Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I make my DD include her Half sister on her Bday trip?

233 replies

BamBamBambi · 26/06/2023 12:17

Our Dds (11) birthday is next month. She has requested for her and 4 friends to go to the cinema and watch a movie and then get Pizza Hut after.

However it will be our weekend to have my dsd (14) and Iv mentioned to her about maybe letting her sister come along but she’s reluctant and doesn’t want her there. She wants it to be just her and her mates.

Im unsure if I should broach the subject again or let her have the birthday trip she wants as after all it is her birthday!

Normally this isn’t a issue as any gatherings have landed on the weekends we don’t have dsd.

Im leaning towards letting her have the trip she wants.

For context We also have a son that won’t be attending the cinema either so it’s not like she’s just leaving dsd out.

OP posts:
Yousee · 28/06/2023 13:17

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 28/06/2023 11:53

I find forcing dc to include their siblings in everything they do to be quite strange, and likely to build resentment.

Doing everything with your siblings is unreasonable but two days of the year come on. My children can go out at any time they want to watch a movie or go to a cafe with their friends without their siblings.

I just asked my daughter if she would resent it she is home from university and she laughed when I asked her if she resents sharing her birthday with her sisters. She just told me she loves showing off her sisters to her friends how sweet. She also said that she does like to spend time alone with her friends as well but doesn't see it as being unreasonable to spend time with her siblings on her birthday. She is 19 for your reference and my other children are 17, 15 and 8. She's mature for her age.

Would your daughter resent asking for a family celebration and being told what she wants on her birthday doesn't matter, only the feelings of another family member, so nobody from the family would be there?
That's the real comparison. Your daughter likes to celebrate with her siblings and that's what she gets to do. If course she's happy with that!

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 28/06/2023 11:53

I find forcing dc to include their siblings in everything they do to be quite strange, and likely to build resentment.

Doing everything with your siblings is unreasonable but two days of the year come on. My children can go out at any time they want to watch a movie or go to a cafe with their friends without their siblings.

I just asked my daughter if she would resent it she is home from university and she laughed when I asked her if she resents sharing her birthday with her sisters. She just told me she loves showing off her sisters to her friends how sweet. She also said that she does like to spend time alone with her friends as well but doesn't see it as being unreasonable to spend time with her siblings on her birthday. She is 19 for your reference and my other children are 17, 15 and 8. She's mature for her age.

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 28/06/2023 11:45

I can’t think of a single friend’s birthday party/trip I attended as a child where the older sibling tagged along. It’s weird.

To you it's weird to other families it's not. I don't know a family who thinks like this only on Mumsnet. If a family decides to arrange a home party should the parents tell their siblings to go hide in their rooms and don't come out?

Two days of the year birthday and Christmas that's it. When my children grow up and have their own families the dynamics will change again. If you think that children will be miserable and resentful if they have to share a day with their siblings then that's sad.

Blood is thicker than water and in the end, when you are old you never see friends visit only family. You can tell who is close to their family and who isn't they are the ones on their own and it's sad.

BelindaBears · 28/06/2023 10:17

I find forcing dc to include their siblings in everything they do to be quite strange, and likely to build resentment.

I never got to do anything just with my friends, always forced to have my siblings tagged on (or I had to tag along with them) and I absolutely hated it. By 11 and 14 though even my parents had dropped the ludicrous “siblings must attend absolutely everything” rule though. I don’t even get why people are suggesting SD needs a treat, unless the OP’s child will also have to be taken for a treat on SD’s birthday.

Avondale89 · 28/06/2023 04:15

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 27/06/2023 23:49

It's sounds like you have a lovely family but do you want to go down the road of treating one differently to the other.

An 11 year old wants a birthday trip out with her friends and doesn’t want her sister there. It’s fine and entirely normal. The family can always have a separate celebration. I can’t think of a single friend’s birthday party/trip I attended as a child where the older sibling tagged along. It’s weird. Will the 11 year old be joining when the 14 year old turns 15?

UsingChangeofName · 28/06/2023 00:38

It's sounds like you have a lovely family but do you want to go down the road of treating one differently to the other.

Not sure which of us you are replying to ?

However, I'm not seeing anyone suggesting they are treating one differently from the other.
Most families with dc of this sort of age, who support their dc to go to something they want to go to with friends when it is their birthday, would also do that for the sibling(s) when it is THEIR birthday(s) . Thus treating them the same, but not forcing siblings to spend time with their brother / sister and brother or sister's friends doing something that probably isn't age appropriate.

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 27/06/2023 23:49

It's sounds like you have a lovely family but do you want to go down the road of treating one differently to the other.

Wenfy · 27/06/2023 23:37

I think you need to stop overthinking for the 14 yo. There is no way a 14 yo would normally want to go with her 11 yo sibling and their friends. It’s possible she’s just polite and easygoing and slots in wherever because it’s easier - some kids are just like that especially with the non-resident parent.

UsingChangeofName · 27/06/2023 23:31

Well put @Yousee

UsingChangeofName · 27/06/2023 23:30

Going out with friends has been a separate event from family members since mine were late primary age. We got round it (and still do) by having a friends gathering and s family gathering separately

Same here, except from when they started school. My dc have all, always had 3 separate birthday celebrations........

  1. cards and presents from parents and siblings on birthday, with cake and candles at tea time
  2. 'Birthday tea' with all local relatives invited on a weekend, at some point close to the birthday
  3. 'Something' with friends...obviously changing from party with school mates to going out with whichever pals they chose as got older
I think they'd feel quite deprived if they didn't have 3 birthday celebrations.

I find forcing dc to include their siblings in everything they do to be quite strange, and likely to build resentment.

Skinthin · 27/06/2023 22:23

BamBamBambi · 26/06/2023 15:28

Respectfully I don’t think that’s always the case.

Meeooowwww

Yousee · 27/06/2023 22:08

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 27/06/2023 21:36

@BamBamBambi all I am saying is ask yourself how your Step daughter would feel being left out. You already posted that she would want to go. I like to make people think especially on here everyone piles in and posts after post is agreeing with the op. As I see it you have doubt in your mind because if you knew it was right and you was confident you wouldn't be in here asking in the first place.

Ask yourself how OPs DD would feel if her simple request to go out with her closest friends for her birthday got turned into a drama about her sisters feelings.
"No DD, I know you think your birthday should be about you but you are wrong, your sister has to come"
Instead of
"no DSD, this one's just for DD and her best mates, it's not a family trip"

Stompythedinosaur · 27/06/2023 22:04

I think at that age, and celebrating alone with friends, they don't have to include siblings.

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 27/06/2023 22:02

You posted this:
We took dsd to a trampoline park for dsd birthday while she was with us and all 3 kids went.
DSD wouldn’t have a clue what we spend for each birthday etc.

The above trip does sound like a lot of fun you had with your SD and family on her birthday. Leave her at home with her dad if you want to she may notice and she may feel left out but she won't say anything and that will be the end of it.

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 27/06/2023 21:36

@BamBamBambi all I am saying is ask yourself how your Step daughter would feel being left out. You already posted that she would want to go. I like to make people think especially on here everyone piles in and posts after post is agreeing with the op. As I see it you have doubt in your mind because if you knew it was right and you was confident you wouldn't be in here asking in the first place.

DiscoBeat · 27/06/2023 21:32

Going out with friends has been a separate event from family members since mine were late primary age. We got round it (and still do) by having a friends gathering and s family gathering separately (eg last year DS14 had a family meal at our local Indian restaurant and an airsoft day and sleepover with his friends. They don't like to mix family and friends these days!

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 27/06/2023 21:28

Yousee · 27/06/2023 19:26

I'm not sure why you think people have a problem with families being close or siblings celebrating birthdays together because that's not what's being said.
For someone who likes to go on about their generous, unselfish children you aren't really displaying those qualities in your posts.
Calling kids selfish for just wanting a small trip with a few friends, sniffing about cinema trips not being good enough for your children (they were a massive treat for me when I was young, my parents didn't have money to burn) and implying that others are poor parents for allowing children to have time with their friends when they choose, suggesting that siblings are bound to not like each other if they aren't forced together at birthdays... It's all not a good look.
Nobody thinks it's wrong to have a happy, close family.

I was dragged up and I am unapologetically ferrel. My children are different.

Sennelier1 · 27/06/2023 19:39

I would let daughter have the birthday she wants, then later the same week-end do something special including DsD. Maybe icecream? O

BamBamBambi · 27/06/2023 19:36

Yousee · 27/06/2023 19:26

I'm not sure why you think people have a problem with families being close or siblings celebrating birthdays together because that's not what's being said.
For someone who likes to go on about their generous, unselfish children you aren't really displaying those qualities in your posts.
Calling kids selfish for just wanting a small trip with a few friends, sniffing about cinema trips not being good enough for your children (they were a massive treat for me when I was young, my parents didn't have money to burn) and implying that others are poor parents for allowing children to have time with their friends when they choose, suggesting that siblings are bound to not like each other if they aren't forced together at birthdays... It's all not a good look.
Nobody thinks it's wrong to have a happy, close family.

Exactly this.

and as for … ‘We don't do cinema we go out of our way for them to have fun. Beautiful memories and photos of those days.’

Honestly, Get that stick out of your ass… what a ridiculous stuck up thing to say.

I also have lots of beautiful memories and photos of my kids too. This trip to the cinema is a minor thing she wants to do with her friends on the weekend close to her birthday.
It’s not her birthday present or her birthday day out.

We were in Disneyworld Florida last year for her birthday, maybe that qualifies as something I went out of my way for.

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 27/06/2023 19:30

I think what you are doing is appropriate, I would have made the same decision in your shoes OP.

Yousee · 27/06/2023 19:26

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 27/06/2023 17:44

Your the parent you need to set an example your DD knows she will come first in your eyes.

We are a close family my children tell me everything. They like being around me my oldest lives in Wales for part of the year and attends university and she still calls me if she needs advice about anything. She has introduced me to her friends of video chat. We are close what's wrong with that.

I'm not sure why you think people have a problem with families being close or siblings celebrating birthdays together because that's not what's being said.
For someone who likes to go on about their generous, unselfish children you aren't really displaying those qualities in your posts.
Calling kids selfish for just wanting a small trip with a few friends, sniffing about cinema trips not being good enough for your children (they were a massive treat for me when I was young, my parents didn't have money to burn) and implying that others are poor parents for allowing children to have time with their friends when they choose, suggesting that siblings are bound to not like each other if they aren't forced together at birthdays... It's all not a good look.
Nobody thinks it's wrong to have a happy, close family.

UsingChangeofName · 27/06/2023 19:01

My daughters are generous people with their friends and their family because I guided them and taught them not to be selfish.

Oddly enough, so are my daughters. I have never expected them to have to take siblings along when they go out with their friends though. It's completely inappropriate when the dc are different ages and stages. Now, as young adults, they choose to socialise together sometimes, which is nice, but all the nicer because it is an option they have chosen rather than being conditioned into thinking that they have to.

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 27/06/2023 17:44

BamBamBambi · 27/06/2023 14:57

So essentially you are saying my daughters selfish for wanting her birthday with her mates only. You’re not a better parent then me because you have forced your kids to do everything together.

Your kids will be the ones that are too ‘generous’ and get taken advantage by people as you never taught them to get a back bone.

Blood doesn’t mean you are stuck to people for life. Sometimes friends are the ones that are always there for you.

Your the parent you need to set an example your DD knows she will come first in your eyes.

We are a close family my children tell me everything. They like being around me my oldest lives in Wales for part of the year and attends university and she still calls me if she needs advice about anything. She has introduced me to her friends of video chat. We are close what's wrong with that.

fireflyloo · 27/06/2023 15:35

I think you made the right call. I also think the step sibling part is relevant as people feel they need to give more consideration than if it was a sibling living in the same house full time. My dd (12) has gone to lots of birthday parties/ get together like your dc wants and none of the siblings have gone and some have sisters close in age. Your dc should be allowed time with her friends on her birthday,

BamBamBambi · 27/06/2023 14:57

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 27/06/2023 11:01

That's up to you and how you want to bring up your children. My children don't mind sharing a special event like a birthday with their friends and sisters together. My daughters are generous people with their friends and their family because I guided them and taught them not to be selfish. You can say that's not always the case but I say it depends on the parenting.

So essentially you are saying my daughters selfish for wanting her birthday with her mates only. You’re not a better parent then me because you have forced your kids to do everything together.

Your kids will be the ones that are too ‘generous’ and get taken advantage by people as you never taught them to get a back bone.

Blood doesn’t mean you are stuck to people for life. Sometimes friends are the ones that are always there for you.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread