Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say this is my house?

341 replies

LovelySparrow · 25/06/2023 06:58

Have name changed as I know dp's family is on here

I have been going out with dp for nearly 5 years. We are both in our 50s and divorced with our own kids, none together.

He moved into the house I was living in at the time, since then, I sold the house and bought somewhere bigger where we all had our own space. It is solely in my name and I purchased it on my own and I pay for everything to do with its maintenance/upkeep.

Dp still owns a house with his ex where she lives. She was meant to have sold it by now but doesn't want to (kids have left home etc.). I'm not involved in that. He pays part of the mortgage on that house.

This weekend we were talking about the house and dp mentioned he had paid for something and I said I would refund him. He said why would you do that, it's our house. I said but it isn't actually, it's my house. I said you have a house. This may be your home but it's actually legally my house.

He's now really upset. Said I'm being incredibly nasty and he feels really shit. When we went to bed, I saw he had tears in his eyes. I tried to clear the air but he didn't want to hear it but I'm going to today.

I don't think I'm wrong. We have no kids together. If I die, everything goes to my kids, I've always been clear about that and although we don't have a co habitation agreement, he has (legally) acknowledged that he has no claim on me/my estate if I did die.

I don't think, just because he's moved in with me, that he has any rights to say it's his house or our house in any way. Happy for it to be our home.

Was I a bitch because he seems to be implying that I'm incredibly cruel and unfair?

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 25/06/2023 10:00

LovelySparrow · 25/06/2023 09:31

I am definitely definitely not marrying him or anyone

I don't think I have low self esteem. He pays his share of living bills, no he doesn't pay rent but that doesn't bother me. I want him to pay for the extra costs of him living here as opposed to me being on my own, which he does which I suppose is somewhat akin to rent though far lower.

I just will not be taken advantage of. I have an appointment booked with a solicitor in a few weeks time to go through my will because both my kids are over 21 now and I need to update it so I will mention all this at the same time.

He has landed on his feet with me. And I have no problem with that. But that does not mean he gets to share in all the hard work it took for me to get where I am today by contributing nothing financial.

If the situation was reversed and I had a house I already owned and I moved in with someone else, I wouldn't dare call it my house.

I'd leave things a few days because emotions seem a bit raw, but bring it up again mid week. How would you feel if he paid a lump off the mortgage and became a tenant in common? Presumably he would have to sell his home first, and as marriage isn't on the cards this could reinforce your commitment to each other. Essentially you both have to put yourself out for the relationship. If this makes either of you feel uneasy, maybe you need to have a serious think about how you feel about each other. In your partners position, I think I'd struggle to remain essentially a long term guest. This would make me feel incredibly insecure.
Good luck.

DaaamnYoullDo · 25/06/2023 09:59

So he knows full well he doesn't contribute to the house. He asked you for money back for something he DID buy once. But he still thinks he has a claim to the house.... that he doesn't contribute to.

I think the cocklodger thought you were going to be his knight in shining armour and he wouldn't have to put on his big boy pants and deal with his efforts his own house.

Northernparent68 · 25/06/2023 09:58

AdaColeman · 25/06/2023 07:46

Far from being cruel and unfair, you are facilitating his AND his ex wife's life style by your major financial contribution.

Hopefully, he contributes substantially in other ways to your relationship. But if he continues to attempt to guilt trip you, perhaps you need to re evaluate just what he brings to your relationship.

Not really, she wants to pay for the upkeep.

Chatillon · 25/06/2023 09:58

@LovelySparrow

This is what you need to be concerned with (assuming you live in England & Wales). It sounds as if you are doing everything correctly, but be aware over time anything you may say, do or indicate a long term home. You could have a clause in your Will that allows him to occupy your home for a period of 24 months which will give him time to rearrange his life if you die first. Sometimes having a clear tangible line is better than leaving things unwritten.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proprietary_estoppel

Proprietary estoppel - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proprietary_estoppel

BMW6 · 25/06/2023 09:56

Why has this come as a surprise to him?

Surely you had a conversation when he first moved into YOUR property that it was entirely your asset and he had no entitlement to it?

When you sold that property and bought this new one entirely with YOUR money surely you had the same conversation that this is your property and again he has no entitlement in it?

You DID have those conversations didn't you? So why is he hurt now?

weirdoboelady · 25/06/2023 09:55

It sounds reasonable to me. Have you explained to him that the reason you are not considering the house a joint asset is because it's your kids' inheritance? Because looked at that way, I don't see how he can feel he has a right to it. He has a house - or 50% equity in one (or I might have missed something - 25% equity?) He really needs to get that sorted in some way and actually hanging on to the house probably is the most financially savvy thing he can do, assuming there is reasonable equity in the house.

itsmylife7 · 25/06/2023 09:55

You've stated the truth so whys he upset .
It's YOUR house !

Ardiaei · 25/06/2023 09:50

The next question is what happens when he does sell his old house and does want to start contributing to this one?

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 25/06/2023 09:50

I think you’ve done the right thing. And talking to the solicitor about your will and what would happen with him is sensible. I agree with giving him 6months breathing space to move out, but very clear that he has to. I think in order for him not to come back and contest your will, you need to name him and give a small bequest to show that you have thought about it-say £2k and then he has nothing to come back from.

ItsOnlyMeNow · 25/06/2023 09:50

STARCATCHER22 · 25/06/2023 07:24

If OP marries this man, he would then be entitled to 50% of the house as it would be a marital asset.

This is not the case necessarily depending on what legal agreements are made.

JudgeJ · 25/06/2023 09:48

SeeingSpots · 25/06/2023 07:02

If he has legally acknowledge he has no claim on the property I think you were being quite petty to pick him up on it.

He obviously sees it as his house in that he wants to help pay for things and enjoys living there with you. It seems a very spiteful thing to bring up unnecessary to what was a very innocent comment.

He sounds to be trapped between two unpleasant women, why on earth doesn't he force the sale of his former family home now the children are grown, let his ex fend for herself for once or she'll be leeching off him forever.

Oblomov23 · 25/06/2023 09:45

Why not insist he sorts his house situation with ex?

daisychain01 · 25/06/2023 09:44

It sounds like you're resentful that your DP hasn't sorted out the finances on his former marital home with his ex. It's probably rumbled on for years with him kicking the can down the road and not taking decisive steps to untangle himself financially from his previous life. Normally all the finances get sorted out with the divorce, including a clean break to ensure nobody has further financial claims on the other. That was his to sort out and for whatever reason he hasn't bothered.

quite frankly I would never have allowed him to move in, that was your biggest mistake. If he wasn't motivated enough nor had the balls to sort it out to enable him to move forward in his life, that's his fault.

Zonder · 25/06/2023 09:43

And he’d be out on his ear?

With only half another house to his name!

Ireolu · 25/06/2023 09:43

You have a clear plan OP and he is aware of it. Tearful response from him may mean it crystallised in his mind at that particular point in time. YANBU.

MzHz · 25/06/2023 09:43

I do think @LovelySparrow you're absolutely correct in your position and you’re going to have to have another very clear conversation

your dp has made the decision to allow his ex to keep his part of a house because he’s not proactive enough or perhaps hungry or driven enough to want to get this sorted out and get his assets back and the mortgage done with.

whether he does anything about this is up to him as you say, but he could potentially sell up and buy something small to let out and generate his own income or secure himself accommodation as a back up or as something he himself owns.

ignore the tears, that’s bollocks! IT’s manipulation and that would seriously worry me that he’s trying to renegotiate by stealth and trying to get his hands on my house

loislovesstewie · 25/06/2023 09:42

And he needs to sort out the situation with the former marital home. That really is ridiculous.

HermioneKipper · 25/06/2023 09:40

It does seem a little harsh but it’s absolutely your house and he needs to know that. Sounds like perhaps he was starting to feel his way into making it his house too

Is he fully aware it will be going to your kids should anything happen to you? And he’d be out on his ear?

We’ve had some awful situations in our wider family where a second spouse has got everything and given nothing to the original children. I know you’re not married so that shouldn’t be an issue though.

MinnieMountain · 25/06/2023 09:38

Ask about Lasting Power of Attorney whilst you’re there OP.

Willmafrockfit · 25/06/2023 09:37

very strange reaction from him though to be tearful

Willmafrockfit · 25/06/2023 09:36

well done op
glad you have a solicitor appointment to check your will

LovelySparrow · 25/06/2023 09:31

I am definitely definitely not marrying him or anyone

I don't think I have low self esteem. He pays his share of living bills, no he doesn't pay rent but that doesn't bother me. I want him to pay for the extra costs of him living here as opposed to me being on my own, which he does which I suppose is somewhat akin to rent though far lower.

I just will not be taken advantage of. I have an appointment booked with a solicitor in a few weeks time to go through my will because both my kids are over 21 now and I need to update it so I will mention all this at the same time.

He has landed on his feet with me. And I have no problem with that. But that does not mean he gets to share in all the hard work it took for me to get where I am today by contributing nothing financial.

If the situation was reversed and I had a house I already owned and I moved in with someone else, I wouldn't dare call it my house.

OP posts:
FOJN · 25/06/2023 09:31

I think he'll probably leave after something like this. The feeling of security is one of the most fundamental needs that we have as humans and you've just completely ripped that away from him.

He could have achieved that sense of security for himself if it was so fundamental to him, he already part owns a house and is paying part of the mortgage whilst someone else lives there. The OP is not responsible for giving him the security he could get for himself.

He may be happy to let his hard earned cash line someone else's pocket, the OP doesn't have to do the same. She's protecting her own security from a man baby.

If he leaves he will have to sort out the house he owns with his ex so that may be a good thing for him. My guess is that he likes an easy life and he will stay so that OP can continue to subsidise him and he doesn't have to adult about the house he owns with his ex.

ProudThrilledHappy · 25/06/2023 09:30

Daisiesandprimroses · 25/06/2023 08:27

Surprised at some of the very entitled answers. Like living with someone means you get a share of the house. I suspect some projection going on.

op it was the right thing to do. He was testing the water there. He’s got a house. He doesn’t get yours too and it’s important that that’s clear and it doesn’t change by drip drip dripping in it’s his.

he is a grown ass responsible adult, he’s making choices. And he’s choosing not to own with you but his ex. He doesn’t get to own with her and put his hand out to you.

and honestly. He’s taking the piss financially too

Yes this is my thinking, it was a first step towards a slow claim on OP’s home. A lot of women would pussyfoot around it and not contest the “our house” part to avoid offending, but the fact is the house belongs to OP and she is protecting her asset as many people would advise her to do if starting this set up.

I own my home and if I did decide to move a partner in, would be making the ownership situation very very clear to protect the asset I intend to pass to my children.

OPs partner is benefitting from lower costs which enable him to continue paying toward his own asset

WaterIris · 25/06/2023 09:29

OP has done nothing except said, truthfully, that it's not his house. If her comments cause him "trauma" then he should sort out the sale of his property, agree with OP that he will buy-in jointly with her, and step up to become an equal financial partner.

I think he'll probably leave after something like this. The feeling of security is one of the most fundamental needs that we have as humans and you've just completely ripped that away from him

I doubt it - as it would mean him being considerably financially worse off than he is now. Far easier to stay in place, look tearful and wounded and have OP feeling guilty about saying something which is fair, true and reasonable. He's an adult. He got a polite reminder of the reality of his situation. If his intrinsic feeling of security is so vital, then why hasn't he done something to safeguard it?