Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Heartbreaktuna · 25/06/2023 12:07

This was a sad read. Eating wild also isn't great to be honest. And I admittedly absolutely love eating octopus. When we had a house in Greece I would watch the fishermen clubbing live octopuses to death on the quayside most mornings. Really brutal stuff.

Kindofcrunchy · 25/06/2023 12:07

I don't see how farming octopuses is any different to farming any other animal. It's pretty black and white for me so I don't eat any of them.

If you forgive the slaughter of cows, pigs, chickens etc in the name of "food" then you might as well condone octopus farming as well, imo.

RonObvious · 25/06/2023 12:03

This is such a tricky one. I eat meat, but I don’t eat octopus, because I have dived with them and they are very intelligent and playful. However, my friend (vegan) makes a good point that intelligence isn’t an indication of something’s value - would you then value the life of a child with a learning disability less than one without, for instance. So…I don’t know.

In terms of sustainability- I think it would cause similar problems to fisheries, where lots of cheaper fish (which could potentially feed locals) are used to produce higher end fish.

BadMotorhomeParent · 25/06/2023 12:02

@NeverDropYourMooncup

Well said!!

OP posts:
Dahlietta · 25/06/2023 11:58

But no excuse into turn them into human food.
It's not that unusual to find octopus on a menu. They've been human food for a long time! Objection to methods of farming them is a separate (and very valid!) issue.

plantsandwich · 25/06/2023 11:56

Humans are a horrendous species. This does not surprise me in the slightest

NeverDropYourMooncup · 25/06/2023 11:54

pd339 · 25/06/2023 10:48

Do you eat other meat? Genuine question.

Oh, forgot about that. Only vegans are allowed to oppose this.

That means it has to go ahead, as it's inappropriate for omnivores who don't want Octopus farmed (and may not eat it themselves) to do anything to prevent it. Best reverse any laws that omnivores have voted for whilst we're at it - you know, bring back full, blatant hunting with dogs, bear baiting, bull fighting, the establishment of all the environmental and animal welfare charities, send everybody back their donations because they've eaten meat, close down and go back to the Middle Ages.

User19844666884 · 25/06/2023 11:50

BarelyLiterate · 25/06/2023 11:45

I’m an enthusiastic omnivore, I often eat wild octopus along with many other types of seafood when I’m on holiday in Spain & Portugal, and I would have absolutely no problem eating farmed octopus either, assuming it is done humanely, of course.

It can’t be done humanly though, that’s the point. They have established that it can’t be done without causing huge suffering to the octopuses, but are going ahead anyway.

BadMotorhomeParent · 25/06/2023 11:49

I am currently reading book, "Dominion", about the human-animal "relationships". One of the justifications for the killing of whales, is that they
are seen to be "offering themselves" to the ships...... When their approach is actually curiosity and a very real lack of fear, due to having no NATURAL predator.

I agree with you @BiscuitsandPuffin - who says we have the right to do ANY of what we do to animals, and other creatures?

My thoughts about this come from not only my own instincts, but watching, many years ago, "Earthlings" - which opened my eyes, as well as underlining what I already knew or feared. It just seems that "we" keep on moving the goalposts - and hardly ever in a direction that benefits the animals, only the people.

OP posts:
WiseUpJanetWeiss · 25/06/2023 11:45

As an aside, octopi have a longer natural lifespan than us.

Octopuses live between 12 months and about 5 years depending on the species.

That doesn’t mean it’s OK to farm them though.

JudgeRudy · 25/06/2023 11:45

GeorgeSpeaks · 25/06/2023 11:33

How sentient are octopi? Do they know they exist? Do they know they're in a farm?

They're pretty intelligent. More so than say pigs and dogs.

BarelyLiterate · 25/06/2023 11:45

I’m an enthusiastic omnivore, I often eat wild octopus along with many other types of seafood when I’m on holiday in Spain & Portugal, and I would have absolutely no problem eating farmed octopus either, assuming it is done humanely, of course.

FavouriteDogMug · 25/06/2023 11:44

The difference is whilst there are some cruel farming practices with other animals this has started up before people were so aware of it. Its much harder to stop something that has been going on for years. Octopuses have never been farmed in this cruel way in the past so let's not let it start up. I'm not against eating meat if the animals have had a fairly good life, well treated in comfortable, fairly natural surroundings and slaughtered in the most humane way possible. These octopus farms have very cruel conditions and the Octopuses are killed in a painful manner. They should be stopped right away

TheRainMustFall · 25/06/2023 11:42

I find this concerning too, op. It seems that these farms won’t meet basic needs and will cause huge suffering.

Not all farming is equal in terms of impact on animals and different species have different needs, and this concerns me in the same way that vast dairy farms concern me.

The fact animals already suffer in food production is not an argument for dismissing additional suffering as irrelevant. I want to see welfare standards improved and the number of animals affected reduced, not the reverse.

faw2009 · 25/06/2023 11:40

BadMotorhomeParent · 25/06/2023 11:35

It is probably "necessary" because there is not enough land to keep walking meat alive, even on feed lots. And I suppose octopuses won't cause a demand on water in the same way that the grain required for beef cattle etc does, when used for growing the feed.

Just the water to keep them confined in tanks prior to dismemberment,.
So they are a drought-resistant product!

But the octopuses will require fish for feeding , leading to more overfishing and very inefficient use of resources.

I love octopuses. This has made me very sad. (I am a hypocrite though, not a vegetarian).

BiscuitsandPuffin · 25/06/2023 11:38

GeorgeSpeaks · 25/06/2023 11:33

How sentient are octopi? Do they know they exist? Do they know they're in a farm?

Who are we, as humans, to decide that about other creatures? Our standards of sentience and the way we "measure" such things are so anthrocentric we have no way of knowing what other creatures think and feel beyond our own reference points so we should just leave them alone. As an aside, octopi have a longer natural lifespan than us.

thecatsthecats · 25/06/2023 11:38

pd339 · 25/06/2023 10:48

Do you eat other meat? Genuine question.

I'm not the OP, but I do eat meat and come from a farming family, and grew up with hens.

There's farming and there's farming.

The fell sheep where I grew up had nice lives, even if their lambs had short ones.

My uncle's beef cattle were well looked after, he opposed badger culls, and he suffered a mental breakdown during foot and mouth when his animals were, in his view, needlessly slaughtered.

The farmer whose land surrounded us, by no means a fluffy character, refused to allow the hunt on his land because they caused needless destruction, distressed his sheep, and if a fox needed sorting, he had a shotgun for that.

Our rescue hens were in an AWFUL state when we got them, and became productive layers after a bit of rehab and space.

I don't know enough about octopuses, or the proposed octopus farm, to know that there is a vast, VAST difference in farming methods. It really isn't as simple as "do you eat meat" in my opinion.

BunnyBettChetwynnd · 25/06/2023 11:37

GeorgeSpeaks · 25/06/2023 11:33

How sentient are octopi? Do they know they exist? Do they know they're in a farm?

A recent report by the London School of Economics found “very strong evidence of sentience” in octopods.

https://www.lse.ac.uk/News/News-Assets/PDFs/2021/Sentience-in-Cephalopod-Molluscs-and-Decapod-Crustaceans-Final-Report-November-2021.pdf

Newtothisanddonunderstand · 25/06/2023 11:37

Octopus is delicious 😳

The article talks about the slaughter plans potentially being more humane than how they slaughter wild octopus. It says there aren’t welfare regulations yet, but perhaps the creation of a farm will prompt legislation.

Most meat that we eat is farmed, and the conditions for dairy cows, shredding make chicks etc are pretty horrific, yet the majority of humans are still carnivorous.

BadMotorhomeParent · 25/06/2023 11:37

GeorgeSpeaks · 25/06/2023 11:33

How sentient are octopi? Do they know they exist? Do they know they're in a farm?

They will know they are not in THEIR natural environment.

Have you seen My Octopus Teacher? We cannot know everything about them..... But no excuse into turn them into human food.

OP posts:
WiseUpJanetWeiss · 25/06/2023 11:36

GeorgeSpeaks · 25/06/2023 11:33

How sentient are octopi? Do they know they exist? Do they know they're in a farm?

They are intelligent - they recognise people apparently.

BadMotorhomeParent · 25/06/2023 11:35

ginghamstarfish · 25/06/2023 11:15

Not sure what the difference is between this and farming any other creature to eat it?

It is probably "necessary" because there is not enough land to keep walking meat alive, even on feed lots. And I suppose octopuses won't cause a demand on water in the same way that the grain required for beef cattle etc does, when used for growing the feed.

Just the water to keep them confined in tanks prior to dismemberment,.
So they are a drought-resistant product!

OP posts:
GeorgeSpeaks · 25/06/2023 11:33

How sentient are octopi? Do they know they exist? Do they know they're in a farm?

BadMotorhomeParent · 25/06/2023 11:31

continentallentil · 25/06/2023 11:30

I don’t have a problem with it in principle, but I doubt it can be achieved economically without causing the animals distress.

Do you think it's necessary?
Do they have any real nutritional value?

OP posts:
BadMotorhomeParent · 25/06/2023 11:30

ginghamstarfish · 25/06/2023 11:15

Not sure what the difference is between this and farming any other creature to eat it?

I don't agree with that either, or believe it to be necessary.
But this is a new "idea", so it IS different.

OP posts: