Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be asked where are you from

264 replies

Tweetypie1st · 25/06/2023 01:59

For background, DH & I live in UK but originally came from South Asia several years ago. This is our home now.
So we are getting quotes for a garage conversion and we had someone come over to have a look. It was an older husband & wife team and they are telling us all sorts of stories(my understanding was trying to build a rapport) and then the guy asks where are we from. And I could tell my DH getting annoyed, so I just replied where I came from. And then he tells us more stories. And then he asks my husband what does he do? And my DH said we live here and then laughed so it doesn't get awkward. After they were gone, he was fuming saying how racist of him to ask us where are we from; we live & work here! Would it be okay if I asked him the same question? What if we were born here; he thinks it's okay to ask this question just because we have a different skin colour.

Would you ask this question to anyone, especially a stranger? Would you be offended if someone asked you that? How would you reply to the question?

OP posts:
JazbayGrapes · 25/06/2023 17:43

Why do some people think it's ok to pester complete strangers on the street/shops/public transport or barge into someone else's unrelated conversation and demand personal information?

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 25/06/2023 16:58

I think if you MUST (some posters seem to think society as we know it we crumble unless they ask) ask , if it's that essential to you and the way you converse, ok fine. (Not really but your need to know if obviously more important than someone else's comfort)But if you get an answer that's British related, just stop there.

AhNowTed · 25/06/2023 16:54

That's a great video.

I will say this though. It's not hard to differentiate between someone asking who's a bigot, and someone being friendly and making conversation.

I'm an immigrant. But yes Im white and no one would know until I open my mouth.

I absolutely get it - constantly made to feel you don't belong, are from somewhere else. And I would totally back off.

yadeciN · 25/06/2023 16:41

AintNobodyHereButUsChickens · 25/06/2023 15:56

Reminds me of this video 😆

She is hilarious.

Rummikub · 25/06/2023 16:27

@AintNobodyHereButUsChickens

I liked that video 😂😂

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 25/06/2023 16:19

I did sometimes play the game (before kids).

Where are you from?

City.

Where are you really from?

Oh, small town part of City.

But where are you originally from?

Oh well , we moved from Willsden Green, and before that we were in Northolt. We also lived in South Kensington but that was only for a week , so I don't think it counts. Grin

And so on.

Mercurial123 · 25/06/2023 15:51

orangeblosssom · 25/06/2023 14:55

If you're white and you have a regional accent , the assumption is you're British. If you are brown or black, those who ask where you're from, assume you have come over from another country. Even if you are 4th generation British as my nieces and nephews are.

In America, even if you've been living there for 200 years and had an ancestor from China- you're Chinese- American.
If you're white- you're just American

I'd disagree. I have African American friends, and that's how they refer to themselves and their family. I also have friends who call themselves Irish American. Some people identify with their ancestry, that's not surprising, is it?

Gytgyt · 25/06/2023 15:28

Alwaysoneoddsock · 25/06/2023 02:09

I live in London and have an accent from the north of England. I get asked where I’m from a lot. I quite like being asked about myself and I’m not offended. However, I’m aware I haven’t experienced racism in the past.

I get this too. I'm a Northerner I don't mind someone asking. However when I tell someone and they are like where are you really from I sometimes think how dim can one be?

I've had this from mainly black people to be honest. So don't take it too much to heart OP!

LivingInFlorida · 25/06/2023 15:07

Happens to me all the time. I still have my British accent and probably always will. I live in the US and I’m white so it’s nothing to do with skin colour. It does bother me. I don’t ask the local people where they are from but I don’t think people mean anything malicious by it. They are just genuinely curious and have probably not met anyone from that country before so it’s all new and exciting to them.

People here also assume I’m on holiday as I live in an area which is a very popular tourist destination. When I’m in a shop or restaurant they ask how long I’m here for. I just laugh and say I’m not planning on dying anytime soon and hope I’ve got decades left in me (I’m in my 40s).

Simonjt · 25/06/2023 15:05

Ah yes

”where are you from”?

”London”

“But where are you originally from?”

”Oh, Nottinghamshire”

It is always very clear that those asking are upset with the answer Nottinghamshire.

DustySoil · 25/06/2023 15:01

@Zarah123 You reply to my post sounded aggressive. I did read your post. You haven't understood my post. I do NOT ask people where they are from (unless in certain circumstances where it's definitely appropriate) .

You are rightly angry at people who are racist towards you when they ask you where you are from but the extension at feeling anger towards anyone who asks you where you are from is why I won't risk asking people where they are from. It seems a shame though.

Doesn't it feel like you are letting the racists win?

I've travelled and lived in a lot in certain countries and if I knew someone was from a certain country I be be interested to chat to them about it (if they wanted!). I mix with people from all sorts of backgrounds, including lots of different countries and lots of different social groups. Talking about peoples backgrounds is very standard stuff.

ChangeIsInevitable · 25/06/2023 15:01

Artoodeetoo · 25/06/2023 08:25

I do worry stuff like this is counter productive as it'll get to a point people are scared to talk to us in case perfectly innocent questions get misconstrued as racist.

I agree but for a lot of people who get offended, they also believe you should know, through the art of mindreading, what to say, when, how and to whom at all times.

Saying you're too scared to talk for fear of offending anyone is also offensive to them. Apparently, that too makes you racist. Damned if you do and damned if you don't. See colour. Don't see colour.

Rummikub · 25/06/2023 15:00

No but experience has taught me to get get ready for those follow up questions. I can feel myself tense. If it doesn't happen great , but I have still had a reaction.

Nevermind31 · 25/06/2023 14:59

I live in London, where loads of people are from somewhere else. It is a very common question.
i get asked (I am white, have lived here for my adult life, but clearly have an accent) - and why wouldn’t people ask?
if you’ve moved in the last few years you are clearly not from here - so not really racist to ask.

ChangeIsInevitable · 25/06/2023 14:56

yadeciN · 25/06/2023 08:10

The issue is not the asking, but the subsequent shite comments. Simple question without these comments is nit inherently bad.

I get asked all the time, brown DH doesn't because he has british accent. If anyone came up with "are you even legal haha" they wojld be swiftly told to fuck iff and taken to hr so they can repeat their super funny joke.

But without these follow ups, it's just big standard convo.

Spot on. Was going to say this.

A pp asked how you can tell if the question would lead to it or not (so it's best to consider it a microaggression to ask).

Well you can't tell what anyone would say next, but there's no need living life getting offended before the offence has been committed.

orangeblosssom · 25/06/2023 14:55

If you're white and you have a regional accent , the assumption is you're British. If you are brown or black, those who ask where you're from, assume you have come over from another country. Even if you are 4th generation British as my nieces and nephews are.

In America, even if you've been living there for 200 years and had an ancestor from China- you're Chinese- American.
If you're white- you're just American

Mercurial123 · 25/06/2023 14:53

The OP seems to have gone quiet.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 25/06/2023 14:50

I think it depends if you have a non-local accent or not, I would potentially ask somebody where they’re from if they had an accent that clearly wasn’t local to the area but certainly wouldn’t ask solely due to skin colour. Do you have a distinctive non-British accents or was the person asking despite you clearly sounding British?

ChangeIsInevitable · 25/06/2023 14:47

Tohaveandtohold · 25/06/2023 07:50

I’m black and a naturalised British citizen so only moved to England 12 years ago and I get asked this and can’t take offence as it’s just part of having a conversation, neither does DH as we still obviously have an accent.
Our children were born in England and they’ve never been to our home country though obviously they’re black but have a British accent and I remember visiting the US and when my daughter was speaking to someone, they asked if she was from England as she had a British accent. If she likes, she can talk about where her parents are from, etc.
What could obviously be offensive is if you ask my daughter for example where she’s from and she says ‘England’ and you start quizzing her further like expecting that someone who’s black can’t be just British.

Well said.

ChangeIsInevitable · 25/06/2023 14:40

*are the minority

ChangeIsInevitable · 25/06/2023 14:40

Justroundthecorner · 25/06/2023 06:50

I’m probably a minority but I don’t like it.

People making a fuss about a perceived difference, whether based on accent or appearance, can really make you feel like a stranger.

Unless those who don't like it are a loud minority, it seems those who like in the minority instead, at this point.

Okshacky · 25/06/2023 14:32

FiveShelties · 25/06/2023 13:34

I can honestly say I have never asked anyone how they got a scar on their face, why they went to prison or why they are in a wheelchair but I often ask people where they are from.

I ask people where they are from in social settings, to make conversation and it just never occurred to me that they would be upset - I am asked this all the time with my strong Lancashire accent living in NZ.

I suppose it is easy to see offence sometimes when none is meant.

Or to put it another way “it’s easy to offend unintentionally” especially if you aren’t disadvantaged in anyway by your heritage so have never experienced the particular sadness and anger at being treated badly for who you are particularly if you are very near to where you have been born and raised.
I’m interested to hear if anyone reading has decided they won’t ask strangers where they are from anymore?

xsquared · 25/06/2023 14:31

JaninaDuszejko · 25/06/2023 10:18

I usually assume when someone asks me "Where are you from?", that they mean where I currently live, so I say my home town.

Really? If someone wanted to know where you lived they'd ask 'where do you live?' 'Where are you from?' is asking where you grew up (or in the case of racists 'explain your family history so I know how racist to be').

Yes, I would say my home town.
If I've travelled to be somewhere for work, I would say the name of the city I live in.

LaMaG · 25/06/2023 14:29

There is a cultural element to it too. I'm Irish, live in Ireland and have local accent. But here it is a normal thing to ask where a person is from. I live and work about 20km from my home town and it would be acceptable for a colleague or neighbour to ask where I was from originally. Likewise I would ask someone, a contractor or the girl at the til in the shop if we are making small talk. It's just what we do in my locality and it means nothing. If someone was to answer and I stare in disbelief and quiz them on it, then it's rude but that's different.

Swipe left for the next trending thread