Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are a "working mum" or a "career mum", would you make the same decision again?

215 replies

SchoolFairNostalgia · 25/06/2023 18:10

This is inspired by another thread (but not a TAAT) about how many women end up "doing it all" in the process of trying to "have it all".

I'm a mum with a career. Busted a gut to train with babies and toddlers, and am now the main breadwinner in our house and work more hours than my DH (and earn the large majority of our income). Very lucky to have a great husband - truly one of the good'uns, and a fantastic dad to the DC. However, I still think a disproportionate amount of mental/household/family load falls on me, inevitably, as the woman. Of course there are exceptions, but on average, I reckon it's pretty indisputable(?) that this happens in our society, for mums who work for money outside the home as much or more than their husbands/partners do.

My question: is it still worth it?
If I'm honest, I might have tried to work out something different, if I had my time again - something with more traditional sex/gender roles.

So, for other "working/career mums":

YABU - no, I would totally go for a career/job/breadwinner status again

YANBU - yeah, given my time again, I'd not focus so much on career (and look for alternative like try to get DH to earn more/train, etc.??)

OP posts:
SerafinasGoose · 25/06/2023 22:00

It irks me no end that the phrase 'have it all' is never, ever used in relation to men. It's also as inaccurate as it's frustrating: doing exactly as you like isn't possible for anyone of either sex. But it's always used for those upstart women daring to stake a claim on what men have taken for granted since time immemorial: the expectation that they can have a family and simultaneously pursue a career.

When you think about it, this isn't asking a lot.

It's also not a given that the mental load inevitably falls to women. Why would you unquestioningly accept this? It's an important question that deserves consideration as it could - probably should - influence your choices.

The foundation of my marriage is the understanding that parenting is a two-person job, that running the house is split likewise, and that I'll be doing my full-time share of paid labour and contributing to the household equally in that respect too. For me, a relationship could work on no other basis, and I've been very clear on that understanding from the outset. Had DH and I been on a different pages about any of this we'd possibly have made different choices about our future much earlier on.

Whatever you decide, the key is to be really clear about your expectations and stick to them.

Anklespraying · 25/06/2023 21:54

UniversalTruth · 25/06/2023 19:02

Totally disagree and this opinion is the problem. Men and women can both do all tasks, mothering etc. Believing that women are better at certain things is the absolute core of the issue.

Also agree with this 100%.

Women have been led to believe by history, society, culture that they are responsible for the quality of child related activity - if school books are forgotten or swimming not booked or vegetables not eaten then women feel they will be judged (by other women usually) not the men. This is what we need to change. Men can step up and we need to let them.

My ideal would be two part time working parents who. 0.8wte with high quality childcare.

This judged by other women thing? I don't remember experiencing that. How does it happen? I'm asking seriously?

Do you have friends that do this? Is that a social media thing? How do they know about your kid's vegetable habits? I used to tell a funny story about finding roasted parsnips behind a cupboard in the dining room. Did people go home and JUDGE me? I struggling to care, I thought it was funny.

Ifallelsefailschocolate · 25/06/2023 21:52

If you’re accepting your partner’s offer to the table in your home, that he is incapable of taking on equal responsibilities for parenting and household responsibilities, you are conned. We are all capable of changing roles that have become comfortable to us, and parents are always learning to take on changing tasks and responsibilities.

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/06/2023 21:48

DepartmentOfMysteries · 25/06/2023 21:23

Maybe not the point of this thread, but I'd be gutted if anyone, especially my children, considered me a 'career mum' rather than just a mum. But no, if we had the financial freedom I would love to not have to work. If I had my time again I would choose a job that was less stressful and be the mum that I want to be able to be, rather than using up all my emotional energy on surviving at work (NHS).

Why would you be gutted if anyone considered you a "career mum"?

DipmeinChoc · 25/06/2023 21:46

I've done both, there is no easy path imo.

I had my kids in my late twenties having worked low level admin jobs from school, dropping down to part time after babies and not chasing big roles and responsibilities to be around my kids. As my youngest started school, I switched to FT. I now want the responsibilities and money and career and now in my 40s I'm doing masters level professional qualifications as well as working FT. This too is exhausting in a different way.

EarringsandLipstick · 25/06/2023 21:38

froidIci · 25/06/2023 18:12

  1. first this is going to end up becoming a Bashing Thread.
  2. second - when do men start creating these threads about men?
  3. and Third in response to your question - Every. single. Time.

Nailed. It. 👏👏👏

Anklespraying · 25/06/2023 21:28

It's 20ish years out of 80 plus.

My nest was empty at 55, so what? 30 years sitting in an empty nest?

No I'm still doing the work I really enjoy and have spare time and money and savings for the next 30 years. I can't imagine what life would be like if I had opted to be a household servant for a man and dependent on his financial whims.

Christ!

Ifallelsefailschocolate · 25/06/2023 21:26

The working fathers that through their upbringing have not been adequately educated in how to deal effectively with household needs and childcare can be guided through the process the same as they can learn any task at work

Some Working mums have become the first generation to guide their husbands through whatever part of the household or childcare work that their husbands had no prior experience in. Some men willingly embrace the emotional and practical tasks and some are reluctant and hang onto stereotypes to avoid equal responsibility.

DepartmentOfMysteries · 25/06/2023 21:23

Maybe not the point of this thread, but I'd be gutted if anyone, especially my children, considered me a 'career mum' rather than just a mum. But no, if we had the financial freedom I would love to not have to work. If I had my time again I would choose a job that was less stressful and be the mum that I want to be able to be, rather than using up all my emotional energy on surviving at work (NHS).

Jellytotsburnmytongue · 25/06/2023 21:21

Yes I would.

I was widowed 5 years ago, and because I'd already worked my way up to senior management by that point it meant I could afford to support my family so we were secure.

If I hadn't focused on my career in the earlier years I know I would have struggled to support my children alone.

The added stress of worrying where money would come from, and whether we would have to move house would have been so upsetting on top of an already devastating time. Having my career meant I could keep some stability for my children.

It was hard when they were babies as I was training, and felt like I survived on hardly any sleep. But we are extremely close now, and I would definitely do it all again for my children.

LaLaRaRaRaa · 25/06/2023 21:18

Single mum working full time. For me this question is really ‘if I won the lottery would I keep working or become a sahm’

I would def be a sahm until my little one went to school. I absolutely hate it that he’s at nursery all week. It’s a great nursery and I’m thankful for the amazing care they take of Lo. But I won’t get this time with him again, and I feel I’m being robbed by the universe (or by an extremely backward political environment when it comes to families) of very important bonding time with my child in his young life.

I am so angry about it but I repress it and keep going. So many of us don’t have a choice.

Despite my amazing lottery winnings, though, I would find some meaningful work to do once LO was at school. I would probably revive my current career actually as I am doing what I want to be doing.

So basically, if I won the lottery I would take about 5 years out and then I would go back to my career. It’s important to me to have meaningful work and I do want to set that example to DO

houseofchaosandclothes · 25/06/2023 21:07

I think this choice is always framed the wrong way - it should really be would you have had children with someone if you knew they wouldn't be an equal partner.

I actually do think at the beginning there is a physical need for mothers to be with their babies in most cases: at the very start, tiny babies only really form one secure bond. But this changes as they get older, however a lot of couples don't seem to adapt. I took 9 months of mat leave then DH took two months both times. He supported me getting back to work, he bonded with them, he was the one who settled them into nursery which makes them marginally less likely to only ring me. And it meant we avoided the situation where I had been doing everything baby related and kept on doing so when I went back to work. I couldn't recommend it more.

In general, I do 90% of the mental load. He does 90% of the housework. It balances - he probably does 60/40 of the overall 'work' but it is hard to quantify: he has never bought either child a single item of clothing but he is the one who does all the cooking and cleans the kitchen etc etc about 28 nights/30 a month. He is the higher earner, not by a huge amount though.

I would say the majority of couples I know where both are working full time try for equality but interestingly I'd say the closer they get to it is probably directly correlated to how close to each other they earn. I think the absolute worst of all worlds is 4 days a week, followed by any kind of part time work. It doesn't lessen the work stress all that much creates more housework than extra time to do it yet seems to place all domestic responsibility on women.

I would be a horrific SAHM, so I have no regrets: I would feel stressed and trapped and overwhelmed. But if I had a crappy husband I would also struggle. While I'm totally aware nobody plans on having children with someone who will check out, I've known enough people to ignore plenty of red flags to think its something that should be discussed more.

Rosebel · 25/06/2023 21:04

I hate being a working mum. I must add since changing jobs last year I don't hate my job but I hate not being at home with my son.
If I could do it again I'd be a SAHM. I'm struggling because two of our children have SEN which makes life more difficult.
DH is pretty good with the kids, especially DS. He remembers appointment, takes them to clubs, sorts out birthdays for his side of the family but is useless with housework or shopping.
Mental load has become more even since I went back to work full time last year and just told DH I can not do it all.
But if I could I would be a SAHM until at least they all started school.

Crankleberry · 25/06/2023 21:00

fireflyloo · 25/06/2023 18:29

Yes I'd do it again. I retrained when dc was 2. Was hard but worth it. We're both high enough earners but I earn more than dh now whilst still working 3.5 days, term time only.

@fireflyloo what do you do, if you don’t mind me asking?

Andywarholswig · 25/06/2023 21:00

I would make the same choices again, the only difference is that I wouldn’t:

  1. give any airtime to all the people (other women) judging my choices
  2. be apologetic for enjoying my work
  3. have the doubts that I was doing the right thing for my fa,ily (I was and I still am)
Onceuponatime56 · 25/06/2023 20:59

I am a working mum and sometimes think I would love to be a stay at home mum. I miss my little one. However, we need two incomes with the current cost of living, we are more stable if we face job losses or other issues, I am making pension contributions and I continue to progress in my career.
We also hope to model a more even partnership, my partner works 5 days but shorter than my days, we split nursery drop offs and pick ups. I still do more with our child but not massively so and he’s very involved.

UlrikakakaJ · 25/06/2023 20:56

Yes I would do it again. I love my children with all my heart and give them the best life I can balancing time with me, time with DH, time with family/friends, money/financial security/the opportunities money brings and parental happiness. For me this involves working.

My DH is great and does his share and honestly I think people make too much of the mental load - we’re a busy family and it’s not a big deal.

I also enjoy my work and it makes the world a better place. I pay lots of tax and am proud to do my share for people in difficult circumstances. I’m proud to be role modelling to my kids and anyone else who cares a relationship where we both contribute financially and domestically.

It’s also quite risky not to work or to damage your career by going very part time etc. DH had a serious health problem and I was damn glad I was earning good money and we didn’t have to worry about that amongst everything else. Two of my fiveish best friends had their husbands suddenly leave them with young children and they were damn glad they had their careers. I’m only quite young so expect more dramas of this type.

UsingChangeofName · 25/06/2023 20:55

It's not just one big decision, it's a millions little ones throughout the years;

this is a really good point

TheMoth · 25/06/2023 20:51

Not sure I'd do the mum bit, if I had the choice again. My child free friends don't seem to have missed out on anything.

audweb · 25/06/2023 20:51

Never regret it. Love my job, love the sector I work in.

ended up a lone parent, always had been the higher earner. I get nothing from him, thank goodness I kept my career going. Can manage myself, and work in an interesting career.

I also had PND and it was very helpful to return to work and get some sense of self back.

work is valuable for my own self esteem, interests and relationships.

also men never doubt themselves working and parenting! So I have never felt the guilt!

BobbitWorm · 25/06/2023 20:51

Career mum here, but the first and only in my family. There are moments where I regret my choices, especially when I travel a lot, or the or times I have had to miss school assemblies.

But, and this is what I base my approach on, I have grown up with women dependent on their pretty rubbish husbands and in most cases it has been catastrophic for them. They have never had security or the ability to cope financially when the relationship has failed. That scares me. I watched my mother bundle up our stuff into a taxi and move us into a council B&B when we lost our home. I never want my kid to see that.

I also have a husband, who is a dream in a lot of ways. We earn similar amounts, and we share the domestic stuff. He, however, has an illness that means he could pass away and cannot get any kind of health insurance and so I take nothing for granted. I have to be financially independent. I have to have this career because it funds my son's security. My female relatives see me as this big shoulder padded, strong, confident woman - whereas in reality, I am just doing what I feel I have to and have horrible anxiety, and quite a lot of therapy to cope.

TorviShieldMaiden · 25/06/2023 20:49

I wouldn’t have children if I did it again.

WonkyPicture · 25/06/2023 20:48

I have been a working mum, it has been hard at times but husband has now completely unexpectedly left me after 24 years, I can buy him out if the house and can move on without any financial problems. In fact I am far better off than he is. No regrets.

Mummadeze · 25/06/2023 20:46

I don’t mind doing everything myself. I wouldn’t be happy without my career and I want control of all the mental load chores. My main regret is not having a partner who earns an equal amount. I feel resentful about that from time to time.

whittingtonmum · 25/06/2023 20:40

It's been totally worth keeping my career going. Firstly, if DH decides to exchange me for a younger model I will be ok financially. Secondly, I have managed to get to the stage in my career where I have been able to negotiate great flexibility. That often requires a certain degree of seniority. Thirdly, if I didn't have the seniority and income to match DH's would I have to sort out all the DCs illnesses cover and everything else that disrupts work? Yes I would because he would be the main breadwinner/have the career - and me being on the lower income would probably swallow that line.

On the latter point it's still a struggle to get him to pull his weight. And I am not going to pretend that recently I didn't shout at the top of my lungs when he point blank refused to work from home when DD was ill. 'Of course you can't work from home today. Because you are a man. And your work is important. Enjoy your male privilege.' It did the trick though and he worked from home that day.

Did my career require sacrifices? Oh yes it did. But when I think of the sacrifices and risks the alternative would have entailed I'd do it again in a heartbeat.

On the mental load: we should not let the dads off the hook so easily. Yes most suck at it but they can learn and improve. Also my kids are at the age now where they whinge and get annoyed with dad if he doesn't do it properly. If they come to me to complain I say: I am sorry but Daddy was in charge. I can't do it all by myself. Please tell him directly how you feel.' That has also let to some improvement and it means that it's the kids whinging at him for forgetting/getting it wrong. Not me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread