Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ideation that girl babies are better than boy babies.

344 replies

Supremechicken · 24/06/2023 19:41

In my family it’s very heavily opinionated that boy babies are an ‘aww better luck next time’ and girl babies are an amazing gift.

My sisters were saying the other day that when they see a gender reveal on Facebook they don’t tend to like or react to the boy ones but the girls they feel excited for.

I don’t really see the difference .

Is there something I’m missing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Sceptre86 · 25/06/2023 08:53

The world over it is skewed the other way and boys are preferred. Your family are idiots and I'd shut down those types of jokes. I've had a lot of girls are bitchy, cost more, teenage years are harder and whatever else. I don't have patience with ignorant people and as I'm getting older have perfected my looks of disdain. I have girl, boy, girl and am happy with my lot.

LooseGoosey · 25/06/2023 08:47

I think a lot of women want a daughter. I don’t know anyone in real life who has had 2 or 3 boys and hasn’t confessed to being secretly gutted that they didn’t have a girl.

Within my circle of family and friends, it is absolutely true that the mothers of daughters are favoured over the mothers of sons (MILs). Even my sister who has one of each, when she was pregnant with her third, really hoped it would be a girl.

It’s interesting that, even on this thread, those that are almost rabidly defending having boys and lambasting those who express gender disappointment, are those who only have boys themselves.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/06/2023 08:45

IMO preference for a girl is a relatively recent thing - that is if it really is a thing.
A few decades ago it was more common for people to say e.g. ‘Never mind, you can always try again’ if you had a second girl. Certainly it was in various other cultures, not all Asian either. Dh bought me a lovely ring right after the birth of dd2 - I’d never had an engagement ring - and a Greek Cypriot neighbour said, ‘You got that for a GIRL?’
This was back in the 80s though.

Wheelz46 · 25/06/2023 08:10

A saying is just a saying, doesn't make it true at all. My brothers were just as close to my mum as I were both growing up and as adults.

Same with my partner and his mum, they are extremely close and she has as much involvement with our kids as my mum did.

I personally don't know of many adult males who are not close to their mum, loved and cared for just the same as a daughter does!

Fairislefandango · 25/06/2023 08:01

What does 'ideation' mean? Is it idea?

I've only heard it used in psychological/mental health contexts (e.g. suicidal ideation). I don't think it's really the right word in the thread title. What's wrong with 'opinion'?

SleepingStandingUp · 25/06/2023 07:40

luckylavender · 25/06/2023 07:35

What does 'ideation' mean? Is it idea?

Kinda

Ideation that girl babies are better than boy babies.
luckylavender · 25/06/2023 07:35

Supremechicken · 24/06/2023 19:41

In my family it’s very heavily opinionated that boy babies are an ‘aww better luck next time’ and girl babies are an amazing gift.

My sisters were saying the other day that when they see a gender reveal on Facebook they don’t tend to like or react to the boy ones but the girls they feel excited for.

I don’t really see the difference .

Is there something I’m missing?

What does 'ideation' mean? Is it idea?

Oysterbabe · 25/06/2023 07:33

snoopybus · 25/06/2023 07:22

Honestly, this saying is why I'm sad I got a boy rather than a girl.

I love him to pieces, but very aware once he's grown and established his own life, if he goes down the standard married to a wife with kids, I'll be the second tier MIL.

I know nobody who has a good relationship with their MIL side - but everyone I know has a fantastic relationship with their own parents side. I'll be sad that I'm going to be the 'once a month scheduled visit' and not the 'basically live there' grandmother (if he has kids - obviously he may not).

It's 100% Unreasonable for me - and I'd never say it to my son or in front of him - but it's just always been a worry.

This definitely isn't how it is in our family.
We visit mine 3 times a year and PIL every weekend. We go on days out and weekends away with them a few times a year. They help us out with childcare in the school holidays sometimes and the kids have a brilliant relationship with them.

MissyB1 · 25/06/2023 07:28

LolaSmiles · 25/06/2023 06:53

It hasn't happened to me - I am so close to my son and DIL. It didn't happen to my mum who is so close to my brother. It didn't happen to my amazing MIL who had two sons and no daughters.

It's all down to relationships not the sex of your offspring. I honestly speak from a lifetime to experience that you really don't need to worry about this
Echoing this but from the other side.
I have a wonderful MIL and we have a great relationship.

I always wonder if there's a large overlap between the people wailing about having a baby boy and the people who view their MIL/DIL as some sort of competition. It's a certain type of mindset that seems very similar to the "pick me" behaviours that come up in the dating scene.

There's lots of people out there who just want to have happy babies, drop the sexist stereotyping of children and don't view their in laws as weird competition to get one up on.

Nailed it! 👆

snoopybus · 25/06/2023 07:22

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 24/06/2023 20:28

My mother in law had 5 boys, no daughters. It was a source of sadness to her over the years, and she often trotted out "a son's a son till he takes a wife, a daughter is a daughter for life" (or something along those lines).

Personally I love having a daughter but would have been delighted with either a boy or a girl!

Honestly, this saying is why I'm sad I got a boy rather than a girl.

I love him to pieces, but very aware once he's grown and established his own life, if he goes down the standard married to a wife with kids, I'll be the second tier MIL.

I know nobody who has a good relationship with their MIL side - but everyone I know has a fantastic relationship with their own parents side. I'll be sad that I'm going to be the 'once a month scheduled visit' and not the 'basically live there' grandmother (if he has kids - obviously he may not).

It's 100% Unreasonable for me - and I'd never say it to my son or in front of him - but it's just always been a worry.

LolaSmiles · 25/06/2023 06:53

It hasn't happened to me - I am so close to my son and DIL. It didn't happen to my mum who is so close to my brother. It didn't happen to my amazing MIL who had two sons and no daughters.

It's all down to relationships not the sex of your offspring. I honestly speak from a lifetime to experience that you really don't need to worry about this
Echoing this but from the other side.
I have a wonderful MIL and we have a great relationship.

I always wonder if there's a large overlap between the people wailing about having a baby boy and the people who view their MIL/DIL as some sort of competition. It's a certain type of mindset that seems very similar to the "pick me" behaviours that come up in the dating scene.

There's lots of people out there who just want to have happy babies, drop the sexist stereotyping of children and don't view their in laws as weird competition to get one up on.

MRSDoos · 25/06/2023 06:44

Gender disappointment is a real thing.
I never understood it especially after my miscarriage I just wanted a healthy baby. Then when I fell pregnant again and our gender scan was coming up - I felt anxiety that the scan would show a girl. Me and DH really wanted a son deep down and had his name picked out, I imagined myself with a boy since I was a teen. I cried the night before a scan wondering how I’ll feel if we have a girl, of course I’d love her to bits just as much as a boy. Our scan revealed we were having a boy and he is here now and we are in love!
I would say that some people have a preference for girls and some for boys. It was 50/50 in our friendship group for preference. My DM was hoping I’d have a girl and my MIL hoped we was having a boy. DM adores him and says he is the best thing to happen to her. From my experience it’s very divided on which sex is preferenced.

Some of the comments on this thread are a bit nasty though.

SleepingStandingUp · 25/06/2023 00:03

Shinier · 24/06/2023 23:56

Well if you are the type of woman sticking limes up your foof and abstaining from sex for weeks for the sake of a girl it might explain why the relationship might be more stressful lol. I'll happily stick with my stress free marriage and lovely sons

yeah that’s all lovely and cool @Holihobbies you do you, but you really shouldn’t post misinformation and state it as fact. That’s Trumpian territory. Any lie to win an argument

😂😂

MysteryBelle · 24/06/2023 23:58

Lostmum2407 · 24/06/2023 23:55

Wow! To have a baby is a wonderful thing. The sex doesn’t matter at all!

This exactly!

Shinier · 24/06/2023 23:56

Well if you are the type of woman sticking limes up your foof and abstaining from sex for weeks for the sake of a girl it might explain why the relationship might be more stressful lol. I'll happily stick with my stress free marriage and lovely sons

yeah that’s all lovely and cool @Holihobbies you do you, but you really shouldn’t post misinformation and state it as fact. That’s Trumpian territory. Any lie to win an argument

Lostmum2407 · 24/06/2023 23:55

I have one of each and love them both equally!

Lostmum2407 · 24/06/2023 23:55

Wow! To have a baby is a wonderful thing. The sex doesn’t matter at all!

GilChesterton · 24/06/2023 23:53

Totally - you have to let them find their own interests (and hope they might share some of yours!) but the outside influences they face often push them down quite narrow tracks. All you can do is try your best.

SleepingStandingUp · 24/06/2023 23:48

GilChesterton · 24/06/2023 23:42

And you don't feel a desire to top that on its head and buy the kid a dinosaur TShirt? How old is she? What if she loves dinosaurs and robots? Likes worms and mud and football and black?

It's really difficult. The range of things that work on them are so much bigger than just what parents can influence. I'm absurdly pleased that our youngest is a little sci-fi geek (a female Doctor Who was huge in our house), though.

I get that, I have a son who doesn't fit the boy mould and it doesn't matter how much we don't care, people do.

But at least you try and bring them up with some freedom of expression

SleepingStandingUp · 24/06/2023 23:46

PinkButtercups · 24/06/2023 23:42

@SleepingStandingUp No!
It's obviously the double yolk I even gave it a squirt of lime and I reckon that's how I have B/G twins.

That's how you must've got your twins too because that's the only way it works so...

Ah, mine are identical. A squirt of line would have made girls. I think you used too much lime juice and it set free two eggs. Whereas I just juggled about too much and it split

GilChesterton · 24/06/2023 23:42

And you don't feel a desire to top that on its head and buy the kid a dinosaur TShirt? How old is she? What if she loves dinosaurs and robots? Likes worms and mud and football and black?

It's really difficult. The range of things that work on them are so much bigger than just what parents can influence. I'm absurdly pleased that our youngest is a little sci-fi geek (a female Doctor Who was huge in our house), though.

PinkButtercups · 24/06/2023 23:42

@SleepingStandingUp No!
It's obviously the double yolk I even gave it a squirt of lime and I reckon that's how I have B/G twins.

That's how you must've got your twins too because that's the only way it works so...

JennyJenny8675309 · 24/06/2023 23:39

Supremechicken · 24/06/2023 19:54

I’m pregnant at the moment and really nervous to find out as I know there won’t be any excitement for a boy.

When I was pregnant with my first baby over 30 years ago, I HAD to have a girl. There was no other option—I was really irrational about it. Then I had a boy! I went on to have a girl several years after.

My babies are both grown up now and my son is the father of a boy—and I love him and everything he is interested in makes me smile. I’m embarrassed to think I ever felt the way I did. It was utterly ridiculous.

SleepingStandingUp · 24/06/2023 23:37

Muddygreenfingers · 24/06/2023 23:29

Personally I'm happy I had a girl. I much prefer the stereotypical girly stuff. I like dressing her up in flowery dresses and doing her hair.

Yes it's sexist but take a look around. Society is still very sexist as a whole. Even now boys still tend to go for dinosaurs and girls princess dresses.

And you don't feel a desire to top that on its head and buy the kid a dinosaur TShirt? How old is she? What if she loves dinosaurs and robots? Likes worms and mud and football and black?

Holihobbies · 24/06/2023 23:32

Well if you are the type of woman sticking limes up your foof and abstaining from sex for weeks for the sake of a girl it might explain why the relationship might be more stressful lol

I'll happily stick with my stress free marriage and lovely sons.