Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say this is my house?

341 replies

LovelySparrow · 25/06/2023 06:58

Have name changed as I know dp's family is on here

I have been going out with dp for nearly 5 years. We are both in our 50s and divorced with our own kids, none together.

He moved into the house I was living in at the time, since then, I sold the house and bought somewhere bigger where we all had our own space. It is solely in my name and I purchased it on my own and I pay for everything to do with its maintenance/upkeep.

Dp still owns a house with his ex where she lives. She was meant to have sold it by now but doesn't want to (kids have left home etc.). I'm not involved in that. He pays part of the mortgage on that house.

This weekend we were talking about the house and dp mentioned he had paid for something and I said I would refund him. He said why would you do that, it's our house. I said but it isn't actually, it's my house. I said you have a house. This may be your home but it's actually legally my house.

He's now really upset. Said I'm being incredibly nasty and he feels really shit. When we went to bed, I saw he had tears in his eyes. I tried to clear the air but he didn't want to hear it but I'm going to today.

I don't think I'm wrong. We have no kids together. If I die, everything goes to my kids, I've always been clear about that and although we don't have a co habitation agreement, he has (legally) acknowledged that he has no claim on me/my estate if I did die.

I don't think, just because he's moved in with me, that he has any rights to say it's his house or our house in any way. Happy for it to be our home.

Was I a bitch because he seems to be implying that I'm incredibly cruel and unfair?

OP posts:
LadyBird1973 · 25/06/2023 08:23

I think the context in which you said it was harsh, even if essentially true.
But it has thrown up a bigger issue. It's time he severed his financial connections to his ex wife and I would be pushing for that. I do view it as your business because he's being subsidised by you.
And if you did die, then your children have the problem of asking him to leave the house. It's kind of making it their problem to solve because he has nothing in savings to actually enable him to move out! His ex wife might try to block a sale and even if she's cooperative, it can take months to get a buyer etc. I think this is something that ought to be sorted asap.

But I can see why his feelings were hurt - you basically told him that his home isn't his home, and until that point he'd felt emotionally that it was.

Roselilly36 · 25/06/2023 08:22

I wouldn’t want this complication in my life tbh. If DH died, no way would I allow any other man to move in. We have worked hard for our assets and they will go to our DS’ when the time comes. Get some advice from a solicitor to protect your assets now, if you haven’t done so already.

EggInANest · 25/06/2023 08:21

OP, I see nothing wrong with this set up. Hah! If a woman was earning much less than a male partner and living in a house of his ownership, many posters would strongly advocate that she should not pay towards someone else’s property, was in an insecure position, needed to be on the deeds etc!

HOWEVER, it sounds as if even without the fact that he is paying his old mortgage on ex’s house he is in a weaker finance position than you.

He paid a bill, he sounds as if he was happy to pay it as a contribution, and it might have sounded to him as if you were throwing it back in his face. Or passive aggressively establishing your boundary, or emphasising your territory.

Listen to what he says about this.

Does it ever feel as if he is hanging on to anything with his ex, by keeping that house and not rocking that boat? Guilt? Feeling protective?

I hope you get it resolved between you.

StopMindlesslyScrolling · 25/06/2023 08:20

This fella has nothing to cry about 🙄

He's living rent free with you, not even contributing to council tax (when his residing with you means that you pay 25%more than you would living alone) so he's costing you money, you're subsidising his lifestyle and he gets pissy when you say the house isn't his.

You're not his mum. He's an adult and should be paying his own way. If he can't afford to, then he should sell his place with his ex wife.

He's a cocklodger with the hump; I'm surprised that doesn't give you the ick.

Daleksatemyshed · 25/06/2023 08:19

I don't understand why he's still paying towards his old home, unless he still has young DC living there why wouldn't he divorce and force the sale of the house. At the moment he seems to want committment from you and gets to live in your house for next to nothing whilst having no money as it all goes to the exs mortgage. Sounds too close to being a cocklodger to me Op

RaininSummer · 25/06/2023 08:18

I don't think there is anything wrong with what you said or your set up. If your partner wants a share of the house then you would buy one together. Quite clearly this is your asset and he lives there. I have the same thing with my house going to my children when I die. My partner will need to plan for this eventuality as the house is his home now but not his actual house. And thank goodness it is as there is a reason people, especially older ones, don't want to get married and risk losing their assets.

Dibbydoos · 25/06/2023 08:17

Def you're house, def reimburse him.

I'd also make sure your will is watertight. He might say he has no claim but his behaviour says otherwise.

YANB

YouJustDoYou · 25/06/2023 08:17

You were right to be clear about it. It's your home that you have paid for. You are not married. You need to protect your assets. If the sexes were reversed it would be the same deal - if it were all in the male partner's name and the female partner paid nothing towards it, no marriage etc, everyone would be saying she would be very vulnerable financially...IF she ALSO didn't actually own her own home, which your male dp does!!

I don't know what he's crying for, people have to be practical about these things and he doesn't get to just have financial dibs on YOUR property just because he's your boyfriend, just as a girlfriend wouldn't get financial dibs on a boyfriend's property he pays everything for.

Daffodilwoman · 25/06/2023 08:17

I’m with you op.
He has a property with his ex. His dc will benefit from that. Your dc will benefit from your house.

EarringsandLipstick · 25/06/2023 08:16

EarringsandLipstick · 25/06/2023 08:12

This all sounds like a mess.

You're not a

Oops.

You're not wrong OP, to have set out a clear arrangement that protects you & your DC.

However, your DP is in a vulnerable position & I'm not sure why he hasn't resolved matters with his own property and ex. If he is divorced, this should have been finalised then?

You sound quite cold to him. I felt for him, that he had tears in his eyes.

I think if you are truly in a relationship you need to have another discussion about your positions & financial futures.

CapEBarra · 25/06/2023 08:15

So he’s not contributing to the mortgage, etc.? Does he realise the only reason his wife is getting to stay in their joint house is because you’re subsidising his lifestyle.

1970X · 25/06/2023 08:14

I think you were absolutely right to remind him that it’s your house, he has a house just not with you.

How long does he have until his mortgage is paid off? Is he definitely paying that?

Moveoverdarlin · 25/06/2023 08:14

Oh darling, I didn’t mean to upset you. If you feel that strongly, kick out your ex-Mrs, sell your house and pay off my mortgage? Then it can be our house. No? Don’t fancy that?

You weren’t out of order at all, if anything it’s good to reinforce this type of stuff all the time.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 25/06/2023 08:13

I think you were right to be very clear about this. Of course much depends on the way it was said, which is hard to judge without being there.

EarringsandLipstick · 25/06/2023 08:12

This all sounds like a mess.

You're not a

TheaBrandt · 25/06/2023 08:11

if you are “supporting” him which includes providing him with somewhere to live and leave him out of your will he is in the category of people who could make a claim on your estate on death. It would be for a court to decide what’s fair in the circumstances.

I would redo your will give him a right of occupation which ends after say 6 months to 2 years to give breathing space and maybe a small cash gift and draft a letter of wishes saying the house is for your kids and he has his own house to head off a claim.

Mirabai · 25/06/2023 08:10

In the list of stuff he pays for OP you don’t list utilities.

If he can’t afford to pay his way he needs to sort out his divorce: either ex takes over the mortgage or the house is sold and the proceeds divided.

You are subsidising his ex’s lifestyle - why?

If he hadn’t moved in with you he would have been forced to push ahead with divorce or he wouldn’t have been able to afford to live.

Paq · 25/06/2023 08:08

I imagine your comment reinforced his feeling of vulnerability. He is in a very weak position in that you could toss him out at a moment’s notice on a whim.

It’s not your responsibility but he needs to sort out his housing situation with his ex.

PriOn1 · 25/06/2023 08:08

I don’t quite understand why it came up. In your first post, you said:

”This weekend we were talking about the house and dp mentioned he had paid for something and I said I would refund him. He said why would you do that, it's our house.”

But in a later post you say:

”I know he mentioned paying that bill because he wants the money back, not because he was being generous!”

If he was mentioning it because he wants the money back, why would he then question why you would refund him? Do you think he was looking for a fight, or that he isn’t happy with the current arrangement? Or did I misunderstand something (very possible as I’m unwell and not at all with it)?

FWIW, it sounds a very sensible arrangement and you sound like you have good boundaries.

AP5Diva · 25/06/2023 08:07

If I'm living with someone and I said "my house" and my partner turned round and said it's not your house. It's my house and it'll never be your house, I'd be upset. I'd feel pretty undermined and worthless. I get that the op is just being truthful but there are just nicer ways to say it, I guess.

This reflects my thinking too. Even tenants in a rental will refer to the heap of bricks and mortar as “their house” as in you should come over to ours, check out our house.

DP knows he doesn’t own it and there was no need for OP to remind him of it so bluntly and essentially pull him up on saying “our house” instead of “your house”. I can see why he reacted as he did
”He's now really upset. Said I'm being incredibly nasty and he feels really shit. When we went to bed, I saw he had tears in his eyes.”

continentallentil · 25/06/2023 08:06

SeeingSpots · 25/06/2023 07:02

If he has legally acknowledge he has no claim on the property I think you were being quite petty to pick him up on it.

He obviously sees it as his house in that he wants to help pay for things and enjoys living there with you. It seems a very spiteful thing to bring up unnecessary to what was a very innocent comment.

Yep.

He’s obviously hurt, so let it settle and then have a conversation about it.

Oomph · 25/06/2023 08:05

charabang · 25/06/2023 07:18

I'm with you OP. At this stage of life it's important everyone knows where they stand legally and financially. If he wanted the committment he could have sold his house and had a financial input into a joint home. Instead he has a leg in both camps; neither in or out. I'd be checking out legally that he has no claim on your home if you split up because he is not viewing ownership the same way you do.

What this lady said

borntobequiet · 25/06/2023 08:05

He is being unreasonable. Tell him to stop the silly sulking.

AgnesX · 25/06/2023 08:04

You're quite right and I think you need to spell out to him exactly why.

I wonder though, as he has so little input, why he has the idea that it's yours in the plural. Is he entitled or have you inadvertently let him think that way.

Tanfastic · 25/06/2023 08:04

Op, I think you've been very clear. I would have said exactly the same. Don't feel guilty.