Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take my daughter’s pocket money off her?

130 replies

Badabingy · 25/06/2023 16:48

So yesterday I travelled 300 miles to see my 80 year old dad. He’s frail, and because of the distance (and work/ kids) we don’t see each other often - couple of times a year.
In the middle of lunch with him and my brother/ his family, my phone started to ping. 14 year old daughter and husband had had an argument about her refusing to take the dog out (a dog he conceded in getting on the basis he wasn’t responsible for it). He told her that if she didn’t walk the dog he wouldn’t be paying for her hair to be cut that afternoon. This was an appointment I’d made for her with my own hairdresser. She started to call/ text me constantly (angry rather than upset). I reminded her I was at lunch with her grandad, said she needed to take it up with her dad, and to cancel the appointment if she wasn’t going (I sent her the number). I also told my husband this, and because the angry texts from her were stressing and distracting me I turned my phone off.
She didn’t go to the hairdressers, no one cancelled it, and so I told her her pocket money would be zero until she’s paid for it (I’m going to call the hairdressers tomorrow when they are open and apologise and pay).
Things have escalated today- she’s screamed at me about her pocket money (I ended up taking her phone away), and called me a lazy cow for not organising her birthday party (I’d asked her weeks ago what she wanted to do and it was just last week she actually made a decision- I hadn’t sorted as I’d been at work and then away all yesterday. I told her if she was going to talk to me like that there was no way I was organising or indeed paying for a birthday party- it’s not an entitlement and we already have a day out planned as a family on her actual birthday).
I feel really miserable- things have got completely out of control. I’m really annoyed with my husband too because his bad handling of the situation yesterday led to this, but I’m now the focus of all her anger.
not sure what to do? Maybe I just ride it out.
am I being unreasonable to take her pocket money off her?
(btw I’m not averse to her earning money by doing jobs around the house so it’s not as though she’s got no means to get money if she needs it).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cinnamonfrenchtoast · 26/06/2023 13:16

I don't think it's unfair that she's having to pay the costs from her pocket money though

We'll have to agree to disagree.

Her mum booked the haircut and dad agreed to take her and pay. That was the agreement. It wasn't a case of "I'll only take you if you walk the dog" - that was a random condition added on at the last minute because dad didn't want her sat in bed on her phone all morning.

Dad issued the last-minute ultimatum therefore dad should pay.

luckylavender · 26/06/2023 13:10

I think her Dad should have dealt with this really without you having to be disturbed. He's the grown up.

elessar · 26/06/2023 13:03

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 26/06/2023 11:21

The responsibility is a bit of a red herring though in this situation, as even had the daughter not suggested she would help care for the dog, it would not be unreasonable for her father to ask her to walk it

I agree that it's not unreasonable for her to walk it as part of her chores - what's unreasonable is that she's now being made to pay for a haircut she never booked to begin with because her dad came up with a silly punishment.

I agree (and I said in my first post) that it was a silly punishment, but only because it wasn't fair on the hairdresser, as it's not something that could be cancelled without consequence to somebody completely innocent in the situation.

I don't think it's unfair that she's having to pay the costs from her pocket money though. She had a choice, all she had to do to a. Have the haircut and b. Not have to pay for it - is get up and help her dad walk the dog. He didn't spring the consequences on her as a surprise after she refused, she was aware of what would happen if she didn't do what he'd asked and she made an active decision not to comply regardless.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 26/06/2023 11:21

The responsibility is a bit of a red herring though in this situation, as even had the daughter not suggested she would help care for the dog, it would not be unreasonable for her father to ask her to walk it

I agree that it's not unreasonable for her to walk it as part of her chores - what's unreasonable is that she's now being made to pay for a haircut she never booked to begin with because her dad came up with a silly punishment.

elessar · 26/06/2023 11:14

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 25/06/2023 21:36

Also a bit baffled by the idea that a teen can never be expected to be responsible or to look after an animal. I was allowed to get a pony when I was 14 on the proviso I did all the care and also got a job to help pay the bills, and I absolutely did...

But the point people are making is that ultimately, a minor cannot be held responsible for the welfare of an animal. Any parent buying an animal for their minor child is agreeing to take full responsibility for for that animal.

At 14, you can't legally be held responsible for a pet - you can't take out insurance or agree to surgery or be taken to court if it causes an accident. You may have agreed to do the care but if you'd refused or been unable for some reason, your parents would have had to step up and either take over or sell the pony.

Of course, legally that would be the case, and of course had I refused then my parents would have had to ensure the pony was cared for (until it could be sold). But it doesn't mean it was unreasonable for them to expect me to take responsibility and uphold the commitment I had made. And had I refused, it would have been more than acceptable for them to impose whatever sanction they deemed appropriate.

The responsibility is a bit of a red herring though in this situation, as even had the daughter not suggested she would help care for the dog, it would not be unreasonable for her father to ask her to walk it.

weirdo123 · 26/06/2023 09:23

She's a brat. U did the right thing. Don't give in

LaMaG · 26/06/2023 09:18

I think maybe the issue was driving her to the appointment not getting the hair cut itself. 'If you don't get off that phone you can forget about a lift to your appointment..' in hindsight it seems unrelated but I'm sure it was an instant decision not some long thought out consequence. Probably cos she was being a stroppy brat ignoring him. I do find 'walk with me' to be a bit odd. I'd walk over hot coals before with my Dad at that age. Absolutely no excuse for how she treated you OP.

I am gobsmacked by posters who say she is too young to make a phone call - I get the argument that she shouldn't have to but that's different. If anyone at 14 is incapable of making an appointment related phone call then I think you have much greater problems.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 26/06/2023 09:09

fancreek · 26/06/2023 09:02

Only on mumsnet would a father issuing a consequence and following through be deemed as 'the issue'

Your husband did nothing wrong and your daughter is acting awfully, hold firm.

His sex is irrelevant.

He picked a stupid punishment that impacted multiple people rather than one that would only impact his DD.

fancreek · 26/06/2023 09:02

Only on mumsnet would a father issuing a consequence and following through be deemed as 'the issue'

Your husband did nothing wrong and your daughter is acting awfully, hold firm.

rookiemere · 26/06/2023 08:11

Also sounds like your DH deliberately escalated things. Did he really need DD to walk the dog with him as she was already going out to hairdressers so wouldn't have been sat in her room all day anyway?

I would see how much hairdressers will charge and take it from there. I don't think either your DH or your DD acted particularly well and you shouldn't have got involved after the event, so if there is a way to draw a line under the event I'd try for that.

rookiemere · 26/06/2023 08:03

I think how you handled it initially was perfect. DH was there so he should have taken the parenting decisions. I wouldn't then have waded in when you got back.

I'd tell her next time she comes and visits her DGD - which surely she should be doing a few times a year anyway.

But sympathies it is hard, particularly when they play off one DP against the other. I've just secretly given DS17 some money for a break with friends as I know DH will just kick off about it , so I'm hardly one to talk.

chemistnightmare · 26/06/2023 08:02

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 26/06/2023 07:35

Was it even enough notice to cancel, and not have pay?

No. That's the whole point of the thread - OP is taking the pocket money from her to pay for the missed appointment

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 26/06/2023 07:35

Was it even enough notice to cancel, and not have pay?

Sigmama · 26/06/2023 07:23

*dog

Sigmama · 26/06/2023 07:23

It's not about whether the child should have walked the dig or not, it's about your dh not taking control of the situation so that the 2nd parent 300 miles away didn't need to get involved, he's a twat

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 26/06/2023 06:51

She was told to cancel the appointment if she wasn't going. She didn't. She should feel the consequence of that.

Why would she ring and cancel an appointment she didn't even make in the first place, and that she was quite happy to go to?

Her dad should ring and cancel if he wants to issue stupid punishments. His choice to refuse to take her - he's the one who should be cancelling and paying the hairdresser for the inconvenience, not her.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 26/06/2023 06:49

Bollocks. Of course you don't get a dog on the whim of a child but at the same time, walking the dog is a family task and sometimes a teenager will be asked to do it as part of being in the family. Sounds like this girl wasn't even expected to walk the dog on her own!

Again, for what feels like the hundredth time, I don't disagree with you. Dog walking is a household chore in the same way as vacuuming or loading the dishwasher.

What I do disagree with is the way OP has said she expects her daughter to want to walk the dog and to show interest in it because she's the one who asked it. She's fourteen - of course she doesn't want to waste her Sunday morning walking the dog anymore than she wants to spend it tidying her room or doing homework.

I also disagree with the way the DH handled the situation - trying to force her to walk the dog or she'd have to cancel and pay for a hair appointment she didn't even make in the first place! The whole thing makes no sense.

If she was refusing to walk the dog, why not pick any other number of consequences?

Gytgyt · 26/06/2023 05:37

@WiddlinDiddlin I agree.
@WilkinsonM why would DD cancel her own appointment your saying it like it was a positive thing to do. Like the other poster has pointed out!

WilkinsonM · 26/06/2023 05:13

WiddlinDiddlin · 26/06/2023 04:44

I think its him I'd be pissed off at more...

His responsibility to discipline in a way that is effective and practical.

Making her miss an appointment that will still cost you money is neither.

Then making her pay for it... she's already been punished for not walking the dog by not having her hair cut.... so now she's being punished for not having her hair cut too.... lose lose situation.

It sounds like it is your dog, and he picked a battle he knew he wouldn't actually win in trying to bully her into walking the dog with him when she was doing something else so would not want to.

Suddenly springing extra conditions on things at the last minute and backing a teenager into a corner over such things is a foolish pursuit.

I think you've all handled this badly, her included but she does at least have the viable excuse that she is a hormonal adolescent - you and your DH are presumably, not!

She was told to cancel the appointment if she wasn't going. She didn't. She should feel the consequence of that.

WilkinsonM · 26/06/2023 05:12

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 25/06/2023 20:35

She's fourteen years old. Of course she doesn't want to get up and walk the dog.

It makes so angry when people get pets because their child has promised to walk them, or feed them, or clean up after them - it never happens.

Common sense should tell you that you don't get a dog on the whim of a child. They're too young and immature to understand what they're agreeing to and it inevitably always ends up with the parents doing all the work and getting increasingly resentful and angry.

Parents should only get a pet (be that a hamster, a dog or a horse) if they're willing to step up and do everything involved in their care.

Bollocks. Of course you don't get a dog on the whim of a child but at the same time, walking the dog is a family task and sometimes a teenager will be asked to do it as part of being in the family. Sounds like this girl wasn't even expected to walk the dog on her own!

OP your DD was being awful and still is. Your husband is a twat for threatening a punishment that impacted negatively on you. Does he accept that?

Theoldgreygoose · 26/06/2023 04:56

EasterBreak · 25/06/2023 17:58

Sounds like you're husband is the problem and caused all the drama and frustration. She's a 14 year old child.

Is a 14 year old child not capable of taking a dog for a walk? That was all she had to do, he didn't ask her to work down a mine.

WiddlinDiddlin · 26/06/2023 04:44

I think its him I'd be pissed off at more...

His responsibility to discipline in a way that is effective and practical.

Making her miss an appointment that will still cost you money is neither.

Then making her pay for it... she's already been punished for not walking the dog by not having her hair cut.... so now she's being punished for not having her hair cut too.... lose lose situation.

It sounds like it is your dog, and he picked a battle he knew he wouldn't actually win in trying to bully her into walking the dog with him when she was doing something else so would not want to.

Suddenly springing extra conditions on things at the last minute and backing a teenager into a corner over such things is a foolish pursuit.

I think you've all handled this badly, her included but she does at least have the viable excuse that she is a hormonal adolescent - you and your DH are presumably, not!

TwoPairsOfPantsAndAMohairVest · 26/06/2023 03:41

I wouldn't take her pocket money for not walking the dog at lunchtime when it's so hot. She could do that later. But I would for calling me a bitch. She's taking you for granted OP. That's really poor behaviour from her.

whats the situation like at home now? You must be stuck between two similar sounding strong headed people. If you didn't have work id stay with your family!

Plasticplantpot · 25/06/2023 22:40

Personally I think your husband was really nasty to say he wouldn’t pay for her hair cut. I don’t see the link between the two events and I don’t see why a small business owner should suffer because he’s realised his DD is a person and not a robot he can control. Doubly mortifying that it’s your hairdresser too, OP. It was too hot to walk a dog midday this weekend anyway, so completely something your DH could have avoided.

justasking111 · 25/06/2023 22:38

Badabingy · 25/06/2023 19:58

The even more frustrating thing is she’s now point blank ignoring me while laughing and joking with him😩.

Your husband should be backing you up. He's not her mate he's her father. I'd be angry if mine did this