Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ideation that girl babies are better than boy babies.

344 replies

Supremechicken · 24/06/2023 19:41

In my family it’s very heavily opinionated that boy babies are an ‘aww better luck next time’ and girl babies are an amazing gift.

My sisters were saying the other day that when they see a gender reveal on Facebook they don’t tend to like or react to the boy ones but the girls they feel excited for.

I don’t really see the difference .

Is there something I’m missing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
SallyWD · 26/06/2023 12:21

Shinier · 26/06/2023 12:19

I do think a lot of people on here need to stop fighting men’s (perceived) battles for them. They don’t have many and they don’t need you doing it for them.

I'm not fighting any battles for men, just giving my honest opinion if that's OK.

SunnyEgg · 26/06/2023 12:20

If I had a boy I assume I would have loved him and brought him up well

That’s not different to people who do have boys.

Holly60 · 26/06/2023 12:20

Shinier · 26/06/2023 12:16

@MissyB1 i have a girl. I don’t despise men at all. I love lots of men. You’re misunderstanding the picture here

I think maybe you are looking at it from the perspective of a mother with a girl. Obviously she is the best girl in the world and no one could be better than her (I have one of those 🥰)

you maybe can't imagine loving another child, let alone a child of a different sex as much.

I felt like that after I had my DD. Lo and behold I had my son and I love him just as much and he is the best boy in the world and I can't imagine another child being as perfect as him.

I still think they are the best children in the world and they are adults with their own families now 😂

Shinier · 26/06/2023 12:19

I do think a lot of people on here need to stop fighting men’s (perceived) battles for them. They don’t have many and they don’t need you doing it for them.

Shinier · 26/06/2023 12:18

If I had a boy I assume I would have loved him and brought him up well. My preference was a girl. Doesn’t mean I hate all men.

Rorlaa · 26/06/2023 12:17

I just want a neurotypical baby after an asd DS and DD. I'd put up even chili tampons if I could just try for another without worrying... From my point of view neurotypical baby boys and girls are equally freaking lovely 😍

Shinier · 26/06/2023 12:16

@MissyB1 i have a girl. I don’t despise men at all. I love lots of men. You’re misunderstanding the picture here

SunnyEgg · 26/06/2023 12:14

MissyB1 · 26/06/2023 10:58

@Shinier you would prefer to bring up a girl /woman because men are just so violent and awful, but how are you going to conceive this baby girl? You would have to use sperm from a man - you know that sex that you distrust and despise so much that you don’t want to give birth to.

Also this, what’s the plan for conceiving

SunnyEgg · 26/06/2023 12:13

Shinier · 26/06/2023 09:32

@LolaSmiles yes you’re right, it so sad other women choose to perpetuate this.

99% of sexual assaults, rapes, murders, domestic abuse are carried out by men. For these reasons - and many many more I’ve explained - I have stated I’d prefer to bring up a girl/ woman. Sadly, many women on here (@SleepingStandingUp @Surprisedbysummer) have decided that means I am a ‘pick me’ woman desperate to fight my (imaginary) MIL in order to win the fight for my (imaginary) husband. It’s like they have to defend the patriarchy at all costs.

@Shinier do you have dc or plan to have them? If you do what would you have done if you were pg with a boy, if the latter same question but what will you do?

SallyWD · 26/06/2023 12:10

Shinier · 26/06/2023 09:32

@LolaSmiles yes you’re right, it so sad other women choose to perpetuate this.

99% of sexual assaults, rapes, murders, domestic abuse are carried out by men. For these reasons - and many many more I’ve explained - I have stated I’d prefer to bring up a girl/ woman. Sadly, many women on here (@SleepingStandingUp @Surprisedbysummer) have decided that means I am a ‘pick me’ woman desperate to fight my (imaginary) MIL in order to win the fight for my (imaginary) husband. It’s like they have to defend the patriarchy at all costs.

What a miserable way to see 50% of the population. Maybe your statistics are right but it's also true that 99% of men DON'T commit violent and sexual crimes! So why hate 99% of men when most are fine?
I have a son and I'm raising him to be a decent man (although you can never be sure how your sons and daughters will turn out but you can do your best).
So if you're so certain you couldn't bear to raise a son, how have you death with this? By not having children at all? By getting pregnant but praying it's a girl? What if you found out you were having a boy - would you have had a late abortion? Put him up for adoption? Assuming you're heterosexual will you remain single for the rest of your life because a minority of men do bad things?

Fightyouforthatpie · 26/06/2023 12:00

"ideation"?

What's wrong with idea?

Holly60 · 26/06/2023 11:57

Shinier · 26/06/2023 09:32

@LolaSmiles yes you’re right, it so sad other women choose to perpetuate this.

99% of sexual assaults, rapes, murders, domestic abuse are carried out by men. For these reasons - and many many more I’ve explained - I have stated I’d prefer to bring up a girl/ woman. Sadly, many women on here (@SleepingStandingUp @Surprisedbysummer) have decided that means I am a ‘pick me’ woman desperate to fight my (imaginary) MIL in order to win the fight for my (imaginary) husband. It’s like they have to defend the patriarchy at all costs.

Again this seems so backwards. If you are preoccupied with the threat of male to female violence, wouldn't you have preferred to have a boy??

Holly60 · 26/06/2023 11:55

Shinier · 25/06/2023 21:49

@Avondale89 @Shinier you don’t need to attack me a call me a nutter because I have a different opinion to you. I think it’s a pretty wide held view that alpha male patriarchal led society hasn’t exactly worked. Lots of men agree too. I’m sorry if you think this threatens your little boys.

If your main concern really is the problems of a patriarchal society (i agree with you there) It seems a bit backwards logic to only wish for female offspring.

Surely it would be better to have male offspring who a) have more chance of actually making a difference for the better in society due to their sex (unfortunate but true) and b) will have an easier time of it generally.

Women who have baby boys don't look at their new baby and worry about the impact he will have on others way down the line, they just want their baby to have the best life possible. The fact he is a boy is a massive advantage in our society (still).

I have both and I must admit I've worried about my girl more than my boy. I always assumed he would be as lovely and sweet and caring as his sister (he is) but I also felt a sense that he had a bit of an advantage over her too, just because he is a boy.

MissyB1 · 26/06/2023 10:58

@Shinier you would prefer to bring up a girl /woman because men are just so violent and awful, but how are you going to conceive this baby girl? You would have to use sperm from a man - you know that sex that you distrust and despise so much that you don’t want to give birth to.

Shinier · 26/06/2023 09:32

@LolaSmiles yes you’re right, it so sad other women choose to perpetuate this.

99% of sexual assaults, rapes, murders, domestic abuse are carried out by men. For these reasons - and many many more I’ve explained - I have stated I’d prefer to bring up a girl/ woman. Sadly, many women on here (@SleepingStandingUp @Surprisedbysummer) have decided that means I am a ‘pick me’ woman desperate to fight my (imaginary) MIL in order to win the fight for my (imaginary) husband. It’s like they have to defend the patriarchy at all costs.

LolaSmiles · 26/06/2023 07:14

@LolaSmilesthat’s an incredibly misogynistic stance to take. Women don’t hate other women. That’s a narrative men used for years to try and diminish women as just fighting for their attention. Try harder.
It's not misogynistic at all. It's the reality.

The pick me, make sure you get the man is embedded into the socialisation of girls from a young age. It's everywhere and it certainly suits the patriarchy.

Look at how many threads are on here with relationship issues where one or both of the MIL/DIL is demanding the man picks their side over the other. Look how often it suits the man in the middle for his wife and mother to be arguing and competing with each other. Look how often the MIL/DIL being competitive with each other allows the man in the middle to display crappy behaviour.

Look how many times people have gender disappointment about having a boy because "a girl is a yours for life and a boy is only yours until he gets a wife'". It's not hard to see how women with that outlook are likely to be the MIL in the situation above.

It's a similar behaviour to "but I'm not like the other girls" internalised misogyny. Who benefits from this? Men.

Another recent thread was on women calling themselves "work wives" and posters identified that it's not something men do (eg men don't go around calling themselves work husbands and falling about proving they're just so much better with female colleagues). Who benefits here? Men who are looking for a shag or someone to dump their work on.

It's not hating other women to identify a pattern of behaviour that absolutely shafts women who choose to step outside of it.

MIL/DIL do not have to be in competition with each other. Unfortunately some choose to perpetuate this damaging dynamic.

Surprisedbysummer · 26/06/2023 04:55

@Shinier You wrote
'hello @SleepingStandingUp! You’ve not quite grasped this. Summers was defending the idea that women don’t want baby boys because they’re in competition with their MiL. I said this was misogynistic. They responded with this article to back it up. It doesn’t. H2h'

I wrote a brief post referencing Swansea Uni research about women and aggression. I never said anything about MILS or baby boys. I am afraid you made it up. Thank you @SleepingStandingUp for sticking up for me.
You are adopting an aggressive tone, supposedly interpreting my post. Please allow me to speak for myself. If you are objecting to the research findings I suggest you take it up with Swansea University.

WJC1981 · 26/06/2023 01:51

It's selfish people like you that are the issue, you do t own your son and you need to let him lemiev his life, it's not about you!

WJC1981 · 26/06/2023 01:48

It does to a lot of people for many different reasons, it isn't as plain and simple and you think

Shinier · 25/06/2023 21:53

@Surprisedbysummer you’ve misunderstood. I’m not speaking for you. Why would you think that? I’ve no idea who you are? This is just a bizarre convo right now

Shinier · 25/06/2023 21:49

@Avondale89 @Shinier you don’t need to attack me a call me a nutter because I have a different opinion to you. I think it’s a pretty wide held view that alpha male patriarchal led society hasn’t exactly worked. Lots of men agree too. I’m sorry if you think this threatens your little boys.

SleepingStandingUp · 25/06/2023 17:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I think @Shinier has daughters. Goodness knows what she'd have done if they'd been boys or how she'll reach of her daughters get male partners and have sons. Perhaps disowned for letting down feminism.

Avondale89 · 25/06/2023 17:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Avondale89 · 25/06/2023 17:22

SnuggleBuggleBoo · 24/06/2023 20:06

I'd be hugely disappointed to have a boy. One of the reasons I've decided not to have any children. I dislike the things boys are stereotypically interested in - vehicles, football, fighting, farts, superheros, dinosaurs, guns, their genitaliia, monsters, rough-and-tumble etc (and yes, of course I know that not all boys are like that and it's perfectly possible to have a daughter who is, but statistically speaking it's far more likely with a boy, and if I had a boy who wasn't into all that stuff I'd be worrying he was so different from his peers he'd be ostracised!)

In my experience boys have a completely different style of play than girls. Set up a small world zoo and a girl will have little families walking around looking at the animals, buying an ice-cream at the cafe, a zookeeper giving a talk... A boy will have the lions driving the zoo jeep (which can also fly, maybe occasionally squashing the little people flat!?) I just can't relate to that. It annoys me.

Boys grow into men and I, for the most part, don't like men. Aggressive, sex- crazed, selfish, intimidating, misogynistic, all that fun stuff. It's depressing to think you can plough your life into trying to ensure your son turns out right and then he goes and grooms a bloody 15 year old when he's in his mid 30s (one of my school mates, a former 'head boy', popular lad and pillar of the community did just this). I'd hate to have a son.

This has to take the biscuit for one of the most bizarre posts I’ve ever seen on MN. Just wow.

SparklingMarkling · 25/06/2023 17:17

Personally I think the luckiest mothers are the ones who have the opportunity to raise both sexes. I’m lucky enough to have sons and a daughter. I get the preference for daughters (I really wanted a daughter myself) but I think it’s a bit pathetic when people go over the top with it.

I also cringe when you hear mothers of only girls slating boys. Like, come on, you can’t even comment because you simply haven’t got the experience of having a son. You are speaking from a place of ‘unknowing’ and ignorance.

Like I said, it’s the mothers who raise both sons and daughters who are the most fortunate in my opinion.