Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend who never pays

167 replies

Bubbles111 · 25/06/2023 11:17

Hello

I have a friend who ive known for 15 years. She has always been funny with me and has always had issues with her bank card for as long as i have known her (i.e. i cant use my card, can you buy with your card and i will transfer etc).

Anyway, she has always been in v.low paying jobs (well min wage) and had a baby unexpectedely (which obv hit finances, she has a parter, though) and with rising bills, she said they have been skint for months.

But as i said she has always been funny with money. She never pays for stuffor says she will give you money back and never does. Ive had enough. I earn 15k more than her but why should i subsidise her when she has never done that with me.

She came over to mine last night for a girls night and told me how skint she was. She kept hinting at me picking her up beforehand to save her payibg for a taxi (but i just ignored as shes 20miles away). She met me at my local shop and happily let me pay for snacks, drinks for us, all of whch she picked out. She said she would give me half - never did. She then kept saying she couldnt wait to order food (we agreed a takeaway) she then ordered £20 worth of food from my account (just eat) and said she would give me the money. She picked up her phone as if she was going to transfer but then put it back down.

We went on a short break months ago and she kept forgettibg to take her bank card on nights out or refusubg to buy food as it was too pricy but happily letting us buy drinks and food (for her!) On the alusion she woild pay back.it got to the point that I started eating less and drinking less because i didnt want to pay for her anymore.

Anyway she told our friend that we (4 friends) would arrange her baby shower. Its 1 week to go and nothing has been booked or organised becuse we are all refusing to buy anything until my friend does. Becuaee she keeps sending us ideas and asking us to all pay. I have no bother payinf for things but i am refusing because my friend is dictating all ideas and has yet to pay for 1 thing.

I am meeting her through thr week. How would you handle this?

X

OP posts:
MsRosley · 25/06/2023 14:31

I have a friend like this, known her since childhood. She's always been exactly as you describe her friend. I rarely see her now, but if we do, I make sure she can never put me in a situation where I have to pay, and I have banned my DH from ever offering to pay for her.

pimplesquisher · 25/06/2023 14:26

The number of people who are total door mats just astounds me.

StaunchMomma · 25/06/2023 14:24

I've voted YANBU but actually you have been extremely unreasonable in allowing this to go on for literally years!

Just tell her the gravy train stops here. The cost of living crisis is affecting everyone and you can no longer afford to buy things for her. She'll probably push back because she's a whacking great CF but do yourself a favour and stand firm.

2bazookas · 25/06/2023 14:23

How would you handle this?

Long ago. I would have stopped gicing in, paying for her,"lending" money that's never returned.

You can control your own behaviour. Why don't you?

UniversalAunt · 25/06/2023 14:21

“I won’t let my friend go without”

Why not?
Are you her Mummy?

ssd · 25/06/2023 14:20

Good lord.

PinkIcedCream · 25/06/2023 14:11

15 years! For goodness sake, grow a backbone and get her told!

I couldn’t be friends with someone like you who prefers to gossip and moan about another so called friend behind her back, but does feck all about solving the actual problem.

You’re really just as bad as she is with your passive aggressive stance and sitting waiting for her to make a move.

Why can’t you at least be honest with her and tell her you’re fed up with her taking the piss?

Dottielottie123 · 25/06/2023 14:05

You need to message her and say simply ‘ just noticed you haven’t sent the money for your food, please sent £__, you always do this’

get the baby shower out the way and then cut contact

Redebs · 25/06/2023 13:56

Nobody needs a baby shower if they are on a low income. Why did you suggest it?
Your friend shouldn't be throwing a party; she will need all her money for the baby.

If you don't want to pay for things when you socialise with her, then don't. Just have her over for a coffee and biscuits at your place.

Solved!

Fraaahnces · 25/06/2023 13:56

I want to know why she’s never called out on this. That would drive me nuts. Ask her why she never ever pays for anything.

Puckthemagicdragon · 25/06/2023 13:50

It's a shame it's come to a head at this moment, which should be a joyful one. Re her additional suggestions, cost them up and say, 'that's fine, it will be XX. Please can you do a bank transfer by Wednesday, otherwise we'll just go with what we have.' But if you've been passively funding her life up til now it's very poor timing to suddenly decide she has to pay for herself.

rookiemere · 25/06/2023 13:50

Also most people have encountered someone like this. I have a friend who is lovely, but very slow and somewhat cavalier about paying you back for big expense items like flights. As she is otherwise lovely, I simply refuse to put myself in the position where I have any financial responsibility for her, so for trips we book own flights and separate hotel rooms now.

Another friend pays her way but moans about the cost of everything, so again separate rooms, only eat at cheap restaurants to avoid any issues.

What I wouldn't do is continue to let someone mooch and scam me for 15 years.

LookItsMeAgain · 25/06/2023 13:49

Oh and to start establishing boundaries, the best way to do this is to follow up as quickly as possible if she doesn't pay, asking her to transfer the money for X event or Y items.
If you start now, it will get easier

ChrisPPancake · 25/06/2023 13:47

When she put her phone down after not paying you, did you not say anything? Why not? Why have you never just said no when she's asked for stuff?! Is it really too hard to say "You haven't paid me back from last time yet, so you'll have to get your own this time"?!

uncomfortablydumb53 · 25/06/2023 13:44

15 years? User is ingrained into her personality and I doubt if it would make any difference if you told her to pay up now
Ignore the baby shower completely. She has the hide of a rhino
I'm glad your other friends are on the same page

Mary46 · 25/06/2023 13:42

Stop suggesting social things. My friend dithers when paying. Its not nice. I find these people put you off meeting them.. op dont pay for her going forward

midsomermurderess · 25/06/2023 13:38

How have you tolerated this using behaviour all this time? You’re a mug, she knows that. Stop going on about her here and deal with it in real life. How do so many Mumsnetters have such dysfunctional’friendships?

TallerThanAverage · 25/06/2023 13:33

Bubbles111 · 25/06/2023 11:30

To be clear, there is a venue and food and drink have been organised. My friend keeps chatting about big ideas for drinks and games. Im not buyinf anything she tells me.

To be clearer, you should be telling her not us.

oldperson1 · 25/06/2023 13:30

“I won’t let my friend go without”
But she is not going without is she she has been going out enjoying herself drinking and eating and being subsidized by other people for the last 15 years.
If she is expecting you and your other friends to be subsidizing her baby shower and none of you are willing to do so you really need to have the talk with her beforehand.

CoffeeCantata · 25/06/2023 13:29

BrutusMcDogface · Today 11:21
You’ve put up with this fir way too long. I think you should message her re: the baby shower and say “all sounds great. Please book/ order bits and let us know how much we owe you.”

Great advice. Try and make it always 'you pay and let ME know how much I owe you'.

It's difficult when friends have different incomes etc, but in the end - you can't have things you can't afford, and she needs to own this and work out how best to navigate her social life.

Lacucuracha · 25/06/2023 13:27

Time to speak to your mutual friends about what a CF she is and to agree that you will all stop bank rolling her.

Well done for not doing a thing for her baby shower, get everyone else on board as well.

Honestly I’d just dump the CF for good.

TonTonMacoute · 25/06/2023 13:27

UndercoverCop · 25/06/2023 12:05

You just say look I understand things are a bit tight for you financially, but with everything on the increase it is for me too. In the past I've covered things and not said anything, but I can't do it anymore. (Insert examples if she challenges this)
Last weekend you said you'd go half on takeaway but didn't transfer the money, you said you contribute to the snacks and drinks you chose but didn't.
I am happy to help organise your baby shower but I can't contribute financially anymore, other than to cover my own costs. I know you'll understand because you're on a budget too.

This is actually perfect.

Say this to her, it is quite clear and reasonable. If she takes offence you will know she's been using you and can have a clear conscience.

JusthereforXmas · 25/06/2023 13:26

I use to be the one that would pay for things with friends, like their train/tax/bus fare, club entry, drinks, takeaways etc... but it was fair as they use to let me stay with them, feed me home cooked meals, they where beauticians and would do pamper nights for free and basically would share anything they had etc... so it never felt 'user' relationship just like we brought different things to the friendship.

I had one friend when young (like 11-14) who did that though OP. I was constantly lending her tiny amounts (we are talking 40p for sweets, 90p for a bottle of pop, £2 for a sandwhich, £1.20 for bus etc... multiple times a day EVERY day) and it must have added up over a couple of hundred over years (small amounts individually but over time a lot for kids). She never once paid for stuff or tried to pay anything back.

My mam treat her like a daughter too always taking her places and paying which her parent accepted. Her family never invited me anywhere, didn't even invite me in to their house/garden for their BBQ's (I have seen inside quickly in the past. It was a perfectly normal house and nice garden with swing set etc... so they hands out accepted us paying for their kid but didn't seem to like us or see us as equals).

She also stole from me several times and never apologized or acted remorseful when caught red handed.

I do wonder how people like that are so brazen.

mouldyfalafel · 25/06/2023 13:24

Nah, a takeaway you split. How cheeky to think if you go to a mates for a takeaway they should pay for you

I agree- I'd always offer to go halves if someone ordered me a takeaway, I'd never just assume they were paying. Also, the fact is, she isnt paying for takeaways when OP is at her house so it isnt the case of "the host always pays"- because she isnt reciprocating!!

Anaemiafog · 25/06/2023 13:24

I agree she's a user but just once I'd love to hear the story from the CF's point of view. I have a friend who does this. There were times I was much better off financially than her so I really didn't mind as she was a hard working single mum but she didn't change even when she had plenty of money. Do they not feel anything when they're taking the piss?