Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are a "working mum" or a "career mum", would you make the same decision again?

215 replies

SchoolFairNostalgia · 25/06/2023 18:10

This is inspired by another thread (but not a TAAT) about how many women end up "doing it all" in the process of trying to "have it all".

I'm a mum with a career. Busted a gut to train with babies and toddlers, and am now the main breadwinner in our house and work more hours than my DH (and earn the large majority of our income). Very lucky to have a great husband - truly one of the good'uns, and a fantastic dad to the DC. However, I still think a disproportionate amount of mental/household/family load falls on me, inevitably, as the woman. Of course there are exceptions, but on average, I reckon it's pretty indisputable(?) that this happens in our society, for mums who work for money outside the home as much or more than their husbands/partners do.

My question: is it still worth it?
If I'm honest, I might have tried to work out something different, if I had my time again - something with more traditional sex/gender roles.

So, for other "working/career mums":

YABU - no, I would totally go for a career/job/breadwinner status again

YANBU - yeah, given my time again, I'd not focus so much on career (and look for alternative like try to get DH to earn more/train, etc.??)

OP posts:
fireflyloo · 26/06/2023 09:48

@Crankleberry I'm a psychologist

SerafinasGoose · 26/06/2023 09:42

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/06/2023 08:05

@Outofthepark

Where are all these women who say they want to 'have it all’

Theres a thread on here roughly once a month from someone who self importantly tips up and posts “AIBU to think it’s a myth that women can have it all?”. Cue pages and pages of conspiracist nonsense about women being “sold a lie” like some JFK style cover up. Who has sold them this lie (apart from evil feminists) is never made clear.

Theres still a very strong school of thought among many people, despite the fact that non working mothers are now in a minority, that mothers who work are playing at being a “career girl” as if we were all raiding the dressing up box for fun. The suggestion being that at some point we will all come to our senses, have a nice cuppa and put the briefcase and the shoes back.

The problem with this attitude is that for a large number of us working isn’t just play acting, it’s survival. I wish people would think about this before posting this kind of bollocks.

This is a good summary of the nuances of that discussion. It's for sure not women who are trying to balance their professional and domestic lives. It's (once again) a mechanism for putting upstart women back into their box; the same sort of attitude extended to my daring to retain my original family name and then have people inform me it's not really my name, and persisting in addressing me as Mrs Hisname.

'Having it all' is coming from the same place as this. It's no more used about men than the repulsive term 'maiden name' ever applies to them.

The PP was right in stating that having a family and a job is a low bar, and to point out that very few people in the world really do 'have it all'. Again, the implication behind this is greedy, 'selfish' women wanting their slice of the workplace.

I kept my career, because I wanted to. We could have survived as a one-income family. I value and love my work and thrive on the research in particular. I'm also extremely good at it, have worked for years on postgraduate qualifications on a very meagre income, and see no reason why my biological sex alone should force me to give that up.

Incidentally, the marriage bar imposed in the interwar period was only fully revoked with the Sex Discrimination Act of the mid-1970s. Seems unbelievable, I know, but true.

MotherofGorgons · 26/06/2023 09:31

Gytgyt · 26/06/2023 08:20

Life is not work unless you are absolutely desperate for money it's understandable if not you need to find a life outside of work!

I don't agree. I think work is very important for a number of reasons other than money as well. Self-respect, structure, ambition, pride in getting to the top...

I don't want to moan too much as stepping back from work did enable me to achieve in a hobby which earns money, but not much. I was also able to be an SAHM for a while, but tbh I don't think that made much difference to my DC. If I had had a choice, I would have worked full time.

atotalshambles · 26/06/2023 09:27

Everyone is different so I would recommend you follow your gut feeling. Whichever you decide, you will have some regrets I think. Please don't judge those who decide to make a different decision though.

BitOutOfPractice · 26/06/2023 09:27

I had a choice when the dc were born. I was married. I am very glad I made that choice because when my circumstances changed I wasn’t left high and dry.

your first answer to me sounded very much like “single parents need not answer”. Hence the rolling eyes.

SouthLondonMum22 · 26/06/2023 09:23

Beesandhoney123 · 26/06/2023 09:06

If I had a choice then sahm. Dh would also prefer and no he is not a misoginist twat

Unfortunately, given the cost of living and desire by government to make everything unattainable - house, mortgage , car, rent, food, utility bills, unless both partners work or earn a massive salary that option is impossible for us.

Why would DH prefer you to do it? Why wouldn't he want to do it himself?

SchoolFairNostalgia · 26/06/2023 09:20

BitOutOfPractice · 26/06/2023 08:14

Oh sorry I didn’t realise you only wanted to hear the musings of people who “had a choice” 🙄

I am also going to start using “working father” and “career dad” and asking my make colleagues how they juggle a career and parenthood.

Good idea re the male colleagues. I already do that sometimes, in my job, and it's interesting to see the reactions.

As for "Oh sorry I didn’t realise you only wanted to hear the musings of people who “had a choice” 🙄" - please read the post. You don't have to have directly had a choice (as it happened, I didn't really have one, in the specific circumstances I was in, either) to muse on it.

OP posts:
Mothwingdust · 26/06/2023 09:16

I did spend a few years being main breadwinner but overall it’s been DH. Absolutely worth it just to exercise the brain, make friends and mainly make money. Never trapped due to lack of money. Plus even in the most loving mutually respectful relationship someone can drop dead.

I am a bit older than DH and retired early safe in the knowledge that as an individual I have a really decent pension that is enough to run a household easily with some left over without having to rely on state pension.

Beesandhoney123 · 26/06/2023 09:06

If I had a choice then sahm. Dh would also prefer and no he is not a misoginist twat

Unfortunately, given the cost of living and desire by government to make everything unattainable - house, mortgage , car, rent, food, utility bills, unless both partners work or earn a massive salary that option is impossible for us.

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/06/2023 09:05

Life is not work unless you are absolutely desperate for money it's understandable if not you need to find a life outside of work!

Invariably posted by people who don't need to work but who lack the imagination to recognise that many of us do need to. See also "people who live to work are boring" and "If you enjoy your job you have no imagination".

If you need to work (as I do), you will want to make damn sure that you get some pleasure out of your work. Even if you don't need to. There's absolutely no shame in wanting to enjoy what you do, taking pride in your job and wanting to make it count, and no it doesn't make you dull or lacking in imagination, nor does it preclude you from enjoying your family or having hobbies.

Toooldtoworry · 26/06/2023 09:03

I would absolutely be a 'career woman' if I had my time again. Mainly because I've been divorced twice and I have had to rely on myself for income. Now I am the main breadwinner. DH is probably going to have to give up work in a few years as it is very physical and his body won't be able to take it as already getting injured.

GCSister · 26/06/2023 08:56

Life is not work unless you are absolutely desperate for money it's understandable if not you need to find a life outside of work!

What a patronising response!

YOU might feel this way but others view life/work differently.
My career is a huge part of my identity and my life.

Nottodaty · 26/06/2023 08:26

Im a mother first. I just happen to have a career. my eldest is 20 now & she hasn’t been damaged by going to nursery we have a very close relationship. When she was younger I earned nothing while paying nursery but I was only just starting my career with a surprise pregnancy - just kept telling myself think of the long term not the short term.

My husband is the same he is a Dad first - has been to all school events and also regardless of his job has taken on his share of the pickups and sick days. We a team and we share the load. I recently had to go home due to a death in the family he was fine for the week all the thinking and mental load too.

Though I will never judge a women choice SAHP or a Mum that works - we all just trying to do our best for our families.

Gytgyt · 26/06/2023 08:20

MotherofGorgons · 25/06/2023 18:40

I stepped back from my career and went part time for various reasons- didn't have much of a choice- and deeply regret it. If I could do it again, I would have worked full time all my life. On my deathbed, I will definitely wish I had worked more.

Life is not work unless you are absolutely desperate for money it's understandable if not you need to find a life outside of work!

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/06/2023 08:18

I am also going to start using “working father” and “career dad” and asking my make colleagues how they juggle a career and parenthood.

Cue nonplussed expression while they start to say: “Oh my wife does all the childcare…. Oh, wait”…..

BitOutOfPractice · 26/06/2023 08:15

*male

BitOutOfPractice · 26/06/2023 08:14

SchoolFairNostalgia · 25/06/2023 18:56

You're right, of course - this doesn't apply to lots of people, and lots don't have a choice (especially single parents). Just wondered about people who could muse on this choice (which lots do make, at least on some level, I think)

Oh sorry I didn’t realise you only wanted to hear the musings of people who “had a choice” 🙄

I am also going to start using “working father” and “career dad” and asking my make colleagues how they juggle a career and parenthood.

cptartapp · 26/06/2023 08:14

Absolutely. I went back to work pt at four and five months respectively. I didn't need to but we had no family help and it was the only break I ever got. Spent many thousands on nursery fees- best investment ever.
It maintained my mental health, the power balance in our marriage and my professional skills.
Now twenty years on the DC are smart and independent young adults off to uni, all bonded just fine. My pension looks great and am looking good to retire at 55.

Gytgyt · 26/06/2023 08:09

From my understanding about OP I thought it was about those who have worked whilst their little ones were small doing a graduate job/training rather than being a mum and working a less intense job. Not being a SAHM per say!

The question was would you do it all again or make different choices and step back a bit/step up a bit more.

Tailfeather · 26/06/2023 08:05

MrsElsa · 26/06/2023 07:19

The point isn't about career vs SAHM when the kids need a lot of input though. The point is much longer term. Your pension. Your enjoyment and interests in life when you're 50/60/70. Your social life maybe.

When women post that they've given up work totally to become a SAHM, it usually transpires that they haven't thought about what the consequences of that will be 10, 20, 30 years down the line. That makes me feel frustrated. We should be more conscious in our choices. A lot of things in life we have no idea of the consequences and just have to do our best. But giving up work has some very obvious consequences if you think on it for more than 30 seconds, and a woman giving up work should be making an informed choice i.e. be aware that she is choosing those consequences. Rather than 10/20 years later going "oh...."

So true. I employ lots of mums as I run my own online business and operate 9-3 and then do accounts/payroll/marketing etc in the evenings once DS is in bed. They were all career women in the city on good salaries who became SAHMs for years and years and all regret giving up their careers as job opportunities are limited for them now. Two of them met their husbands when working with them and are quite resentful having watched their husband's careers flourish when they had the same qualifications and training.

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/06/2023 08:05

@Outofthepark

Where are all these women who say they want to 'have it all’

Theres a thread on here roughly once a month from someone who self importantly tips up and posts “AIBU to think it’s a myth that women can have it all?”. Cue pages and pages of conspiracist nonsense about women being “sold a lie” like some JFK style cover up. Who has sold them this lie (apart from evil feminists) is never made clear.

Theres still a very strong school of thought among many people, despite the fact that non working mothers are now in a minority, that mothers who work are playing at being a “career girl” as if we were all raiding the dressing up box for fun. The suggestion being that at some point we will all come to our senses, have a nice cuppa and put the briefcase and the shoes back.

The problem with this attitude is that for a large number of us working isn’t just play acting, it’s survival. I wish people would think about this before posting this kind of bollocks.

Sceptre86 · 26/06/2023 07:39

I have a career but I do work part time. Dh has also compessed his hours.When we had our older two he was able to work from home 2 days a week so they only went to nursery in the morning and napped in the afternoon. I did feel guilty that they were in childcare but it was the best solution we could find. We wouldn't have been able to buy our house if I hadn't gone back to work as wouldn't have got enough of a mortgage on dhs salary at the time. Fastforward 7 years and we have 3 kids and I work 2 days. No guilt over leaving my 1 year old as she is with dh on my working days. She's happy and I'm happy. Dh outearns me 3x but still values my contribution. I help people as part of my job, it's challenging and overall I enjoy it. He supported me to go freelance and I have a new lease for life.

The answer to your question is no I wouldn't rewind time to be a sahm. I put my kids before myself all the time but having a roof over the head is important and we wouldn't have this house had I not gone to work after my first and second may leave. I am organised to the hilt and dh is an equal partner. Had he been lazy or a waste of space I wouldn't have gone onto have 3 kids and would have left him. We did have a conversation early on in our marriage about the mental load and when I pointed it out to him he got it.

christmastreefarm · 26/06/2023 07:32

Me staying working meant I had to freedom to split from my husband and not worry (too much) about financial implications. Had I stayed at home I would not have had that choice.

We were able to remain in the house and I bought him out giving stability for my children.

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 26/06/2023 07:25

whatfreshhellisthis23 · 26/06/2023 07:24

I'm a career PARENT and would always choose this. Husband died when I was pregnant with number 2 so we'd have been screwed if I hadn't protected my earning capacity, there's only so long the life insurance can last.

Also, I would never support a man's career at the expense of my own, it's 2023

Yes yes yes to the last paragraph

So sorry for your loss @whatfreshhellisthis23

Outofthepark · 26/06/2023 07:25

Where are all these women who say they want to 'have it all'? I've never met one, but I have seen the phrase endlessly since I was a kid in magazines! I think it's an urban myth that women actually say this. Besides having a baby and a job is kind of a low bar for 'having it all' anyway isn't it? If it was having it all that we were after, surely we'd be looking for a beachfront pad in Monaco a private jet and Brad Pitt as well as having children.

Anyway yea I'd make my decision again! I was able to be a SAHM for a bit when they were v little then went back to work. Worked great but everyone has different financial situations etc so I guess it's different for us all. Much respect from me for all SAHM and working mum's.

Swipe left for the next trending thread