Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Incident at MIL’s. Am I being a ‘hysterical mother’?

462 replies

Freyawiththeblondehair · 25/06/2023 20:04

I’m really upset. For full disclosure I have obsessive compulsive disorder in part based around fears of contamination and chemicals, so that may be playing a part in my reaction to this.

This afternoon we were at MIL’s house, it was lovely and sunny so we were all out in the garden. She can be a bit lax around safety with the children who are 1 and 3 so we don’t leave them with her unattended anymore. Nothing awful, but she’s just not very ‘on it’, although I am aware I can be over protective.

My 3 year old had a toy watering can and was ‘helping’ her water her plants. I popped to the toilet and when I got back, MIL had taken some chemical plant feed from her shed, had my child help her ‘mix it’ and was watering the plants. Not only this but my child’s hands were under the spray, ‘ruffling’ the plants as she watered them (if you see what I mean). I washed his hands straight away and ordered him to keep away from the watering can, and told my partner immediately what had happened. He just kind of shrugged in an embarrassed way saying ‘well he isn’t eating it’.

I made our excuses and we came home but I am absolutely livid. Livid at MIL, livid my partner didn’t intervene and directly tell her not to use chemicals around the children, and livid with myself that I didn’t kick up a fuss. But I’ve had a few run ins with MIL before and feel I’m painted as a ‘neurotic, hysterical’ type. And I never know if my reactions are proportionate because of the OCD.

Am I right to be really angry about this? With both of them?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Loveplants123 · 27/06/2023 10:05

Nonsense, she is 3 years old!!! The MIL should know better. Read about chemical fertilisers before making inappropriate comments.

Feraldogmum · 27/06/2023 10:05

Your reaction by most people’s standards would be OTT ,but you are not most people & have a serious mental health condition which affects your judgement and reaction to situations.
My late father had ocd and as a child I did not realise,I only knew that he was an angry man and that one moment he was fine and then seemingly the slightest thing would have him in a rage. It was not until I was an adult that I recognised that anger was actually panic and fear. His 4 children spent their childhood walking on eggshells and scared of setting him off, my 3 brothers still haven’t forgiven him despite the knowledge of his condition.
Seeing as an adult the sheer torture he lived with, broke my heart, the worst was after his death when I found his notebooks with lists and records, though it was predominantly his fear of germs that were the main issue. I have myself some ocd tendencies, but recognising them have worked in nipping in the bud.
My father didn’t seek help as he feared losing his job as a consultant psychiatrist, yes I know, you couldn’t make it up. Despite suffering himself he helped many folk over the course of his life, but at great cost to his family.
This is not your fault, there is help available but I think you need a psychiatrist rather than a therapist. There are medications that are useful and look for someone who uses Cognitive Behavioural Therapy. You can get better, sending you a big virtual hug.

Ilovebigbooks · 27/06/2023 09:20

Your child should be fine if they didn't have an immediate reaction.
The problem is that we ourselves are very lax with our own safety and don't think anything of it.
So while you're right to be cautious about things like this, it's important to take a deep breath, explain nicely and gently to MIL about your fears and please next time can she follow the instructions on box when your child is around or at least make him wear gloves?
Don't get all het up and start arguments as it's important to be calm and not alienate people. Yes, he should've worn gloves and maybe grandma should've mixed it alone, but once it's been diluted with water it should be fine for your child to handle as long as they wash their hands afterwards.

LimePi · 27/06/2023 07:39

Seagull97 · 26/06/2023 22:49

Good grief. You sound like my sister in law who has isolated my brother and cut him off from all the family. She won’t see us- they have been married for 10 years and I’ve met her twice. My brother is miserable. You are making your husband and his family miserable (and you’re making enemies of them) and you will make your kids miserable. This is a huge non issue and one of these days you’ll cause a fuss about something that doesn’t need a fuss and you’ll end up divorced. My brother is on the verge of it and I’ll wager your husband is too.

If you do to your SIL what MIL described here does, you should take a long hard look in the mirror

LimePi · 27/06/2023 07:37

LimePi · 27/06/2023 07:37

This is nonsense. There is immunity with chemicals like plant fertiliser. Immunity comes from exposure to viruses/bacteria. (And even organic fertiliser like manure contains bacteria that’s too dangerous to be exposed to intentionally for a 3 year old who can immediately put their hands in their mounts)

it really shows that UK educational system for some reason thinks that chemistry is too hard for most people to study. Level of ignorance displayed here is shocking

should read “there is NO immunity”

LimePi · 27/06/2023 07:37

Bakingbread · 26/06/2023 21:43

@sunflowersunday Immunity comes from exposure to small amounts of any and everything that is technically 'harmful'

This is nonsense. There is immunity with chemicals like plant fertiliser. Immunity comes from exposure to viruses/bacteria. (And even organic fertiliser like manure contains bacteria that’s too dangerous to be exposed to intentionally for a 3 year old who can immediately put their hands in their mounts)

it really shows that UK educational system for some reason thinks that chemistry is too hard for most people to study. Level of ignorance displayed here is shocking

1234S · 27/06/2023 07:22

U are hysterical as in ha ha.
this is obviously a wind up

SunshinyDay1 · 27/06/2023 07:08

Google miracle grow.
It says very clearly wear gloves. Wash off any you get on.

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 27/06/2023 06:53

Mogwais · 26/06/2023 22:46

YANBU, I have a 2 year old & I'd go mad if someone allowed her to have her hands in plant food, I totally believe you on the goggles & gloves too as many fertilisers mainly lawn feed have warnings on saying wear goggles & especially gloves.plant food even if it is organic is still a potent chemical,which is incredibly dangerous to children especially if ingested, dilute or not. You will always be judged negatively by some because of your ocd but ocd or not it's just common sense. Your mil could have just let him use plain water.

Exactly, well said

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 27/06/2023 06:51

Excited101 · 26/06/2023 23:11

I’m a gardener, there’s no way I’d let a small child handle plant food like that.

This is about the most sensible response on here, imo

Juced · 27/06/2023 05:58

YABU kids have to be exposed to some risks it’s how the learn and I’m sure you MIL isn’t that silly. I think you ruined a nice moment between your son and his grandma but it’s understandable considering but in future try to assess the situation before being so reactive you will make life hard for yourself and your family if you don’t get some grasp on your condition!

Victoria319 · 27/06/2023 05:23

Hotflushesinthesunfun · 25/06/2023 20:30

I would guess that anything that you can pour on plants to nourish them isn’t going to harm your child. Surely if it had anything harmful in it it would kill the plants?

Haha, you know how dangerous pesticides are right? That the people farming the crops won't go in the field afterwards because they're so dangerous??

OP, I did vote YABU, BUT then I read the comments. And I feel I, and a large number of others, have potentially misjudged you.

Unfortunately by telling us in advance that you have OCD, it has enabled us all to fix on that, and basically do exactly what you feared, and call you a hysterical mother. Or at the very least hint at it whilst telling you that you need help with your OCD 🙄 Yep, you perhaps do, hut thats not the issue here. The issue is, did grandma do something that could have been potentially harmful to one or both toddlers, when she likely knows that mum is an overthinker at best. And the answer is yes, yes she did. She could have 'fed' her plants another time when the kids were not there. Hell, she could have watered them another time! I expect she thought it'd be cute and gave no thought to the consequences. Well someone has to 🤷‍♀️ and this time, as is usually the case, it was mum!

Leaving the open box on the floor was a BIG fucking problem for me too, considering theres TWO toddlers on the premises!! If she thought it was cute to let 3 yr old help, she could easily have put water only in the cans.

Miracle Gro is one of the most popular plant feeds and if you look at their boxed powder (to be made up with water) it has warnings ALL over it, to not allow contact with the skin and eyes, to rinse immediately if any splashing occurrs to ANY part of the skin, and most of all to KEEP AWAY FROM CHILDREN.

So yeah, OP, I wish I could go back and change my vote tbh, but I can't. All I can do is offer an apology for casting a vote too soon! And also let you know, in this situation, with this information, no you were not being unreasonable. You were being perfectly reasonable in fact, as well as classy in the way in which you withdrew, if it went as you tell it anyway 😉

Its your husband's mother, not yours. He needs to say something to her, NOW, soonest possible, not next week, not next month, not even next time you see her. And he needs to take your side, he needs to say we had a problem with it, not wife had a problem with it. When he married you, he agreed to forever have YOUR back. And in this situation, more so than ever@)!

So no, you were NOT being unreasonable. BUT I do also think that a little help with your OCD wouldn't hurt. At the very least it may help you stop second guessing your very right mummy intuition. Xxx

Incident at MIL’s. Am I being a ‘hysterical mother’?
Incident at MIL’s. Am I being a ‘hysterical mother’?
Catsmakemehappy · 27/06/2023 00:44

I do not think you are being unreasonable. Children’s skin is delicate.

I would be upset too, helping yes having hands covered in plant feed no!

Well done for seeking help and support .

Foxyaus · 27/06/2023 00:32

JockSmashnova · 25/06/2023 20:53

I used to work in the horticultural industry. I now write risk assessments as part of my job.

there is No Bloody Way I’d let a 3yo handle plant food. It’s a fucking stupid thing to do.

to allay your fears in this instance OP, splashes of diluted miracleGro aren’t too bad in the scheme of things. But it is irresponsible bordering on stupid to involve small children in handling garden chemicals of any description. You don’t want them becoming familiar with the stuff and thinking they can ’help‘. Some plant foods genuinely can be hazardous to humans— especially the so called organic ones. Eg Fish, Blood and Bone or the Turkey pellet manure can carry pathogens. I have small kids, and I do use those in the garden, but only when the children aren’t there to see me do it.

and for the muppets on here saying “ooo if it doesn’t kill plants, how can it harm a human? ‘. FFS. Things can be good for a plant and bad for a person.

This 100%

audeloquipalam · 27/06/2023 00:12

It’s just nitrogen, potassium and phosphorus at around 6%. Goggles and gloves because it can be an irritant to eyes and skin. Contact isn’t going to kill anyone or mutate their DNA. Keep away from kids because kids do things like drink liquids kept in interesting looking bottles. You don’t have to know about fertiliser but you do have to know that Gran loves your child. And in her own way may be showing you the path with risk perception? Just a thought.

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 27/06/2023 00:04

Absolutely no overreaction from OP. It was a ridiculous and dangerous thing to do.
People focusing on her OCD are missing the point and being very judgemental and lacking in any sort of empathy to boot

Joyful2347 · 26/06/2023 23:13

I would never let my small grandchildren use any plant food or chemical on the garden. Using a watering can with plain water fine. Or using a trowel fine. I think your reaction was correct. I am amazed at the attitude of others thinking you are being fussy. Better safe than sorry!

Excited101 · 26/06/2023 23:11

I’m a gardener, there’s no way I’d let a small child handle plant food like that.

RemoteDesktop · 26/06/2023 22:55

Seagull97 · 26/06/2023 22:49

Good grief. You sound like my sister in law who has isolated my brother and cut him off from all the family. She won’t see us- they have been married for 10 years and I’ve met her twice. My brother is miserable. You are making your husband and his family miserable (and you’re making enemies of them) and you will make your kids miserable. This is a huge non issue and one of these days you’ll cause a fuss about something that doesn’t need a fuss and you’ll end up divorced. My brother is on the verge of it and I’ll wager your husband is too.

Maybe she doesn’t like meeting you because you’re quite a horrible person?

JudgeAnderson · 26/06/2023 22:55

@Seagull97 do you generally attack people suffering from illnesses or just in the case where you want to project your own issues onto them?

Seagull97 · 26/06/2023 22:49

Good grief. You sound like my sister in law who has isolated my brother and cut him off from all the family. She won’t see us- they have been married for 10 years and I’ve met her twice. My brother is miserable. You are making your husband and his family miserable (and you’re making enemies of them) and you will make your kids miserable. This is a huge non issue and one of these days you’ll cause a fuss about something that doesn’t need a fuss and you’ll end up divorced. My brother is on the verge of it and I’ll wager your husband is too.

RemoteDesktop · 26/06/2023 22:48

Verystressedsenmum · 26/06/2023 22:38

The thing is op yeah I get you worry that it could be harmful and yes I’d probably be washing their hands and saying nog to touch mouth. But it’s the comment afterwards that you’re livid that’s unreasonable why ? it was adult supervision and you washed dc hands? What is the actual harm and why livid ? That’s the overreaction .

What do you mean ‘it was adult supervision’? It was an adult who encouraged a child to do something dangerous.

I think OP perceives that MIL purposefully waited until both parents were briefly absent, because she likes to do and say things to provoke a reaction from OP.

Mogwais · 26/06/2023 22:46

YANBU, I have a 2 year old & I'd go mad if someone allowed her to have her hands in plant food, I totally believe you on the goggles & gloves too as many fertilisers mainly lawn feed have warnings on saying wear goggles & especially gloves.plant food even if it is organic is still a potent chemical,which is incredibly dangerous to children especially if ingested, dilute or not. You will always be judged negatively by some because of your ocd but ocd or not it's just common sense. Your mil could have just let him use plain water.

ImnotanumberIAMAFREEMAN · 26/06/2023 22:43

JudgeAnderson · 26/06/2023 22:42

Jesus christ. Cancel the cheque part 2.

Indeed!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread