Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be asked where are you from

264 replies

Tweetypie1st · 25/06/2023 01:59

For background, DH & I live in UK but originally came from South Asia several years ago. This is our home now.
So we are getting quotes for a garage conversion and we had someone come over to have a look. It was an older husband & wife team and they are telling us all sorts of stories(my understanding was trying to build a rapport) and then the guy asks where are we from. And I could tell my DH getting annoyed, so I just replied where I came from. And then he tells us more stories. And then he asks my husband what does he do? And my DH said we live here and then laughed so it doesn't get awkward. After they were gone, he was fuming saying how racist of him to ask us where are we from; we live & work here! Would it be okay if I asked him the same question? What if we were born here; he thinks it's okay to ask this question just because we have a different skin colour.

Would you ask this question to anyone, especially a stranger? Would you be offended if someone asked you that? How would you reply to the question?

OP posts:
Justroundthecorner · 25/06/2023 09:54

Quinoawoman · 25/06/2023 09:49

If you have a foreign accent, it's fine to ask where someone is from, regardless of the colour of their skin.

Why on earth did you husband reply 'we live here' to the question 'what do you do'?

Bloody hell, no, it is not.

Justroundthecorner · 25/06/2023 09:54

@nancy2022 but is there really such a dramatic difference between ‘where are you from?’ if the answer is London or Lahore?

‘Where are you from?’ is a question to me that is fine in some contexts but really is not in others. If I am buying a coffee and I say to the person serving me ‘where are you from?’ I would say that’s inappropriate. Maybe some people do mean it as friendly small talk but I would say the weather, gosh town is busy / quiet is better.

OTOH if I am chatting with a colleague and she says something like ‘the public transport system here is atrocious!’ and I agree and she says it’s far better where I grew up, asking where that is is then totally appropriate, friendly and non intrusive.

But I do think demanding to know where people who have opened their mouths fewer times than their fingers are from is just not quite on. I get some people don’t mind, but the thing is that the potential to make people feel uneasy is quite big if they do mind, and bear in mind people will often be polite and respond whilst thinking, oh fuck off!

Quinoawoman · 25/06/2023 09:49

If you have a foreign accent, it's fine to ask where someone is from, regardless of the colour of their skin.

Why on earth did you husband reply 'we live here' to the question 'what do you do'?

Justroundthecorner · 25/06/2023 09:48

Actually, thinking about it, it is possibly not entirely different to the unusual name debate.

Some people (and I am one of them) like to blend in. I am not shy, or particularly reserved, but standing out isn’t massively comfortable for me and I feel awkward when a difference or a perceived difference is commented on, especially when it is constant.

Others absolutely love it. It isn’t for me to say who is right and who is wrong in that scenario but I do think some recognition that even if you’re only ‘being curious’ it might not always be appreciated is appropriate!

nancy2022 · 25/06/2023 09:48

@xsquared In your scenario that is racist. They should ask where your parents / grandparents were born.

This is not the same as the OP's issue.

doubleoseven · 25/06/2023 09:47

Most of my colleagues are here on work visas and the students we work with are here on student visas. Its very normal for everyone to ask each other where they're from, although they'll usually volunteer that information by talking about something back home. Personally I love hearing about what life, and our profession is like in all these far flung countries. It's makes for a very interesting work place and I've actually learned a lot about their home countries, the politics, education systems etc.
I think your DH massively overreacted, he was probably just interested/trying to build a rapport as you say.

Callyem · 25/06/2023 09:47

Where are you from and what do you do seem to me to be perfectly normal conversation questions when trying to build a rapport with someone.

DojaPhat · 25/06/2023 09:45

Your responses will vary according to which demographic you ask. If you and your husband are both South Asian then I find it odd that you'd be perplexed by your husband's response/feelings about it even if you personally are okay with it.

xsquared · 25/06/2023 09:44

nancy2022 · 25/06/2023 09:35

They aren't doing it based on skin colour though.

If they had a British accent I doubt he would need to ask?

Not true in my experience. I still get asked "Where are you really from?" and I'm Asian and have a Southern UK accent.

Maybe skin colour was indeed a factor.

Blueberry40 · 25/06/2023 09:43

chopc · 25/06/2023 08:12

People who are white with regional/European/American accents or heritage who have made uk their home don't get offended when asked where they are from as they are white and feel like they are being asked about their accent but they still belong in UK. Future generations will have a different accent and will no longer get asked that question.
Those with a different skin colour feel offended because no matter how many generations live in the UK, you can't change the colour of your skin. So they will never get that same sense of belonging . I am not white but I am happy identifying as an British Asian

This is not true for me. I’m white (very pale) with a typical accent for the region I live in and have lived in the UK all my life but constantly get asked where I’m from because of my hair colour. When I tell people they usually act with disbelief. Sometimes disappointment because they were sure I had more interesting heritage.

It makes me feel very uncomfortable and some comments feel as though they are suggesting I don’t belong in the UK because I look as if I have Turkish/Iranian heritage. I have tried dying my hair but it is so black that it won’t take dye at all and so am just embracing it now. I am so tired of people telling me I “don’t look English” though…I’m just me! People have even tried arguing with me about my heritage and I often get the “but where are your parents/family from” question. It’s tedious.

RedTemple · 25/06/2023 09:38

My DH is a first generation immigrant from SE Asia. He loves asking people about their background/heritage, even if he has just met them. I find it stressful in case he offends somebody.
I am a second generation immigrant, white and born and brought up in UK. I never ask anybody anything about their background until I feel I know them reasonably well. I would be worried about causing offence.

nancy2022 · 25/06/2023 09:35

autieawesome · 25/06/2023 03:36

The assumption you are from another country based on skin colour is appalling. I would find that offensive.

Northerners who live in the south being asked where they are from is not offensive and vice versa

They aren't doing it based on skin colour though.

If they had a British accent I doubt he would need to ask?

Blip · 25/06/2023 09:35

If you have anything other than the local accent it's an obvious question to be asked.

Justroundthecorner · 25/06/2023 09:34

aurynne · 25/06/2023 09:23

Well then please wear a sign saying "don't ask me any questions", because all questions are asked to satisfy someone's curiosity.

There are countless questions where someone’s interest / curiosity might be sincere but we recognise that it wouldn’t be appropriate.

’Why are you in a wheelchair?’
‘I’ve heard you were in prison - how come?’
’How did you get that scar on your face?’

Now I know people will get all annoyed and say those questions are so different to ‘where are you from’ but actually they aren’t, really. Questions in the context of a conversation are vastly different to just randomly grilling people through curiosity.

xsquared · 25/06/2023 09:33

rockywilderness · 25/06/2023 07:33

I think there’s a very big difference between where are you from and where are you really from - the first is polite, getting to know you chit chat, the second is very offensive.

Totally agree with this, but it seems a lot of white posters don't get that being asked "where are you from?" is a different experience for someone of colour.

I usually assume when someone asks me "Where are you from?", that they mean where I currently live, so I say my home town.

However, I have had exchanges where I have given 4 different answers : my home town, where I grew up, where I was born and finally the country my parents were born which I've only visited twice, because what they really wanted to know was what my ethnicity is.

Why was my first answer not good enough but the last one, which has the least to do with where I'm from is?

OP I get you. Perhaps they were just trying to make conversation, and in your dh's position, I would have just answered with where you currently live. I think when it leads to "Where are you really from?, it just kills conversation anyway, undoing the purpose of the original question!

Mothwingdust · 25/06/2023 09:29

I’m Chinese but born and raised in England so also British. DH is from the South of England and white English. I’m asked all the time, I speak with an RP accent. I don’t get offended.

@bladebladebla1 Agree with you 100% on what it feels like being asked.

Natsku · 25/06/2023 09:29

I live abroad, I always get asked where I'm from based on my name, accent, language skills. That's fair enough, its obvious I'm not native and its a common question for people to ask when meeting someone. If I was getting asked just based on the colour of my skin that would be different because that's not a fair assumption.

aurynne · 25/06/2023 09:23

Justroundthecorner · 25/06/2023 09:22

Not all ‘where are you froms’ are racist. A lot are tedious as hell though and a fair few are racist.

I don’t exist to satisfy your curiosity.

Well then please wear a sign saying "don't ask me any questions", because all questions are asked to satisfy someone's curiosity.

Justroundthecorner · 25/06/2023 09:22

Not all ‘where are you froms’ are racist. A lot are tedious as hell though and a fair few are racist.

I don’t exist to satisfy your curiosity.

xogossipgirlxo · 25/06/2023 09:22

Okshacky · 25/06/2023 09:07

I get asked this a lot and I hate it and always have, mostly because I don’t really know the answer. What do people mean? Do they want to know where you were born, where you lived as small child, your ethnic origin, where you live now??? What do they want to hear?

It’s true. Once landlord asked me where we are from, I said country XYZ and he laughed and said „no I meant what part of London do you live in now?”. How was I supposed to know? No one asked me for this information in such way.

aurynne · 25/06/2023 09:21

Justroundthecorner · 25/06/2023 06:50

I’m probably a minority but I don’t like it.

People making a fuss about a perceived difference, whether based on accent or appearance, can really make you feel like a stranger.

But... for the person asking, you ARE a stranger.

I'm a Spaniard living in New Zealand. I expect people to ask me where I'm from as I have an accent... why on earth would that be racist? I ask people where they are from all the time, because I am curious.

SallyWD · 25/06/2023 09:17

Some might ask "Where are you from?" in a slightly racist "othering" way but I'm sure others are just genuinely interested and trying to make conversation. I've been to India a lot (in laws live there) and people see me as a white person and ask where I'm from. I don't see it as racism but curiosity. If your DH has been at the receiving end of racism then I can see why he might see this as another attempt to treat him as a "foreigner" or different somehow.

SomePeopleAreNice · 25/06/2023 09:15

Okshacky · 25/06/2023 09:07

I get asked this a lot and I hate it and always have, mostly because I don’t really know the answer. What do people mean? Do they want to know where you were born, where you lived as small child, your ethnic origin, where you live now??? What do they want to hear?

This is the same with my kids. They were born in different counties to where they were raised and to where they now live and have parents from different countries. Their accents and the colour of their skin is quite different to mine too. People love to try and guess where they are from.
They don't feel they are 'from' anywhere.
They all love to be asked where they are 'from'

GodspeedJune · 25/06/2023 09:11

I live in a different part of the country to where I am from and get asked this frequently due to my accent. I’m white so it’s not racist. I understand it can have racist undertones sometimes, but just to reassure you at other times it’s genuine interest.

SomePeopleAreNice · 25/06/2023 09:10

If you are not white plus if you have an accent then is it still a rude question.

My kids are very olive skinned and dark and all have strange accents from having lived in different countries, they get asked where they are from a lot. I assume because it's not obvious.

I'm always interested in people backgrounds but I'm careful about asking where someone is from if it's someone who could think I'm being racist.

It's a normal question usually though and it's a shame that people find it racist. It's interesting.

Is it a question that should literally never be asked? I feel that sometimes it is ok (but I'm white so.......) Is it acceptable to fudge the question and ask if someone grew up in the area. Then the person being asked can just say yes or no without having to having ti explain more if they don't won't to.
I think lots of people like to talk about where they are from if it's from overseas.
I'm used to being in circles where people are from all over the world so maybe it's more of a normal question.

Having said all that I don't ask 'where are you from' as it's easier enough not too and I don't want to risk being thought of as racist

Swipe left for the next trending thread