Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How far would you go to accommodate a vegan?

758 replies

Juicyj1993 · 24/06/2023 23:22

In a few weeks we're hosting a bbq for my Husband's birthday.

We have about a dozen guests coming, one of whom is vegan. As we don't normally buy vegan food I've started looking at what we'd normally buy and what is and isn't vegan. To make sure the vegan has the same variety of choice as everyone else I'm going to have to spend quite a bit on alternatives. As we have the non vegan alternatives we won't be eating the vegan versions, so they'll either go home with the guest or be thrown.

How much would you accommodate a vegan?

Would I be unreasonable to provide vegan burger with vegan cheese, plus bun and nothing else or do I need to go the whole hog and get vegan sausages, vegan condiments and vegan coleslaw?

Ps they are vegan by choice, not for medical reasons

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Emmamoo89 · 01/07/2023 17:14

5128gap · 30/06/2023 18:28

Vegans actually don't have a bad reputation. Most people are too busy minding their business to give us a thought.
There is a minority of people who for their own reasons, (about which we have speculated already) feel the need to sneer at and criticise our diet and attribute negative stereotypes to us; that we are sanctimonious, joyless, demanding, hypocritical etc. But like all stereotyping of people based on one shared characteristic, few with intelligence take it seriously. So they are thankfully in the minority, with most people either indifferent or respectful, even at times admiring.
These threads give a skewed perspective because they act as a magnet for the militant meat eaters and those with a personal interest in trashing veganism, who like to believe everyone feels as they do.

Actually Vegans do have a bad reputation. I'm not saying they're all bad but some don't help and cause them to have the bad reputation. The ones I've spoken to have been total aholes.

RunningUpThatMill · 30/06/2023 22:50

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 30/06/2023 14:20

@RunningUpThatMill

Thanks for responding - what you say makes a lot of sense and I completely respect that.

Thanks 👍

DumDeeDoh · 30/06/2023 19:39

Vegan here. Have not read the thread. A vegan burger plus a bit of salad (eg. Pasta salad with beans) would suit me. Tbh I hate when people go to too much effort, and often the food is not what I would choose, so a couple burgers (veggie for me, rather than those fake meat ones) (with bun, pickles, leaves and cheese), a salad, as well as a green salad and maybe a bag of crisps I could eat and I would be fine. Most vegans will have eaten beforehand and some people as so stupid about the thought of eating vegan food (ever had an apple?) And they may spend time waving food at the vegan making animal noises as that is hilarious 🙄.

specialassistance · 30/06/2023 19:34

I do a massive potato salad with nee potatoes, vegan mayo and chives.

You'd never know it was vegan!

specialassistance · 30/06/2023 19:32

Just be careful to keep the vegan food separately. Not because of cross contamination, but because sometimes a meat eater will think they'd like to try it, and then there's nothing left for the vegan to eat.

plantsandwich · 30/06/2023 19:15

It's not as simple as that 'comparing eating meat to a paedophile' (he was a child abuser as well as a paedophile).

It is comparable not because the poster thinks eating meat is as bad as being a child sexual abuser, but that Saville continued to state how much he loved children-and he caused them severe harm.
Claiming to love animals while (as I detailed above) contributing to an industry where they live short, often terrifying lives and mostly suffer abuse, separation from their children, awful conditions and then a terrifying brutal death, is the comparable factor.

It's bizarre to say you love a whole population while (for example) you actually love dogs/cats/hamsters and hate seaworld/circuses/the dog meat industry but are happy to contribute to the severe mistreatment of other animals in that population.

5128gap · 30/06/2023 18:28

BathroomOnTheRight · 30/06/2023 17:22

That is one of the most ignorant comments I've ever heard and signifies the smug sanctimony of some vegans. Of course you can love animals and abide by a normal meat-eating healthy diet. Your absolutist position is absurd. And part of the reason why vegans have the bad reputation they have.

Vegans actually don't have a bad reputation. Most people are too busy minding their business to give us a thought.
There is a minority of people who for their own reasons, (about which we have speculated already) feel the need to sneer at and criticise our diet and attribute negative stereotypes to us; that we are sanctimonious, joyless, demanding, hypocritical etc. But like all stereotyping of people based on one shared characteristic, few with intelligence take it seriously. So they are thankfully in the minority, with most people either indifferent or respectful, even at times admiring.
These threads give a skewed perspective because they act as a magnet for the militant meat eaters and those with a personal interest in trashing veganism, who like to believe everyone feels as they do.

BathroomOnTheRight · 30/06/2023 18:22

Someone put it very well upthread when they compared it to how Jimmy Saville loved children

Wow. Just when I thought some comments couldn't get any lower. To compare meat-eaters to a pedophile is, well, I can't believe that post is still standing. Just when my view of (some) vegans couldn't get any more rock bottom. They really have no idea just how they come across.

plantsandwich · 30/06/2023 18:03

I don't believe it either, sorry. How can you claim to love animals (as in love ALL animals) yet contribute to them being farmed for you to eat, having quite often suffered terror, awful conditions, had their young snatched from them, and then suffered a terrifying ordeal ending in a brutal death-be honest and say you love SOME animals and don't have emotion toward some others. Someone put it very well upthread when they compared it to how Jimmy Saville loved children-although as far as I know, he didn't contribute to the deaths of any of them.

BathroomOnTheRight · 30/06/2023 17:22

LuckySantangelo35 · 30/06/2023 14:56

@Emmamoo89

you can’t. You can’t live animals and eat meat. Soz.

That is one of the most ignorant comments I've ever heard and signifies the smug sanctimony of some vegans. Of course you can love animals and abide by a normal meat-eating healthy diet. Your absolutist position is absurd. And part of the reason why vegans have the bad reputation they have.

LuckySantangelo35 · 30/06/2023 14:56

Emmamoo89 · 28/06/2023 18:19

Yes we can. Because i do. I love animals so much but i also love the taste. And another thing I've been told by vegans that milking cows is raping them. So are we supposed to not do it and allow them to get mastitis. You know what happens then. Sepsis. That kills. So that would contribute to the "murder and cruelty".

@Emmamoo89

you can’t. You can’t live animals and eat meat. Soz.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 30/06/2023 14:20

@RunningUpThatMill

Thanks for responding - what you say makes a lot of sense and I completely respect that.

mewkins · 30/06/2023 13:00

BeSensible23 · 29/06/2023 20:45

I really don't understand the entitlement of people these days. If it's a week long catered holiday or boarding school, yes, food intolerances need to be discussed but for a single afternoon the guest should just eat before or after. I've had severe inflammatory bowel disease since age 6 which means I can pretty much only eat plain meat/fish/chicken, dry vegetables, fruit and white rice. I have never once brought my own food to an event or asked for an accommodation by a host. I have been to multiple dinner parties and restaurant meals. I just push my food around on my plate and pretend to eat. Snack on a few crudites. Be a sensible polite adult!

Bingo! Another thread where someone is labelled 'entitled' for expecting something very basic - in this case, food! 😄😄😄

plantsandwich · 30/06/2023 12:48

@Emmamoo89 that's an age-old cliché and very untrue. Nobody knows I am vegan unless I have to tell them (e.g. they invite me to dinner) or it comes up in conversation initiated by somebody else-for example if someone says to me 'I've got a vegan coming for dinner and I don't know what to cook', or 'I want to make more vegan dinners' -then I'll tell them-or on threads such as this. I don't know of any other vegans who 'talk about nothing else' either. As I've said in several comments on this thread and others, generally they want the attention off them to avoid all the unsavoury comments toward them-and personal attacks. We get that all the time-for some reason seen as acceptable. If I tried to remember all the awful comments I've had once people ascertain that I am vegan I don't think MN would have enough bandwidth for me to list them. If you know a vegan who 'talks about nothing else' I guarantee they're in the minority and would probably be that sort of person no matter what they were doing/what philosophical belief they follow.

I'd never eat before or after a BBQ, I'd take my own unless the host discussed it with me and insisted that they were happy to get me something. I usually take something to a BBQ anyway even if they do do that-likely an interesting salad or some cake for pudding, but I like cooking.

MykonosMaiden · 30/06/2023 10:39

Ohgollymolly · 29/06/2023 07:01

I enjoy hosting, so would always be very accommodating. If you’ve invited them, I’m not sure why you wouldn’t provide them with adequate options!

I’m vegetarian, and cannot tolerate a lot of the fake meats. It always feels a little humiliating to get somewhere and realise there is nothing you can eat.

I would get some vegan burgers, vegan sausages (M&S do some lovely vegan sausages), rolls, salad & accompaniments. You can always offer the vegan to take home the uneaten food if it’s things you can’t make use of.

Replace Vegan with allergies/religious beliefs and I don’t think you’d be questioning being a gracious host.

Allergies are different, you have no control. Religious is the same category as vegan it's a personal choice.
Same policy for me though. If people have severe allergies I'm not going to faff about avoiding cross contamination etc they'd better bring their own food

RunningUpThatMill · 30/06/2023 02:45

@FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper

Even if you don't object to killing any living things without a brain for food, that still doesn't answer the question of how you ensure that no animals have died in the production of your food - chiefly those killed by pesticides and combined harvesters. How many vegans are strict about only buying food - with the significantly increased costs, of course - from producers that use no pesticides and carefully reap the harvest by hand?

I know that animals will unfortunately die in the process of harvesting crops that I eat. Unfortunately, I have to eat something.

When there is mass production of animals for food, profit becomes priority and welfare standards begin to slip. If you think about the amount of land animals that are killed each year for food, and then think about the food that they eat, more animals are going to be killed in order to feed what you are eating.

Even if I did eat meat, I would still eat plants, so, I'd be responsible for not only the killing of animals whilst crops are harvested, but also the animals that are slaughtered so that I could eat meat.

If I presented you with a tomato plant and a cow, and gave you the option of pulling a tomato from the stem, or stunning a cow in the head and then processing it for food, which would you choose? I know which I would choose, and therefore I no longer expect anyone else to do something that I could never do myself.

I made a decision, not just based on the fact that I always felt guilt when eating meat, but also on the science. I know that many animals that we consume have brains, CNS and nociceptors, therefore they are able to feel pain just like we do - they may not be able to express it like we do, but they certainly feel pain. They are able to establish relationships and communities, just like we do. They feel and they suffer, just like we do.

I haven't eaten an animal, or anything produced by an animal in over 6 years. I'm not declining in health and so know I don't need to eat animals or their produce.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 30/06/2023 00:41

@RunningUpThatMill
plants are not sentient. Whilst they are living, they do not have a brain, CNS or nociceptors and therefore can not feel pain. Unlike all the mammals that are killed each year for human consumption.

Letittow
Plants (of which I'm sure non vegans eat too) aren't sentient beings so no not really the same is it, nice reach though. A ridiculous and boring one but still.

I never said that they were sentient, at least not in the way that we would understand it - of course they don't have a brain, although they can of course react to external stimuli. We can assume that they don't feel pain as we would recognise it, but we still have no way of knowing for an absolute fact whether they feel any distress when they are killed. Not that they are traditionally eaten as food for humans, but something like the (clearly non-vegan itself!) venus flytrap appears to have quite a sophisticated method of reacting to external stimuli and prioritising its own survival.

All I said was that they are living organisms that people deliberately kill in order that they can survive. As I said, there is a very small minority of people whose ethical stance means that they would killing them as completely unacceptable, but most vegans obviously are not this strict.

Even if you don't object to killing any living things without a brain for food, that still doesn't answer the question of how you ensure that no animals have died in the production of your food - chiefly those killed by pesticides and combined harvesters. How many vegans are strict about only buying food - with the significantly increased costs, of course - from producers that use no pesticides and carefully reap the harvest by hand?

On one level, it could be argued that, if you don't care about the animals that are inevitably killed in the normal processes of producing plant-based food, you might as well ethically eat rennet, on the grounds that no animals are killed only to provide it and were going to die to provide meat anyway.

To reiterate, this is not meant as a 'gotcha' for vegans, who are mainly trying to do the very best that they can; it's simply my response to the minority of sanctimonious ones who will piously lecture others, sneering and calling them names for their personal ethical choices, claiming that they personally strictly do not eat anything that is the product of (non-plant) death, when this appears not to be the case at all.

Thebirdhouse · 29/06/2023 23:21

I would cook whatever I was cooking for all the other guests and serve the vegan without meat. I 'might' buy vegan burgers . That would be it. I would expect the vegan guest to bring their own milk alternative and whatever else they wanted to eat themselves.

Oakbeam · 29/06/2023 21:37

The amount of people talking about disposable bbqs. The point is to minimise waste. Not add to the landfill

Apart from the ash, which is pretty inert, they are easily recyclable aluminium and steel so shouldn’t go landfill.

BeSensible23 · 29/06/2023 20:45

I really don't understand the entitlement of people these days. If it's a week long catered holiday or boarding school, yes, food intolerances need to be discussed but for a single afternoon the guest should just eat before or after. I've had severe inflammatory bowel disease since age 6 which means I can pretty much only eat plain meat/fish/chicken, dry vegetables, fruit and white rice. I have never once brought my own food to an event or asked for an accommodation by a host. I have been to multiple dinner parties and restaurant meals. I just push my food around on my plate and pretend to eat. Snack on a few crudites. Be a sensible polite adult!

BathroomOnTheRight · 29/06/2023 20:44

The amount of people talking about disposable bbqs. The point is to minimise waste. Not add to the landfill.

KarmaStar · 29/06/2023 20:38

You've had loads of replies already.
the best bet is to cook stuff on a disposable bbq or in the oven so meat fat doesn't get attached.
vegan burgers and sausages,a few vegetable kebabs /baked potatoes and that will do as they can eat fresh salads too.they will appreciate all your effort no doubt.💐💐

LaBefana · 29/06/2023 20:34

Tomateen · 29/06/2023 19:59

I wouldn’t invite a vegan. They talk about nothing else.

That's just silly, prejudiced nonsense. I worked with someone for 5 years before finding out they were vegan.

Emmamoo89 · 29/06/2023 20:01

Tomateen · 29/06/2023 19:59

I wouldn’t invite a vegan. They talk about nothing else.

You are completely right.

Tomateen · 29/06/2023 19:59

I wouldn’t invite a vegan. They talk about nothing else.

Swipe left for the next trending thread