Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
User19844666884 · 25/06/2023 18:45

thecatsthecats · 25/06/2023 18:16

I dont accept the hierarchy of species basically.

I agree with this, because most people won't admit that if they use a value like intelligence to choose between species, they will also use it to separate people.

But that doesn’t omit treating anything we eat in an humane fashion, which it also has to be said, almost always vastly improves the quality and nutritional value of the food itself.

We have a vested interest in letting animals live well before we dispatch them.

I think most people do accept a hierarchy of species, even if it is difficult to articulate what that judgement call is based on.

I believe most people, if told they must chose between killing a slug or a dog, will dispatch the slug.

Regardless, farming animals in constant pain and terror, for them then to have a horrendous death (as would be the case here) should surely be advocated against, whether one eats meat or not.

nocoolnamesleft · 25/06/2023 18:21

Ultimately, everyone who is non vegan accepts some hierarchy of species, or else we'd be happily subsisting on solyent green.

thecatsthecats · 25/06/2023 18:16

I dont accept the hierarchy of species basically.

I agree with this, because most people won't admit that if they use a value like intelligence to choose between species, they will also use it to separate people.

But that doesn’t omit treating anything we eat in an humane fashion, which it also has to be said, almost always vastly improves the quality and nutritional value of the food itself.

We have a vested interest in letting animals live well before we dispatch them.

GalileoHumpkins · 25/06/2023 16:06

I dont accept the hierarchy of species basically

"in the end, meat is meat, it doesn’t matter where it’s from" - Agustina Bazterrica Tender is the Flesh.

redboxer321 · 25/06/2023 16:00

I dont accept the hierarchy of species basically.

I bet you couldn't eat a whole baby though. Do you just go for an arm or a leg?

JaninaDuszejko · 25/06/2023 15:58

GeorgeSpeaks · 25/06/2023 11:33

How sentient are octopi? Do they know they exist? Do they know they're in a farm?

Octopuses are by far the most intelligent invertebrate. And we still know relatively little about them and how their intelligence has developed in such a short lived and solitary species. Fascinating creatures.

gogomoto · 25/06/2023 15:53

@sausage767

Blush whale is delicious as is seal meat (had it in the USA , legally caught, my friend is Native American)

I dont accept the hierarchy of species basically.

Choose not to eat meat, fine - but I find this good meats and bad meats hypocritical

BadMotorhomeParent · 25/06/2023 15:49

gogomoto · 25/06/2023 15:48

I love octopus, yummy. I can't see how it's different to any other farming, pigs are intelligent creatures for instance. If you eat meat I can't see why one animal is less worthy than another really. I honestly would eat anything if I was hungry, I'm not so I get to choose, but I recognise that I'm fortunate to have that choice.

Yes I eat farmed animals, though I choose higher welfare standards as im fortunately able to afford them, ditto sustainable fish.

And you are part of the problem.
Makes me sick.

OP posts:
gogomoto · 25/06/2023 15:48

I love octopus, yummy. I can't see how it's different to any other farming, pigs are intelligent creatures for instance. If you eat meat I can't see why one animal is less worthy than another really. I honestly would eat anything if I was hungry, I'm not so I get to choose, but I recognise that I'm fortunate to have that choice.

Yes I eat farmed animals, though I choose higher welfare standards as im fortunately able to afford them, ditto sustainable fish.

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 25/06/2023 15:44

Octopi are among various species of animals which zoologists have wanted to call 'non human persons' due to their intelligence and sentience. I don't agree with any of our farming methods, but this is absolutely barbaric and disgusting.

FavouriteDogMug · 25/06/2023 15:38

It would be like taking ravens, one of the most intelligent of the wild birds and keeping them in the battery cages used for hens. Of course most of us would like to see these banned for hens but it's hard to change an established industry. I think it can be effective though, to campaign to prevent it being set up. No-one is relying on cheap octopus meat, there's just no need for it.

BadMotorhomeParent · 25/06/2023 15:37

I cannot remember where I read this; it is not original to me (but has played a part in my personal ethos):

"For the animal shall not be measured by man.
In a world older and more complete than ours, they move
finished and complete, gifted with the extension of the senses that
we have lost, or never attained, living by voices we shall never hear.
They are not our brethren, they are not underlings;
they are other nations - caught with ourselves in the net of life and time-
fellow prisoners of the splendour and the travail of the Earth."

Henry Weston.

OP posts:
GalileoHumpkins · 25/06/2023 15:18

It's absolutely abhorrent, not every living creature needs to be food.

garfieldeatscake · 25/06/2023 15:11

Octopus are highly, highly intelligent animals. In aquariums they have to be given regular cognitive tasks or they get bored, languish and die.
Whilst I'm not a fan of any 'factory' farming techniques, I'd rather they were farmed than become endangered/ extinct. Octopus play a very important role in marine biodiversity, so if they are hunted to extinction it would disrupt the marine ecosystem.
I personally don't think any marine life should be on a menu (unless living on an island with no other food source). As our seas really need TLC, and humans need to stop plundering marine life; take out a food source for bigger marine life, and that will bring humans into greater conflict as a food source for bigger fish.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 25/06/2023 13:36

Kosher and veggie here, thanks for linking the petition. All industrialised farming is cruel.

Kindofcrunchy · 25/06/2023 13:25

BadMotorhomeParent · 25/06/2023 12:15

I don't though.

Happily eating plants for most of my adult life.
I see no need whatsoever to eat what had once been a living being; I just don't.

Sorry, I meant 'you' generally speaking (ie. Most of mumsnet)

Thanks for your compassion. Vegan here for almost six years and have never looked back!

Fiddlerdragon · 25/06/2023 13:25

donquixotedelamancha · 25/06/2023 13:10

They are certainly not nearly as sentient as pigs, cows and sheep.

There is good evidence they feel (in the emotional sense) pain/distress and (on a simple level) pleasure/affection.

They’re vastly more sentient than any other farm animals

Fiddlerdragon · 25/06/2023 13:23

GeorgeSpeaks · 25/06/2023 11:33

How sentient are octopi? Do they know they exist? Do they know they're in a farm?

They’re terrifyingly intelligent, more intelligent than humans. I watched a study where they were pitting octopodi against humans in tasks including problem solving/tool using/puzzles etc and they out scored humans in every one. If you could turn an octopus into a human and have it perform an IQ test, it’s thought they’d average at 140.

FantasticElasticBand · 25/06/2023 13:16

Octopodes* are very, very smart. Puzzle solvers, face recognition, can survive out of water for a few hours etc…
I’m pretty sure they and related species if used in a lab, have to have anaesthetic/pain relief.
Amazing development- they have a (ring) donut shaped brain to accommodate their beak. Copper, not iron - so their blood is blue. The female Pacific stays with her young to guard them & starves to death.

Any animal farmed should have a good life and death & we should be prepared to pay for that.

  • Greek root word = ‘des’ rather than Latin ‘i’ plural.
donquixotedelamancha · 25/06/2023 13:14

sausage767 · 25/06/2023 12:14

Obscene indeed. I stopped eating octopus long ago, when it was realised how intelligent they are. It’s just unnecessary, doesn’t need to be part of our diet. It would be the same as eating whale or dolphin to me.

It's not remotely the same as eating dolphin. If you want to avoid eating clever animals pigs should be top of the list.

Octopi are strongly curious and exploratory but it doesn't mean the are cleverer than (for example) cows just because they are less sedentary.

donquixotedelamancha · 25/06/2023 13:10

GeorgeSpeaks · 25/06/2023 11:33

How sentient are octopi? Do they know they exist? Do they know they're in a farm?

They are certainly not nearly as sentient as pigs, cows and sheep.

There is good evidence they feel (in the emotional sense) pain/distress and (on a simple level) pleasure/affection.

meandtheboy · 25/06/2023 13:05

if you really want to know how sentient octopi are, this is a wonderful book. https://www.waterstones.com/book/other-minds/peter-godfrey-smith/9780008226299

an octopus brain is arguably as evolved as a human brain, they hate being away from their natural environment and especially hate being in captivity and it is not possible to equate farming them with farming other water-based creatures such as fish.

Eating meat of any kind is, or should be, predicated on the animal having a good life and then as quick and painless a death as possible...neither of these would be available to the octopus. Wild-caught is the only humane option, and even that is a stretch.

MonumentalLentil · 25/06/2023 12:56

GeorgeSpeaks · 25/06/2023 11:33

How sentient are octopi? Do they know they exist? Do they know they're in a farm?

They are very intelligent creatures.

Petiton here for those that care:

https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/635152

Petition: Make it illegal to farm octopus for the production of food

Prevent the start of any form of octopus farming for the production of food to be allowed. Be a country which shows the world that this is completely unacceptable.

https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/635152

BadMotorhomeParent · 25/06/2023 12:15

Kindofcrunchy · 25/06/2023 12:07

I don't see how farming octopuses is any different to farming any other animal. It's pretty black and white for me so I don't eat any of them.

If you forgive the slaughter of cows, pigs, chickens etc in the name of "food" then you might as well condone octopus farming as well, imo.

I don't though.

Happily eating plants for most of my adult life.
I see no need whatsoever to eat what had once been a living being; I just don't.

OP posts:
sausage767 · 25/06/2023 12:14

Obscene indeed. I stopped eating octopus long ago, when it was realised how intelligent they are. It’s just unnecessary, doesn’t need to be part of our diet. It would be the same as eating whale or dolphin to me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread