Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say this is my house?

341 replies

LovelySparrow · 25/06/2023 06:58

Have name changed as I know dp's family is on here

I have been going out with dp for nearly 5 years. We are both in our 50s and divorced with our own kids, none together.

He moved into the house I was living in at the time, since then, I sold the house and bought somewhere bigger where we all had our own space. It is solely in my name and I purchased it on my own and I pay for everything to do with its maintenance/upkeep.

Dp still owns a house with his ex where she lives. She was meant to have sold it by now but doesn't want to (kids have left home etc.). I'm not involved in that. He pays part of the mortgage on that house.

This weekend we were talking about the house and dp mentioned he had paid for something and I said I would refund him. He said why would you do that, it's our house. I said but it isn't actually, it's my house. I said you have a house. This may be your home but it's actually legally my house.

He's now really upset. Said I'm being incredibly nasty and he feels really shit. When we went to bed, I saw he had tears in his eyes. I tried to clear the air but he didn't want to hear it but I'm going to today.

I don't think I'm wrong. We have no kids together. If I die, everything goes to my kids, I've always been clear about that and although we don't have a co habitation agreement, he has (legally) acknowledged that he has no claim on me/my estate if I did die.

I don't think, just because he's moved in with me, that he has any rights to say it's his house or our house in any way. Happy for it to be our home.

Was I a bitch because he seems to be implying that I'm incredibly cruel and unfair?

OP posts:
determinedtomakethiswork · 25/06/2023 09:27

I am not sure why you are funding his lifestyle to the extent that he isn't even paying regular bills, never mind rent.

I am also not sure why he is complaining about you refunding him when he wanted that in the first place.

CJsGoldfish · 25/06/2023 09:26

You've deeply hurt your partners feelings, to the point where a man in his 50's is crying which suggests a they've incurred some trauma from your comments
🙄

I think he'll probably leave after something like this. The feeling of security is one of the most fundamental needs that we have as humans and you've just completely ripped that away from him

How dramatic 🤣
He's not going anywhere. He'll be playing the long game

yadeciN · 25/06/2023 09:25

Arightoldcarryabag · 25/06/2023 09:23

And can I just add, some of the replies to a grown man being reduced to tears, saying that he is "sulking" are just beyond unkind.

I bet you are the same people posting about mental health awareness and changing your facebook profile pictures saying "Be Kind". Absolute rotters.

It costs nothing to employ a little empathy. You can agree with OP and how this has been handled but beyond that to attacking someone you don't know, well that's pretty hideous.

👏

Arightoldcarryabag · 25/06/2023 09:23

And can I just add, some of the replies to a grown man being reduced to tears, saying that he is "sulking" are just beyond unkind.

I bet you are the same people posting about mental health awareness and changing your facebook profile pictures saying "Be Kind". Absolute rotters.

It costs nothing to employ a little empathy. You can agree with OP and how this has been handled but beyond that to attacking someone you don't know, well that's pretty hideous.

Pubgardener · 25/06/2023 09:21

@Arightoldcarryabag I think he'll probably leave after something like this. The feeling of security is one of the most fundamental needs that we have as humans and you've just completely ripped that away from him.

I doubt he will leave, at the moment his housing costs are all paid for (including his council tax) by the OP. Tax and rent in most parts of the continent are going to mean at minimum he needs to find another £700 a month to look after himself. He’s not going to do that.

Beaverbridge · 25/06/2023 09:20

Tell him that's he's free to move back into the house he's still paying for!!

ThinWomansBrain · 25/06/2023 09:17

Why do so many people keep droning on about pre-nups when OP stated "Crikey not getting married again, definitely not!"?

If he is so unhappy that he's crying himself to sleep - and sulking - tell him to move out and rent or buy somewhere of his own.
Maybe he'll turn on the waterworks on for the ex-wife who's home he is funding?

billy1966 · 25/06/2023 09:15

Panteranoir · 25/06/2023 07:37

He's got some front sulking about you saying your house is your own, whilst he can't even sort out his previous house with his ex and you are subsidising hs life.

He's straying into cf territory

Absolutely this.

He's not half entitled.

Having a pouty sulk because a house he has never contributed to isn't now his.

That the nasty unkind woman he lives off hasn't been stupid enough to say of course you may have have of my home that you never paid a penny for and live rent free in🙄.

OP, his behaviour would give me the Ick.

He pays for an asset that continues to grow, but also feels entitled to some of yours.

Deep down he hoped you were a bit of a mug.

He's upset for himself.

He's a user.

No thanks for housing him rent free while he pays for a home for his wife?

You must have low self esteem to be so used and have such a low man bar.

Ick.

formulaonecar · 25/06/2023 09:12

Panteranoir · 25/06/2023 07:37

He's got some front sulking about you saying your house is your own, whilst he can't even sort out his previous house with his ex and you are subsidising hs life.

He's straying into cf territory

I agree and I dont understand the people saying where would he go if the OP died- he HAS a house of his own already, he'd have to sell that and split the proceeds with his ex and use that to get a new place. He wouldnt be out on the street if he already owns his own house fgs.

Arightoldcarryabag · 25/06/2023 09:12

You've deeply hurt your partners feelings, to the point where a man in his 50's is crying which suggests a they've incurred some trauma from your comments.

For your reaction to that to be to seek confirmation online that they are unreasonable (which is essentially what you are doing) says a whole lot about how you view your partner and it is certainly not as an equal.

I think he'll probably leave after something like this. The feeling of security is one of the most fundamental needs that we have as humans and you've just completely ripped that away from him.

I don't buy the argument made by some that this needed saying. It has changed absolutely nothing from a legal standpoint, OP still has exactly the same control over their finances as they had 2 days ago, they are in the same position but have made their partner feel very insecure, a partner who has already had their home seemingly taken from them previously with his Ex still living in his "other" property.

Willmafrockfit · 25/06/2023 09:09

have you made a will
do you plan to get married

Orangetreexherry · 25/06/2023 09:09

OP, I am with you here when you make sure he doesn't get an ideas, for the sake of your children

Orangetreexherry · 25/06/2023 09:08

If he wants to call a home his house, he can always move in with you to the house he actually owns (where his wife lives now) and where he pays for everything. Otherwise, tough

RosaGallica · 25/06/2023 09:05

Shoxfordian · 25/06/2023 07:02

It doesn’t sound like you really feel very committed to him; especially if he pays for things in the house

This is the response of a 20 or 30 yr old with the experiences of just setting out in life with the love of their life. Not with the experiences of an older woman who has already had to pay the motherhood penalty for one man and now has to consider the realities in modern Britain. The realities of providing for her children in the modern world where inheritance matters rather more than what work they will do, and where women’s rights are slowly dying.

Men take off women if we give them the chance, and it’s entirely possible that a new man may have expected to do the same. You’ve told him where he stands op, which is on your ground that he contributes nothing to. Judge him on his response: it will show you how entitled or caring he feels about your time and energy.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 25/06/2023 09:04

Five years is nothing. Hang on to your house.

(If) when he buys one fifty fifty with you, and pays his share of the bills, then it will be his ( and your) house. Currently he has a house, but his once wife lives in it.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 25/06/2023 09:03

STARCATCHER22 · 25/06/2023 07:24

If OP marries this man, he would then be entitled to 50% of the house as it would be a marital asset.

Not quite right in law, but in practice probably.
in law, yes it would become a marital asset. On divorce both she and an ex would have rights to fair settlement
that’s defined in law by about 10 or so criteria that need to be met if applicable- not all would be applicable in this case
only once that is met are any “surplus” assets divided

both parties would need to declare their properties in the legal financial disclosure. So, the ex would declare his property with wife still in, and she would declare her property. Plus all pension pots, plus all savings etc . So, in practice she may keep the house, if he has other assets such as a larger pension pot etc

IncompleteSenten · 25/06/2023 09:02

If he was only telling you what he'd paid for so you would pay him back, he wouldn't have said "why would you", when you replied you'd reimburse him, surely?

If you've got it all completely legally sorted so he has no right to your property then does it really matter if he says house instead of home?

Chopchopbusybusyworkwork · 25/06/2023 09:01

Are you certain that he is still paying towards the mortgage with his ex?

SoShallINever · 25/06/2023 09:00

I wouldn't be with a man who was paying his ex wife's mortgage for her. He is an idiot for doing that. They need to sell that so he has some money behind him to bail him out should his relationship with you, end.
I think he was so upset by your "it's my house" remark, because he does indeed see your house as his. It's good that you have some legal protection in place.

Beautiful3 · 25/06/2023 08:59

You were right, it's your house, not his. It was a strange thing for him to say. Is he trying to guilt trip you into putting his name on it? Please don't ever do that.

LadyBird1973 · 25/06/2023 08:58

@Daisiesandprimroses her words were that it is his home, but not his house - her actions made it clear that it's neither!

LadyBug2022 · 25/06/2023 08:57

I would defo go back to solicitors and check the legal arrangements. Solicitors can make mistakes, get another opinion, make sure the law hasnt changed. Maybe firm things up.

This is the sort of thing that if left can result in huge problems later.
You dont have to tell him you are seeing a solicitor.
Crying over a legal situation, hmmm?
Dont put it off - see a solicitor

EnterSandwoman · 25/06/2023 08:57

So would he say you own half of his house? No? There it is.

And what on earth would he do if you weren't around to fund his living costs?

He'd have had to tidy up his financial mess with the ex years ago - the fact you're allowing him to avoid facing that sounds both unacknowledged and unappreciated by him.

Personally I'd get myself to a lawyer to draw up a tenancy/rental agreement just so it is absolutely legally clear how he could be removed if you die. I see massive issues if he decides to be an entitled arse when you're gone...

1970X · 25/06/2023 08:51

He’d have to sell his house if he didn’t live with you (rent free) so perhaps he needs to think long and hard as to why he’s upset.

Pubgardener · 25/06/2023 08:49

You are completely in the right and you should correct him. It isn’t unreasonable to assume that a man who already has gone through one breakup involving property has a vague idea of how these things work- including that financially contributing allied over time another party to accumulate some interest. You would be mad to think he doesn’t know this.

I would just send him the money and on any household expenses like this in the future I would send him the money back without even mentioning it.

I would also speak to a solicitor just to make sure that you are not drifting into s situation where he might have a claim.

quite frankly this man seems to have fallen on his feet-you mention that he couldn’t afford to pay you more because of his existing financial commitments- you have taken a lot of the financial load off of him- that he should be trying to make you feel guilty doesn’t sit right with me at all.