Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect my friend to have checked on me?

138 replies

WalkingDisaster1 · 24/06/2023 19:03

Name changed cos this is outing.

I’ve been away this weekend with a group of 10 strangers in a national women’s walking group.
It was all women except for my friend of 15 years.

I’m a larger woman and we planned to go for a walk as a group, it was meant to be 1 mile which was absolutely fine by me.
What I didn’t expect was the hill, it was more like mountain climbing.
I got out of breath quickly and the rest of the group except 1 woman charged on ahead.
I had a panic attack, the worst I’ve had in years. I couldn’t breathe so I decided to go back. I told the woman I was with and thanked her for staying with me, she went off to the group and I walked back.

The group leader had the accommodation key and had to send someone who was a runner back with it for me.

They suggested I drove to meet them and I did but they were nowhere to be found and there was no internet nor phone signal so I went back to the accommodation, put the key in the key safe and left.

I sent the group a WhatsApp message saying I couldn’t find them so I’d put the key in the safe and was going home. I’d planned to go home early evening anyway (I have young kids) when they were staying a second night so I just left a few hours earlier.

Now to the point… my friend didn’t come back to check on me and it’s been 8 hours and I’ve not heard from her at all. I know signal isn’t great around there but other people managed.

I would never have done that, if I knew my friend was struggling (especially knowing their mental health struggles) then walk be damned, I’d have been back there to check on them.

Aibu to have expected more of her?

OP posts:
DragonDoor · 25/06/2023 02:45

I can’t get over the fixation on the day’s itinerary that some people have. The OP is asking for advice, after having a tough time.

Just because it’s not how some of you would have planned the day, doesn’t mean that wasn’t what the happened, or that the post is not genuine.

Of course, it’s entirely possible the OP has changed some details to avoid outing herself, but there are a range of other scenarios too.

It really doesn’t take much thinking to consider other possibilities

  1. Some people in the group set off in early the morning, and then they met with the rest of group in a village or a location with a car park before beginning the 1 mile hike collectively.

  2. As it was an activity/ walking weekend, the group did something else in the morning and then set off later in the day - quite a relaxed type of situation. OP may well even have picked something up wrong and there has been a misunderstanding about the distances others intended to walk.

  3. The hike to the picnic bench may have been to a viewpoint, and then back down again. There was then an option of taking a 5 mile or 15 mile route in the area. 15 miles on a flat enough terrain could actually be possible in the afternoon in the summer.

  4. Although this was a group, these individuals weren’t actually very experienced/ dedicated walkers, or it was an informal set up like glamoracks. They planned the day poorly.

  5. Who cares? OP had been asking if she was unreasonable to have expected her friend to check in on her.

Pythacalling702 · 25/06/2023 02:35

I think it would have been fair for the organisers to warn everyone that there was a steep hill included in the first leg of the walk. I can walk for miles at quite a fast pace but find inclines disproportionately difficult. It's just the way I am built in comparison to others. So I don't think YABU for that at all op; I think you were brave to go!

Having said that, I think your friend may not have had a signal or was tied up with second day's activities. So I think you were a little unreasonable to blame her for not texting in those circumstances. Since you have spoken, did she offer an explanation as to why she took so long? (Obviously you don't have to answer that!)

Well done op for trying! Please change your NN to WalkingAgain! 😃

MadKittenWoman · 25/06/2023 02:28

Clymene · 24/06/2023 19:39

OP I mean this kindly but if you can't walk a mile, even if it's a steep one, I'm not sure a walking group is for you

This. Concentrate on improving your physical health and your mental health should also improve.

Chickenkeev · 25/06/2023 02:26

LadyVF · 25/06/2023 02:15

A panic attack is a recognised NHS condition. It’s not ‘drama’ so you might want to brush up on your definitions.

And don’t be so bloody patronising.

Lol! I had a terrible one in a soft play, i happened to be stuck up on the top level of it and the only way down was the slide. And i just couldn't force myself down the (tiny tunnel) slide. It was comical but terrifying at the time. On the medicine since!

Chickenkeev · 25/06/2023 02:22

OP, people who don't get panic attacks don't 'get' panic attacks. Like essentially they're nothing, they won't kill you, they're just in your head (and the awful physical symptoms etc) but if you haven't had them, you may well struggle to understand them. Your mates might fall into that category, not bad but just not knowing.

LadyVF · 25/06/2023 02:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

A panic attack is a recognised NHS condition. It’s not ‘drama’ so you might want to brush up on your definitions.

And don’t be so bloody patronising.

JudgeRudy · 25/06/2023 02:11

WalkingDisaster1 · 24/06/2023 19:25

There was no formal plans on walks, it was said that everyone could do what they felt comfortable with.
I'm absolutely fine walking 3/4 miles on the flat. I didn't know it would be hill climbing.

It was a walking group it was organised through but it wasn't a holiday just about walking, we were planning some wild swimming and crafting things too, a general fun and relaxing weekend for a group of women.

No we didn't car share.

Ok I get it, perhaps I'm wrong in feeling miffed, I will wait for her to reply to my message when she has signal and go from there.

I think you had unrealistic ideas of what a walk entails. The very fact that you say you can walk 3/4 miles on the flat is telling.
Don't get yourself worked up waiting for your friend's text so you can analyse her response. Let it go.
Don't look at this as a failure. You had a go. Tbh many people would be apprehensive about spending a weekend away with a bunch of friends let alone strangers. Factor in that you have poor mental health and were embarrassed in front of them, it's no wonder you panicked. You sure did set the bar high. Try a few smaller smart goals, concentrating on what's realisticly achievable snd get a few wins under your belt before you tackle another huge task. Who knows, maybe this time next year you could be running your own Walk yourself well group for those with poor mental health.

pinkginfizz9 · 25/06/2023 02:04

I can understand you not wanting to complete the walk, but to then jack off the whole weekend because of it when they had all been so kind to you especially the poor runner who had to do the climb twice because of you, is just plain rude

JudgeRudy · 25/06/2023 01:51

WalkingDisaster1 · 24/06/2023 19:10

How is having a panic attack causing drama?

I kind of agree with @whitebreadjamsandwich . It was a walking group, and the group planned a one mile walk. Now unless it's a group for the disabled or elderly I think it would be reasonable to assume they'd be more to the walk than a flat one mile.
You're expecting people to ask after you and give you their attention, yet you say there was no drama. If there wasn't, why do you need attention?

aurynne · 25/06/2023 01:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Rapunzzel · 25/06/2023 01:15

I'm finding this very difficult to believe. You wouldn't walk a mile, have a picnic lunch and then walk 15 miles in the afternoon. 15 miles would be a day's walking and most experienced walkers prefer an early start

Agree. A 15 mile walk would start at 8.30am latest. And have lunch sitting on a log somewhere around 8 miles in.

oakleaffy · 25/06/2023 01:11

A women's national walking group and you only walked a mile??
The other walkers are probably used walking and go at a fast pace, and having to walk slowly is a pain for them -

Lesson learned.

Rapunzzel · 25/06/2023 00:50

I thought oh this would be a good start to recovering

I'm a big lady and over 60. I do a "parkwalk" (most people run it) every Saturday. That's about 3 miles. My best time so far has been 43 minutes. I'm quite proud of that although my daughter runs it in about 27/30 mins.

It's taken me 12 months to achieve this startling speed of 43 mins. Was well over an hour to start with. And the tailwalkers had to chivvy me along. Mortifying, but they were very nice to me. There were people very obviously heavier than me (but maybe younger) making much better time! And this is on a seafront where it is totally and completely and utterly flat.

If this was on a hill I'd be fucked after 10 minutes and I'd chuck in the towel.
Not surprised that on a first attempt you were overwhelmed with the effort.
Not really a good start to recovering, to overchallenge yourself. You've made the first effort. It'd be great to continue, now you know your limitations. You can gradually work up your fitness from that.

Your friend knew you were ok, and she knew that you weren't staying another night anyway. No reason really for her to get in contact. Maybe doesn't want to make a mountain out of a molehill. My advice is to get out on your own walking for a bit and work on your stamina (says she who can't walk 10 minutes uphill!!)
Just walk 3 miles, if you can find the time, every day. And then you have a head start. And if you can't manage three miles just do one, then two and work up to three.
It really does work.

There's really no shame in not being able to keep up. Give it 12 months of commitment and you will be doing way better. To attempt a walk you cannot manage is not a good start to recovering. You are going to get out of breath and your body will fail you. Panic attacks are also shit and don't help.
It takes a little bit of commitment ( unless you are a lean 18 year old) to stride uphill and down. But please don't fall at the first fence. Persevere.

A year ago I couldn't walk a mile without getting out of breath.
Now I can walk 8/10 miles and feel the benefit. Still preferably not uphill though.

Don't be hard on your friend. She has no idea.

daysleepers · 25/06/2023 00:47

Hmm you posted in the group so she knew you were ok...so...what is the issue here?

Sorry OP but I think this is OTT and wouldn't expect special treatment if I weren't up for a 1 mile walk. Please don't fall out with your friend over something this tiny, there is wayyyy more to life.

Mamai90 · 24/06/2023 23:54

There's very rarely any support or sympathy on these AIBU threads but I agree with you OP, it would be nice if your friend had checked in with you but if she hasn't read your message then I'm guessing it's because of the poor signal. I wouldn't jump to any conclusions just yet.

I know how shit panic attacks are, I've had a couple and they can be pretty terrifying. Hope you're OK now OP.

EliflurtleTripanInfinite · 24/06/2023 23:51

WalkingDisaster1 · 24/06/2023 19:51

Yeah it would seem that way.
I'm fine now and we've just had a nice chat so we're fine.
Just got too much in my head about it I guess.

I think posting on MN to see if you're being reasonable can be a good reality check when you get caught in your head, but posting in AIBU isn't necessarily a great idea. Relationship forum is usually a more supportive option. Panic attacks are horrible to go through. I think this weekend was a bit ambitious, too much at once, it's understandable after that long time, you just want things to change, charge in, hope it works. Keep trying, just make it something a bit more realistic next time.

Kitcaterpillar · 24/06/2023 23:48

Threads like this make me think Mumsnet is one of the least nice places on the internet, and there's some fucking strong competition. Noone asked your bitchy little opinions on the walk or its length or the appropriateness of the OP being there.

Well done for giving something a go, OP. I'm sure your friend is just enjoying her weekend and replying slipped her mind. We're all guilty of this, sometimes it feels like every third message I send starts 'sorry I didn't reply sooner...'

Clymene · 24/06/2023 23:40

Group walking is always going to be at the pace of the majority. While the idea of 'no man left behind' is a very worthy one, realistically a group made up of women who don't know one another shouldn't be expected to reduce their pace to fit the slowest. It sounds like other women were kind and made sure the OP was ok. That's really the most she should expect.

I agree with @GoldfincTart that starting the day with a 1 mile very step walk and then having lunch sounds v unlikely. Even if you crawled on your hands and knees a mile wouldn't take more than an hour.
Bit early for lunch

TommyNever · 24/06/2023 23:34

My sympathies with the OP. Similar thing has happened to me, joining in a walk that was mostly up the side of a mountain, finding it exhausting and having to turn back halfway.
It wasn't a very long walk at all in terms of distance, but such uphill hiking over boulders and debris can take ages and I was waiting for hours for the others to return.

Dogsitterwoes · 24/06/2023 23:32

I'm sorry people are being a bit mean about not managing the hill OP. I'm overweight but enjoy walking, and there are hills, and there are hills. I've found myself on a couple that were going up escarpments, and thought there was every possibility I'd have a heart attack, I was gasping for breath (and getting chest pains on one of them). Like 45 degrees steepness at points, for quite prolonged stretches, 300 metres gain in height, and I'm not in a famously hilly area.. One was my own fault, but one was on a walking group's advertised 'beginners walk', which pissed me off no end.

GoldfincTart · 24/06/2023 23:03

WalkingDisaster1 · 24/06/2023 19:29

It was a mile to our picnic point where we would stop for lunch and then the group planned to split into different length walks, some going back then, some doing 5 and some doing 15 miles.

I'm finding this very difficult to believe. You wouldn't walk a mile, have a picnic lunch and then walk 15 miles in the afternoon. 15 miles would be a day's walking and most experienced walkers prefer an early start. And I can't imagine anyone goes on a walking holiday expecting everything to be on the flat. There are always going to be hills.

dickheed · 24/06/2023 22:47

I think you'd be better off doing some walks with just your friend or some easy walks on your own on the flat.
I hike long-distance trails of hundreds of kilometres, carrying full kit and food and sleeping out in a tent for up to 3 weeks at a time. I also do a lot of ascent and descent.
BUT I absolutely cannot cope with anything in a group. I feel like the pacing isn't right and because I haven't got complete control over where we are going, when we stop and so on, I just completely lose the plot and get really stressed. So I just don't do it any more!

nebulae · 24/06/2023 22:31

Some very harsh replies on this thread, especially since OP said she's struggled with anxiety and depression. She was trying to do something to help herself and it didn't work out. She'll be feeling bad enough without people putting the boot in.

I was on a city break with a group of friends when one of the group fell and really hurt her knee. Apart from me, the rest of the group marched on regardless which I thought was really mean.

I was always taught that when you're out in a group you walk at the place of the slowest. Not just take off and leave someone behind.

KarmaStar · 24/06/2023 22:25

Sorry,and I really hope you are feeling better now,but you are being dramatic a bit.I'm sure you'll hear from her soon then feel daft for having posted about this on social media.
It is outing and I doubt your nc will disguise you.

azlazee1 · 24/06/2023 21:55

Well it sounds like the group made efforts to see that you were ok. The fact that you let them know you were leaving and had driven to try to find them, plus were well enough to drive home may have sent a message to your friend that you were ok.