Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I make my DD include her Half sister on her Bday trip?

233 replies

BamBamBambi · 26/06/2023 12:17

Our Dds (11) birthday is next month. She has requested for her and 4 friends to go to the cinema and watch a movie and then get Pizza Hut after.

However it will be our weekend to have my dsd (14) and Iv mentioned to her about maybe letting her sister come along but she’s reluctant and doesn’t want her there. She wants it to be just her and her mates.

Im unsure if I should broach the subject again or let her have the birthday trip she wants as after all it is her birthday!

Normally this isn’t a issue as any gatherings have landed on the weekends we don’t have dsd.

Im leaning towards letting her have the trip she wants.

For context We also have a son that won’t be attending the cinema either so it’s not like she’s just leaving dsd out.

OP posts:
DemonicCaveMaggot · 26/06/2023 13:24

If your DH wants fairness let your DD celebrate her birthday with her friends, then let your DSD celebrate her birthday with her friends (if that is what she wants). Fairness doesn't have to mean they get everything at exactly the same time.

Elevensesatnoon · 26/06/2023 13:23

Can DSD and DH not sit separately in the cinema ? and have a table of 11 year olds at Pizza Hut and a family table a little distance away ? On the basis you are saying dsd would probably like to go to the movie

billy1966 · 26/06/2023 13:22

Absolutely not.

This is her birthday treat with her friends, not family.

Very normal for siblings not to attend.

BungleandGeorge · 26/06/2023 13:20

Will there be a parent there? For an 11th party I would have booked tickets for birthday party and then family ones in separate area (eg them at back you at front) and 2 tables at Pizza Hut as I think they still need an adult on site at that age and they’d need transport. In which case dh goes and takes dsd (and possibly ds) but sits separately?

pollykitty · 26/06/2023 13:19

I don’t see how your dsd being a half or step or it being ‘her weekend’ with her dad should have any influence on your dd’s plans. She’s a sibling and you ddd doesn’t want her there. It’s totally normal for kids to have their own friends and not want a sibling around.

Viviennemary · 26/06/2023 13:17

I think it would be difficult if she isnt included in the trip. It would be better if she either came to you on a different weekend or the date kf the trip was changed.

Verv · 26/06/2023 13:17

Sounds like DH is keen to avoid looking after 2 kids so is trying to send one off to gatecrash a party.

It's DD's birthday, she should be able to choose who she spends it with.

cordelia16 · 26/06/2023 13:16

born2runaway · 26/06/2023 13:04

Why doesnt she want her there?

Perhaps ypur husband can do
Something nice with the other two kids to compensate

My question is why would she want her there? Siblings are not tied at the hip and are actually allowed to have separate friends and lives. It has nothing to do with it being a half-sister. My mother made my older sister (roughly the same age gap as here) tag along on everything I did, and I could never just be myself with my friends, feeling self-conscious over what my sister was thinking.

Also, the other two don't need to be coddled. It's a birthday outing, not a once-in-a-lifetime special event.

HollywoodTease · 26/06/2023 13:15

To all those who are saying "DH should take the older girl and/or DS to the cinema as well" - WHY?

It's DD11's birthday, her special treat. The other children will get their own special treats on their own birthdays.

Poor DD11. Is she not allowed anything of her own, not even one day where she doesn't have to share with her siblings?

YABVU to even consider either letting siblings crash her cinema trip and meal or thinking that you have to compensate said siblings because they can't.

You asked DD, she said no. Leave it at that. Older DD and DS get a normal day at home, they don't need to be compensated, it's not their birthday.

As many PP have said, perhaps get cake to have at home with the family. But please let your DD spend her birthday the way she wants.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 26/06/2023 13:15

Can you plan a separate family celebration for that weekend aswell that the sister and brother are included in so it’s not being left out it’s just doing something else.

cordelia16 · 26/06/2023 13:12

Goldbar · 26/06/2023 12:59

This is a birthday trip with friends. Siblings aren't invited. You can all go to the cinema as a family some other time. Having a 14yo around would change the dynamic for the younger girls.

Exactly what I was going to say... all of it!

Why on earth would DH expect his 11yo DD to take her 14yo sister (full or half - no difference) with her and her friends?? That's just odd. It's not like it's a family event. If DH feels bad (guilty), he can take his DD out to do see a film. But don't choose the same film. Let your 11yo DD have a fun party without family.

Amuseaboosh · 26/06/2023 13:11

BamBamBambi · 26/06/2023 12:17

Our Dds (11) birthday is next month. She has requested for her and 4 friends to go to the cinema and watch a movie and then get Pizza Hut after.

However it will be our weekend to have my dsd (14) and Iv mentioned to her about maybe letting her sister come along but she’s reluctant and doesn’t want her there. She wants it to be just her and her mates.

Im unsure if I should broach the subject again or let her have the birthday trip she wants as after all it is her birthday!

Normally this isn’t a issue as any gatherings have landed on the weekends we don’t have dsd.

Im leaning towards letting her have the trip she wants.

For context We also have a son that won’t be attending the cinema either so it’s not like she’s just leaving dsd out.

I have 3 children, all from the same set of parents. Even then, I don't let siblings impede on time/celebrations that a child may have with their own friends. Especially birthdays.

DSD needs to not be included, and at such times, that should work both ways.

OfCourseFailureIsNotABadOptionAtAll · 26/06/2023 13:10

If your son isn't invited then I think that's a good justification for your step daughter to not be invited either. If she would like to go to the movies though could your dh take her and your son? Or all of you go together some other day?

viques · 26/06/2023 13:09

Why are people suggesting the others need to be taken out for a treat as well? They are all old enough to know that birthday treats happen on your own birthday, but you don’t get compensatory treats on your siblings birthdays.

Quartz2208 · 26/06/2023 13:06

born2runaway · 26/06/2023 13:04

Why doesnt she want her there?

Perhaps ypur husband can do
Something nice with the other two kids to compensate

I suspect because she wants it to be her close friends and doesn’t want her sibling there which is perfectly normal

born2runaway · 26/06/2023 13:04

Why doesnt she want her there?

Perhaps ypur husband can do
Something nice with the other two kids to compensate

Quartz2208 · 26/06/2023 13:03

DD has two close friends with sisters and they have never come to birthday celebrations

he needs to give his head a wobble he is over correcting here. It is perfectly normal for your DD to have her friend birthday celebration without her siater

MysteryBelle · 26/06/2023 13:03

Dad can take his daughter and the son out to the movies, I had forgotten about the son.

Whendoesmydietstart · 26/06/2023 13:02

No. I have a sister 2 years difference in age to me, we got on brilliantly and are still very close. I remember Birthday celebrations just for me and my little group of friends being very separate from those I would spend with my sister and my family. Its very important each child gets to have their own friendship groups and not be forced to share constantly. The 11yo certainly wouldn't be invited out with the 14yo's friends.

cocksstrideintheevening · 26/06/2023 13:01

Of course it's fine, it's normal. It would be off for him the older one to be there.

FWIW DTs are doing something similar for their 11th birthdays but seperatley with their own friends if that makes sense. Neither will be attending the others.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 26/06/2023 13:01

Nah, siblings don’t need to come on birthday trips. Would be different if you were including your son and only excluding her but you’re not. It’s your dds birthday and she would rather just spend it with her friends which is fine. I bet dsd wouldn’t want her younger siblings tagging along to her birthday trip with friends.

let your dd just go with her friends. Your husband can always take the other two out separately if he wants.

funinthesun19 · 26/06/2023 13:00

You don’t have to give dsd special treatment just because of who she is. Because that would be the only reason, wouldn’t it?

Some key points:
DS isn’t going.
DD doesn’t want DSD there because she wants
it to be just her and her friends.
If it was DSD’s birthday, I doubt your DD would be invited.

The only reason dsd would go now is because people feel like she has to, because she’s the child from dad’s previous marriage and apparently she needs to go to everything. And that makes no sense and doesn’t take in to account other people, most importantly your DD as it’s her birthday and she wants to be with friends only.

Listen to your DD.

Gofeta · 26/06/2023 13:00

Her brother isn't going either so I think it's fair that DD just has her friends there. Could DH maybe get a takeaway or plan something with DS and his DD for that evening?

MysteryBelle · 26/06/2023 13:00

That day have your husband take his daughter and a friend to the movies. Problem solved.

At first I was with you, but I can see why there might be a little awkwardness felt by your stepdaughter. Both are girls as you said, but also there is a three year age difference, and, should a sibling be automatically inserted into a child’s birthday outing with friends…so I see both sides.

Her dad taking her out with her own friend that day will solve the problem.

Goldbar · 26/06/2023 12:59

This is a birthday trip with friends. Siblings aren't invited. You can all go to the cinema as a family some other time. Having a 14yo around would change the dynamic for the younger girls.