Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Needing help from both side of the family?

92 replies

Sarahmille80 · 25/06/2023 13:53

At the end of 2021 I had a life changing illness.

This has resulted in me having to have surgeries. Whilst I’m recovering from surgery I’m pretty much unable to leave sofa/bed for 8-12 weeks.

We have 2 DS 8 year old and 5 year old.

So as you can imagine we have needed a lot of help with the boys/school runs/pick ups etc. DH works full time.

The first time I had my surgery it was unexpected, everyone in my family rallied round to help look after me and the boys-most of this responsibility fell on the shoulders of my mother. She’s in her 70’s this was up in the morning to help me, get the boys ready, take them to school, back to pick them up in the afternoon, give them tea she also did little jobs like the washing etc. My auntie was cooking meals for us and bringing them round. My MIL offered to come and help only when I was in hospital-hubby was off work and declined and said he needed the help when he goes back to work.

As you can imagine it didn’t take long for this to all become too much for my poor mum. We reached out to my MIL to see if she can help with a school pick up once a week-she refused and said it’s my mum’s responsibility to do it and she only lives 5 minutes away and really couldn’t understand why she doesn’t want too, she then went on to say a lot of nasty things about my mum and myself. I actually resulted in a big family feud between MIL, DH and myself. DH on my side as MiL is very bitter and twisted and a difficult woman.

MIL reluctantly apologised and surgery 2 she offered to come and do some cleaning for us (only at weekends when DH was home) which just involved her sitting around drinking tea, not cleaning anything apart from a little dusting. Following DH around and generally being more of a hindrance. We said again it’s childcare we need help with.

Surgery 3 is now in the pipeline-we are now aware of what we need to make life easier and employed a childminder to pick up a few times a week and to have over the school holidays and a cleaner once a week. We have asked MIL to do 6 school pick ups. Since asking she’s already dropped out of 2 as she had appointment (morning I might add) and she’s now making noises that she might not be able to do the others due to further appointments. As this is a planned surgery for myself I feel like she could arrange her appointments accordingly.

This is now causing constant ongoing rows between myself and my DH I’m miffed this is a huge nightmare that we are living as a family that she thinks it’s ok to not to put herself out for a few weeks to help us.

She is not close to the her grandchildren. She does not interact with them at all she is very awkward and cold around them.

She has my nephew twice a week after school and twice a week in the holidays.

I’m really struggling to be civil to her and hate it when my DH meets up with her like everything is ok. Even though he fully agrees that it’s not ok what she is doing.

At the end of the day the children are our responsibility but I do not feel we’ve been unreasonable to ask for support at a time when family should come together.

OP posts:
Secondwindplease · 25/06/2023 15:19

To be honest I think you’ve imposed enough on your mother and MIL already. It’s your husbands job to pick up the slack when you’re unwell and if he has to take parental leave then so be it.

Drives me barmy when people think that older women’s time is just freely available for them to tax as they see fit.

RidingMyBike · 25/06/2023 15:16

TBH I've found friends to be a lot more help than family. We had zero family help when DD was born and I had health problems.

I have however provided a lot of practical help to a friend in a similar situation to you with major surgery and 3 young children. But the family outsourced as much as possible by using wraparound childcare and paying for a cleaner. Could a different friend help you out on different days? That's what we've done with a family at school when the mum was having cancer treatment.

I hope everything goes smoothly for your operation.

Sarahmille80 · 25/06/2023 15:16

I agree with you, he shouldn’t need help cleaning the home! We have never asked MiL for this, she offered as an excuse to come and see him at the weekend.

We have paid a cleaner to start after my surgery.

OP posts:
peeinthepool · 25/06/2023 15:14

Sounds like a very difficult situation but no one has the right to expect unpaid childcare from grandparents.

alltoomuchrightnow · 25/06/2023 15:11

I would never in a million years expect or ask ANY member of my family to come round and do anything for me,, least of all, cleaning. Never have, never will.
Even when I was home alone with a broken shoulder and therefore couldn't drive (and live middle of nowhere) I managed alone. No member of family visited . I just got on with it all one armed in a lot of pain. It wasn't fun, admittedly.
but no.. I'd never ask for cleaning

nevynevster · 25/06/2023 15:10

JobzaGoodun · 25/06/2023 15:02

It's nice if families can/want to rally round, but it should never be an expectation as it's not a responsibility.

You need to add your MIL to the same list as the father, father in law, and brother who also cannot/will not help.

Yes, I am truly sorry to hear you have such life changing illness and I am sure so many surgeries must be very stressful.

However this seems a lot of demands on your family to help and whilst I am sure some of my family would pitch in if I were in your situation, not all of them would.

It's quite reasonable to ask, it's also reasonable of them to refuse. They don't need to justify to you. Maybe MIL feels like she hasn't bonded with the Kids, maybe she feels your mum gets all the grandma love and she gets none. Maybe she just isn't that into kids !

I can't believe your DH work wouldn't allow him some time off to help eg leaving early and I think you need more help than a childminder. By the sounds of it you really need a nanny or mother's help ie someone who can do everything that is needed and can be relied upon. Childminders are great but you are incapacitated and you need way more help than this, including a cleaner too.

Good luck and try to focus on your health and recovery and just forget expectations on relatives.

Playdoughcaterpillar · 25/06/2023 15:09

Lots of students around this time of year that would be keen for a few hours babysitting. Ask on a local mums group?

JobzaGoodun · 25/06/2023 15:02

It's nice if families can/want to rally round, but it should never be an expectation as it's not a responsibility.

You need to add your MIL to the same list as the father, father in law, and brother who also cannot/will not help.

Sarahmille80 · 25/06/2023 15:01

We ask for no help from my MiL and this time we have asked under exceptional circumstances.

All through covid I did all her shopping as she didn’t want to go to the supermarket and hubby delivered it there every single week. Which I have not given another thought to until now.

OP posts:
RedHandGangMember · 25/06/2023 15:00

You can't change who she is.

I agree. You've asked her and asked her and asked her. She doesn't want to.

If there are not a few gaps then your husband will have to fill them. Or one of his friends or one of your friends. Something like that. Because your MIL isn't going to do it.

Sarahmille80 · 25/06/2023 14:59

Yes he has, he’s going in late sometimes to drop them off to breakfast club.

OP posts:
AhNowTed · 25/06/2023 14:57

Has your DH made no adjustments..

Has he approached his company to temporarily change his hours?

Expecting all of this to fall on elderly parents is a bit much.

Sarahmille80 · 25/06/2023 14:57

Thank you

OP posts:
BigChesterDraws · 25/06/2023 14:57

Is this related to the accident you had? If so, I’d there anyway way to claim for professional help (cleaner, child minder, etc) through the insurance or the responsible party?

Screwballs · 25/06/2023 14:56

I'm finding your tone difficult to sympathise with. Yes its lovely if everyone helps everyone, but no, families aren't there to have demands made of them. You also make no mention of what you/DP do for your mother or MIL that leads you to believe they should be be owing you all this.

I'm sorry you are ill, but you are sounding quite entitled here.

MrsJellycat · 25/06/2023 14:52

It's shitty when family won't step in and help. My family was the same when I was unwell a few years ago. Let's just say I won't be caring for my parents in their old age.

Is there a FB group for parents of the school your kids go to? On the one for the primary school my kids went to there used to be lots of posts asking for help with school pick ups for situations like yours. Other parents and grandparents were always only too happy to help out, even if they didn't know the parent requesting help.

I think most decent people will try to help someone if they're unwell like you are

NowItsSpring · 25/06/2023 14:51

Your MIL has shown you who she is and unfortunately she is unlikely to change. Have you spoken to school? Is there another parent who lives nearby who might help. I do regular school runs 3 days a week for my grandchildren and was approached to see if I would be willing to help a family who were struggling in similar circumstances. I literally walked past the end of their road so did drop offs when needed. School staff also helped out a couple of days.

billy1966 · 25/06/2023 14:46

Different issues.

Your husband shouldn't be requiring help cleaning the home, women certainly wouldn't if the situation was reversed and I think you are out of order in this case, by all means pay a cleaner to come in.

His mother doesn't want to help and that is clear.

This is one of those times where you need to approach the school for help with someone in the class who lives near you, that might help.
Would a neighbour help, or know a teen that might?

Let your husband navigate his own relationship with his mother, but once well you need never feel the need to engage with her again.

She is allowed to choose not to be involved and you are allowed to choose how you respond going forward.

You can't change who she is.

Focus your energies on getting help from elsewhere.

Would an au pair make sense?

Topee · 25/06/2023 14:43

Your DH should be asking work for temporary flexible hours.

It’s lovely if family are willing and able to help, but they are not obligated to do so and for whatever reason your MIL doesn’t want to.

If your husband changed his hours then you could relieve your Mum of helping every day too if she struggled last time.

Willyoujustbequiet · 25/06/2023 14:37

TheYearOfSmallThings · 25/06/2023 14:13

Can your husband not get the children up and out in the morning? Are your father and FIL deceased or not around?

There just seems to be an assumption that if you can't do it then obviously your mother and MIL should, but it sounds like a lot for elderly women to take on.

This

I don't understand why you need so much help. Millions of single parents manage to work and sort school runs and childcare by themselves.

chopc · 25/06/2023 14:34

As this is elective surgery, I suggest you make plans for the other 20% of the time as well.

It is also a big deal for your mum to commit to coming over every single day for 6-8 weeks except the weekends . I am glad she is OK with it but be aware that this is a big ask

ThunderStormPlease · 25/06/2023 14:32

Your DH needs to be flexible on those days, don't ask her for anything else. Infact when she needs your help one day and it will happen, remind her of this.

NerrSnerr · 25/06/2023 14:30

For whatever reason she can't/ doesn't want to help so you need to sort it elsewhere. What about your dad? Does he have a long commute or is he working 11-12 hours 5 days a week? Can your children be difficult to manage at times? Could that be the reason?

ModeWeasel · 25/06/2023 14:29

Sorry you have had a tough time. It would be nice if people helped out. However you are not entitled to help from anyone so if the answer is no I would just let it go and use your energy elsewhere.

YouveGotAFastCar · 25/06/2023 14:29

Are families not supposed to help in times of need?

Well yes, ideally, if they can. But she can't, like your brother can't, and your FIL can't - either because she genuinely has appointments she can't/doesn't want to rearrange, or because she's struggling to look after them.

You need a different solution. It'd be ideal if she could do more, but she can't, and arguing with your husband won't change that - so stop asking her to do things. My pride would stop me asking her to do anything, you might feel differently. Could you have a back-up childminder? Ask friends?

Swipe left for the next trending thread