Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are a "working mum" or a "career mum", would you make the same decision again?

215 replies

SchoolFairNostalgia · 25/06/2023 18:10

This is inspired by another thread (but not a TAAT) about how many women end up "doing it all" in the process of trying to "have it all".

I'm a mum with a career. Busted a gut to train with babies and toddlers, and am now the main breadwinner in our house and work more hours than my DH (and earn the large majority of our income). Very lucky to have a great husband - truly one of the good'uns, and a fantastic dad to the DC. However, I still think a disproportionate amount of mental/household/family load falls on me, inevitably, as the woman. Of course there are exceptions, but on average, I reckon it's pretty indisputable(?) that this happens in our society, for mums who work for money outside the home as much or more than their husbands/partners do.

My question: is it still worth it?
If I'm honest, I might have tried to work out something different, if I had my time again - something with more traditional sex/gender roles.

So, for other "working/career mums":

YABU - no, I would totally go for a career/job/breadwinner status again

YANBU - yeah, given my time again, I'd not focus so much on career (and look for alternative like try to get DH to earn more/train, etc.??)

OP posts:
Tarantella6 · 25/06/2023 19:00

We earn about the same, similar hours, stress etc and I think that's the ideal. No-one can complain about doing their fair share when they're bringing home 50% of the money.

Johnisafckface · 25/06/2023 19:00

I would never want to be a SAHM. I was for a few months and hated it. Plus I’m terrified to be dependent financially on someone else.

I had my DD a long time ago, but if WFH/hybrid was an option then I think that’s what I would’ve preferred. I’m a much better mom when I’m working. ☺️

andHelenknowsimmiserablenow · 25/06/2023 18:57

@jooon
I agree totally. We we're sold a lie. I craved being a SAHM when I had DC, but just never had the choice. Unless you are independently wealthy or can claim enough benefits to stay home you need a DP willing and able to support you. The stress of those early years, rushing to nursery, sweating in traffic, being made to feel less than at work for not staying over, guilty at home for being tired and stressed. Judged for not being more involved in the endless - middle of the work day - school events.
Spending all weekend trying to get the house organised.
When EXDP left us for someone else though, as the higher earner I could take over the mortgage on the house and didn't have to worry about it bieng sold from under me at a later date. When I look at my pension forecast I am glad I don't have to worry about retirement at least.

MotherofGorgons · 25/06/2023 18:57

PreviewPost · 25/06/2023 18:55

It was hard when the kids were little but I wouldn’t change a thing. Final kid has left home now and I have a great career and pension. I have options if the worst should happen to my marriage. My job has kept me mentally active and allows me to meet all kinds of people.

My husband has shared childcare equally. We have done the same number of drop offs, picks ups, share cooking and laundry. V v few people we know have managed to share this stuff.

I made the decision that I would never do all the housework etc age ten when I saw the imbalance and tensions at home. I achieved what my ten year old self set out to do.

I feel sad now because I haven't achieved what my 10-year-old self set out to do. Well done to you and those who have, though.

SchoolFairNostalgia · 25/06/2023 18:56

BitOutOfPractice · 25/06/2023 18:54

If I hadn’t worked and made a career for myself, and done everything for the house, kids and myself, then who do you think would have provided for my kids? Not every mother has a partner to provide / help them provide.

The problem isn’t working mothers. It’s shit husbands and fathers.

Even if I hadn’t been a single parent, I’m very glad I did build and maintain my career. I’ve enjoyed it and I think I’ve provided a good role model for my DDs.

You're right, of course - this doesn't apply to lots of people, and lots don't have a choice (especially single parents). Just wondered about people who could muse on this choice (which lots do make, at least on some level, I think)

OP posts:
PreviewPost · 25/06/2023 18:55

It was hard when the kids were little but I wouldn’t change a thing. Final kid has left home now and I have a great career and pension. I have options if the worst should happen to my marriage. My job has kept me mentally active and allows me to meet all kinds of people.

My husband has shared childcare equally. We have done the same number of drop offs, picks ups, share cooking and laundry. V v few people we know have managed to share this stuff.

I made the decision that I would never do all the housework etc age ten when I saw the imbalance and tensions at home. I achieved what my ten year old self set out to do.

Cookiecrumblepie · 25/06/2023 18:55

SchoolFairNostalgia · 25/06/2023 18:50

You might be right. I used to think this. I just don't think it at the moment, and the older I get and the more different family set-ups I see, the more I think there is something innate about females. Why would there not be? We carry, feed, physically commit to our kids. Certain behaviours/personality traits seem (again, on average) shared across females across cultures (including lower aggression, etc). Why wouldn't there be innate differences which make us better equipped in some areas? But maybe I'll change my mind again.

(Of course, there are equivalents for males (and maybe some of the more financially valued "world of work" traits are suited best to them - which is a problem)).

There aren't innate differences. It's cultural/social conditioning. A lot of women think that they know how to raise a child 'properly' and then they want men to help but 'do things their way'. This is the issue.

Women should just 100% leave men with a child and let them handle it. Everyone is perfectly capable of looking after a child and carrying the mental load. There is no right way. There is no better way. It is just done by the person who is left to do it. There are homosexual couples who raise perfectly balanced children, there are single parents (fathers) who raise perfectly balanced children.

Men and women can both do everything, whether that's being a parent, CEO, nurse, doctor, anything. I appreciate this is not everyone's view, but unless people truly believe that men and women are equally capable, it is difficult to share tasks 50/50, because underneath there is always a belief that one sex should be doing more or something than the other.

BitOutOfPractice · 25/06/2023 18:54

If I hadn’t worked and made a career for myself, and done everything for the house, kids and myself, then who do you think would have provided for my kids? Not every mother has a partner to provide / help them provide.

The problem isn’t working mothers. It’s shit husbands and fathers.

Even if I hadn’t been a single parent, I’m very glad I did build and maintain my career. I’ve enjoyed it and I think I’ve provided a good role model for my DDs.

febrezeme · 25/06/2023 18:52

The only thing i would do differently is have children with a man who respected himself and our family enough to go out and maximise his income the same way I have had to so that the pressure hasn't always fell on me all of the time to be the main earner and breadwinner

TheSnootiestFox · 25/06/2023 18:51

SchoolFairNostalgia · 25/06/2023 18:42

Oh, I didn't really have the choice either. It's all theoretical really (I'd actually probably have had to choose another DH to do what I'm proposing). More to see whether other people feel the same about the choices they made, even if they had to really...

Aah I see! Yes I'd have needed another DH too and there are days when I wish I'd made that decision 😂bloody good jobs the resulting children are fab!

BertieBootsy · 25/06/2023 18:51

Career mum - wouldn’t do it again. I’ve scrimped and saved, worked two or three jobs at times and ye I’m pleased to be where I am now. I’m comfortable, minimal financial worries, can do things I only dreamed of before. It’s just suddenly hit me in the last few months though that I’ve got a nearly teenager and just feel like I’ve missed out on so much on the way!

If I had my way again, I’d have taken things a lot slower and worked a lot less and just been a lot less stressed out.

SchoolFairNostalgia · 25/06/2023 18:50

Cookiecrumblepie · 25/06/2023 18:38

Totally disagree and this opinion is the problem. Men and women can both do all tasks, mothering etc. Believing that women are better at certain things is the absolute core of the issue.

You might be right. I used to think this. I just don't think it at the moment, and the older I get and the more different family set-ups I see, the more I think there is something innate about females. Why would there not be? We carry, feed, physically commit to our kids. Certain behaviours/personality traits seem (again, on average) shared across females across cultures (including lower aggression, etc). Why wouldn't there be innate differences which make us better equipped in some areas? But maybe I'll change my mind again.

(Of course, there are equivalents for males (and maybe some of the more financially valued "world of work" traits are suited best to them - which is a problem)).

OP posts:
Mangogogogo · 25/06/2023 18:50

I absolutely love being a working mum. It’s hard as fuck but I personally feel much more confident and motivated than when I stayed home for a brief moment back in the day. I know sahms who feel the same but opposite though!

continentallentil · 25/06/2023 18:50

SchoolFairNostalgia · 25/06/2023 18:32

I try. And really, it's not too bad for me.

But honestly, I think females are - on average - just better suited to some tasks (e.g., to do with emotional load of caring). I should repeat - on average. And they tend to retain them even when they work outside the home. Forcing men into immersing themselves as much, emotionally, in their children/household as women usually do a) often doesn't work, and b) makes men (and hence everyone) miserable. Sexist, but - in my opinion - probably true.

We have been conned.

Nah, sorry but no.

It’s the weight of history that you are talking about, not some kind of innate ability.

I do agree that men tend to do it differently , and women - because they reckon that’s their realm - find that hard. But decent men can do it fine and it only makes decent men miserable if they aren’t given agency to do it their way.

Seriously, if he’s a decent guy, do a list, sit him him down say I’ve got 64 jobs and you’ve got 13 and this has to change because I’m writing sexist posts on mumsnet.

There are many threads on this but the easiest thing is to divide areas not tasks - he does medical, you do parties, you so packed lunches, he does laundry. And then you need to sit back and let him fuck up a bit maybe, but find his way. It won’t be your way, but you can deal with that.

It will be much better for everyone if you do this. It doesn’t work with crap men but it will with a good one.

whiteroseredrose · 25/06/2023 18:49

Interestingly, one of the dads in our group has been incredibly career focused. He is now extremely senior and earns a fortune.

His younger DD has just finished her second year at University and has struggled with her mental health. Last time we met he said how much he regrets devoting so much time to his career because he has missed his daughters growing up. He could have missed the last 4 promotions and been home more. Much to everyone's amazement he has handed his notice in and is on 6 months garden leave.

He is looking for a part time job so that he can be there for his daughter.

So in answer to your question, even men can regret too much career focus.

7Worfs · 25/06/2023 18:48

No, I wouldn’t change it - I’ve learned so much about myself and life through working.
Though now that I’m approaching 40, I fantasise about being married to a rich aristocrat, and quitting my day job to run the estate and associated businesses. 😆

StrictlyCandelabra · 25/06/2023 18:48

I'd definitely still focus on career and being a working mum so that I was financially stable in my own right.

What I would change is my expectations of my husband. I enabled a lot of his manchildness in the first 10 years of our marriage (married in 2003). I'd make him step up sooner than I did.

darkmodeon · 25/06/2023 18:48

GCSister · 25/06/2023 18:40

Nobody ever uses the phrase 'working dad' or 'career dad' do they?

And yes..... 100% I'd focus on my career as well as being a mum.

I'm going to start

jfshu · 25/06/2023 18:48

Yep, wouldn't change a thing. Thankfully DH does pull his weight, but if someone doesn't have a DH who pulls his weight the relationship would be doomed one way or another no matter the choice made, so better to have the financial independence.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 25/06/2023 18:48

Oh, I don't know. I've been doing 3 days for nearly 5 years and will do 4 when DS starts school. DH is the breadwinner but WFH and will be doing both school runs. I'd probably do it again but honestly things went this way due to me being made redundant in Covid Times.

Delatron · 25/06/2023 18:47

I’ve done career Mum, part time working and a bit of SAHM.

If I could go back to the beginning I would have put more pressure on my DH to do 50:50. It seemed silly back then - I’d get home at 7.30 he’d get home at 8.30 earliest. So I did the cooking/ tidying because on paper it looked like I had an extra hour or so at home.

But I’d still worked an entire day until 6pm then gone and picked kids up from nursery and done bed time etc. Ended up burnt out and massively stressed due to trying to do it all. I know single Mums do this and I have no idea how they manage!

So that would be the one thing I’d change . Would have loved to have kept my old career but with more support at home.

ProfessorXtra · 25/06/2023 18:46

Oh and even though I am a single parent I don’t recognise the ‘mental load’ that many talk about. Until exh became ill. He did at least his fair share.

and as a single parent I don’t find the ‘mental loa to be intrusive at all. I think perhaps, it might be more difficult when you have another adult to consider, but who isn’t contributing

MotherofGorgons · 25/06/2023 18:45

I earn much less and work less than DH and therefore carry the mental/household load, but sad to hear that even those mums who are the main breadwinners still have to carry the mental/household load!

Lanesdown · 25/06/2023 18:45

I focused on my work and career and thank god I did! I'd make the same decision every single time. Having now divorced I was able to afford to by the ex out of the family home and my kids get the exact same lifestyle they had before. Never in a million years would this have happened if I'd been a SAHM or work a basic part time job.

Mama_bear · 25/06/2023 18:45

It's such a good question. I wouldn't be where I am if I hadn't worked.
I think on balance yes, but I would have fought harder to wfh more pre-pandemic.
There is no right or wrong, you do what works for you, what you can afford and adapt over time. No one year was the same as the one before for a variety of reasons. It's not just one big decision, it's a millions little ones throughout the years; do I take this job, does this child minder work, are they happy at this summer camp, can I buy more annual leave, should I go for that promotion, you get the picture.

Swipe left for the next trending thread