Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How far would you go to accommodate a vegan?

758 replies

Juicyj1993 · 24/06/2023 23:22

In a few weeks we're hosting a bbq for my Husband's birthday.

We have about a dozen guests coming, one of whom is vegan. As we don't normally buy vegan food I've started looking at what we'd normally buy and what is and isn't vegan. To make sure the vegan has the same variety of choice as everyone else I'm going to have to spend quite a bit on alternatives. As we have the non vegan alternatives we won't be eating the vegan versions, so they'll either go home with the guest or be thrown.

How much would you accommodate a vegan?

Would I be unreasonable to provide vegan burger with vegan cheese, plus bun and nothing else or do I need to go the whole hog and get vegan sausages, vegan condiments and vegan coleslaw?

Ps they are vegan by choice, not for medical reasons

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
JohnnysSoLongAtTheFair · 02/07/2023 10:18

Being vegan isn't being fussy though.. They don't want to eat animals, don't want to contribute to their suffering. Why is that "being fussy?"
You wanting to eat animals that's up to you but you can eat both meat and vegetable dishes no problem, so why should they go against their morals and beliefs just because you don't like the thought of going without meat or dairy for one day?

It's fussy because veganism has nothing to do with morals or beliefs. It's not a faith; it has no religious history or scripture, it has nothing to say about how we treat each other or about any other 'big' human question. I said straight up that religious dietary law and medical need are different. But veganism isn't a religion and if they have a medical food need they should and would tell me. They just choose what they do. And I don't believe that an extreme attitude to animals has anything to with morals either. Apart from morals being about humans' relationships with each other, it's very unattractive to suggest that people who eat and use animals (which is as old as humankind) are immoral. Leather, wool and silk are immoral? FFS. Veganism is just a lifestyle choice.

Well I suppose that’s a lot better than holding your “peculiar fundamentalist view” on certain groups of people based purely on what they don’t eat/west. Are you normally this insecure that you’re threatened by other peoples lifestyles?

I don't have a fundamentalist view about vegans, or a peculiar one. If people want to live as vegans, rock on, as I've said. I just cba to pander to them.

And "insecure"? You're having a laugh. Somebody decided to call me narrow minded, selfish and thick because I don't want to run around for someone else's lifestyle choice. I suspect vegans are on the whole quite unpleasant when they don't get their way or are disagreed with.

I think that's borne out by a PP throwing around "bragging", "defiant", "belligerent", "mean spirited", "riled up", "spiteful" and "angry" because I've made clear that I won't put myself out to cater for a person who has chosen to live in such a restrictive way that hosts have to be more careful about them than anyone else. Maybe that's the reason behind the vitriol against people who say "jolly good, but you'll have to look after yourself": vegans' desire to be treated as special.

Toodles101 · 02/07/2023 09:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

5128gap · 02/07/2023 08:37

@JohnnysSoLongAtTheFair if you're comfortable with your choice to eat meat, why do you need to attack vegans? It comes across very defensively.
Bragging all defiantly about how you wouldn't cater for them, getting all irate and belligerent about their choices? You're sufficiently generous enough to imaging yourself hosting guests, yet so mean spirited towards some of them you'd be comfortable if there was nothing for them to eat in your home.
It would be an odd person indeed who had a moral objection to people NOT doing harm to animals, so what has you so riled up and spiteful?
I'm more than happy to listen to arguments about why you believe people shouldn't be vegan if you have them, because this level of anger towards a harmless lifestyle seems excessive.

OMG12 · 02/07/2023 06:08

*Wear not west

OMG12 · 02/07/2023 06:07

JohnnysSoLongAtTheFair · 01/07/2023 23:48

Yes, I know the label ‘pescatarian’. Like most of the world I just talk about vegans and vegetarians, who come with different diets.

If you choose to adopt a peculiar fundamentalist view about animals, knock yourself out. Just don’t expect others to indulge you by altering how they live their lives to suit you.

“If you choose to adopt a peculiar fundamentalist view about animals,”

Well I suppose that’s a lot better than holding your “peculiar fundamentalist view” on certain groups of people based purely on what they don’t eat/west. Are you normally this insecure that you’re threatened by other peoples lifestyles?

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 02/07/2023 00:08

JohnnysSoLongAtTheFair · 01/07/2023 21:18

Why?

Why should I pander to vegans? They made the choice to be such fussy eaters. I don’t know what’s in all the stuff I use and I’m not going to spend time checking it, buying alternatives and cooking it all separately.

Vegans wouldn’t compromise for me or any other non-vegan. Why are they so fucking special?

Being vegan isn't being fussy though.. They don't want to eat animals, don't want to contribute to their suffering. Why is that "being fussy?"
You wanting to eat animals that's up to you but you can eat both meat and vegetable dishes no problem, so why should they go against their morals and beliefs just because you don't like the thought of going without meat or dairy for one day?

JohnnysSoLongAtTheFair · 01/07/2023 23:48

Otherland · 01/07/2023 23:29

No vegan would contribute to unnecessary animal suffering, so of course we won't provide flesh or animal secretions for you. It's just not comparable to non-vegans buying vegetable stuff which surely most of you do anyway.

No vegetarians eat fish. Those people are pescetarians.

Yes, I know the label ‘pescatarian’. Like most of the world I just talk about vegans and vegetarians, who come with different diets.

If you choose to adopt a peculiar fundamentalist view about animals, knock yourself out. Just don’t expect others to indulge you by altering how they live their lives to suit you.

Otherland · 01/07/2023 23:29

JohnnysSoLongAtTheFair · 01/07/2023 22:47

I haven’t met a vegan who’d buy and cook with meat, dairy, eggs etc. It’s true that I’ve only met a few, but tell me if I’m wrong and vegans are generally happy to do so. The few I know are totally finicky about animal products and wouldn’t.

Vegetarians don’t usually shun dairy or eggs. Many eat fish. (They’d be able to eat the fish and the Greek salad we’re having tomorrow with a bbq. I’m not making the Greek salad without feta.)

People who drink alcohol also drink soft drinks. Soft drinks are always available, for drivers if no-one else. That’s a foolish comparison.

I’ll plead guilty to not being willing to indulge vegans’ self-imposed rules. But the selfishness and stupidity are all yours.

No vegan would contribute to unnecessary animal suffering, so of course we won't provide flesh or animal secretions for you. It's just not comparable to non-vegans buying vegetable stuff which surely most of you do anyway.

No vegetarians eat fish. Those people are pescetarians.

JohnnysSoLongAtTheFair · 01/07/2023 22:47

WellPlaced · 01/07/2023 22:13

What makes you think they wouldn’t compromise for you?

Would you accommodate vegetarians?
Teetotallers? or would you just provide beer, wine or gin?

You sound narrow minded, selfish and just plain thick tbh

I haven’t met a vegan who’d buy and cook with meat, dairy, eggs etc. It’s true that I’ve only met a few, but tell me if I’m wrong and vegans are generally happy to do so. The few I know are totally finicky about animal products and wouldn’t.

Vegetarians don’t usually shun dairy or eggs. Many eat fish. (They’d be able to eat the fish and the Greek salad we’re having tomorrow with a bbq. I’m not making the Greek salad without feta.)

People who drink alcohol also drink soft drinks. Soft drinks are always available, for drivers if no-one else. That’s a foolish comparison.

I’ll plead guilty to not being willing to indulge vegans’ self-imposed rules. But the selfishness and stupidity are all yours.

WellPlaced · 01/07/2023 22:13

JohnnysSoLongAtTheFair · 01/07/2023 21:18

Why?

Why should I pander to vegans? They made the choice to be such fussy eaters. I don’t know what’s in all the stuff I use and I’m not going to spend time checking it, buying alternatives and cooking it all separately.

Vegans wouldn’t compromise for me or any other non-vegan. Why are they so fucking special?

What makes you think they wouldn’t compromise for you?

Would you accommodate vegetarians?
Teetotallers? or would you just provide beer, wine or gin?

You sound narrow minded, selfish and just plain thick tbh

OMG12 · 01/07/2023 21:45

Emmamoo89 · 01/07/2023 17:14

Actually Vegans do have a bad reputation. I'm not saying they're all bad but some don't help and cause them to have the bad reputation. The ones I've spoken to have been total aholes.

Nah, they prob just disliked you and wanted you to go away, understandable if you were anything like you have been here.

JohnnysSoLongAtTheFair · 01/07/2023 21:18

WellPlaced · 01/07/2023 21:07

Totally mad

Why?

Why should I pander to vegans? They made the choice to be such fussy eaters. I don’t know what’s in all the stuff I use and I’m not going to spend time checking it, buying alternatives and cooking it all separately.

Vegans wouldn’t compromise for me or any other non-vegan. Why are they so fucking special?

WellPlaced · 01/07/2023 21:07

JohnnysSoLongAtTheFair · 01/07/2023 18:03

Doesn’t get my back up.

I never anticipate that anyone I don’t know who’s coming - like a partner - might be a vegan. If someone is a vegan and they can eat something that is being provided anyway, then fine. If that’s not acceptable, they can go without.

If I’m told beforehand that someone’s vegan I ask them to bring their own food and if necessary cook it themselves.

Veganism is nothing like religion or food allergy/intolerance. It’s just a choice. So they can sort themselves out.

Totally mad

mewkins · 01/07/2023 20:17

OMG12 · 01/07/2023 19:55

Someone invited you for dinner then refused to make you anything?? WTAF? I really could not be
friends with anyone that rude. What the guck is wrong with people?

Yes. It's weird behaviour 😄 People can be very strange indeed.

OMG12 · 01/07/2023 19:55

mewkins · 01/07/2023 19:16

Someone invited me round for dinner several weeks in advance knowing I was a vegetarian. They told me to bring my own food as they weren't prepared to make me anything. I did, but brought plenty of extra. It turned out his meat dish for everyone else took an age to make and was inedible, so all the other guests ate mine too and enjoyed it. It was most amusing.

Someone invited you for dinner then refused to make you anything?? WTAF? I really could not be
friends with anyone that rude. What the guck is wrong with people?

mewkins · 01/07/2023 19:16

JohnnysSoLongAtTheFair · 01/07/2023 18:03

Doesn’t get my back up.

I never anticipate that anyone I don’t know who’s coming - like a partner - might be a vegan. If someone is a vegan and they can eat something that is being provided anyway, then fine. If that’s not acceptable, they can go without.

If I’m told beforehand that someone’s vegan I ask them to bring their own food and if necessary cook it themselves.

Veganism is nothing like religion or food allergy/intolerance. It’s just a choice. So they can sort themselves out.

Someone invited me round for dinner several weeks in advance knowing I was a vegetarian. They told me to bring my own food as they weren't prepared to make me anything. I did, but brought plenty of extra. It turned out his meat dish for everyone else took an age to make and was inedible, so all the other guests ate mine too and enjoyed it. It was most amusing.

JohnnysSoLongAtTheFair · 01/07/2023 18:03

EbonyRaven · 24/06/2023 23:41

This is an interesting one....I know this is going to get people's backs up.... but I don't go very far to accommodate vegans now, because all the vegans that I know, never, EVER attempt to accommodate me. They don't even buy like, a pack of chocolate biscuits in or anything I may like. I have to take my own snacks/food to their house because they don't buy fuck all for me..., Yet I'm expected to provide for them being vegans.

I've provided for them for the last 5 or 6 years, but about 9 months ago, I decided to stop and just get take out now when they come (or a prepared ready meal,) because I'm not going to get special vegan food in and soy milk and cook and prepare different food - when they can't be fucked to do it for me.

Some people say 'oh, but it's their belief..!!! They simply CAN'T go against it.' Yeah sure! Hmm. Not all but SOME vegans I know/know of are utterly insufferable and arrogant. Want everything their own way, but won't bend an INCH for anyone else.

Doesn’t get my back up.

I never anticipate that anyone I don’t know who’s coming - like a partner - might be a vegan. If someone is a vegan and they can eat something that is being provided anyway, then fine. If that’s not acceptable, they can go without.

If I’m told beforehand that someone’s vegan I ask them to bring their own food and if necessary cook it themselves.

Veganism is nothing like religion or food allergy/intolerance. It’s just a choice. So they can sort themselves out.

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 01/07/2023 17:51

BathroomOnTheRight · 29/06/2023 15:26

https://scienceillustrated.com.au/blog/ask-us/the-smell-of-fresh-cut-grass-is-an-attack-warning/

This is how smart plants are: "The smell of cut grass in recent years has been identified as the plant’s way of signalling distress, but new research says the aroma also summons beneficial insects to the rescue."
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/09/140922145805.htm

" The validity of the CBC is independent of whether plants are sentient. For Calvo, Sahi, & Trewavas (2017), who work in the area they have dubbed "plant neurobiology," however, the issue poses a number of other problems ─ problems with ethical overtones that I have yet to see addressed. If they are right, ethical vegetarians and vegans are going to have to confront some uncomfortable propositions. ..."
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/319530528_Are_plants_sentient

To say that plants are not sentient, is quite clearly, untrue and thoroughly debunked. Of course they are sentient. And science has proved it without a shadow of a doubt.

That's a really interesting article, love finding out new stuff like this!

5128gap · 01/07/2023 17:45

Emmamoo89 · 01/07/2023 17:14

Actually Vegans do have a bad reputation. I'm not saying they're all bad but some don't help and cause them to have the bad reputation. The ones I've spoken to have been total aholes.

You're mistaking your personal negative view for a negative view held by the majority of people. The second is a bad reputation. The first is just your opinion.
I've been both a meat eater and a vegan so I'm well placed to have garnered uncensored opinions had they been forthcoming, and I can assure you, outside of these threads few people give a thought to vegans one way or the other.
I'm actually curious as to why you care so much as it happens?

CurlewKate · 01/07/2023 17:21

This thread has gone completely insane. Nobody is coming out of it well. Maybe time for it to die a quiet death?

Otherland · 01/07/2023 17:20

Emmamoo89 · 01/07/2023 17:14

Actually Vegans do have a bad reputation. I'm not saying they're all bad but some don't help and cause them to have the bad reputation. The ones I've spoken to have been total aholes.

I feel the same about non-vegans. Though we aren't the group killing animals, so I can see why pointing that out gets your back up.

Otherland · 01/07/2023 17:19

Emmamoo89 · 01/07/2023 17:17

Erm yes you can. You don't know how I physically/emotionally feel. I fucking love my cats and bird. And you can't come back and say that's different in some countries they eat cats and birds.

Also, it's cruel to keep birds.

Otherland · 01/07/2023 17:18

Emmamoo89 · 01/07/2023 17:17

Erm yes you can. You don't know how I physically/emotionally feel. I fucking love my cats and bird. And you can't come back and say that's different in some countries they eat cats and birds.

I think YOU don't know how you feel.

You might profess to love SOME animals.

You certainly don't love all animals though.

Emmamoo89 · 01/07/2023 17:17

LuckySantangelo35 · 30/06/2023 14:56

@Emmamoo89

you can’t. You can’t live animals and eat meat. Soz.

Erm yes you can. You don't know how I physically/emotionally feel. I fucking love my cats and bird. And you can't come back and say that's different in some countries they eat cats and birds.

Emmamoo89 · 01/07/2023 17:15

BathroomOnTheRight · 30/06/2023 18:22

Someone put it very well upthread when they compared it to how Jimmy Saville loved children

Wow. Just when I thought some comments couldn't get any lower. To compare meat-eaters to a pedophile is, well, I can't believe that post is still standing. Just when my view of (some) vegans couldn't get any more rock bottom. They really have no idea just how they come across.

It's ridiculous isn't it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread