Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be able to stop thinking about the Titan tragedy?

210 replies

coraldiamond · 25/06/2023 20:31

I cannot get those poor men out of my mind. It seems to have quietened down in the news now, but every so often I catch myself thinking of them and their poor families who are now having to adjust to life without them.

It is so, so sad.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MavisMcMinty · 26/06/2023 12:44

It brought up lots of interesting discussions and information about science, deep diving (which is something most probably don't know much about).

It did for me, @Gofeta - like a crash course in physics, really fascinating, I understood so little about the pressures under the ocean.

Gofeta · 26/06/2023 12:32

I think lots were invested because its a highly unusual scenario that feeds into a lot of people's fears- claustrophia, being trapped, the unknown etc whilst being far removed from being a situation theyre likely to find themselves in ever. Add the media's drama of pushing the countdown and the backstory of a reckless CEO who made some very questionable decisions along with the Titanic of course it was going to get headlines. I genuinely believe the people onboard were of least interest to people (I don't mean that badly I just mean I think the other elements were the draw rather than the other way round). It brought up lots of interesting discussions and information about science, deep diving (which is something most probably don't know much about).

MavisMcMinty · 26/06/2023 12:25

I’ve just read a beautiful book called The Salt Path by Raynor Winn. Thought it was a novel at first, but it’s the true story of a 50-year old married couple who within a week are given a terminal medical diagnosis and also, unrelatedly, lose their home, business and income after a protracted court battle where the evidence that would have won them their case was submitted late/without proper procedure so the judge ruled against them.

I mention this because one week this was a successful, comfortable couple with two children at university, the next week they were homeless and living off tax credit of £30-ish a week. They could have been any of us, we just don’t know what’s in the future (thankfully), but most of us fail to appreciate just how close to calamity we actually are. I think that’s why there seems such a lack of empathy for desperate people risking their lives in dangerous dinghies because they want what all of us want - safety and security for ourselves and our families.

silversquared · 26/06/2023 12:17

Why fixate on those 5?*
*
Op can't help how she feels

silversquared · 26/06/2023 12:15

*It's because it's more relatable and "that could have been me/my son/my dad".. a lot of people have been on tourist excursions of a similar nature and could possibly consider they would do that trip if they had the funds/interest etc

.... People generally can't relate to people desperately fleeing a country that isn't safe, have watched their wife been raped, their neighbours kids abducted, shelling from artillery at any given moment, roaming bands of thugs, and have been subsequently shoved onto a boat that they'd given some traffickers all of their money too in the desperate hope they'll reach a safe country with their baby and toddler and get some sort of respite*
*
I agree, it's the relatability*

MrsMikeDrop · 26/06/2023 11:52

JapaneseTony · 26/06/2023 11:44

I think a better comparison than the migrant boats would be the Thai football team or the Chilean miners, and in fact this is how the story was presented in the media- a race against time to save people who were trapped in great peril. (Of course in reality that wasn't the case.) I struggle to believe that anyone was particularly interested in the story because the people involved were rich, just as the miners and boys weren't rich.

Yes good point, it's knowing they still have a chance of survival

LoopyLoo1991 · 26/06/2023 11:52

JapaneseTony · 26/06/2023 11:44

I think a better comparison than the migrant boats would be the Thai football team or the Chilean miners, and in fact this is how the story was presented in the media- a race against time to save people who were trapped in great peril. (Of course in reality that wasn't the case.) I struggle to believe that anyone was particularly interested in the story because the people involved were rich, just as the miners and boys weren't rich.

Your right!
It's the race against time thing.
We all seen those films where people are saved at last minute: old and new Poseidon adventure, grey lady down sub one, the abyss, raise the Titanic, towering inferno, gravity.

James Cameron interviewed on BBC and ABC news interesting on YouTube or on demand.

JapaneseTony · 26/06/2023 11:44

I think a better comparison than the migrant boats would be the Thai football team or the Chilean miners, and in fact this is how the story was presented in the media- a race against time to save people who were trapped in great peril. (Of course in reality that wasn't the case.) I struggle to believe that anyone was particularly interested in the story because the people involved were rich, just as the miners and boys weren't rich.

LoopyLoo1991 · 26/06/2023 11:44

HMS Thetis. Sank with propellors and stern sticking out of the water and it's bow stuck in mud on seabed.
June 1939

Just wikied it.

Toddlerteaplease · 26/06/2023 11:43

This

To not be able to stop thinking about the Titan tragedy?
LoopyLoo1991 · 26/06/2023 11:40

Think it might be a 'claustrophobic trigger' type reaction?

Royal Navy and US Navy submariner post on Facebook etc are some grim reading at times.

Implosion and instant deaths would be preferable to running out of oxygen or freezing.
Remember those sailors on Russian Kursk sub? Some survived but died later on.
Similar was that British sub near Liverpool before WWII in shallow water where 99 people (not just crew) died.

OvaHere · 26/06/2023 11:39

kirinm · 26/06/2023 11:29

But that is their choice. And they are suggesting it was combustible implosion. They wouldn't have felt a thing. They didn't suffer.

Yes I know that. But there was a week of coverage to the contrary and my comment was more about what specifically has tapped into the OP's psyche more than what is and isn't factual about the case.

NotTerfNorCis · 26/06/2023 11:36

I know what you mean. It's because we were dragged into the story as it unfolded and encouraged to imagine being trapped there, slowly running out of air. An absolute horror story. And some of those videos on Twitter, with the eerie sound effects... We knew the men's names, faces and stories. There was the hope they might be rescued. Personally I was relieved to learn it would all have been over very quickly.

kirinm · 26/06/2023 11:29

OvaHere · 26/06/2023 10:56

Horrible events that play on our minds are more about what taps into our personalised deep fears than who are the most deserving victims. In the same way we all have different types of horror films that get to us (or don't).

I'm guessing for the OP it's the isolation and claustrophobia of being trapped miles under the sea that has provoked those feelings.

But that is their choice. And they are suggesting it was combustible implosion. They wouldn't have felt a thing. They didn't suffer.

Innocents4321 · 26/06/2023 11:17

The media coverage was very strange and sensationalist and that really wasn’t helpful. It reminds me of the boys in the cave who were rescued. They were still leading with this story after it was known that the boat had imploded. Very odd and unsettling. I feel very sorry for the boy who didn’t want to go-it seems very unfair.

Also worrying is that the company tgat operated the sub had spammed multiple famous people trying to get them to go, were operating a boat known. to be unsafe etc etc.

I get my news from reputable sources which state thefacts and don’t overdramatise. It makes life much calmer.

Angrymum22 · 26/06/2023 11:07

I watched Titanic, the movie, at the weekend. It sort of put it into perspective. The five men died instantly. The poor souls who died in the wreck they were going to look at spent several hours contemplating their death in freezing conditions. Only a handful that entered the water with life vests on were rescued and survived. Death was not instant and would have been pretty painful. I know which scenario I would prefer.
Maybe it’s time that all visits to the sight stop. They have saturated the scientific exploration of the wreck, let’s just leave it alone.

Coolhwip · 26/06/2023 10:56

HairyKitty · 26/06/2023 08:39

Why is it ok and socially acceptable here to lose sympathy or feel less pity for calamities befalling rich people? That makes absolutely no sense to me at all, it feels pretty despicable in fact

What people are saying is that they knowingly signed up to an extremely dangerous activity.

When Kirsty MacColl from the Pogues was diving and was killed by a speedboat coming towards her, that was a rich woman killed by a rich man but she didn’t sign a disclaimer knowing what she was doing could result in her death.

OvaHere · 26/06/2023 10:56

Horrible events that play on our minds are more about what taps into our personalised deep fears than who are the most deserving victims. In the same way we all have different types of horror films that get to us (or don't).

I'm guessing for the OP it's the isolation and claustrophobia of being trapped miles under the sea that has provoked those feelings.

kirinm · 26/06/2023 10:43

HairyKitty · 26/06/2023 08:39

Why is it ok and socially acceptable here to lose sympathy or feel less pity for calamities befalling rich people? That makes absolutely no sense to me at all, it feels pretty despicable in fact

They died doing something which had a high chance of death and was completely unnecessary.

MyLostSock · 26/06/2023 09:34

@Butchyrestingface

I do feel less sympathy for the submariners fate than I would for drowned migrants/refugees or even fishermen going out to do a day’s work and encounter a treacherous sea. And that’s to do with the level of choice and compulsion involved in the various scenarios.

You know, I've never felt that my sympathy has levels or can be used up. It's either there, or it isn't. Perhaps we are mixing up the emotions of grief and sympathy here.

I feel sad for all of them and their families, as they are no longer here. Certainly, the submersible occupants weren't forced to be there, but the same could be said of people who go recreational deep-sea fishing and strike trouble. Or those who go for a joyflight in helicopters in a holiday area, but the helicopters collide (to cite a recent case). Where does your sympathy-line end?

Sparklybanana · 26/06/2023 09:27

Unless you are actively going out and putting some effort into preventing migrant deaths then you are just using their deaths to justify laughing or shrugging at a dead 19 year. Yes he had privilege - but so do most of you living in this country compared to millions of children who die each decade from war, famine or preventable diseases. Do you think its acceptable for people to meme the death of your child because they are privileged in the world? No? Because I don't think it's ever justified to act this way when someone has died or lost their loved one unless the world is better off without them.
All lives are precious. Be a better person.

sheeplikessleep · 26/06/2023 09:01

I think this is just normal human psychology. It was all over the media for days, with worst case scenarios of their possible suffering (luckily which weren’t true we now know). Those ‘what ifs’ were awful to contemplate and they were all over the media as it was happening.

I think it’s understandable that the widespread media coverage has a lot to say for how you are feeling now. It’s almost like we all ‘lived it’ as it was happening. Sadly much more than migrant boats so we don’t really see the horror there to the same extent. There are also fewer personal stories conveyed for those, so don’t impact on an individual level (again not saying this is right, it isn’t). Not saying it’s right, of course other tragedies are happening every day.

I try to do what I can, donate what I can to worthwhile causes but find watching media coverage personally too much sometimes and not helpful to my own mental health.

Butchyrestingface · 26/06/2023 08:50

HairyKitty · 26/06/2023 08:39

Why is it ok and socially acceptable here to lose sympathy or feel less pity for calamities befalling rich people? That makes absolutely no sense to me at all, it feels pretty despicable in fact

If a rich man was walking down the street minding his own business, when a car mounted the pavement and hit him, I wouldn’t have any less sympathy for him than a poor man. Wealth is irrelevant there. I might think that being the widow or orphans of such a person is less likely to incur the huge financial burden and stress than those of the poor man’s widow and children, possibly left scrimping and struggling to pay the mortgage, etc. But levels of sympathy relating to the actual death would be the same.

The above doesn’t apply in the sub case. The men put themselves in an unnecessarily dangerous situation, one that they were only able to do so by virtue of extreme wealth. They took (arguably) extreme risks with their own safety and paid the ultimate price. I do think it’s unlikely that the passengers and guide truly understood the exact level of risk and that this had probably been concealed from them. That’s on the CEO’s head, but he’s dead and can’t answer for his failings.

I do feel less sympathy for the submariners fate than I would for drowned migrants/refugees or even fishermen going out to do a day’s work and encounter a treacherous sea. And that’s to do with the level of choice and compulsion involved in the various scenarios.

ElleMD80 · 26/06/2023 08:41

You are not being unreasonable, we all have some events which may seem to have nothing to do with us but which affect us. You’re only human. Just keep in mind they did not suffer and do not let it take over your thinking too much.

HairyKitty · 26/06/2023 08:39

Why is it ok and socially acceptable here to lose sympathy or feel less pity for calamities befalling rich people? That makes absolutely no sense to me at all, it feels pretty despicable in fact

Swipe left for the next trending thread