another job if need be.