Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Incident at MIL’s. Am I being a ‘hysterical mother’?

462 replies

Freyawiththeblondehair · 25/06/2023 20:04

I’m really upset. For full disclosure I have obsessive compulsive disorder in part based around fears of contamination and chemicals, so that may be playing a part in my reaction to this.

This afternoon we were at MIL’s house, it was lovely and sunny so we were all out in the garden. She can be a bit lax around safety with the children who are 1 and 3 so we don’t leave them with her unattended anymore. Nothing awful, but she’s just not very ‘on it’, although I am aware I can be over protective.

My 3 year old had a toy watering can and was ‘helping’ her water her plants. I popped to the toilet and when I got back, MIL had taken some chemical plant feed from her shed, had my child help her ‘mix it’ and was watering the plants. Not only this but my child’s hands were under the spray, ‘ruffling’ the plants as she watered them (if you see what I mean). I washed his hands straight away and ordered him to keep away from the watering can, and told my partner immediately what had happened. He just kind of shrugged in an embarrassed way saying ‘well he isn’t eating it’.

I made our excuses and we came home but I am absolutely livid. Livid at MIL, livid my partner didn’t intervene and directly tell her not to use chemicals around the children, and livid with myself that I didn’t kick up a fuss. But I’ve had a few run ins with MIL before and feel I’m painted as a ‘neurotic, hysterical’ type. And I never know if my reactions are proportionate because of the OCD.

Am I right to be really angry about this? With both of them?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
usernamealreadytaken · 28/06/2023 13:46

Freyawiththeblondehair · 26/06/2023 15:23

Thank you Jock, you’re right - absolutely pointless, she has a ton of hanging baskets and potted plants on ledges as well that she asked partner to get down so she could water them as well. Just not the sort of task you would normally think to start when you have family over, not to me anyway. To be honest I think the timing is just too coincidental, I was sat out for a good couple of hours and was probably gone for about 2-3 minutes, during which time all this happened, she must’ve been waiting for her moment.

I wish in these scenarios people would genuinely consider whether they would be happy for it to happen to their own child rather than just somebody else’s on the internet. Much easier to be chilled and relaxed about the latter isn’t it. If you wouldn’t go outside right now and let your small child play with plant feed mix, why wouldn’t you?

I do understand your concerns but you mentioned in your OP that DS3 was already helping MIL to water the garden so she didn't just decide to start that when you were away for a few minutes. TBF, if I was in the garden on a warm, sunny day and the plants needed to be watered, unless I was engaged in something else I would probably potter and water them - perhaps she saw it as a nice way to entertain DS3 and engage him by helping to water them.

Assuming the product was this, it recommends wearing gloves at all times when gardening, not specifically for using this product - most amateur gardeners will tell you they rarely follow that advice - if I'm walking through the garden I'll potter and pick as I go past my pots. It also advises washing hands after use and washing splashes from skin - it doesn't say IMMEDIATELY and it also doesn't have strong hazard warnings; issues may arise on breathing a large amount of dust or eating the product, but it should be safe for general use, so I do think you might have slightly overreacted - having said that, he's your son and you were doing what you thought was right. He is also your partner's son, and if he is happy for the exposure then you need to discuss that between you - one does not trump the other.

UK_016922_MG_PS.png

Miracle-Gro® All Purpose Soluble Plant Food

https://www.lovethegarden.com/uk-en/product/miracle-gro-all-purpose-soluble-plant-food-1kg

coconutpie · 28/06/2023 09:39

Oh OP, you are getting a very hard time here. YANBU, your MIL was negligent and I wouldn't allow unsupervised access any longer but your partner was also negligent by not supervising your DC either.

pinkstripeycat · 28/06/2023 09:05

I don’t think you are BU. If your child got the stuff on their hands they could so quickly put them in their mouth.

Too many casual, “don’t make a fuss” kind of people. Same ones who let their 5 year old walk to and from school or expect them to cook their own dinner saying they’re 10 years old! 😂

AutumnCrow · 28/06/2023 08:49

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 28/06/2023 07:51

Of all the comments on here that are actually at least relevant to what occurred, this has to be the most ridiculous statement on the entire thread. Possibly written by a bot????
Struggling to understand how a remotely human human being could have thought this, let alone written it in response to the situation as described by OP.

The bots needs to learn to at least read the OP’s posts and pick up RELEVANT NEW INFO like ‘MiL also makes racist comments’.

Bad bots.

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 28/06/2023 07:51

Avondale89 · 27/06/2023 21:09

Some interesting chemistry lessons on this thread, but the OP was OTT because the child was absolutely fine. What is the issue here? Yes, ideally it wouldn’t have been on the child’s hands but no harm was done and his hands were washed. How can someone flounce off and then still be so angry about this hours later? The child didn’t drink miracle gro!

Of all the comments on here that are actually at least relevant to what occurred, this has to be the most ridiculous statement on the entire thread. Possibly written by a bot????
Struggling to understand how a remotely human human being could have thought this, let alone written it in response to the situation as described by OP.

TheOrigRights · 27/06/2023 21:49

but the OP was OTT because the child was absolutely fine.

What's this? Parenting by hindsight?

My child didn't drown in the bath when they were unsupervised so therefore I am being OTT in hitting the roof when I find out my child was left alone?

RemoteDesktop · 27/06/2023 21:43

Avondale89 · 27/06/2023 21:09

Some interesting chemistry lessons on this thread, but the OP was OTT because the child was absolutely fine. What is the issue here? Yes, ideally it wouldn’t have been on the child’s hands but no harm was done and his hands were washed. How can someone flounce off and then still be so angry about this hours later? The child didn’t drink miracle gro!

Are you for real?

You’d probably be angry at someone who let your toddler play in the road, regardless of whether or not they were hit by a car.

Pouring dangerous chemicals over a small child’s hands is a really stupid thing to do and it would be understandable for anyone to be somewhat angry.

The OP, presumably, would not have known whether her child would be okay or not, because symptoms may not immediately arise.

On top of that, the OP has a mental disorder whereby she suffers from obsessive, obtrusive thoughts, with chemicals and contamination being her particular triggers.

Avondale89 · 27/06/2023 21:09

Some interesting chemistry lessons on this thread, but the OP was OTT because the child was absolutely fine. What is the issue here? Yes, ideally it wouldn’t have been on the child’s hands but no harm was done and his hands were washed. How can someone flounce off and then still be so angry about this hours later? The child didn’t drink miracle gro!

Molly2023 · 27/06/2023 20:49

I'd be the same re any sort of chemicals on little hands and in general I'm pretty easy going. I'm a peads nurse and unfortunately have seen nasty things happen when people are too laxy daisy with cleaning/gardining stuff so well done for taking action before anything happened. If anything like this happens again just tell her you don't want your child near them. If she kicks off it's her who looks unreasonable not you! They are your children. As you mentioned in one of your posts, if you hadn't of brought up the OCD people here wouldn't be zoning in on that and would most likely be siding with you. Your MIL sounds like a wagon, who makes racist jokes to pick at someone? So gross

Peachypopples · 27/06/2023 20:05

I don't think unreasonable at all. If it states to take care around children then she should have taken care around children. Letting it get on their skin even in diluted form is not taking care - hands can go in mouths.

Know everyone has jumped on your OCD like "get some help" and that is a good thing to do in general by the sounds (get help and work on that). But I think your feelings here are totally reasonable. Just wanted to say.

fatchilli123 · 27/06/2023 17:22

Seems there a quite a few people think that plant food is not dangerous to humans. It is not designed or made for humans.
I react to some organic plant foods highly diluted and still makes my skin itch and burn.
I would also add some plant foods are misused by some stupid humans for a 'high' which has unfortunate and rather bad side effects in some cases.
I think you are right not to want Mil to use this in your child's presence unless used as a teaching aid when old enough to understand it is not for human consumption or to get on your skin. I sat with small people and had discussions about how sick you can get and really sore tummies if they eat stuff out the garden and always to show mummy , not me , mummy came and asked me often 🤣
Glad you washed him afterwards . It us good to learn washing hands from a very early age anyway but particularly in this case necessary .

Nanaof1 · 27/06/2023 16:22

JockSmashnova · 25/06/2023 20:53

I used to work in the horticultural industry. I now write risk assessments as part of my job.

there is No Bloody Way I’d let a 3yo handle plant food. It’s a fucking stupid thing to do.

to allay your fears in this instance OP, splashes of diluted miracleGro aren’t too bad in the scheme of things. But it is irresponsible bordering on stupid to involve small children in handling garden chemicals of any description. You don’t want them becoming familiar with the stuff and thinking they can ’help‘. Some plant foods genuinely can be hazardous to humans— especially the so called organic ones. Eg Fish, Blood and Bone or the Turkey pellet manure can carry pathogens. I have small kids, and I do use those in the garden, but only when the children aren’t there to see me do it.

and for the muppets on here saying “ooo if it doesn’t kill plants, how can it harm a human? ‘. FFS. Things can be good for a plant and bad for a person.

Thank you. When I read that comment, all I could think was, there are things people use and eat that would harm plants so the opposite is also true.

As for organic, lots of things are organic that I would not want a child to have on them. Oleander and hemlock are "organic" for instance. As is cow and horse 💩.

OP--YANBU

Longdarkcloud · 27/06/2023 12:08

OP everyone needs to distinguish between rational fears based on fact and irrational fears and just because someone has OCD does not automatically mean their fears are irrational. As is clear from this thread many people are appallingly ignorant with regards to hazardous substances and are too quick to dismiss sensible advice.
Alsojust because symptoms do not appear instantly it does not mean harm is caused eg insecticides previously cast about with gay abandon which are stored in human fat cells.

coronafiona · 27/06/2023 11:21

Wow that's severely ott op.

Backthetruckup · 27/06/2023 10:44

@Victoria319 You can change your vote - just click on the opposite box where you vote and it should switch over.

Islandgirl68 · 27/06/2023 10:38

No yiu are not being unreasonable, not all plans stuff is safe, yiu have every right to be mad at your MIL. She should have been more careful with garden chemicals.

Linnie61 · 27/06/2023 10:25

No - you most certainly are NOT being unreasonable. Just because something is "organic" doesn't mean it can't be toxic or caustic. https://whyfarmit.com/is-plant-food-poisonous/ The clue is in the instructions on the box , as you say, about wearing gloves and goggles when using it, and to avoid contact with bare skin and using it around children. Some people are far too cavalier, using these products without observing the safety recommendations. They are printed on the box for a reason. Stick to your guns - you're being a responsible parent.

A woman's bare hands dropping fertilizer onto the soil surrounding small seedlings.

Is Plant Food Poisonous? Symptoms, Treatment & Prevention

Plant food is the fertilizer you feed your plants to make them healthy and enjoy a good yield at the end of the season.

https://whyfarmit.com/is-plant-food-poisonous

Tandora · 27/06/2023 10:22

YABVU to be furious with your MIL. She was engaging with your child which is lovely, and they were doing an enjoyable activity together. Is it ideal he got plant feed on his hands? No. Is it the end of the world? No. Just wash his hands and he’ll be fine. Your child will have a miserable childhood if this is your attitude towards everything. We can’t wrap our children in cotton wool. Don’t turn a fun activity with granny into stress/ a row and don’t make your MIL terrified of doing anything with your child because of your extreme anxiety.

Loveplants123 · 27/06/2023 10:20

Feraldogmum · 27/06/2023 10:05

Your reaction by most people’s standards would be OTT ,but you are not most people & have a serious mental health condition which affects your judgement and reaction to situations.
My late father had ocd and as a child I did not realise,I only knew that he was an angry man and that one moment he was fine and then seemingly the slightest thing would have him in a rage. It was not until I was an adult that I recognised that anger was actually panic and fear. His 4 children spent their childhood walking on eggshells and scared of setting him off, my 3 brothers still haven’t forgiven him despite the knowledge of his condition.
Seeing as an adult the sheer torture he lived with, broke my heart, the worst was after his death when I found his notebooks with lists and records, though it was predominantly his fear of germs that were the main issue. I have myself some ocd tendencies, but recognising them have worked in nipping in the bud.
My father didn’t seek help as he feared losing his job as a consultant psychiatrist, yes I know, you couldn’t make it up. Despite suffering himself he helped many folk over the course of his life, but at great cost to his family.
This is not your fault, there is help available but I think you need a psychiatrist rather than a therapist. There are medications that are useful and look for someone who uses Cognitive Behavioural Therapy. You can get better, sending you a big virtual hug.

I’m sorry about your grandfather, however in OP case, her reaction has nothing to do with OCD, she has been a responsible parent!

Ilovebigbooks · 27/06/2023 10:16

I didn't say it was okay, I was trying to reassure you that if your child hasn't had a reaction by now, then they'll be okay.
AsI said in my post, try to be calm when talking to ppl and explain rather than freak out and isolate them.
It makes a lot of difference

SunshinyDay1 · 27/06/2023 10:12

@Ilovebigbooks.
Again.

It's not fine at all.

No product should go on bare skin.

I wouldn't panic if a little got on me but I wouldn't hold a watering can with it in and pour it onto their hands in a constant steam and then they rub eyes etc

No! It's not ok!!

TheOrigRights · 27/06/2023 10:11

Feraldogmum · 27/06/2023 10:05

Your reaction by most people’s standards would be OTT ,but you are not most people & have a serious mental health condition which affects your judgement and reaction to situations.
My late father had ocd and as a child I did not realise,I only knew that he was an angry man and that one moment he was fine and then seemingly the slightest thing would have him in a rage. It was not until I was an adult that I recognised that anger was actually panic and fear. His 4 children spent their childhood walking on eggshells and scared of setting him off, my 3 brothers still haven’t forgiven him despite the knowledge of his condition.
Seeing as an adult the sheer torture he lived with, broke my heart, the worst was after his death when I found his notebooks with lists and records, though it was predominantly his fear of germs that were the main issue. I have myself some ocd tendencies, but recognising them have worked in nipping in the bud.
My father didn’t seek help as he feared losing his job as a consultant psychiatrist, yes I know, you couldn’t make it up. Despite suffering himself he helped many folk over the course of his life, but at great cost to his family.
This is not your fault, there is help available but I think you need a psychiatrist rather than a therapist. There are medications that are useful and look for someone who uses Cognitive Behavioural Therapy. You can get better, sending you a big virtual hug.

No she does not need additional support for the way she handled this issue.
Her reaction is entirely appropriate to the situation i.e. being very unhappy about her young child being exposed to caustic chemicals.

SunshinyDay1 · 27/06/2023 10:10

@Feraldogmum

You do realise that miracle grow very clearly states... Wear gloves and wash any product off.

Ops ocd has nothing to do with this.
It's what is called am red herring.

Eg I'm terribly anxious, am I being ott by not wanting to walk down a dark alley at 4am where heroine addicts hang out and there has been weekly stabbings?

Oh yes go and get help for the your God dreadful anxiety fancy living like that. 🙄

Loveplants123 · 27/06/2023 10:09

Loveplants123 · 27/06/2023 10:05

Nonsense, she is 3 years old!!! The MIL should know better. Read about chemical fertilisers before making inappropriate comments.

This was in response to @Seagull97

SunshinyDay1 · 27/06/2023 10:07

@LimePi

I think I totally failed chemistry.

I fully understand you don't expose young skin let alone any skin to stuff like miracle grow.

It's callous and irresponsible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread