Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would it be awkward/problematic in your family to date outside your race?

220 replies

Saramax · 25/06/2023 00:51

We were discussing interracial relationships at work the other day and I’m intrigued to see how people’s families would react to them dating person of a different ethnicity.

YABU - it would probably be awkward
YANBU - it would be completely normal

OP posts:
stickygotstuck · 25/06/2023 09:02

yadeciN · 25/06/2023 07:05

Race/colour is not the big issue.
But people really, really should think properly before dating different cultures and religions.
The mixing of cultures can go really well or really badly. I think some people enter these relationship in really naive way and then issues start. Like "oh well my x religion husband/wife wants kids to go to x religion church but I am catholic and I don't want them to go to his/her church" Really? Did it not cross their mind before having kids? 🤦

We are mixing cultures and religion and it can sometimes be pita and sometimes glorious. I am always quite sad and weirded out about people who completely give up all their culture for the other person and just blend into the new one. It's weird and I don't get it.

Very much agree with this.

NancyJoan · 25/06/2023 08:55

My MIL would definitely be weird about it. Micro aggressions would abound.

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 25/06/2023 08:55

In my social circles and acquaintances I only know if problems towards the white person in the party. So one Muslim family who didn't like the non Muslim, non Asian wife, one black family who didn't like him marrying a white girl.
It's interesting that from the op, the assumption is that the white part of the couple it being racist but my limited experience I only know the reverse.

That said, back in the 60s my mother was distinctly told not to marry a black man by her father which I find so shocking.

CoalCraft · 25/06/2023 08:55

In a word, no. I could maybe see my grandmothers making some well-meant but perhaps tactless or clueless remarks ("ooh it's exciting to have someone brown in the family isn't it??"), but there'd be no hostility.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 25/06/2023 08:51

My parents (now in their 70s) had a real problem with the idea of me dating anyone who wasn't white British.

It was ridiculous. I had a good friend who was mixed race, and was outside school waiting for a lift chatting to him about some coursework.

My dad pulled up, started sounding the horn and had a face like thunder. I got in the car, embarrassed of his behaviour.

All the way home he wanted to know who my friend was. He was angry because I had spoke about this friend who had a typically British name (think Paul or Alan) so had assumed he was white.

I asked why it made a difference and was told he didn't want me paraded as a trophy!

They are a miserable pair of fuckers though who I've not spoken to in 25 years as they were truly vile to me growing up

They would probably drop dead if they knew their granddaughter is gay. That would not go down well either as they didn't like me "knowing" gay people.

DH is Irish and they hated him for that. Literally for being Irish.

Honestly. I'm so embarrassed of them

mindutopia · 25/06/2023 08:49

I’m happily married and NC with my family, but thinking back to when I was dating, yes, it probably would have led to some raised eyebrows amongst immediate family to overt racist comments by extended family. I wouldn’t necessarily think of them as racist, generally speaking, but they are very set in their ways and don’t know much about the world outside their comfy social bubble.

Penguinsmum · 25/06/2023 08:46

It was initially for my dh family. They disowned him. Eventually came round and all is well now. They absolutely love our son and I think they do like me now they've got to know me. But I'll never really forget how horrible it was in the beginning although 18 years ago now.

howrudeforme · 25/06/2023 08:33

My parents are different races and I married a man from another country. My ds has a girlfriend of yet a different race.

Think religion can be more of an issue.

Phineyj · 25/06/2023 08:21

Given how my relatives all seem to exist in a bubble where no-one is gay or has any additional needs, and there is already significant tension over one branch of the family being very religious while the rest of the family are not, plus a load of class anxiety, I'm guessing it wouldn't go well tbh.

Although people can surprise you.

I already feel like I live in a parallel universe to the rest of my family most of the time.

Interesting question!

I do struggle with the idea of "microaggression" when it's someone engaging with something entirely outside their experience. Unless they don't learn from it.

Outwiththenorm · 25/06/2023 08:20

DH and I are both white but from different parts of the UK. Our Asian friends asked us if our parents were ok with us being in a ‘mixed race relationship’ 🤷‍♀️

yadeciN · 25/06/2023 07:54

Emanresu9 · 25/06/2023 07:46

I think there is an expectation that white people have to be totally open to inter-racial marriages and it’s disgusting and racist if they don’t want their children to marry outside their race.

and there is a blind eye turned if Asian families would rather their children married with the race. Nobody wails about Asians marrying Asians or says “where is the diversity” whereas I’ve definitely seen comments about the British royal family having no diversity and always choosing the marry within their race until Harry came along. I’ve literally never seen these comments about asian families with no inter racial marriage in them.

just my observation.

You are not wrong tbh.

JoyceMeadowcroft1 · 25/06/2023 07:53

No one in my family cares about the race of family member's partners.
We care about values aligning, which means being anti racist. We also have zero tolerance for any hint of controlling behaviours.

Emanresu9 · 25/06/2023 07:46

I think there is an expectation that white people have to be totally open to inter-racial marriages and it’s disgusting and racist if they don’t want their children to marry outside their race.

and there is a blind eye turned if Asian families would rather their children married with the race. Nobody wails about Asians marrying Asians or says “where is the diversity” whereas I’ve definitely seen comments about the British royal family having no diversity and always choosing the marry within their race until Harry came along. I’ve literally never seen these comments about asian families with no inter racial marriage in them.

just my observation.

newtb · 25/06/2023 07:46

I live in France where there is a lot of racism. I think there are sufficient cultural differences to overcome without adding racial/religious ones into the mix.

Girasoli · 25/06/2023 07:41

My family no issues at all.
DHs family, I think were disappointed at first he didn't marry someone from the same ethnicity/culture. They're used to me now though 😁

We're both the same religion (and denomination) though which helps massively as the festivals are the same/no arguments over how to bring up the DC etc.

sparkellie · 25/06/2023 07:39

Different race would be fine. I think my mum would struggle if I was in a relationship with someone of a different religion, I don't think it would matter what it was.

Sceptre86 · 25/06/2023 07:37

In wider family, no issues. In my parents house outside religion would be an issue. Outside of culture, ethnicity, nationality fine. Dh and I feel the same as my parents.

SimonsCow · 25/06/2023 07:34

I don’t think it would be an issue at all. But then we are not religious and don’t have a strong culture that wouldn’t blend well with another culture or religion.

my late grandmother (who would be about 100 if she was still alive) definitely had some racist views. I remember her expressing shock that an interracial couple on the TV were together. My grandfather quickly told her off for it.

PinkNailpolish · 25/06/2023 07:31

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 25/06/2023 07:14

Show me where I disputed ANY of that? I didn’t so not sure why you felt the need to say all of this when I haven’t said anything against these points.

Nowhere did I say that both parents of different cultures won’t be able to embrace both cultures for their children so not sure where that came from? I also never said people of different races can’t have similar interests so again, not sure where that came from.

You’re mixed race (White and East Asian) and I’m black, do you think we’d have the same struggles through life? If you do then you’re terribly mistaken. The way society treats us is very different and our experiences in life will not have been the same.

I’ve been in two interracial relationships when I was younger. One with a Kurdish guy who I was with on and off for about 3 years and one I was with an Italian guy for 10 months (barely a relationship tbh). I don’t need to sit here writing paragraphs and paragraphs on why the relationships were so different to when I’m in a relationship with a Black guy.

So again, nowhere was I disputing interracial relationships and whether they work or not. Whether people from different races can’t have the same interests and all of the nonsense that you mentioned for absolutely no reason. If you refer to my original post you see that I mention myself and my family. Nothing to do with anyone else and I don’t hold any negative opinions to those in interracial relationships. It’s that simple

Nothing I mentioned was 'nonsense.' You said that your family wouldn't like it if you were in a long term relationship with someone of a different race. I said that's sad. It's good that you personally don't have negative opinions of interracial relationships.

You’re mixed race (White and East Asian) and I’m black, do you think we’d have the same struggles through life? If you do then you’re terribly mistaken. The way society treats us is very different and our experiences in life will not have been the same.

How would you know? We don't know each other or the struggles we've been through. I experienced a lot of racism growing up (from people of different races) but you might not have. I still face racism whereas you might have it relatively easy. You might be from a privileged family with money, but my parents were working class. I don't know your life and you can't assume someone has the same struggles as you based on their race.

yadeciN · 25/06/2023 07:24

puppypawpaw · 25/06/2023 07:19

@yadeciN I think it's more things like having dc and having to argue out how they are raised, which culture, what's right, which religion. Or how you get married etc. You would have to make these choices most likely at some point.

My parents would have said don't bother, 'stick with your own' attitude because it's easier and what you know because less chance of problems down the line.

Yeah there has to be lots of compromises so neither loses their cultural identity. But none has to give up theirs, just need to find their middle ground. Which can be hard. These things should really be discussed well before kids, unfortunately lots of people don't do it.

We sorted it by not having kids😂

MargotBamborough · 25/06/2023 07:24

I once had a thing with a Muslim guy I met whilst travelling. His race was absolutely no issue, but he said that if he introduced me to his mum as a friend she'd be really welcoming and want to know all about me and teach me how to cook their family favourites and everything, but that if he introduced me to her as his girlfriend it would be very difficult. At the time I didn't see it and thought the main obstacle to us being together was long distance. We stayed in touch for a few years (during which he dated at least one non Muslim woman) and then he met a Muslim woman - possibly someone introduced by his family, or if not, certainly someone they would have approved of - and within months they'd had a big religious wedding and he had disappeared from all social media. If I wanted to contact him now I'd have to dig out an old phone to find his number and hope he hadn't changed it, or ask one of his friends, and I feel that would be inappropriate so I just privately wish him well and hope he is happy. I now think he was being realistic and that for someone like me, trying to have a serious relationship with him and be accepted into his family would have been a nightmare. Even if they had accepted me, I would have had to accept all kinds of things like raising our children in his religion. I don't think love is always enough to make it work in situations like that.

GADDay · 25/06/2023 07:23

My parents are intrinsically bigoted farts. They would say, if asked that it would not be a problem and in the next breath make a stupid <insert>phobic comment.

DH and I have no issue with anybody our children bring home. Couldn't give a monkeys about gender/skin colour/religion. More concerned about mutual respect and happiness.

Times are changing. Thankfully.

Iamclearlyamug · 25/06/2023 07:23

Interesting topic for me because I am English but haven't dated an English man in 10 years - think my exH put me off for life 🤣

I spent 4.5 years in a long distance relationship (and subsequent engagement) to a Turkish man. Some family were supportive and some weren't. This was far less to do with him being foreign and more to do with the fact he wasn't HERE (in England) so I think they wondered how it would ever 'go anywhere' in hindsight they were likely right and eventually he met a Turkish woman and we split

I've now been with a Polish man for almost 2 years and had none of the same issues. He's been in England for 13 years, has never been back to his home country and works incredibly hard. All my family and friends are very supportive, as are his.

So in conclusion I think it depends - I spent a short time (5 or 6 dates) with a Pakistani doctor. He was a lovely man and we got on great but he admitted that his family would never accept a relationship outside his culture. I could never be in a relationship where I wasn't accepted so we parted on good terms and are still friends now 😊

Phos · 25/06/2023 07:22

I’m in my late thirties. I don’t think it would be an issue. Perhaps when I was much younger, my grandparents might have been a bit thrown by it at first, maybe made a few remarks but generally nah don’t think they’d have minded.

YDBear · 25/06/2023 07:19

Married outside my race. Nobody even blinked. Of course I had been living in DP's country for 10 years so it was kind of inevitable, but I was rather proud of my parents for never questioning it for a moment--given that my father was born in 1911, they weren't exactly progressives.

Swipe left for the next trending thread