Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say this is my house?

341 replies

LovelySparrow · 25/06/2023 06:58

Have name changed as I know dp's family is on here

I have been going out with dp for nearly 5 years. We are both in our 50s and divorced with our own kids, none together.

He moved into the house I was living in at the time, since then, I sold the house and bought somewhere bigger where we all had our own space. It is solely in my name and I purchased it on my own and I pay for everything to do with its maintenance/upkeep.

Dp still owns a house with his ex where she lives. She was meant to have sold it by now but doesn't want to (kids have left home etc.). I'm not involved in that. He pays part of the mortgage on that house.

This weekend we were talking about the house and dp mentioned he had paid for something and I said I would refund him. He said why would you do that, it's our house. I said but it isn't actually, it's my house. I said you have a house. This may be your home but it's actually legally my house.

He's now really upset. Said I'm being incredibly nasty and he feels really shit. When we went to bed, I saw he had tears in his eyes. I tried to clear the air but he didn't want to hear it but I'm going to today.

I don't think I'm wrong. We have no kids together. If I die, everything goes to my kids, I've always been clear about that and although we don't have a co habitation agreement, he has (legally) acknowledged that he has no claim on me/my estate if I did die.

I don't think, just because he's moved in with me, that he has any rights to say it's his house or our house in any way. Happy for it to be our home.

Was I a bitch because he seems to be implying that I'm incredibly cruel and unfair?

OP posts:
giraffetrousers · 25/06/2023 11:14

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 25/06/2023 11:01

I know the man in your situation. He does find it upsetting the house isn’t his, he’s worked hard for what he has and just chance and timing means it’s not his. He struggles with having to defer all the time and not having a say over a friendly opinion on his home.

despite those gripes there’s also respect and understanding that it’s her house. He also has a backup plan.

neither of you are wrong it was probably just a reminder to him that he could lose it, he has no claim and actually he needs to sort his shit out with the other house.

Why does he find it upsetting the house isnt his? it was paid for by the OP. Are you saying he thinks he should own half her house ASWELL as having his own house (that the OP has no claim over). How the fck is that fair? he sounds vile

Prelapsarianhag · 25/06/2023 11:13

Boo hoo. He needs to sort his shit out with his own house before crying over yours.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 25/06/2023 11:10

ARareKindaBear · 25/06/2023 07:24

😱 even though she’s the sole owner and bought it before they married?

How do people not know this stuff?! It also works the other way, a woman moves into her partner's house, they don't marry but have kids together. She may end up paying towards the upkeep of the house, bills, etc, but when they split up she's shocked that she's not entitled to anything. Has this ignorance about the benefits (and downside) of marriage come about because it's been pushed as a feminist thing for so long "I'm not anyone's property! I don't belong to anyone, I'm not being "given away" by anyone etc etc etc".

Come on, marriage is a LEGAL process. It MEANS something. I wish people would stop trying to claim that it's anti-feminist or "just a piece of paper" or "just a big waste of money on a meringue dress and a party"

Yes, of course, you don't HAVE to get married if you arrange your legal affairs otherwise so that you are protected. But for a young couple buying their first house together and wanting to start a family, why on earth bother going the complicted route when a simple marriage ceremony does exactly the same thing.

For older couples who have previous partners, homes, children, it's probably better NOT to get married if you don't want your spouse inheriting most of your estate automatically if you were to die.

OP, I think the fact that he's still paying a mortgage elsewhere is all the argument you need for why he has no legal claim to half your house. It's presumably because he has a legal claim to half the house he has with his ex, assuming they were married then divorced. How come he is still paying towards it? Won't it sell or something? Has she told him a sob story about how she can't afford to buy him out?

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 25/06/2023 11:10

ARareKindaBear · 25/06/2023 07:24

😱 even though she’s the sole owner and bought it before they married?

I'm not sure this is right, or at least, not the whole story. I know a guy whose house is worth 2 million. His sole name. His GF lived there for 4 years and then they married, but split up in less than a year. He kept the house but had to buy her a place for 200k mortgage. No dch. So sounds as if 'it depends'.

formulaonecar · 25/06/2023 11:09

I know the man in your situation. He does find it upsetting the house isn’t his, he’s worked hard for what he has and just chance and timing means it’s not his. He struggles with having to defer all the time and not having a say over a friendly opinion on his home

No, its not chance and timing that the house isnt his, its the OP working hard and actually paying for it with her own money, thats exactly why it belongs to her. OP has worked hard too, and she reimburses him for things he buys for the house. If he's so upset about having to defer then why doesnt he contribute more? Oh thats right, its because he cant because he's already paying for his own house.

Lacucuracha · 25/06/2023 11:07

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 25/06/2023 11:01

I know the man in your situation. He does find it upsetting the house isn’t his, he’s worked hard for what he has and just chance and timing means it’s not his. He struggles with having to defer all the time and not having a say over a friendly opinion on his home.

despite those gripes there’s also respect and understanding that it’s her house. He also has a backup plan.

neither of you are wrong it was probably just a reminder to him that he could lose it, he has no claim and actually he needs to sort his shit out with the other house.

How do you know him? Chance and timing have nothing to do with why he has no claim on OP’s home.

Olderandolder · 25/06/2023 11:03

LovelySparrow · 25/06/2023 07:34

Crikey not getting married again, definitely not!

He pays an amount each month into a joint account (the only one we have together) that pays for things like food, meals out, petrol, vet bills. The bills like council tax etc I pick up. He couldn't afford more. I don't mind that, I earn a lot more than him, but I have always been v clear that he has a house that he is choosing to carry on funding.

He doesn't have a life right to live here. If I die, house goes to my kids and I assume at that point, he could sort out his own house by making his ex sell (which he should have done years ago, even before we met).

Are you sure you have legally excluded a claim from him against your estate as a dependent?

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 25/06/2023 11:01

I know the man in your situation. He does find it upsetting the house isn’t his, he’s worked hard for what he has and just chance and timing means it’s not his. He struggles with having to defer all the time and not having a say over a friendly opinion on his home.

despite those gripes there’s also respect and understanding that it’s her house. He also has a backup plan.

neither of you are wrong it was probably just a reminder to him that he could lose it, he has no claim and actually he needs to sort his shit out with the other house.

Griff2 · 25/06/2023 10:55

He's trying to guilt trip (i.e. manipulate) you; the tears in the eyes and refusal to talk about it give that away. You've got your house and he's got his and he knows it.

FictionalCharacter · 25/06/2023 10:51

LovelySparrow · 25/06/2023 07:08

Well yes - he can't actually financially contribute because he is paying the mortgage on his house.

I know he mentioned paying that bill because he wants the money back, not because he was being generous!

Then he has no right to be “upset”, especially as he still has a house with his ex and pays towards it - so he’s still financially entangled with her.
It is your house, that’s a fact.

ForTheSakeOfThePenguin · 25/06/2023 10:48

AdaColeman · 25/06/2023 07:46

Far from being cruel and unfair, you are facilitating his AND his ex wife's life style by your major financial contribution.

Hopefully, he contributes substantially in other ways to your relationship. But if he continues to attempt to guilt trip you, perhaps you need to re evaluate just what he brings to your relationship.

This

burnoutbabe · 25/06/2023 10:47

EbonyRaven · 25/06/2023 10:23

Gosh how awkward. Blush As pps have said it IS his home but of course it's YOUR house. I can understand him being a bit miffed and hurt, and as a few others have said, even though you have been together 5 years and are living together, you don't sound 100% 'in' to this relationship and are clearly keeping your DP at arm's length.

You clearly don't have the confidence to go full on and put the house in both names, and have him pay half for everything - and that is your choice, and your right. I am sure you have a good reason for it. Been stung before, want to keep the inheritance for your kids etc, but don't expect him to be happy with your comments and attitude. Also though, if he wanted to have a share in YOUR house, it's only fair you have a share in the one he and his ex have. Suggest that to him!

You are coming across a bit more like flatmates sorry @LovelySparrow and if the genders were reversed and a man was keeping a woman at bay, and calling the home they lived in HIS house, there would be probably 95% of posters saying he is being unreasonable.

Tricky one. I don't envy you. I think this relationship is at a crisis point now, and has serious cracks in it. Not sure you will both move on from it actually.

Confidence?

If she puts him on the deeds she is gifting him £100k+??

I mean that is some confidence! 1/2 of relationships end.

If he pays he can get a share.

And yes we advise women/sham to get on the deeds if they are vulnerable as we are advising them. If we are advising the man who had the house we'd say do not do it.

rainbowstardrops · 25/06/2023 10:46

Why on earth is he still paying towards a mortgage for his ex when there are no young children still living there? I'd have an issue with that I think.

Willmafrockfit · 25/06/2023 10:44

he is an idiot not to discuss with his ex about selling their house
he is no planner by the sounds of things

BookLover7777 · 25/06/2023 10:43

billy1966 · 25/06/2023 10:35

This.
Exactly.

He has spectacularly landed on his feet, yet wants compensating for the smallest item, whilst all sulky upset half the house isn't his.

OP, you sound like a nice woman but your man bar is real low.

You have a chancer on your hands who is way ahead of you.

Wake up to how mean and entitled he is.

Both ex and him are only weak for this arrangement that suits THEM so well.

"No man as loving as one that is living off you"🙄🤷🏻‍♀️

How is her man bar low if she's financially ring fenced her property and her life? MN is hilarious – women are berated all the time for not protecting themselves in relationships, OP does that and she's blasted for it.

JusthereforXmas · 25/06/2023 10:41

Your house, his home... like the landlord 'own' this but its my home.

You don't have to refund him either, I technically pay the mortgage and up keep through my rent payments as well as all bills here and have for a decade but I have zero state in the ownership of the house. If you live somewhere you pay towards it, it doesn't mean you have any rights to ownership.

BookLover7777 · 25/06/2023 10:41

I don't think you were out of order at all – you were just stating facts. Like it or not, it isn't his house, but it's his home. He has no more claim on your house than you have on the one he owns.

The bedtime tears would bother me more – feels like a manipulative reaction.

FOJN · 25/06/2023 10:41

*soothe

FOJN · 25/06/2023 10:40

classylassie · 25/06/2023 10:00

This is one of the few threads I’ve seen a woman being financially sensible and protecting herself and her kids and posters are saying she’s being mean! Typically MN.
Poor bloke offended by her ‘this your home but my house words’ 🙄

He has a house he pays for!

Absolutley.

OP accepts she is the higher earner and is facilitating their living together by paying a bigger share of their living costs; this is partnership.

She is not interfering with his inaction regarding the former marital home even though it's actually costing her money. She has made the decision to stay out of it and accepts the financial consequences of that.

She draws the line at him having or thinking he may have any claim on her assets.

She is being very clear and fair but some women still think it's a woman's job to sooth the hurt feelings of a man even when he's being unreasonable.

AhNowTed · 25/06/2023 10:38

I'm totally with the OP here.

If something happened to my husband NO WAY would i remarry. And NO WAY would I be signing over any part of my house to a partner who owned another house with his ex.

My assets are going to my children end of.

If he genuinely wanted a shared asset he should have sold the old house.

Instead he wants his cake and eat it.

Pubgardener · 25/06/2023 10:36

@JudgeJ how on earth are you calling the OP unpleasant? She has said that she is happy for him to live in her house whilst she picks up most of his living expenses. She is happy with this. Her line is that she doesn’t want him to have even more whilst he is still paying for the house his ex is living in.

essentially the OP is subsidising this man and his ex. That makes her a bloody saint.

billy1966 · 25/06/2023 10:35

classylassie · 25/06/2023 10:23

Are posters not reading OP’s post where she said he mentioned the bill because he wants the money back? Yes he acted all faux surprised when asking why would LovelySparrow pay him back but she obviously knows him and knows he wants reimbursement. Like his tears his words are manipulative.

This.
Exactly.

He has spectacularly landed on his feet, yet wants compensating for the smallest item, whilst all sulky upset half the house isn't his.

OP, you sound like a nice woman but your man bar is real low.

You have a chancer on your hands who is way ahead of you.

Wake up to how mean and entitled he is.

Both ex and him are only weak for this arrangement that suits THEM so well.

"No man as loving as one that is living off you"🙄🤷🏻‍♀️

burnoutbabe · 25/06/2023 10:26

Zippedydoo123 · 25/06/2023 08:36

You need to take legal advice op. I knew somebody with a private school background she owned her house a new man moved in (father of her 3 children walked out years ago and all children were working and had moved out long since). She was advised to charge him rent and give him a special tenancy agreement to. sign. Go and see a red hot solicitor sharpish as this should have been done years ago op. Good luck.

But if you are not charging any rent to them and they are not paying for major house alterations what claim would they have on your house?

I studied co-habitation in land law and it's very hard to claim a share if you are not on the deeds.

Blossomtoes · 25/06/2023 10:25

ARareKindaBear · 25/06/2023 07:24

😱 even though she’s the sole owner and bought it before they married?

Yes. Unless she lives in Scotland.

EbonyRaven · 25/06/2023 10:23

Gosh how awkward. Blush As pps have said it IS his home but of course it's YOUR house. I can understand him being a bit miffed and hurt, and as a few others have said, even though you have been together 5 years and are living together, you don't sound 100% 'in' to this relationship and are clearly keeping your DP at arm's length.

You clearly don't have the confidence to go full on and put the house in both names, and have him pay half for everything - and that is your choice, and your right. I am sure you have a good reason for it. Been stung before, want to keep the inheritance for your kids etc, but don't expect him to be happy with your comments and attitude. Also though, if he wanted to have a share in YOUR house, it's only fair you have a share in the one he and his ex have. Suggest that to him!

You are coming across a bit more like flatmates sorry @LovelySparrow and if the genders were reversed and a man was keeping a woman at bay, and calling the home they lived in HIS house, there would be probably 95% of posters saying he is being unreasonable.

Tricky one. I don't envy you. I think this relationship is at a crisis point now, and has serious cracks in it. Not sure you will both move on from it actually.