Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone satisfied with the amount of maintenance they receive?

113 replies

MaxwellCat · 24/06/2023 18:42

Just wondering as I see so many threads where people are unhappy with the amount of maintenance they get but Is anyone satisfied with the amount ? Or is everyone unhappy with the amount they get? As someone that gets absolutely zero and never has I am often shocked when people are getting hundreds but still think it isn’t enough (I’m talking £500+) I don’t think anyone should be grateful and of course every nrp should be paying for their kids but just wondering if anyone feels satisfied with the amount they get?

OP posts:
MaxwellCat · 24/06/2023 20:00

J0S · 24/06/2023 19:55

The amount that needs paid is related to the income of the paying parent. So asking if an amount is “ enough” or if the receiving parent is “ happy “ doesn’t really make sense. There’s not enough information about the context.

It’s like asking “ is £20,000 a good salary ?”. The answer is it depends on the job, the hours worked, the cost of living etc.

Let me turn it around . How would you feel about a single mum with a huge income who bought herself designer clothes, ran a luxury car and went on holidays to the Caribbean etc . Yet clothed her kids from the charity shop, took them to Butlins for the weekend and told them they couldn’t do any after school activities because they were too expensive .

You’d judge her, right? Would you say “ Well these kids should be grateful because some kids have no clothes and get no holidays”?

You'd expect the mum to share her good standard of living and her money with her kids.

It’s the same for fathers. Rich and well off dads need to pay more for their kids. It’s their kids right. No point in saying “ they should be glad of a tenner a week because these other kids over there get £7 a week. “.

The Uk is full of well off dads who pay little or nothing for their kids, while their mum and the kids scrape by. Lots of them have to be supported by the tax payer because their selfish bastard fathers don’t pay for their own kid.

SO no they don’t need to be happy or grateful.

Again I did not say anyone needs to be grateful. People do get the amount they are entitled to but still say it isn’t enough so I’m asking if anyone does feel satisfied which a few have said they are. You don’t have to respond.

OP posts:
J0S · 24/06/2023 19:55

The amount that needs paid is related to the income of the paying parent. So asking if an amount is “ enough” or if the receiving parent is “ happy “ doesn’t really make sense. There’s not enough information about the context.

It’s like asking “ is £20,000 a good salary ?”. The answer is it depends on the job, the hours worked, the cost of living etc.

Let me turn it around . How would you feel about a single mum with a huge income who bought herself designer clothes, ran a luxury car and went on holidays to the Caribbean etc . Yet clothed her kids from the charity shop, took them to Butlins for the weekend and told them they couldn’t do any after school activities because they were too expensive .

You’d judge her, right? Would you say “ Well these kids should be grateful because some kids have no clothes and get no holidays”?

You'd expect the mum to share her good standard of living and her money with her kids.

It’s the same for fathers. Rich and well off dads need to pay more for their kids. It’s their kids right. No point in saying “ they should be glad of a tenner a week because these other kids over there get £7 a week. “.

The Uk is full of well off dads who pay little or nothing for their kids, while their mum and the kids scrape by. Lots of them have to be supported by the tax payer because their selfish bastard fathers don’t pay for their own kid.

SO no they don’t need to be happy or grateful.

Lira715 · 24/06/2023 19:46

I was happy with my maintenance payments, was an odd situation though as we married and had our DD in dubai so over there he would be required to pay for practically everything me and Dd needed until she was 8 would have been thousands each month ( it would also be very easy for him to get custody and stop DD leaving the country) so we agreed I’d move back to uk with DD which was preferable for me due to above and as I wanted to be closer to my parents and allthough was all very civil didn’t want to risk it getting nasty and not having option to move back to uk. Used to get £1750 a month plus flights and accommodation to Dubai 5 times a year so Dd can see him. Exs situation changed and he moved back to uk a year ago and not had any maintenance since he moved back, but know he hasn’t got it. on the plus side my daughter gets to spend lots more time with him now, he does say he will pay and back date once he’s back on his feet but I work now and with new partner so it’s not needed really but new amount will definitely be less anyway.

arethereanyleftatall · 24/06/2023 19:43

Yes. I get £1800 a month for two kids.

MaxwellCat · 24/06/2023 19:39

I know loads aren’t happy I was more wondering if anyone is, of course no one will be happy getting a couple of pounds

OP posts:
Seasidemumma77 · 24/06/2023 19:34

4dc and £7 a week CM, no strangely I'm not satisfied/happy

CoreyTaylorsSoggyTshirt · 24/06/2023 19:34

I get around £70 for 4 kids, but when I asked my ex to contribute towards uniform he told me to send his girlfriend my incoming and outgoings and she could do a budget for me because she's great at that 🙄

They set their situation up so she works full time, he works part time and looks after her kids to save money in maintenence, so that's nice.

LookingForFreeDoughnuts · 24/06/2023 19:31

My ex pays the amount stipulated by CMS, but only because he is religious and his church leader expects him to do so in order for him to remain in good standing. Fine by me. I pay the lion's share toward the children's upbringing but he won't pay more than what CMS has calculated so whatever.

DinoDaddy · 24/06/2023 19:30

I get £800 a month for two, but we also go halves on extras like uniform, school tips snd music lessons for example.

Grasshedgeplants · 24/06/2023 19:27

No my ex left when I was pregnant (had ivf) so not unplanned. Had an affair. 19 years later had no payments and ex went on to have 3 more dc who presumably he provides for. Has not had contact with dc either (ex choice). Child maintenance wrote off the case when they changed the system and I couldn't get the details csa needed to open with the new system because I didn't know if he worked or where he lived. A system that is not fit for purpose. I'm not sure what is a satisfactory amount but probably for me it would be regular payments (at least the minimum csa state) plus a meaningful relationship, because this shows a commitment.

BudgieMom · 24/06/2023 19:24

I get £1.44 a week for my 6yr old so definitely not happy!

Parkandpicnic · 24/06/2023 19:22

Receive maintenance, less than £500 but I think is a fair amount. When I was a single mum received less but then was receiving tax credits and child benefit. Is CMS mandated and think it is a fair amount. I don’t expect it to cover things like our mortgage as obviously that is something I’ll benefit from in the long term. Take my DC on holiday and days out with any money left over. If ex was a lower earner would just accept we couldn’t afford things like that just the same as if we were together and he was a low earner

Ilovemycar77 · 24/06/2023 18:58

I get £1.96 a week for my age 16 child and that only just started this week.
I left the T W A T when my child was 2 weeks old after catching him shagging another Woman in My car.
Apparently he hasn’t earnt anything for the last 15 years and has now only declared £368 yearly earnings which means CSA can award my child £1.96 a week.
So no, I am not satisfied. The CSA or CMS are not fit for purpose and neither are these lazy bar steward men who like to put their
d I c k s wherever they like without consequence!