Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Incident at MIL’s. Am I being a ‘hysterical mother’?

462 replies

Freyawiththeblondehair · 25/06/2023 20:04

I’m really upset. For full disclosure I have obsessive compulsive disorder in part based around fears of contamination and chemicals, so that may be playing a part in my reaction to this.

This afternoon we were at MIL’s house, it was lovely and sunny so we were all out in the garden. She can be a bit lax around safety with the children who are 1 and 3 so we don’t leave them with her unattended anymore. Nothing awful, but she’s just not very ‘on it’, although I am aware I can be over protective.

My 3 year old had a toy watering can and was ‘helping’ her water her plants. I popped to the toilet and when I got back, MIL had taken some chemical plant feed from her shed, had my child help her ‘mix it’ and was watering the plants. Not only this but my child’s hands were under the spray, ‘ruffling’ the plants as she watered them (if you see what I mean). I washed his hands straight away and ordered him to keep away from the watering can, and told my partner immediately what had happened. He just kind of shrugged in an embarrassed way saying ‘well he isn’t eating it’.

I made our excuses and we came home but I am absolutely livid. Livid at MIL, livid my partner didn’t intervene and directly tell her not to use chemicals around the children, and livid with myself that I didn’t kick up a fuss. But I’ve had a few run ins with MIL before and feel I’m painted as a ‘neurotic, hysterical’ type. And I never know if my reactions are proportionate because of the OCD.

Am I right to be really angry about this? With both of them?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
13
Concannon88 · 15/11/2023 12:14

You acknowledge that you have OCD, but have acted like shes in the wrong? She hasnt done anything wrong and you have over reacted and also out your issues onto you son. Poor behaviour I'm afraid.

Calliopespa · 15/11/2023 09:54

Ah have I! Thanks - I’m stuck in bed and bored to tears!

PussInBin20 · 15/11/2023 09:52

@Calliopespa you've resurrected a thread that ended in July.

Calliopespa · 15/11/2023 09:48

Don’t worry OP - on either front. Your LO will be fine if you washed their hands, but it’s also perfectly natural to have heightened awareness of danger through pregnancy and when your LOs are small. It’s actually nature’s way of helping you protect them. If you also have OCD that will be heightening your response. Having said that, your MIL won’t have any of that going on so probably genuinely didn’t see it that way.

TheMILinatorReturns · 02/07/2023 21:32

Freyawiththeblondehair · 26/06/2023 15:23

Thank you Jock, you’re right - absolutely pointless, she has a ton of hanging baskets and potted plants on ledges as well that she asked partner to get down so she could water them as well. Just not the sort of task you would normally think to start when you have family over, not to me anyway. To be honest I think the timing is just too coincidental, I was sat out for a good couple of hours and was probably gone for about 2-3 minutes, during which time all this happened, she must’ve been waiting for her moment.

I wish in these scenarios people would genuinely consider whether they would be happy for it to happen to their own child rather than just somebody else’s on the internet. Much easier to be chilled and relaxed about the latter isn’t it. If you wouldn’t go outside right now and let your small child play with plant feed mix, why wouldn’t you?

Yep my alarm bells are ringing if she waited until you were gone to do it.. That is exactly what my MIL used to do!! E.g. I went to the loo at the restaurant and no sooner had I gone I hear she shoved her finger in her ice cream dessert and stuffed it in my 2 month old's mouth so she could watch him 'have his first taste'. She knew I wouldn't approve as we were nowhere near weaning and kids aren't really supposed to have dairy until they are one year to avoid allergies etc? Of course it wouldn't kill him but she knew it would seriously piss me off, to her sadistic delight. It's so annoying because it's little things to get away with it in front of others but basically is them trying to say 'i'm in control' and I don't care about what you think. Lack of respect. But if you raise it you feel like you are being unreasonable! And usually you are someone who doesn't like confrontation. Which they love watching you squirm even more! I would never have believed it until I lived it. Watch out OP, there will be more incidences like these!

pineapplesundae · 02/07/2023 20:48

I don't think you are being unreasonable. I do not put my hands directly into any type of fertilizers and I certainly wouldn't allow a toddler to use their hands in fertilizer. Years from now you could be wondering why the child has an unusual cancer.

caringcarer · 01/07/2023 12:50

I wouldn't be impressed either OP. Instructions on the box like that are given for a reason.

AliceOlive · 01/07/2023 12:47

GCWorkNightmare · 01/07/2023 10:22

Language. If OP is concerned about “certain chemicals” then that’s the phrase to use. Not just chemicals, because absolutely everything is made of chemicals, including us, and the vast majority are fine in normal use. Even too
much water will kill you.

Yeah, I guess if she’s completely lacking in common sense she won’t understand the difference between chemicals in suncream and or other products made and tested for human use and consumption vs chemicals in fertilizer or cleaning products.

Better explain that in case she’s an idiot.

GCWorkNightmare · 01/07/2023 10:22

Loveplants123 · 01/07/2023 09:24

Yes chemicals are everywhere but what does that prove? This article is about the safety of beauty products, we are talking about fertilisers. Obviously there is no label mentioning the need of using goggles and gloves on creams because the chemicals/levels used are low risks. But this is not the same for other products. Think of bleach for example.

Language. If OP is concerned about “certain chemicals” then that’s the phrase to use. Not just chemicals, because absolutely everything is made of chemicals, including us, and the vast majority are fine in normal use. Even too
much water will kill you.

usernamealreadytaken · 01/07/2023 10:07

joycies · 29/06/2023 22:03

Hiw would you know what kind it was?

OP said it was a box of powder, and “I think it was miracle gro! it was definitely something gro.” The link I posted was Miracle Gro powder, and the instructions don’t mention goggles.

Loveplants123 · 01/07/2023 09:24

GCWorkNightmare · 30/06/2023 17:15

But why did she do expose him to chemicals even once? She can’t be trusted.

DOWN WITH CHEMICALS!!!!!

Oh…….

https://deciem.com/en-gb/everything-is-chemicals.html

Yes chemicals are everywhere but what does that prove? This article is about the safety of beauty products, we are talking about fertilisers. Obviously there is no label mentioning the need of using goggles and gloves on creams because the chemicals/levels used are low risks. But this is not the same for other products. Think of bleach for example.

GCWorkNightmare · 30/06/2023 17:15

But why did she do expose him to chemicals even once? She can’t be trusted.

DOWN WITH CHEMICALS!!!!!

Oh…….

https://deciem.com/en-gb/everything-is-chemicals.html

DECIEM | Everything is Chemicals

Everything is chemicals, including 'clean' beauty.

https://deciem.com/en-gb/everything-is-chemicals.html

Brighteyes2368 · 30/06/2023 16:26

Knowing how easily children can become poisoned by excessive exposure to things like plant food (which is literally fertilizer), YANBU. Your child's safety was at risk. Your OCD had little to nothing to do with this particular situation as fertilizer IS NOT SAFE FOR CHILDREN. A quick Google search proves your concerns and reaction were reasonable.

Loveplants123 · 30/06/2023 15:47

GCWorkNightmare · 30/06/2023 13:32

I washed his hands straight away

using chemicals (everything is made of chemicals including water, air, little boys’ hands…….)

😂

AliceOlive · 30/06/2023 13:48

No reasonable person would purposely pour water with fertilizer in it on a child. Only a really messed up person would do it to another person’s child knowing that it would bother either of their parents.

No, it’s not going to kill him once. But why did she do expose him to chemicals even once? She can’t be trusted.

I know multiple people who have had cancer and been told it was due to exposure to chemicals. Someone I know is currently a party in this lawsuit:

Farmers, landscapers and agricultural workers are filing Roundup cancer lawsuits against Monsanto and Bayer claiming the weed killer caused them to develop non-Hodgkin lymphoma. Bayer offered $10.9 billion to settle thousands of claims in 2020, and Roundup lawyers continue to take cases.

Cigarette manufacturers touted tobacco as healthy for decades and knowingly lied. So the less exposure to chemicals, even though “they probably won’t hurt him”, the better.

usernamealreadytaken · 30/06/2023 13:39

Loveplants123 · 30/06/2023 10:24

Using a fertiliser that requires the use of goggles and gloves is not doing gardening with a child in a ‘safe and managed way’.
To those who understand this or understand it now, please vote or change your vote. This is actually important!
This is the first thread that I decided to cast my opinion on, because I was shocked of the ignorance there is around this topic.

The point is that we don't know whether the instructions require goggles or not as OP is unclear on which fertiliser was actually used - the Miracle Gro soluble has the following caution -

Cautions Keep out of reach of children. Wash splashes from skin. Wash hands after use. Always wear gloves when gardening.

No mention of goggles.

Miracle Gro soluble is an NPK mix -

Nitrogen is naturally found in many things which children may commonly be in contact with - one which springs to mind is urine; human urine is too strong for plants so needs to be watered down before using. Fair enough children was their hands after going to the toilet, but you can't avoid contact with that entirely and babies often put their hands in their mouths when contaminated, it's hard to avoid.

The P is phosphorus - commonly found in banana skins and eaten in the form of salmon, beef, nuts...

The K is for potassium - a mineral we eat copious amounts of in apricots, avocados, salmon, spinach, potatoes, bananas.

It's still a "chemical" fertiliser and should be handled with care, and not ingested, but safe and normal use doesn't result in harm, although those with sensitivities can have a reaction. OP does not indicate that MIL wasn't supervising or that DS was behaving dangerously.

GCWorkNightmare · 30/06/2023 13:32

I washed his hands straight away

using chemicals (everything is made of chemicals including water, air, little boys’ hands…….)

usernamealreadytaken · 30/06/2023 13:24

Loveplants123 · 30/06/2023 10:24

Using a fertiliser that requires the use of goggles and gloves is not doing gardening with a child in a ‘safe and managed way’.
To those who understand this or understand it now, please vote or change your vote. This is actually important!
This is the first thread that I decided to cast my opinion on, because I was shocked of the ignorance there is around this topic.

The point is that we don't know whether the instructions require goggles or not as OP is unclear on which fertiliser was actually used - the Miracle Gro soluble has the following caution -

Cautions Keep out of reach of children. Wash splashes from skin. Wash hands after use. Always wear gloves when gardening.

No mention of goggles.

Loveplants123 · 30/06/2023 10:24

usernamealreadytaken · 29/06/2023 11:21

Yes, my kids were brought up gardening, growing veg, planting seeds, digging compost and learning about safety and not putting their hands in their mouths until they had washed their hands; they were brought up playing in dirt and sand and seawater. I have suffered from MH issues and absolutely did not want to pass my neuroses on to my children.

The racist comments have nothing to do with watering plants. My father had mental health issues and I'm well aware of inappropriateness around children; if OP was concerned then I'm sure she would not have left DS with MIL alone for a moment.

The child's father shrugged it off as he's not concerned, in the same way as lots of other parents aren't concerned because gardening is stuff we do with our kids, in a safe and managed way.

Using a fertiliser that requires the use of goggles and gloves is not doing gardening with a child in a ‘safe and managed way’.
To those who understand this or understand it now, please vote or change your vote. This is actually important!
This is the first thread that I decided to cast my opinion on, because I was shocked of the ignorance there is around this topic.

joycies · 29/06/2023 22:03

Hiw would you know what kind it was?

usernamealreadytaken · 29/06/2023 11:21

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 28/06/2023 14:23

@usernamealreadytaken Have you actually read what happened? Have you noted that OP's DH did not witness the incident as he was away changing another child's nappies? Have you considered what 3 year olds do with their hands, e. g. rub eyes, put them in mouth? Have you considered that 3 year olds and younger need to be taught what's safe and what isn't?

Have you noted that OP's MIL makes racist comments and that OP still lets her MIL 'engage and entertain' her DS, only turning her back briefly on this occasion?
Have you noted that the child's father sort of shruugged it off?

If it were my DS and my MIL I would go non contact and let DP explain exactly why to his mum.

Yes, my kids were brought up gardening, growing veg, planting seeds, digging compost and learning about safety and not putting their hands in their mouths until they had washed their hands; they were brought up playing in dirt and sand and seawater. I have suffered from MH issues and absolutely did not want to pass my neuroses on to my children.

The racist comments have nothing to do with watering plants. My father had mental health issues and I'm well aware of inappropriateness around children; if OP was concerned then I'm sure she would not have left DS with MIL alone for a moment.

The child's father shrugged it off as he's not concerned, in the same way as lots of other parents aren't concerned because gardening is stuff we do with our kids, in a safe and managed way.

Chestnutlover · 28/06/2023 17:21

Honestly this would bug me and my partner out. YANBU

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 28/06/2023 14:23

usernamealreadytaken · 28/06/2023 13:46

I do understand your concerns but you mentioned in your OP that DS3 was already helping MIL to water the garden so she didn't just decide to start that when you were away for a few minutes. TBF, if I was in the garden on a warm, sunny day and the plants needed to be watered, unless I was engaged in something else I would probably potter and water them - perhaps she saw it as a nice way to entertain DS3 and engage him by helping to water them.

Assuming the product was this, it recommends wearing gloves at all times when gardening, not specifically for using this product - most amateur gardeners will tell you they rarely follow that advice - if I'm walking through the garden I'll potter and pick as I go past my pots. It also advises washing hands after use and washing splashes from skin - it doesn't say IMMEDIATELY and it also doesn't have strong hazard warnings; issues may arise on breathing a large amount of dust or eating the product, but it should be safe for general use, so I do think you might have slightly overreacted - having said that, he's your son and you were doing what you thought was right. He is also your partner's son, and if he is happy for the exposure then you need to discuss that between you - one does not trump the other.

@usernamealreadytaken Have you actually read what happened? Have you noted that OP's DH did not witness the incident as he was away changing another child's nappies? Have you considered what 3 year olds do with their hands, e. g. rub eyes, put them in mouth? Have you considered that 3 year olds and younger need to be taught what's safe and what isn't?

Have you noted that OP's MIL makes racist comments and that OP still lets her MIL 'engage and entertain' her DS, only turning her back briefly on this occasion?
Have you noted that the child's father sort of shruugged it off?

If it were my DS and my MIL I would go non contact and let DP explain exactly why to his mum.

AutumnCrow · 28/06/2023 14:08

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 28/06/2023 14:01

@AutumnCrow Exactly. Well pointed out...bad bots learning from bad humans re nor reading and understanding full thread of OP's comments. How's she kept her cool in her responses is only to be admired

Oh yes, the OP needs an award for bravery and resilience in the face of Bad Bots Not Reading Updates.

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 28/06/2023 14:01

AutumnCrow · 28/06/2023 08:49

The bots needs to learn to at least read the OP’s posts and pick up RELEVANT NEW INFO like ‘MiL also makes racist comments’.

Bad bots.

@AutumnCrow Exactly. Well pointed out...bad bots learning from bad humans re nor reading and understanding full thread of OP's comments. How's she kept her cool in her responses is only to be admired