Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say this is my house?

341 replies

LovelySparrow · 25/06/2023 06:58

Have name changed as I know dp's family is on here

I have been going out with dp for nearly 5 years. We are both in our 50s and divorced with our own kids, none together.

He moved into the house I was living in at the time, since then, I sold the house and bought somewhere bigger where we all had our own space. It is solely in my name and I purchased it on my own and I pay for everything to do with its maintenance/upkeep.

Dp still owns a house with his ex where she lives. She was meant to have sold it by now but doesn't want to (kids have left home etc.). I'm not involved in that. He pays part of the mortgage on that house.

This weekend we were talking about the house and dp mentioned he had paid for something and I said I would refund him. He said why would you do that, it's our house. I said but it isn't actually, it's my house. I said you have a house. This may be your home but it's actually legally my house.

He's now really upset. Said I'm being incredibly nasty and he feels really shit. When we went to bed, I saw he had tears in his eyes. I tried to clear the air but he didn't want to hear it but I'm going to today.

I don't think I'm wrong. We have no kids together. If I die, everything goes to my kids, I've always been clear about that and although we don't have a co habitation agreement, he has (legally) acknowledged that he has no claim on me/my estate if I did die.

I don't think, just because he's moved in with me, that he has any rights to say it's his house or our house in any way. Happy for it to be our home.

Was I a bitch because he seems to be implying that I'm incredibly cruel and unfair?

OP posts:
pillsthrillsandbellyache · 25/06/2023 12:23

Good for you OP this is refreshing! Do not apologise to him, in fact I would make a point of reminding him again AND mentioning that you tolerate subsidising HIS ex wife before he tries the old manipulation game again.

Pubgardener · 25/06/2023 12:20

@Twentypastfour Would you seriously pull up a tenant saying something like “we can go back to my house for a barbecue later” with “it’s not actually your house”? Because I don’t see it differently to this at all. He said it in passing.

but he didn’t say it in passing. He said it in regards to a significant financial sum relating to the property, and most people understand that making financial contributions to a cohabitated properties may at some point in the future give a claim.

Twentypastfour · 25/06/2023 12:15

formulaonecar · 25/06/2023 12:04

Of course not but I certainly would query why a tenant was crying about the fact that they dont own my house for sure. Especially if I was paying for everything and funding them to live so they could carry on owning a house with their ex wife.

I just don’t agree with this. Where had it been suggested that he is crying about not legally owning it? He was crying because the OP just reminded him he doesn’t own the house for no real reason (it’s not like he was asking to see a solicitor and change it?). He’s crying because there’s no “our”, it’s all “my” - but no suggestion that he isn’t fine with the current, legal set up of things and wants to dis-inherit the OP’s children.

I was in pretty much this exact situation when my DH (then DP) moved into my then flat. I would never have lived with him at all if we weren’t going to share our lives. His car became “our car”. I was fully aware that should we break up I’d have no claim on his car and he’d have no claim on my flat, but it would have been incredibly petty of either of us to insist on talking about “my flat” / “my car” IMO and I don’t think the relationship would have lasted long.

I don’t see how it’s any different to my children referring to their rooms as “my room” when of course they don’t legally own the rooms or indeed any part of the house…

BurntOutGirl · 25/06/2023 12:14

LovelySparrow · 25/06/2023 09:31

I am definitely definitely not marrying him or anyone

I don't think I have low self esteem. He pays his share of living bills, no he doesn't pay rent but that doesn't bother me. I want him to pay for the extra costs of him living here as opposed to me being on my own, which he does which I suppose is somewhat akin to rent though far lower.

I just will not be taken advantage of. I have an appointment booked with a solicitor in a few weeks time to go through my will because both my kids are over 21 now and I need to update it so I will mention all this at the same time.

He has landed on his feet with me. And I have no problem with that. But that does not mean he gets to share in all the hard work it took for me to get where I am today by contributing nothing financial.

If the situation was reversed and I had a house I already owned and I moved in with someone else, I wouldn't dare call it my house.

Really pleased to read that your financial head overrules your heart. So important when you already own property!

Absolutely it is your house. Maybe he got the reality check remembering he'd be homeless if something happens to you.... hence the tears...

Blossomtoes · 25/06/2023 12:12

formulaonecar · 25/06/2023 12:04

Of course not but I certainly would query why a tenant was crying about the fact that they dont own my house for sure. Especially if I was paying for everything and funding them to live so they could carry on owning a house with their ex wife.

He’s not a tenant, he’s the person she’s apparently chosen to share her life with. It was completely unnecessary to point out that it’s her house. He knows that. He probably heard that as her saying it’s not his home - which is completely different. Anyway it’s a great way to make him question the relationship but perhaps that’s what she wants.

formulaonecar · 25/06/2023 12:04

Twentypastfour · 25/06/2023 11:58

But he’s not asking for a legal claim? They aren’t married and they have discussed and signed legal documentation about how not having a claim? She doesn’t say he’s asked for a change in anything..?

Would you seriously pull up a tenant saying something like “we can go back to my house for a barbecue later” with “it’s not actually your house”? Because I don’t see it differently to this at all. He said it in passing. He didn’t say “Hi Op, I’ve realised I’ve made a mistake in signing away rights my MY HOUSE, let’s go and see a solicitor tomorrow.” He just wants to take pride in the house he lives in.

Of course not but I certainly would query why a tenant was crying about the fact that they dont own my house for sure. Especially if I was paying for everything and funding them to live so they could carry on owning a house with their ex wife.

Twentypastfour · 25/06/2023 11:58

formulaonecar · 25/06/2023 11:53

Is a tenant entitled to say “my home”?

Yes, and OP said it was his home too, but legally its her house which it is. Would a tenant say to their landlord "this house is mine"?

But he’s not asking for a legal claim? They aren’t married and they have discussed and signed legal documentation about how not having a claim? She doesn’t say he’s asked for a change in anything..?

Would you seriously pull up a tenant saying something like “we can go back to my house for a barbecue later” with “it’s not actually your house”? Because I don’t see it differently to this at all. He said it in passing. He didn’t say “Hi Op, I’ve realised I’ve made a mistake in signing away rights my MY HOUSE, let’s go and see a solicitor tomorrow.” He just wants to take pride in the house he lives in.

CustardySergeant · 25/06/2023 11:57

LovelySparrow · 25/06/2023 07:08

Well yes - he can't actually financially contribute because he is paying the mortgage on his house.

I know he mentioned paying that bill because he wants the money back, not because he was being generous!

But you said "This weekend we were talking about the house and dp mentioned he had paid for something and I said I would refund him. He said why would you do that, it's our house." so he was asking why you would refund him as it's 'our house' so why are you saying he wants the money back? That's contradictory.

formulaonecar · 25/06/2023 11:54

In fact, I would argue a tenant has more right to say that because they are paying rent- he isnt.

formulaonecar · 25/06/2023 11:53

Is a tenant entitled to say “my home”?

Yes, and OP said it was his home too, but legally its her house which it is. Would a tenant say to their landlord "this house is mine"?

Twentypastfour · 25/06/2023 11:50

I feel really bad for him. It sounds like he is not trying to make a legal claim on the house - he fully accepts that the Op owns a house and he co-owns another house - but yes, it’s your joint shared home for now. The fact that the OP is picking him up over a slip of words is really sad. What a way to live having to check yourself before you say anything.

Is a tenant entitled to say “my home”?

CurlyhairedAssassin · 25/06/2023 11:49

Out of interest, OP, how long were you going out with him before he moved into yours? Was he still with his ex when he started going out with you, and she chucked him out their jointly-owned house? I can understand you inviting him to live at yours in this scenario, although personally I wouldn't have done that as it would have felt like I was just a convenience. But I would have been very clear about what was going to happen with payments towards the house he had with his ex and when they were going to stop.

stallonesbicep · 25/06/2023 11:48

Does he have tears every time he pays half the mortgage on his property for his ex?

Well, quite. I suspect not because he owns half of it. If PP are saying that due to the fact that they are a couple, he should have a right over her house then it equally follows that the OP should have a third right over HIS house but that hasnt happened. You dont get to share the finances in a partnership that only benefit you but keep the rest back as your own. Thats a case of "whats yours is mine but whats mine is my own"....

Watchinghurling · 25/06/2023 11:45

If you really cared about your children's inheritance, you wouldn't have moved him in. He could cause all kinds of problems after you die for them. Blunt but true.

AhNowTed · 25/06/2023 11:39

CurlyhairedAssassin · 25/06/2023 11:18

Having said that, if I were you, OP, I would not want to think of my partner that I loved being thrown out of his home if I were to die, just so that my children could inherit. You could arrange something legally so that he had a life interest in the house and then after he died it goes to your children. Then again, you've only been together 5 years which isn't a HUGELY long time, and it's a really bloody weird situation where he's still paying towards a different house with his ex.

Just weird all round.

He already owns half a house.

And I can't see him gifting that to the OP!

He wants his cake and eat it.

Nanna50 · 25/06/2023 11:39

Does he have tears every time he pays half the mortgage on his property for his ex?

He has a house, does he view that house as your house?

He needs to wake up to the fact that he is in a very fortunate relationship with you @LovelySparrow how many women would accept subsidising the ex wife with no children? Every year he lives with you his house is earning profit.

Make sure that your Will is watertight including if you need care, become ill, have an accident or just want him to leave.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 25/06/2023 11:37

formulaonecar · 25/06/2023 11:33

Ah I see. But either way, the man in this scenario cant afford to contribute to a joint house even if both of them wanted that because he's still paying for his house with his ex wife. I doubt most of us could afford to have two houses - thats life, no point crying about it. He isnt 14, he is a grown adult and in this case, its not chance or timing, the situation he is in is a direct result of his life choices and him not wanting to give up his house. Thats fine, but he cant really then complain that OP's house isnt his.

No the tears are odd. Giving him the benefit that he’s not an utter cocklodger. The only thing i could think is it’s realisation he needs to sort his shit out, and he’d forgotten himself that it wasn’t his and had got a Little too comfortable.

StormShadow · 25/06/2023 11:36

Exactly, choices have consequences.

formulaonecar · 25/06/2023 11:33

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 25/06/2023 11:16

Well it is in the example of the person I knew. Which is why I said it.

if he’d met his partner sooner he’d have bought the house with her. So, chance and timing.

irrelevant for the op, as she bought it when together.

Ah I see. But either way, the man in this scenario cant afford to contribute to a joint house even if both of them wanted that because he's still paying for his house with his ex wife. I doubt most of us could afford to have two houses - thats life, no point crying about it. He isnt 14, he is a grown adult and in this case, its not chance or timing, the situation he is in is a direct result of his life choices and him not wanting to give up his house. Thats fine, but he cant really then complain that OP's house isnt his.

Womencanlift · 25/06/2023 11:30

As others have said I congratulate the OP on having her children at the forefront of her mind. The tears in the eyes sound manipulative and to get a reaction, that will not be in OPs favour

OP when discussing your will maybe consider stipulating what will happen after your death if he survives you. You don’t want your kids going through a legal hassle of getting him out the house if he refuses to go while they are grieving their mother

dontgobaconmyheart · 25/06/2023 11:23

When you speak with your solicitor OP I would make it a priority to run by them what, if any, right he has to make a claim on the estate as a dependent of yours, given it is you that essentially enables him to maintain a lifestyle and as he has lived with you more than two years without being required to pay rent or a mortgage.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 25/06/2023 11:20

giraffetrousers · 25/06/2023 11:14

Why does he find it upsetting the house isnt his? it was paid for by the OP. Are you saying he thinks he should own half her house ASWELL as having his own house (that the OP has no claim over). How the fck is that fair? he sounds vile

I’m not talking about ops partner. Different man. He doesn’t believe her house is his. He just sometimes struggles with deferring rather than compromise (he’s a tradesman, so capable with his own opinions).

those two would buy together but they love her house and wouldn’t find another like it. So different circumstance but probably similar feelings.

I rent and dislike being able to make decisions about my home, sometimes I cry about it. But I can’t change it. Ops partner can

CurlyhairedAssassin · 25/06/2023 11:18

Having said that, if I were you, OP, I would not want to think of my partner that I loved being thrown out of his home if I were to die, just so that my children could inherit. You could arrange something legally so that he had a life interest in the house and then after he died it goes to your children. Then again, you've only been together 5 years which isn't a HUGELY long time, and it's a really bloody weird situation where he's still paying towards a different house with his ex.

Just weird all round.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 25/06/2023 11:16

formulaonecar · 25/06/2023 11:09

I know the man in your situation. He does find it upsetting the house isn’t his, he’s worked hard for what he has and just chance and timing means it’s not his. He struggles with having to defer all the time and not having a say over a friendly opinion on his home

No, its not chance and timing that the house isnt his, its the OP working hard and actually paying for it with her own money, thats exactly why it belongs to her. OP has worked hard too, and she reimburses him for things he buys for the house. If he's so upset about having to defer then why doesnt he contribute more? Oh thats right, its because he cant because he's already paying for his own house.

Well it is in the example of the person I knew. Which is why I said it.

if he’d met his partner sooner he’d have bought the house with her. So, chance and timing.

irrelevant for the op, as she bought it when together.

AhNowTed · 25/06/2023 11:15

He's done rather well out of the arrangement so far, hasn't he.

OP is essentially subsiding his and his ex-wife's lifestyle.