Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In thinking my friend has the right to change her locks?

88 replies

Moonflower12 · 25/06/2023 13:39

A friend ( let's call her Pansy) has recently split from her partner of 10+ years. He ( 'John') instigated the split.

She was unaware it was going to happen until he went to a rented flat in another town. This was 10 days ago.

Pansy owns the house outright. No mortgage and only her name on the deeds.

John wants some of his stuff back. Nothing of great value. It's sentimental.

Pansy has given him ( on text) a few convenient dates to come and collect his stuff. He has been busy on theses dates. At a festival tbh.

She has now changed the locks on the house. Is this legal? John is claiming he will bring the police and force an entry? How likely is this?

Having offered numerous dates, is it legal to put his stuff out on the drive so he can collect it at his leisure? Will she be liable in any way for it, if it's stolen or damaged?

Thank you for any help. This is stressing her out.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Moonflower12 · 28/06/2023 20:20

@sodthesodoff
You were right!
He came at 3pm in the end-having agreed this time with Pansy.
She had just put his stuff out on the drive. He drove up. She filmed him arriving and then drove off. He took it all.
He apparently has now paid the electricity bill. And having been to CAB he has discovered he has no claim over the ring so she's keeping it for now and may sell it if she has a rainy day.

Thank you for all your help Vipers. Pansy is very grateful as I forwarded the thread to her.

OP posts:
sodthesodoff · 27/06/2023 15:12

Sorry if I've missed it but can someone be there with her when he comes tonight?

He sounds all bluster and someone who'll falter with witnesses to his shit behaviour.

Gettingfleeced · 26/06/2023 22:19

If she is really worried about him coming along with a locksmith or the police, can she stick a note on the door/window saying "FAO JOHN - if you are reading this, please respond to my texts of [insert dates] to arrange collection of your stuff."

Watchkeys · 26/06/2023 22:06

Oh right. Well, the police won't come due to the fact that they can't agree on a date and time to collect his stuff. I'd offer a few more available times and actively request that he brings a police officer. And tell him he's welcome to bring a police officer over whenever he wants, at any time of his choosing.

He'll have a lot of trouble obtaining a police officer to do the job (given that there's no job for them to do), but that's not Pansy's problem.

Moonflower12 · 26/06/2023 20:47

@Watchkeys

It went like this :

P: I'd like you to come and collect your stuff please. I'm available on x,y, and Z dates at these times...
J:I want to come on Monday at noon.
P: I'm at work then as you know.
J: Well, in that case as you won't agree to my terms, I'll make it a police matter.

As I said, he's an arse sometimes.

OP posts:
Watchkeys · 26/06/2023 17:07

She has now changed the locks on the house. Is this legal? John is claiming he will bring the police and force an entry? How likely is this

I don't really understand this.

P - John, I really need to you to come and get this stuff. When do you want to come?
J - No, I'm going to call the police and drop by unexpectedly and they'll break your doors down.

How are these conversations going? She's offering him something he wants. How is he making that a police matter?

Zebedee55 · 26/06/2023 16:26

DrManhattan · 25/06/2023 14:40

Change the locks. Take the stuff to a charity shop. What proof does he have that it was in her house? She could just say he came and got it. Her word against his.

She's best allowing him to collect his stuff. No need for extra drama.

Moonflower12 · 26/06/2023 16:19

Thank you everyone. He has said he'll be there on Tuesday at 7pm.
She is going to wait to see him arrive. Film that and his undamaged stuff and then drive off so he can't bang in the door etc.

OP posts:
Caroparo52 · 26/06/2023 13:47

Tell him it will be available from the charity shop from xx date if he hasn't collected it. I agree with this idea to sell the ring to fund locksmith.
Also if the complete arse does turn up, have a good friend there to oversee the removal so she's got a witness and doesn't have to see the cf

AutumnCrow · 26/06/2023 11:15

Ooh that’s fascinating and very helpful - always serve a statutory notice and record it.

I still find crap of my ExH’s in the loft. It’s been over 20 years since he left.

I’d love to serve him a notice to come get his rusty old penknife and ‘special wood’.

EsmeSusanOgg · 26/06/2023 11:02

He has voluntarily left the property (this vacating any right he had to stay, though as it is her home and she lives there these were limited anyway). He has a right to get his property back, but at a time convenient to your friend. I suggest your friend talks to the local police and asks if they can attend when he comes to collect his things to ensure there is no breach of the peace.

Watchkeys · 26/06/2023 10:58

Let him make a claim, if he wants. From what's been said already on the thread, it sounds like one appointment with a solicitor will cost him more than his lost goods, and he's very unlikely to be able to claim anything from OP because she has made reasonable attempts to give the items back.

Unless she's locked his Porsche or his high spec laptop away from him, she can just work out the value of the goods (sounds like perhaps a fiver) and keep it in an envelope by the door, in case the law comes a-knocking. There's really very little risk in giving him one more chance, making sure she has a record of the contact, and disposing of his stuff after 14 days. Neither the court nor the police would penalise her.

DrManhattan · 26/06/2023 10:19

@TitsonaFishRidingaBicycle but she has already told him several times to collect unless I've read it incorrectly

TheSeaDoesntKnowMyName · 26/06/2023 10:14

Moonflower12 · 25/06/2023 14:34

Thank you everyone. She has offered him a few times going on through this week. He hasn't replied yet to these but is clearly on the train with time to kill.
She has taken on board the advice about her liabilities towards the stuff. It is quite bulky and heavy- some of it. Fingers crossed he is sensible and agrees to a date for collecting it.

He is also demanding she returns the engagement ring he bought her. Can she keep it as it was a 'gift'?

In broad terms, an engagement ring is given as an 'absolute gift' and, as such, belongs to the person to whom it was given. The law takes no account of which partner calls off the engagement, so regardless of who broke off the relationship, the ring does not have to be given back.9 Feb 2023

If your engagement doesn't have a happy ending, who gets ...

If your engagement doesn’t have a happy ending, who gets the ring? - DAS Law

Jade Harrison provides useful insight and clarifies the legal position surrounding ownership of what is often an expensive statement of love.

https://www.daslaw.co.uk/blog/if-your-engagement-ends-badly-who-gets-the-ring#:~:text=In%20broad%20terms%2C%20an%20engagement,have%20to%20be%20given%20back.

TitsonaFishRidingaBicycle · 26/06/2023 10:13

DrManhattan · 26/06/2023 10:08

@willWillSmithsmith not sure how dumping his stuff at a charity shop and changing the locks is strange advice? Other posters have said the same.

Because he would then be able to claim against her

www.rutherfordslegal.com/how-to-dispose-of-goods-on-your-premises-that-dont-belong-to-you/

DrManhattan · 26/06/2023 10:08

@willWillSmithsmith not sure how dumping his stuff at a charity shop and changing the locks is strange advice? Other posters have said the same.

Debini · 25/06/2023 20:26

I’d say she should give the ring back, it was given to her on the basis they were going to be married. They aren’t getting married so I’m my opinion she should return it.
As for his stuff give him some times to collect, if he doesn’t chuck it all in the shed for a while if there’s room and dispose of it a few months down the line so he can’t accuse her of throwing it away.

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 25/06/2023 20:20

Just saw your update re Tuesday.

I would've advised her to email him asking him to pay the money he owes (for electricity and any other bills) and telling him that storing his stuff would incur a fee of £x per week, starting on the date he abandoned it there. And that if it wasn't collected by another date (at least 14 days in the future) it would be disposed of, again at a cost to him. And suggesting that he arrange for a cab/ van to come over to collect his stuff if he for whatever reason doesn't want to come himself before that date.

Him getting his stuff is not a police matter. His making any kind of threat against her is, potentially. And her dumping his stuff on the pavement with no warning, for other people to help themselves to, would be frowned upon legally.

She should hang on to the ring! I thought that traditionally the whole point of an engagement ring being bought and gifted by a man was to back up his promise to marry a woman, and was meant to represent some financial security to her in the case of his breaking off the engagement <which appears to be what's happened here>?

Legally, it's considered an "absolute gift" to the fiancée, and is only considered a "conditional gift" if it's 'stated' (eg the parties involved have put something in writing) or 'implied' (eg it's a family heirloom) to be so. Even if she's been the one to end it, the recipient owns the ring, and can do whatever she wants with it.

CheshireDing · 25/06/2023 20:20

If he doesn’t come on Tuesday I would do as a pp said and book a storage unit for 30 days. Text and email telling him the unit number and that the keys are with the storage company and if it’s not emptied by x date she will dump the stuff

i know it means Pansy spending money but at least it’s out of her house and there is a definite end date

yes she should change the locks on the house

drpet49 · 25/06/2023 20:09

StrawberryWater · 25/06/2023 14:39

Give it back.

Why would she want to keep hold of an engagement ring from a man who is acting like a complete and utter twat? Just give him his stuff back and be done with him. Or does she just like the drama?

This. Give the ring back.

FrippEnos · 25/06/2023 19:41

Moonflower12 · 25/06/2023 19:16

He has said he will collect the stuff on Tuesday at 7pm. Fingers crossed he will.
She is going to put it on the drive just before 7. Go in the house and film him taking it so he can't claim otherwise.
She is going to keep the ring as a bargaining tool on the electricity bill.

I will update on Tuesday as to whether he turns up.

She will need to be careful if she says that he can have it back if he pays the electricity as she is essentially saying that it belongs to him.

But I have never understood why anyone would want to keep the engagement ring when they have broken up.

LuckyCats · 25/06/2023 19:30

How much did he pay for the ring?
Resale value on engagement rings is low for obvious reasons, I can tell you that from bitter experience, my engagement ring cost £3000,
I eventually sold it for £300.
Unless it’s worth significantly more than that (I’m not getting the an impression of John this would be the case) it’s probably not worth the hassle of getting rid of it.

justrude · 25/06/2023 19:26

Moonflower12 · 25/06/2023 19:16

He has said he will collect the stuff on Tuesday at 7pm. Fingers crossed he will.
She is going to put it on the drive just before 7. Go in the house and film him taking it so he can't claim otherwise.
She is going to keep the ring as a bargaining tool on the electricity bill.

I will update on Tuesday as to whether he turns up.

Good luck to her!

Moonflower12 · 25/06/2023 19:16

He has said he will collect the stuff on Tuesday at 7pm. Fingers crossed he will.
She is going to put it on the drive just before 7. Go in the house and film him taking it so he can't claim otherwise.
She is going to keep the ring as a bargaining tool on the electricity bill.

I will update on Tuesday as to whether he turns up.

OP posts: