Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be asked where are you from

264 replies

Tweetypie1st · 25/06/2023 01:59

For background, DH & I live in UK but originally came from South Asia several years ago. This is our home now.
So we are getting quotes for a garage conversion and we had someone come over to have a look. It was an older husband & wife team and they are telling us all sorts of stories(my understanding was trying to build a rapport) and then the guy asks where are we from. And I could tell my DH getting annoyed, so I just replied where I came from. And then he tells us more stories. And then he asks my husband what does he do? And my DH said we live here and then laughed so it doesn't get awkward. After they were gone, he was fuming saying how racist of him to ask us where are we from; we live & work here! Would it be okay if I asked him the same question? What if we were born here; he thinks it's okay to ask this question just because we have a different skin colour.

Would you ask this question to anyone, especially a stranger? Would you be offended if someone asked you that? How would you reply to the question?

OP posts:
Rummikub · 25/06/2023 14:26

Accents are interesting.

When I’m abroad and I’m asked where I’m from I’ll answer England. I’m being asked because of my accent not my colour.

i consider the context of why I’m being asked and intent. If I share my background then feel
free to ask all your burning questions. But don’t just blurt out that question.

garfieldeatscake · 25/06/2023 14:12

I 'collect' accents! Its my party trick, in actual fact I just love accents, it tells you so much about a person! I'd never directly ask someone where their from, but I might say 'oh your accents interesting, let me guess your mum was from the [welsh] valleys and your dad was from London but you lived most of your early life just outside Birmingham' ... the response is always ace!
I find it easy to distinguish between Canadian and American, New Zealand and Australian, but even within those accents, there is is a difference say from someone from Quebec to someone from Toronto, or someone from Christchurch to someone from Auckland etc. even people who speak RP English will have a very, very subtle difference from another RP speaker of English! Admittedly it's a completely useless 'skill', but it's great fun. Sometimes I'll come across a really unusual accent, and that's when I'll ask someone directly about where they have previously lived, rather than where they are from, and of course if someone is throwing out a 'fuck off' vibe, I'll not ask any questions at all! Accents are so unique and individualistic just like a finger print.

RedTemple · 25/06/2023 14:12

DustySoil · 25/06/2023 12:29

This is why life can be tricky. Like many people I go through life trying not to offend people and by trying to be a nice person. I try and keep abreast of what is and isn't offensive. Having lived abroad I've had to be careful to change my language in different countries.

I know not to ask people where they are from so I don't. It's no biggie.

However, as a white personal I have to admit to not understanding (in my head) why showing an interest in someone's background is racist. I'd have thought people would be proud and pleased to talk about their backgrounds. I can see that it is rude to push or continue a line of questioning where someone has indicated that they don't wish to. Anyone with half a brain cell can see "No, where are you really from" is not ok obviously.

I know what to do and I'll do it happily but I do think it's a shame. It seems to be making it a taboo subject. One persons 'othering' seems to be another's 'celebrating our differences'

If you asked my DH where he was from he would be delighted and would tell you anything you wanted to know. He loves meeting people and is genuinely interested, because, I think his experience of coming here as a child is something he likes to talk about and share with people who might have the same experience.
I am very conscious of needing to be much more careful.

kirinm · 25/06/2023 14:12

I often ask somebody whereabouts they are based but never where do you come from. If a builder is at your house then yes, I think it's unreasonable to ask. If somebody volunteers where they're 'from' fair enough.

I don't know if it was a typo but I am forever asking people what they do for a living. I don't think that has any racist connotations

DamnUserName21 · 25/06/2023 14:04

I'm a mixed ethnicity Brit born and raised. I'm brown-skinned. I've been asked this question too many times to count. It's pretty clear 'where I'm from' as my accent is fully British as are my mannerisms and cultural references in speech.

Does it bother me? No but I am aware that not everyone sees me as British because of my skin colour and/or foreign name. Do I see the asking of this question as racism? No. Ignorance and preconceived prejudice, yes.

The thing is how are people to learn about others and broaden their minds if we don't ask controversial questions.

I've also lived abroad and been asked this question based on my accent. I've also asked the odd person about their nationalities (if not obviously/originally British) and/or their ethnic backgrounds.

PetitPorpoise · 25/06/2023 13:47

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 25/06/2023 13:22

Also it seems that people are unable to grasp the difference between random strangers/people asking (including contractors) and friends or people you are friendly with asking.

I agree with this if it's based on appearance and ethnicity, but if I got chatting to a stranger at a bus stop in a different part of the world, and they noticed that I have a different accent to them, I would consider asking me where I came from to be extremely vanilla small talk.

People will therefore conclude that if it's OK to ask a white person with an accent where they come from, then it's surely no problem to ask someone with a different appearance to them where they come from too, because you are treating both people the same. To pointedly not mention it almost feels a bit Basil Fawlty "don't mention the war".

I do get the annoyance at the "no, but where are you really from" comments though. That does seem very rude.

Owlplant · 25/06/2023 13:43

I'm from Wigan and live in the midlands. I get asked where I'm from all the time and don't mind. I can imagine it has connotations when you're not white or aren't British. Lady Susan Hussey comes to mind. As for what do you do, it's a very regular question, just making conversation.

yadeciN · 25/06/2023 13:39

Zarah123 · 25/06/2023 13:23

It’s a weird phenomenon where BAME people are expected to be incredibly tolerant and turn the other cheek at everything.

Firstly, friends should know where you are from by the time you are friends?

Secondly, so people can ask white person "where are you from" , but not others? That is how it is soundong here at this point.

JamSandle · 25/06/2023 13:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ - previously banned poster.

Many people also ask white people there backgrounds especially if they have an accent.

CCC522 · 25/06/2023 13:38

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ - previously banned poster.

FiveShelties · 25/06/2023 13:34

Justroundthecorner · 25/06/2023 09:34

There are countless questions where someone’s interest / curiosity might be sincere but we recognise that it wouldn’t be appropriate.

’Why are you in a wheelchair?’
‘I’ve heard you were in prison - how come?’
’How did you get that scar on your face?’

Now I know people will get all annoyed and say those questions are so different to ‘where are you from’ but actually they aren’t, really. Questions in the context of a conversation are vastly different to just randomly grilling people through curiosity.

I can honestly say I have never asked anyone how they got a scar on their face, why they went to prison or why they are in a wheelchair but I often ask people where they are from.

I ask people where they are from in social settings, to make conversation and it just never occurred to me that they would be upset - I am asked this all the time with my strong Lancashire accent living in NZ.

I suppose it is easy to see offence sometimes when none is meant.

HighEndGrifters · 25/06/2023 13:24

IsGoodIsDon · 25/06/2023 02:24

I’m white but I get asked where I’m from all the time when they hear my accent

This, doesn't bother me.

Wildandwonderful · 25/06/2023 13:24

I don't think it is racist to ask where somebody is from, but unfortunately many people have experiences that make them uncomfortable being asked the question so I no longer ask. I do think it is a shame as I really enjoy discussing heritage (mine is an interesting mix of Scottish and Irish).

Zarah123 · 25/06/2023 13:23

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 25/06/2023 13:22

Also it seems that people are unable to grasp the difference between random strangers/people asking (including contractors) and friends or people you are friendly with asking.

It’s a weird phenomenon where BAME people are expected to be incredibly tolerant and turn the other cheek at everything.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 25/06/2023 13:22

Also it seems that people are unable to grasp the difference between random strangers/people asking (including contractors) and friends or people you are friendly with asking.

Zarah123 · 25/06/2023 13:22

Rummikub · 25/06/2023 13:15

@LakeTiticaca

i like talking about my heritage too. But I have experienced enough realism to know the difference and intent of the where are you from question.

With people I know happy to talk about it. But I’ll generally bring it up to invite that conversation.

if it’s the first/ second question then I wouldn’t be happy.

Well said.

Rummikub · 25/06/2023 13:17

“Enough racism”
not realism . Though that still applies as part of my reality of obviously being not white.

Rummikub · 25/06/2023 13:15

@LakeTiticaca

i like talking about my heritage too. But I have experienced enough realism to know the difference and intent of the where are you from question.

With people I know happy to talk about it. But I’ll generally bring it up to invite that conversation.

if it’s the first/ second question then I wouldn’t be happy.

Okshacky · 25/06/2023 13:14

LakeTiticaca · 25/06/2023 13:10

Nigerian friend. Loves talking about home and family and their way of life. She loves being asked about her culture and friends always enjoy her stories. So that is one person who doesn't think it's racist to ask.
Can't people be interested in other cultures without being labelled racist?

Yes they can, but they aren’t always. It sounds like you haven’t experienced the grinding day to day racism that many put up with in the UK.

Ingrowncrotchhair · 25/06/2023 13:12

ListeningToTheDog · 25/06/2023 03:31

I’m American and white. When I’m asked, it’s not the same as people who are asked because of the colour of their skin. If you don’t understand that, you should really try to.

lots of white people here unable to see the difference

LakeTiticaca · 25/06/2023 13:10

Nigerian friend. Loves talking about home and family and their way of life. She loves being asked about her culture and friends always enjoy her stories. So that is one person who doesn't think it's racist to ask.
Can't people be interested in other cultures without being labelled racist?

Lampzade · 25/06/2023 13:08

ListeningToTheDog · 25/06/2023 03:31

I’m American and white. When I’m asked, it’s not the same as people who are asked because of the colour of their skin. If you don’t understand that, you should really try to.

This

Karmakamelion · 25/06/2023 13:07

@Tweetypie1st I'm Indian but born and raised in the UK and I don't get at all offered by this question. Infact I am more likely to be offended by people calling me Asian as that is a huge area and I don't feel that I identify at all with some people of countries within Asia

JamSandle · 25/06/2023 13:05

Mixed race here. Doesn't bother me.

Zarah123 · 25/06/2023 13:04

Yet another thread where white voices try to drown out BAME voices with ‘doesn’t bother me’.

Plus ça change…

Swipe left for the next trending thread