Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How far would you go to accommodate a vegan?

758 replies

Juicyj1993 · 24/06/2023 23:22

In a few weeks we're hosting a bbq for my Husband's birthday.

We have about a dozen guests coming, one of whom is vegan. As we don't normally buy vegan food I've started looking at what we'd normally buy and what is and isn't vegan. To make sure the vegan has the same variety of choice as everyone else I'm going to have to spend quite a bit on alternatives. As we have the non vegan alternatives we won't be eating the vegan versions, so they'll either go home with the guest or be thrown.

How much would you accommodate a vegan?

Would I be unreasonable to provide vegan burger with vegan cheese, plus bun and nothing else or do I need to go the whole hog and get vegan sausages, vegan condiments and vegan coleslaw?

Ps they are vegan by choice, not for medical reasons

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Ohgollymolly · 29/06/2023 07:01

I enjoy hosting, so would always be very accommodating. If you’ve invited them, I’m not sure why you wouldn’t provide them with adequate options!

I’m vegetarian, and cannot tolerate a lot of the fake meats. It always feels a little humiliating to get somewhere and realise there is nothing you can eat.

I would get some vegan burgers, vegan sausages (M&S do some lovely vegan sausages), rolls, salad & accompaniments. You can always offer the vegan to take home the uneaten food if it’s things you can’t make use of.

Replace Vegan with allergies/religious beliefs and I don’t think you’d be questioning being a gracious host.

OMG12 · 29/06/2023 07:00

Emmamoo89 · 28/06/2023 23:28

Nah I'd rather shit glass and clap than become vegan

If that is truely the case that you would rather self harm in grotesque ways than avoid a few products you might need to consider seeking help

5128gap · 29/06/2023 06:14

WellPlaced · 29/06/2023 04:13

I know this thread has moved on from the original question but I think the issue here is that there’s not really a word to describe someone who doesn’t eat animal products but isn’t vegan. Veganism is a way of life and not just about diet.

HOWEVER, ‘plant based’ just doesn’t cut it imo. My diet isn’t plant based it just plants!
It’s Vegan, although I’m not vegan.

Indeed. If people think saying 'I'm vegan' leads to sneering and animosity, just try out 'I'm plant based' for size. There was actually a thread on here once where someone had described their child so. Page after page of people ridiculing the term, professing it wasn't 'a thing' because they were ignorant of it, excruciatingly unamusing jokes about it, accusing the woman of being so special she needed a new term...
Most people broadly understand 'vegan' when it's necessary to give dietary requirements which is the only time I ever say it. I tend to just follow with 'for health not ethics' if necessary to head off all the noise.

WellPlaced · 29/06/2023 04:15

WTF is plant based anyway?

WellPlaced · 29/06/2023 04:13

I know this thread has moved on from the original question but I think the issue here is that there’s not really a word to describe someone who doesn’t eat animal products but isn’t vegan. Veganism is a way of life and not just about diet.

HOWEVER, ‘plant based’ just doesn’t cut it imo. My diet isn’t plant based it just plants!
It’s Vegan, although I’m not vegan.

HallieHufflepuff · 29/06/2023 02:05

Tofuislovely · 26/06/2023 23:42

Ha, have exactly the same problem in reverse! We are a vegan household but will be, shock horror, buying meat to accommodate family at an event soon. Will have to send leftovers home with them! But onto your vegan problem, I would suggest just asking them. They will probably just offer to bring a pack of vegan sausages or burgers and have a bit of salad and a roll. Sorted.

Why are you choosing to buy meat?

RemoteDesktop · 29/06/2023 00:49

RunningUpThatMill · 29/06/2023 00:33

Like I said, I would never present a 'gotcha' to you, but words mean something and you can't try to change the meaning. A vegan, who isn't perfect, as previously stated, might make a mistake, but, a vegan would abstain from something that might contain animal products. That is what we do.

Odd, because according to most dictionary definitions (including the OED), I’m a vegetarian (and would be even if I frequently consumed gelatine or started eating rennet), but you seem to feel otherwise.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 29/06/2023 00:38

Emmamoo89 · 28/06/2023 22:31

I know you weren't. It's not 100% better for the planet tho..
Plus there's loads of things fucking up the planet. Eating meat isn't the only thing. It's certainly not going to stop enjoying it. Or lose any sleep.

Again, I didn't state it was but as one of papers I linked in a previous post said, phasing out animal agricultrue would have the same cumulative effect as a 25 gigaton per year reduction in CO2 emissions, providing half of the net emission reductions necessary to limit global warming to 2°C, so it is significantly better.

Claiming that you won't stop eating meat because other things are also damaging the planet is a flawed position. It's like saying, 'I won't stop littering because other people do it too'. I bet if you found out a company had been dumping hazardous waste into a local river, park or even your garden and when approached about it said 'Well, the alternative is only significantly better for the environment so not much point in doing that, plus other things are fucking the planet so who cares?' You wouldn't say "you're right, carry on dumping!"

I'm not sure why you keep coming back to comment on this thread given you have no intention of changing habits. There's no need to keep telling me how unbothered about it you are.

RunningUpThatMill · 29/06/2023 00:33

Like I said, I would never present a 'gotcha' to you, but words mean something and you can't try to change the meaning. A vegan, who isn't perfect, as previously stated, might make a mistake, but, a vegan would abstain from something that might contain animal products. That is what we do.

RemoteDesktop · 29/06/2023 00:29

RunningUpThatMill · 29/06/2023 00:22

@RemoteDesktop if you are a vegetarian who occasionally eats gelatin, you aren't a vegetarian. If you are a vegan who occasionally knowingly drinks wine filtered through isinglass, you aren't a vegan. End of.

And yet, if someone asks me my dietary requirements ahead of an event, I’m still going to tell them I’m vegetarian even though, once in a blue moon (maybe every couple of years), I’ll eat a small amount of a product that does contain gelatine.

Who knows, maybe you’ll be lucky enough to be present and declare ‘Gotcha! They aren’t really vegetarian! They just don’t eat meat or rennet and generally abstain from eating products with gelatine but actually do very occasionally sometimes eat gelatine!’

RunningUpThatMill · 29/06/2023 00:22

@RemoteDesktop if you are a vegetarian who occasionally eats gelatin, you aren't a vegetarian. If you are a vegan who occasionally knowingly drinks wine filtered through isinglass, you aren't a vegan. End of.

RemoteDesktop · 29/06/2023 00:21

Posted too soon.

Some vegans abstain from eating bananas that have been (or likely have been) sprayed using animal products. Some don’t. I think that’s fine.

My view is that some people over-police the margins of who is, or is not, allowed to use a term to define themselves (and/or their diet) on a day to day basis.

RunningUpThatMill · 29/06/2023 00:20

@RemoteDesktop don't be so obtuse.

I'm a human and therefore I'm not perfect. I don't make accidents based on decisions. I also don't wish to be the gatekeeper for veganism.

What you are stating is knowingly consuming something that might be/might not be vegan. If I didn't know for sure it was vegan, I wouldn't consume it. I know medication isn't, but I would take it. See the difference?

RemoteDesktop · 29/06/2023 00:17

RunningUpThatMill · 29/06/2023 00:12

@RemoteDesktop a banana is vegan, whether it is organic or not. What is put on it is a totally separate issue. It's like palm oil. Palm oil is fundamentally vegan, however, as a vegan I would not consume something that had unsustainable palm oil in it.

Most non-organic bananas are sprayed with a chemical containing animal products, to slow down the browning process.

RunningUpThatMill · 29/06/2023 00:15

*however, as a vegan personally, I would not consume something that had unsustainable palm oil in it.

RemoteDesktop · 29/06/2023 00:15

RunningUpThatMill · 29/06/2023 00:06

@RemoteDesktop like I said, you have no idea of what the definition of veganism is.

Like I said earlier, I drive, I take medication, I am obviously on an electronic device as I type this.

Veganism is about doing what you can to avoid animal suffering. Making decisions on what you can and can't eat/buy. I can abstain from eating meat, dairy, eggs and honey and alcohol (although I certainly don't abstain from drinking alcohol, I just but alcohol that I know is vegan), and to answer your question regarding wine, yes, a vegan can certainly find vegan wines. There are loads.

Vegans are also fallible. I make mistakes, and whilst I try to be diligent, I sometimes get it wrong. I would never intentionally support the meat, dairy or egg industry though.

Hope that helps?

No that doesn’t really help. When I gave the example earlier of a person who otherwise has a wholly vegan diet (for ethical reasons), but on a rare occasion may drink a glass of wine that was served to them, without first checking whether or not it is vegan-friendly, you said that person would not be vegan, and should use the label ‘plant based’.

I don’t think you can police minor ‘transgressions’ and revoke people’s ‘vegan card’ then also maintain you’re a vegan whilst also acknowledging you yourself sometimes make mistakes and get it wrong.

Tofuislovely · 29/06/2023 00:14

Grapewrath, I am a vegan, but I buy meat products for family at dinners etc. It isn't great to do so but I respect their preferences. I feel that I personally am not adding to the demand for meat and accept I can't change the world. or indeed most people's views, sad as I feel that is. Yeah, would be great if everyone considered animal welfare, but that isn't a thing for most people...

RunningUpThatMill · 29/06/2023 00:12

@RemoteDesktop a banana is vegan, whether it is organic or not. What is put on it is a totally separate issue. It's like palm oil. Palm oil is fundamentally vegan, however, as a vegan I would not consume something that had unsustainable palm oil in it.

RunningUpThatMill · 29/06/2023 00:06

RemoteDesktop · 28/06/2023 23:50

As a non-vegan, I don’t have much skin in the game here, but to give you an example.

I know a couple, both of whom describe themselves as vegan, and abstain from meat, dairy an animal byproducts for ethical reasons.

When at home, they buy wines that they know are vegan-friendly. However, (where I live, at least) there are no laws requiring wine-bottlers to include, on labels, whether-or-not the wine is vegan friendly.

You can sometimes determine whether a wine is vegan-friendly or not by googling, but not always.

Accordingly, my friends take a somewhat relaxed view on wine and will, on the rare occasions that they are being served wine that they did not purchase for themselves, and particularly where they cannot easily discern whether or not it is vegan, simply drink the wine.

I don’t have any issue with them describing themselves as vegan, but it sounds as though you do?

I assume you make some exceptions yourself and make the odd judgment call? For example, with electronics?

@RemoteDesktop like I said, you have no idea of what the definition of veganism is.

Like I said earlier, I drive, I take medication, I am obviously on an electronic device as I type this.

Veganism is about doing what you can to avoid animal suffering. Making decisions on what you can and can't eat/buy. I can abstain from eating meat, dairy, eggs and honey and alcohol (although I certainly don't abstain from drinking alcohol, I just but alcohol that I know is vegan), and to answer your question regarding wine, yes, a vegan can certainly find vegan wines. There are loads.

Vegans are also fallible. I make mistakes, and whilst I try to be diligent, I sometimes get it wrong. I would never intentionally support the meat, dairy or egg industry though.

Hope that helps?

RemoteDesktop · 29/06/2023 00:01

A little sorry to badger you, @RunningUpThatMill , but DP has reminded me of our friends’ other stated exception.

Most bananas that are not organic aren’t vegan, so they buy organic ones. However, they will eat something that has banana listed as an ingredient, without knowing if it’s organic/vegan or not.

To me, this seems like a reasonable judgment call - would you feel otherwise?

RemoteDesktop · 28/06/2023 23:50

RunningUpThatMill · 28/06/2023 23:18

@RemoteDesktop I don't have any intention of trying to 'gotcha' you, but I do refute your statement that 'Most vegans are actually not vegan' on the examples that you gave.

A vegan who eats anything that has traces of dead insects is a vegan.

A vegan that decides to follow a plant-based diet, eats plant-based but then drinks alcohol which they know isn't vegan, well, they aren't vegan. They are plant-based. I don't know why saying plant-based is an issue. Vegans are generally vegan for ethical reasons. If you lack the ability to understand that animals should not be used and abused, then you aren't vegan. You are plant-based for environmental or health reasons, which is great, but you aren't a vegan. Veganism is founded on the fact that animals should not suffer because of human need.

As a non-vegan, I don’t have much skin in the game here, but to give you an example.

I know a couple, both of whom describe themselves as vegan, and abstain from meat, dairy an animal byproducts for ethical reasons.

When at home, they buy wines that they know are vegan-friendly. However, (where I live, at least) there are no laws requiring wine-bottlers to include, on labels, whether-or-not the wine is vegan friendly.

You can sometimes determine whether a wine is vegan-friendly or not by googling, but not always.

Accordingly, my friends take a somewhat relaxed view on wine and will, on the rare occasions that they are being served wine that they did not purchase for themselves, and particularly where they cannot easily discern whether or not it is vegan, simply drink the wine.

I don’t have any issue with them describing themselves as vegan, but it sounds as though you do?

I assume you make some exceptions yourself and make the odd judgment call? For example, with electronics?

RunningUpThatMill · 28/06/2023 23:34

Emmamoo89 · 28/06/2023 23:28

Nah I'd rather shit glass and clap than become vegan

You'd rather shit glass and clap? Have you missed some words out of that phrase?

Emmamoo89 · 28/06/2023 23:28

OMG12 · 28/06/2023 22:36

Everything we do is probably bad in fresh. Surly it’s better to take the least worst alternative- in this case veganism.

for many vegans, being vegan is just part of reducing impact on the environment (and I’ve noticed vegan stuff is often packed in a more environmentally friendly way). They often do many other things in a more environmentally sustainable way as veganism is just part of their overall ethics

Nah I'd rather shit glass and clap than become vegan

JenWillsiam · 28/06/2023 23:25

RemoteDesktop · 28/06/2023 23:13

This is a good example. This poster thinks that someone can’t call themselves a vegan if they sometimes eat mushrooms.

I think to every reasonable-minded person, that is stupid beyond belief, but some meat eaters with massive chips on their shoulders really hold views like this.

Your example of a mushroom is ridiculous. Clearly eating mushrooms doesn’t stop you being vegan.

MumYourBabyGrewUpToBeACowboy · 28/06/2023 23:22

my sister has a strict diet that can’t be “contaminated” so she often collaborates with the host to bring what she might need (although it’s fabulous you want to provide) I think at a bbq the most anxiety provoking aspect to her is the shared grill. It’s super stress-relieving if you are the ‘enforcer’ about getting her food safely grilled first as that’s what makes her self conscious and taking that worry away really helps!