Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be asked where are you from

264 replies

Tweetypie1st · 25/06/2023 01:59

For background, DH & I live in UK but originally came from South Asia several years ago. This is our home now.
So we are getting quotes for a garage conversion and we had someone come over to have a look. It was an older husband & wife team and they are telling us all sorts of stories(my understanding was trying to build a rapport) and then the guy asks where are we from. And I could tell my DH getting annoyed, so I just replied where I came from. And then he tells us more stories. And then he asks my husband what does he do? And my DH said we live here and then laughed so it doesn't get awkward. After they were gone, he was fuming saying how racist of him to ask us where are we from; we live & work here! Would it be okay if I asked him the same question? What if we were born here; he thinks it's okay to ask this question just because we have a different skin colour.

Would you ask this question to anyone, especially a stranger? Would you be offended if someone asked you that? How would you reply to the question?

OP posts:
Rummikub · 25/06/2023 13:03

I’m American and white. When I’m asked, it’s not the same as people who are asked because of the colour of their skin. If you don’t understand that, you should really try to.

this.

im not white and I’ll answer Liverpool. But then get a quizzical look. So I understand your dh pov.

it can be a question asked out of racism - the assumption being you’re not British.

Nowadays I’ll base my response on the context and intent.

AhNowTed · 25/06/2023 13:03

In Ireland they have your life history while waiting for a bus!

It's just conversation.

I speak with an accent and am asked all the time.

Doesn't bother me one bit.

OneTC · 25/06/2023 12:59

Zarah123 · 25/06/2023 12:43

Just the fact that you are a first generation immigrant but can call yourself ‘English’ because you’re white shows your privilege. BAME immigrants do not have this privilege.

My other half describes herself as English or British.

I can be easily mistaken for English but I'm not and I'd feel weird, as an immigrant, to be describing myself as such

BansheeofInisherin · 25/06/2023 12:58

I'd have thought people would be proud and pleased to talk about their backgrounds.

The reason why some of us are sometimes not proud or pleased to talk about our backgrounds ( and I don't mean in the OP's example) is because those backgrounds have been traditionally vilified and continue to be vilified- including by those who come from those very backgrounds like Sunak and company-to gain favour with Tory voters. Suella Braverman has got up there and said multiculturalism does not work, and been applauded. What she meant was: brown and black people do not assimilate. Perhaps you can see why people just want to blend in, in some cases.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 25/06/2023 12:57

I teach a class at the multicultural Centre which is specifically targeted at refugees and migrants. That is actually a requirement of the programme.

At the start of every course, we go around and introduce ourselves - what is your name, where are you from and how long have you lived here.

Nobody has ever been offended and many interesting conversations have been started between participants.

Having been both the majority skin colour and minority skin colour, I have never been offended when people ask me where I am from. I was once offended after an American woman started telling me how shit her stay in that country was back in the seventies. But it wasn’t the question that was offensive, just her response.

Whattodo112222 · 25/06/2023 12:55

I'm Mauritian and get asked where I'm from every single day pretty much... i also get the presumption that I'm Indian or Sri Lankan.. I'm not at all offended.

Zarah123 · 25/06/2023 12:48

Justroundthecorner · 25/06/2023 12:46

@Zarah123 I think some people do think their desire to know (why??) means that the other persons discomfort does not matter.

Totally agree.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 25/06/2023 12:48

DustySoil · 25/06/2023 12:29

This is why life can be tricky. Like many people I go through life trying not to offend people and by trying to be a nice person. I try and keep abreast of what is and isn't offensive. Having lived abroad I've had to be careful to change my language in different countries.

I know not to ask people where they are from so I don't. It's no biggie.

However, as a white personal I have to admit to not understanding (in my head) why showing an interest in someone's background is racist. I'd have thought people would be proud and pleased to talk about their backgrounds. I can see that it is rude to push or continue a line of questioning where someone has indicated that they don't wish to. Anyone with half a brain cell can see "No, where are you really from" is not ok obviously.

I know what to do and I'll do it happily but I do think it's a shame. It seems to be making it a taboo subject. One persons 'othering' seems to be another's 'celebrating our differences'

If someone is happy and proud of their heritage and willing to share then it honestly comes up in conversation anyways which is actually a lot more natural.

Justroundthecorner · 25/06/2023 12:46

@Zarah123 I think some people do think their desire to know (why??) means that the other persons discomfort does not matter.

Zarah123 · 25/06/2023 12:45

DustySoil · 25/06/2023 12:29

This is why life can be tricky. Like many people I go through life trying not to offend people and by trying to be a nice person. I try and keep abreast of what is and isn't offensive. Having lived abroad I've had to be careful to change my language in different countries.

I know not to ask people where they are from so I don't. It's no biggie.

However, as a white personal I have to admit to not understanding (in my head) why showing an interest in someone's background is racist. I'd have thought people would be proud and pleased to talk about their backgrounds. I can see that it is rude to push or continue a line of questioning where someone has indicated that they don't wish to. Anyone with half a brain cell can see "No, where are you really from" is not ok obviously.

I know what to do and I'll do it happily but I do think it's a shame. It seems to be making it a taboo subject. One persons 'othering' seems to be another's 'celebrating our differences'

Did you read my post explaining why it’s not well received?

Why say you don’t understand when you haven’t read or acknowledged people explaining why?

Backstreets · 25/06/2023 12:44

Well I’m mixed so there’s always the undertone of “where are you REALLY from” which does feel a bit shit but I think most who ask are just genuinely curious.

Zarah123 · 25/06/2023 12:43

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 25/06/2023 12:32

@Mamaneedsadrink I'm first generation English and white. My name makes it obvious I'm not of English heritage. I get asked where I'm from... it really doesn't bother me. I happily talk about where my parents and grandparents were born.

It's very common in the UK to be asked where you're from and what you do as as way to make conversation.

The recent issue with an elderly lady in the royal household asking a black lady where she came from opened up a discussion I wasn't aware we needed to have. The social storm that exchange created has made me nervous about asking people where they're from, which I think is a shame as I enjoy learning about other people's culture.

Just the fact that you are a first generation immigrant but can call yourself ‘English’ because you’re white shows your privilege. BAME immigrants do not have this privilege.

Zarah123 · 25/06/2023 12:41

onefinemess · 25/06/2023 12:01

Why do you think I'm white?

Racist much?

🙄

Where did I say you were white?

Beneficialchampion2 · 25/06/2023 12:40

In woke culture it is a micro aggression, not racist in my opinion.

You could have just replied with where are are living currently...

You can't ask bugger all of anyone nowadays without them feeling an entitled sense of offense.

BansheeofInisherin · 25/06/2023 12:37

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 25/06/2023 12:32

@Mamaneedsadrink I'm first generation English and white. My name makes it obvious I'm not of English heritage. I get asked where I'm from... it really doesn't bother me. I happily talk about where my parents and grandparents were born.

It's very common in the UK to be asked where you're from and what you do as as way to make conversation.

The recent issue with an elderly lady in the royal household asking a black lady where she came from opened up a discussion I wasn't aware we needed to have. The social storm that exchange created has made me nervous about asking people where they're from, which I think is a shame as I enjoy learning about other people's culture.

That one was actually racist and unnecessary.

Justroundthecorner · 25/06/2023 12:37

@DustySoil to be honest I really don’t think it’s as tricky as you’re making it out to be.

It is all about the context in which the question comes up. My issue isn’t a friendly chat. It’s when (as someone said above) people leap in to ask when it isn’t relevant or as part of the conversation.

I used to work with families who needed support with a member of their family with a learning difficulty - sometimes a physical need as well, there was crossover. It involved visiting them in their own homes, and so you expect some chat of course but my god if I had a pound for every time someone demanded to know where I was from, where is THAT accent from, you’re not from round here are ya (with a look of triumph) … like I say it got really tedious and boring.

That is different to say talking about schools and it naturally coming up that you went to one elsewhere in the country.

Gettingbysomehow · 25/06/2023 12:33

My Dsis who is not very patient with all this stuff when asked what she does for a living says she runs the local corner shop. She's actually a doctor 😂

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 25/06/2023 12:32

@Mamaneedsadrink I'm first generation English and white. My name makes it obvious I'm not of English heritage. I get asked where I'm from... it really doesn't bother me. I happily talk about where my parents and grandparents were born.

It's very common in the UK to be asked where you're from and what you do as as way to make conversation.

The recent issue with an elderly lady in the royal household asking a black lady where she came from opened up a discussion I wasn't aware we needed to have. The social storm that exchange created has made me nervous about asking people where they're from, which I think is a shame as I enjoy learning about other people's culture.

Gettingbysomehow · 25/06/2023 12:32

Its tedious isn't it, I never get asked where I'm from because I'm white with an english accent but in fact I'm not from the UK.
My siblings who are half asian and younger than me constantly get asked where they are from despite the fact they were born in the UK and have very british accents.
I often get asked if I am their mum. I do wish people would just mind their own damned business.

DustySoil · 25/06/2023 12:29

This is why life can be tricky. Like many people I go through life trying not to offend people and by trying to be a nice person. I try and keep abreast of what is and isn't offensive. Having lived abroad I've had to be careful to change my language in different countries.

I know not to ask people where they are from so I don't. It's no biggie.

However, as a white personal I have to admit to not understanding (in my head) why showing an interest in someone's background is racist. I'd have thought people would be proud and pleased to talk about their backgrounds. I can see that it is rude to push or continue a line of questioning where someone has indicated that they don't wish to. Anyone with half a brain cell can see "No, where are you really from" is not ok obviously.

I know what to do and I'll do it happily but I do think it's a shame. It seems to be making it a taboo subject. One persons 'othering' seems to be another's 'celebrating our differences'

Lndnmummy · 25/06/2023 12:13

ListeningToTheDog · 25/06/2023 03:31

I’m American and white. When I’m asked, it’s not the same as people who are asked because of the colour of their skin. If you don’t understand that, you should really try to.

This. I am white but with an accent as I am from a European country. Me being asked where I am from is not at all the same as when my black midlands born and bread dh gets the same question.

Haveallthesongsbeenwritten · 25/06/2023 12:08

Tweetypie1st · 25/06/2023 01:59

For background, DH & I live in UK but originally came from South Asia several years ago. This is our home now.
So we are getting quotes for a garage conversion and we had someone come over to have a look. It was an older husband & wife team and they are telling us all sorts of stories(my understanding was trying to build a rapport) and then the guy asks where are we from. And I could tell my DH getting annoyed, so I just replied where I came from. And then he tells us more stories. And then he asks my husband what does he do? And my DH said we live here and then laughed so it doesn't get awkward. After they were gone, he was fuming saying how racist of him to ask us where are we from; we live & work here! Would it be okay if I asked him the same question? What if we were born here; he thinks it's okay to ask this question just because we have a different skin colour.

Would you ask this question to anyone, especially a stranger? Would you be offended if someone asked you that? How would you reply to the question?

I live in the UK but from France, i get asked all the time. Not offended, people are just curious/interested thats all.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 25/06/2023 12:07

everybodytidy · 25/06/2023 11:05

If we aren't allowed to ask simple questions like this, we are going to shut down communication at its roots. It sounds like it was more curiosity and conversation making than racism in any form. How are we to learn about eachother if we don't ask questions?

This is like men saying society will cease to desist since they're so afraid to even talk to a woman now.

I do talk to a lot of people, made friends, make small talk at the school gates or random strangers. Never "where are you from?" has ever been necessary to start a conversation or keep it going . Never . Tbh as the friendship/relationship evolves it comes up anyways . If it never goes past one chance encounter, it was never that relevant anyways.

No stranger will become my best friend by stopping me in a shop , while I'm minding me my own business and , interrupting me while I'm talking to my daughter to ask where I'm from because of my accent. Yes that really happened(more than once) , and even if it was with the best intentions I frankly don't care because it was rude, intrusive and worrying for a bit as I didn't know what reaction I's get and I had my daughter with me.

I don't exist as entertainment/education.

Justroundthecorner · 25/06/2023 12:07

You don’t have to describe yourself. That’s the point. No one should have to provide a contextual history of where they are from when they open their mouths.

onefinemess · 25/06/2023 12:04

I'm not "from here" either.

People. An live in lots of places. And saying "I'm not from here" is factually correct. I'm not from here, how else would you prefer me to describe myself?