Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are a "working mum" or a "career mum", would you make the same decision again?

215 replies

SchoolFairNostalgia · 25/06/2023 18:10

This is inspired by another thread (but not a TAAT) about how many women end up "doing it all" in the process of trying to "have it all".

I'm a mum with a career. Busted a gut to train with babies and toddlers, and am now the main breadwinner in our house and work more hours than my DH (and earn the large majority of our income). Very lucky to have a great husband - truly one of the good'uns, and a fantastic dad to the DC. However, I still think a disproportionate amount of mental/household/family load falls on me, inevitably, as the woman. Of course there are exceptions, but on average, I reckon it's pretty indisputable(?) that this happens in our society, for mums who work for money outside the home as much or more than their husbands/partners do.

My question: is it still worth it?
If I'm honest, I might have tried to work out something different, if I had my time again - something with more traditional sex/gender roles.

So, for other "working/career mums":

YABU - no, I would totally go for a career/job/breadwinner status again

YANBU - yeah, given my time again, I'd not focus so much on career (and look for alternative like try to get DH to earn more/train, etc.??)

OP posts:
3sthemagicnumber · 26/06/2023 12:14

This is so interesting, and so hard to have a conversation about without it becoming judgemental/people feeling judged.

I took 6 years off work when my kids were little - a combination of factors, including relocation and three kids in 18 months meant if didn't feel like there was much of a choice to make really. One of the kids was high needs/often ill and would have been hard to combine with a job too.

Now, I am part-time, self-employed. I'm well paid for the area I live in, and totally flexible about how much I work and when I do it. I'm hugely lucky, and it worked brilliantly with primary age kids. I have always been the 'default parent' - DH is a very caring and involved dad, but has a demanding job and earns 10x what I do.

I'm just starting to wonder if I would/could/should have done things differently. We have a nice lifestyle - DH is sufficiently senior that he is able to set his own hours and fit work in around family stuff to a far greater extent than 10 or 15 years ago; I still really value being around the whole time and able to see the kids when they get in from school/college/facilitate their lives after-school etc. But I wonder if I would be more personally satisfied if I had a 'proper' job. I also wonder if we would be modelling something better for the kids than the relatively traditional home set-up that we have. Saying all that, I recognise how lucky I am to see it as a choice.

LegendsBeyond · 26/06/2023 11:45

Yes, I’ve loved my career & it paid well. It set a great example for my DC who now also have great careers & plenty of money. It meant I also have a 50k a year pension which I’m looking forward to enjoying.

Scottishskifun · 26/06/2023 11:37

I wouldn't change being a career mum for love nor money! It keeps me sane and my children have benefited from socialisation at nursery.

Notoironing · 26/06/2023 11:31

I work in a senior role in professional services as does my dh. If I had my time again I’d have chosen a different career as although I enjoy it, clients expect 24/7 availability and it’s just not compatible with family life. I do like working though but in all honesty for our family we just aren’t doing well enough for our children, simple as that.

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/06/2023 11:30

Draconis · 26/06/2023 11:01

I don't like the 'sold a lie' nonsense. Say it's true and all us women realised we were sold a lie and then we all decided to come to our senses and devote our lives to our family henceforth. Where would that leave us as a society?
No women drs, teachers, mps, actors, solicitors and so on.
It would be awful and take us back a few centuries.
Thank goodness we have a choice.

Thank you.

I always find it particularly insulting that the people who bang on about women having been "sold a lie" always imagine that working mums are storming around in corporate offices with huge shoulderpads, ball-busting their way through the Boardroom with big hair and three-inch Manolos like something out of a bad 80s movie while their kids languish in Dickensian-style childcare settings. It's such a load of old shit.

In fact probably a majority of working mums work in the public sector and in teaching, nursing or caring professions. Without working mums many schools and the NHS would grind to a halt overnight.

Welshwabbit · 26/06/2023 11:10

I'm a barrister. My husband also works, but in a less demanding role. At the beginning I did shoulder the greater childcare load, but now he does much more than I do. He is absolutely great and I couldn't have managed to do the job I do without such a supportive husband. My kids are still primary age (the eldest about to go into secondary) so it may all change, but as things stand, yes, I would absolutely do it again.

mindutopia · 26/06/2023 11:07

Yes, definitely. Honestly what I find stressful about life as a parent is all the parenting. It wouldn't be made easier if I had all day to clean the house. I still have to pick the kids up and deal with the fighting and cook meals and do bath and bedtime. I'm not the only one who does these things. Dh does too. But it's still not very enjoyable. They still fucking drive me up the wall screaming about who ate the last ice lolly and I a little bit want to get in my car and drive away. I wouldn't want to do that any less if I'd been at home doing the washing all day or been working. It's still hard work. But my career means I do have a nice house that I really love and I have hobbies I get a lot of enjoyment out of and I can travel. I wouldn't have these things if I was a SAHM because I wouldn't be able to afford them.

BarleySugars · 26/06/2023 11:06

I envisaged being a SAHM with a part time job once kiddos got a bit older so i could have a bit of a foot in both camps as i like to work, pay my way and be stimulated etc. Unfortunately my husband had other ideas and bankrupted me and chucked me out so i've got no choice about being on the hamster wheel AND trying to be a great mum. Given my time again i would like a supportive partner willing to man up for his offspring and go back to plan A.

Catspyjamas17 · 26/06/2023 11:02

Draconis · 26/06/2023 11:01

I don't like the 'sold a lie' nonsense. Say it's true and all us women realised we were sold a lie and then we all decided to come to our senses and devote our lives to our family henceforth. Where would that leave us as a society?
No women drs, teachers, mps, actors, solicitors and so on.
It would be awful and take us back a few centuries.
Thank goodness we have a choice.

This.

Draconis · 26/06/2023 11:01

I don't like the 'sold a lie' nonsense. Say it's true and all us women realised we were sold a lie and then we all decided to come to our senses and devote our lives to our family henceforth. Where would that leave us as a society?
No women drs, teachers, mps, actors, solicitors and so on.
It would be awful and take us back a few centuries.
Thank goodness we have a choice.

SerafinasGoose · 26/06/2023 10:53

GCSister · 26/06/2023 10:23

Exactly. See also this unpleasant narrative which suggests that women who work do so because they are "materialistic", with unpleasant segues about not needing more shoes or a sports car. As if a life of Puritanical, penny-pinching dependence (either on a man or on the state) in order to facilitate spending your entire life running around after children, long after the point when they actually need it, was somehow morally superior.

Oh yes. This infuriates me!
The suggestion that women who work once they've had children are choosing fancy holidays, cars and handbags over spending time with their children.

Ha! Amusing, especially given I live in DMs and Converses. The former, in particular, keep going practically forever (although I confess I do keep buying more)!

The further issue being, children are not small for long. Step out of my profession and you're never getting back in. It's that simple. Once you're out of the curve on the research side - and the sector in itself is not in the best of states compared with the way it's been in the past - that's your window of opportunity closed. It took me seven years on a meagre income to qualify.

If I'd given up work to stay at home full-time, what on earth was I to do with the remainder of my life once my child (now 9) no longer needed me? Paint oil canvasses and volunteer for wildlife and the local bat trust, I guess. I will always find something interesting to keep my occupied, but I want to be a productive member of society and to work to the benefit of others. I have a brain in my head, and I want to use it.

Emotionalstorm · 26/06/2023 10:36

Whatames · 26/06/2023 10:31

I’ve worked full time with 4 kids and tried to get promotions etc. I’ve had a bit of an epiphany and realised I was just juggling and existing and actually one of us needed to create more space for the family. I’m a teacher and love my job but my partner earns much more so I have decided to go 4 days a week and just be a really good teacher rather than seeking promotion etc. I don’t want my life to be like that anymore and want to have more work life balance. I would t want to be a SAHM tho. Too much risk if it all
goes tits up, want a bit of my own identity and want to she my daughters how to contribute out of thr home

Yes my partner has been encouraging me to become a SAHM so I can spend more time with my daughter since I no longer enjoy my job. Also I will never make partner in my firm after going part time for three years so I can never progress beyond senior associate. My career is basically dead. I am worried about become completely dependent on him though.

Whatames · 26/06/2023 10:31

I’ve worked full time with 4 kids and tried to get promotions etc. I’ve had a bit of an epiphany and realised I was just juggling and existing and actually one of us needed to create more space for the family. I’m a teacher and love my job but my partner earns much more so I have decided to go 4 days a week and just be a really good teacher rather than seeking promotion etc. I don’t want my life to be like that anymore and want to have more work life balance. I would t want to be a SAHM tho. Too much risk if it all
goes tits up, want a bit of my own identity and want to she my daughters how to contribute out of thr home

RonObvious · 26/06/2023 10:26

GCSister · 26/06/2023 08:56

Life is not work unless you are absolutely desperate for money it's understandable if not you need to find a life outside of work!

What a patronising response!

YOU might feel this way but others view life/work differently.
My career is a huge part of my identity and my life.

I agree with this. If I didn't have my job, I would still do aspects of it for fun. It's who I am.

GCSister · 26/06/2023 10:23

Exactly. See also this unpleasant narrative which suggests that women who work do so because they are "materialistic", with unpleasant segues about not needing more shoes or a sports car. As if a life of Puritanical, penny-pinching dependence (either on a man or on the state) in order to facilitate spending your entire life running around after children, long after the point when they actually need it, was somehow morally superior.

Oh yes. This infuriates me!
The suggestion that women who work once they've had children are choosing fancy holidays, cars and handbags over spending time with their children.

BrioLover · 26/06/2023 10:21

I'd do the same again, staying in work and keeping my career going. I have two boys and think it is important for them to see that I go to work, I am an equal to DH. DH also pulls his weight in the home, although I carry more mental load. That is my nature though, I am a planner and he is not. However when there is a disaster (like our dishwasher packed in last week) DH sorts it so that my life remains largely unaffected.

SpringleDingle · 26/06/2023 10:12

I am a divorced career mum. My career allowed me to divorce once the marriage became untenable without significant financial issues. I own my home, I can afford for us to holiday and live as we please. I'd also be bored as a SAHM. It's horses for courses but my choice suited me and my DD. It did help that I worked from home throughout her life so I am here even if I am on the phone a lot!!

Assignedtoworryyourmother · 26/06/2023 10:10

My mum was a SAHM and growing up I was embarrassed about that, so was always very keen to have a career myself. My job is not my life, but it's hugely important to me and being a person who stays home was not and is not for me.

SunscreenCentral · 26/06/2023 10:10

I did SAHM for 2 years or so after second dc. I nearly went mad. No thanks.

Hiddendoor · 26/06/2023 10:09

I don't regret working or keeping my career going. If I didn't enjoy my profession and my job was "just" a job then I may have felt differently.

DH did compressed hours in his last job, 4.5 days a week. I think he was worried he'd be seen as a slacker but there was no impact on work and he got to pick the kids up from school and kick about with them for a bit which they all enjoyed.

PriOn1 · 26/06/2023 10:09
  1. I think I might have just had one child.
  2. I would have chosen a better man. It should have been possible.
  3. I would definitely prioritize keeping on with my career as I let it slide and now am looking at working for a long time as my pension suffered badly.
Catspyjamas17 · 26/06/2023 10:09

If I had my time again I'd probably, if possible, organise things so I could have a proper career break and be at home longer with DDs when they were small. But I wouldn't choose to pursue a low-earning non-career job, no way.

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/06/2023 10:05

@SerafinasGoose

Again, the implication behind this is greedy, 'selfish' women wanting their slice of the workplace.

Exactly. See also this unpleasant narrative which suggests that women who work do so because they are "materialistic", with unpleasant segues about not needing more shoes or a sports car. As if a life of Puritanical, penny-pinching dependence (either on a man or on the state) in order to facilitate spending your entire life running around after children, long after the point when they actually need it, was somehow morally superior.

TripleDaisySummer · 26/06/2023 10:03

There is no one option and no options that doesn't come with compromised and downsides and men in our society do face those facts less often than mothers.

When my kid were little I found huge pressure and judgement as many seemed to want me to do same with my children as they did as if that somehow validated their choices. I had a Mum friend who was similar around work/mothering - she tried every combination and when she moved to next work/life combination on was judgemental and scathing about mothers doing different even if their circumstances were different - it felt similar looking for everyone to do same to validate her as she was so unwilling to accept there wasn't a perfect solution.

Wishing changes nothing - you move forward making best choices with limited information that you have and with situation open to change with time- juggling with work children balance changes as they grow being SAHM is fun in early days but hard when you try and re-enter workplace and implication hit later.

Emotionalstorm · 26/06/2023 09:52

I'm working part time currently (three days a week) with a three year old and I know I will get a lot of hate for saying this but if I could go back in time I just wouldn't have my kid. I love her to bits and she's the love of my life. I've tried spend more time with her in her early years but my career has been greatly compromised and I can't focus on grinding the way I used to with such an adorable dumpling at home.