Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone satisfied with the amount of maintenance they receive?

113 replies

MaxwellCat · 24/06/2023 18:42

Just wondering as I see so many threads where people are unhappy with the amount of maintenance they get but Is anyone satisfied with the amount ? Or is everyone unhappy with the amount they get? As someone that gets absolutely zero and never has I am often shocked when people are getting hundreds but still think it isn’t enough (I’m talking £500+) I don’t think anyone should be grateful and of course every nrp should be paying for their kids but just wondering if anyone feels satisfied with the amount they get?

OP posts:
Drywhitefruitycidergin · 24/06/2023 22:57

I'm satisfied. Much as I still think he's a twat going off with OW.....
He's paid CMS amount on time every month since he moved out 7 years ago, he tells me when he gets a pay rise/bonus & adjusts accordingly, he's paid towards parties & stuff & always offers even if I don't take it. When I pointed out how unreasonable it was that he paid less towards his kids because OW's child was there & her dad paid maintenance he adjusted it.
Honestly it was a struggle when we were both paid & I was paying nursery fees - but he wasn't having an amazingly better lifestyle or anything it was just expensive.

Now we are both earning more & actually tbh I would rather he was saving towards getting a bigger rental/buying a house than increasing maintenance but that might change with teenagers 🤣😂

Bad husband, decent enough father

Makemyday99 · 24/06/2023 22:55

IncomingTraffic · 24/06/2023 22:50

That is an amazingly misogynistic view.

Good job I can support my children. And do.

Does that transfer to the other women on this thread? Are they to blame because their exes don’t pay anything at all?

Works both ways

Makemyday99 · 24/06/2023 22:52

IncomingTraffic · 24/06/2023 22:48

Maybe my ex could have fewer nights out, not constantly eat out, not go abroad several times a year, or on uk trips away.

He’s not on the breadline. He could actually pay a meaningful amount.

Last summer I had to borrow money from my mum to pay nursery fees and still eat. While he took his older kids on a 2 week 5* all inclusive holiday in august and gave no fucks about our DS.

Women end up with a hugely disproportionate share of the responsibility for children. That becomes more obvious when relationships break down.

But let’s all talk about how terrible it is for men.

I understand that you want a decent contribution but do you expect something ridiculous like half his wages. Tbf you should be able to support your children alone, I would never had had children unless I could support them independently. Relying on a man is almost pointless

IncomingTraffic · 24/06/2023 22:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

That is an amazingly misogynistic view.

Good job I can support my children. And do.

Does that transfer to the other women on this thread? Are they to blame because their exes don’t pay anything at all?

IncomingTraffic · 24/06/2023 22:48

Makemyday99 · 24/06/2023 22:39

What is it that you want then? Separated parents need to understand that the parent leaving the home has to support themselves also

Maybe my ex could have fewer nights out, not constantly eat out, not go abroad several times a year, or on uk trips away.

He’s not on the breadline. He could actually pay a meaningful amount.

Last summer I had to borrow money from my mum to pay nursery fees and still eat. While he took his older kids on a 2 week 5* all inclusive holiday in august and gave no fucks about our DS.

Women end up with a hugely disproportionate share of the responsibility for children. That becomes more obvious when relationships break down.

But let’s all talk about how terrible it is for men.

Makemyday99 · 24/06/2023 22:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

IncomingTraffic · 24/06/2023 22:42

taxpayer1 · 24/06/2023 22:36

Maybe you should take some responsibility to have even more children with a man that presumably behaved the same with his previous children.

I DO take responsibility. I actually raise and pay for my sons life.

But, hey, let’s have a race to the bottom and somehow blame the women regardless. It’s our fault that so many men are useless. And it’s socially acceptable for them to be.

Makemyday99 · 24/06/2023 22:39

What is it that you want then? Separated parents need to understand that the parent leaving the home has to support themselves also

BibbleandSqwauk · 24/06/2023 22:39

💯 % agree that it's not a race to the bottom. I think it's more helpful to think in terms of percentage. Ex and I earn almost exactly the same. I sure as shit pay significantly more than 16% of my salary per month on their direct costs. Not mortgage, utilities etc which ex has too, but the food, clothes, trips, hobbies, pocket money, clothes, phones + contract etc. When they were younger it was childcare too (and no I didn't get UC help as I earn enough not to).

Apricotflanday · 24/06/2023 22:37

I get £15 a week from my ex for our DC, which I'm very happy with as his income is disability benefits and he also pays for extracurricular activities, clothes, half the air bnb I'm taking DC to stay in during the summer, plus he has DC when I work evenings, as well as Friday and Saturday nights 2 out of 3 weekends...plus he does loads of housework when he's at my place with DC!

I do think that if a man with a debilitating mental health condition can do all that, so could all those men with not only their health but incomes and perhaps even family support (we have none) could do a lot more. But then my ex is a very loving father and has a lot of moral integrity and a sense of what's important and right, as well. I feel lucky when I see how some men treat their exes and children.

taxpayer1 · 24/06/2023 22:36

IncomingTraffic · 24/06/2023 22:34

I don’t think it helps when people whose exes are even worse and pay zero make other women feel bad for not being grateful that their ex begrudgingly coughs up the absolute minimum the CMS calculator spits out.

It’s all part of the same problem.

Maybe you should take some responsibility to have even more children with a man that presumably behaved the same with his previous children.

IncomingTraffic · 24/06/2023 22:34

I don’t think it helps when people whose exes are even worse and pay zero make other women feel bad for not being grateful that their ex begrudgingly coughs up the absolute minimum the CMS calculator spits out.

It’s all part of the same problem.

IncomingTraffic · 24/06/2023 22:27

My STBXH pays the CMS minimum to the penny and believes himself to be amazing for doing so.

Thing is, it doesn’t cover even nearly half of the nursery fees (not having to look after a toddler means he can work just as much as it means I can), never mind feeding or housing or clothing our son. The man has never so much as bought DS a T-shirt. So he’s not amazing.

His contribution is pathetic, even if it’s far, far better than the beyond pathetic amounts other people get. And made more so because he then complains how unfair it is and how skint he is (because he’s got to pay maintenance to two mothers for three kids).

Once DS is in school, it will pan out that the to-the-penny CMS rate is a decent amount. Especially as he gets old enough that I don’t need childcare. But right now, it’s not a sensible contribution to the costs. A decent man would recognise that.

Then again, if he were a decent man, there likely wouldn’t be any need for child maintenance.

BOYBANDLOVER · 24/06/2023 22:15

considering i get zero and he doesn't buy anything for my son but expects visits, any one moaning about getting more should be bloody grateful they get anything.

ex and his new wife gets well over 8 thousand a month maybe more

she has 8 kids(all by different dads i want to point out, not one involved)
when they married(10 months ago) they took my exes surname and was legally adopted
ex has 2 with me so on paper he has 10 kids

there's 5 at home ages 11-18, she put up a 19 and 20 y old up for adoption so that makes 7(like i said all different dads),the youngest the 8th is 11 months, my exes so 8 kids by 8 different men

oldest 5 has a disability each and some multiple so are on high DLA each, my son gets this so i know how much it is
they get this x5

each DLA claim means disability element on UC per child, i get this as well so know how it works

2 adults are carers on carers allowance(hes down as a carer even though its not his DNA child) and gets a carers element on UC each so x2(as do i)

both adults get pip in their own right and the 17 and 18 y old claim carers for adults.
even though said child is disabled and gets high DLA
no idea why the system don't flag this up,
if your disabled enough to get high DLA and a adult needs to care for you how can you care for the same adult who disabled themselves enough to get high PIP, but that's how carers allowance work if you know how to play it

so thats
DLA high rate x5
PIP highest rate x2
CA x4
CE x2
UC for a couple over 25
UC child element x6(as children are disabled the cap is lifted)
CB x6
she also gets things for free off facebook and sells them on

as not one of these are eligible income legally i get zero.

he doesn't buy my son anything or give me anything privately, its all me
living of DLA,UC and CARERS ALLOWANCE as i cant work as son needs 24/7 care

my son, not me went very LC(NC for a while)as dads household is very chaotic and my son cant cope with visits and wont forgive him for walking out on him at 10 to then care-be a full time dad to 5 others

its not a co-parenting arrangement, my son is with me 24/7 its me being forced in to becoming a lone carer-parent overnight as dad left at 3am one night completely out of the blue for her and her kids and never came back

so when i read people moan they only get a few hundreds a month or he's not willing to pay this it gets my backup as there's many many of us that gets nothing

gogomoto · 24/06/2023 21:13

I'm fine with our voluntary agreement - far older, adult but has sn. I get £550 a month plus extra for specific reasons on request

Bumply · 24/06/2023 21:09

I was fortunate to earn more than my x.
Enough to live independently with our two boys.

He did see them every other weekend and pay maintenance to start with, but he saw them less and less and then stopped paying anything.

Thankfully I'd got through the most expensive nursery years by then and was doing well in my job, so apart from feeling sad that he'd turned into a deadbeat Dad that rarely saw them I didn't let it bother me.

If I'd struggled financially without his maintenance money that would have been different.

Parkandpicnic · 24/06/2023 21:06

Curtainpoles · 24/06/2023 21:02

I get just under £500 a month for two children (worked out by the CMS calculator, but done via private arrangement), I'm happy with it. We coparent very amicably, I have the kids full time and he sees them one or two days a week at my house which I am happy with as he doesn't have the space to have them. If there are extra costs eg school trips we go half (if it's a cheap trip costing a tenner I don't bother asking, but he'll happily split the bigger trips) and he's also happy to contribute to things like uniform expenses / music lessons / after school activities - I just ask and he pays no questions asked.
We sometimes take the kids on day trips or out for dinner together and will generally split those costs 50/50.
I'm the higher earner and not entitled to any benefits other than child benefit - half of which I have to pay back as earning too much.
I feel very lucky that we get along so well - we split up before we got really bitter about things. Neither of us are bad people, just not good together, and he appreciates the care I give the children and I appreciate him for what he brings to the children's lives and how easy-going he is about things.

That is so lovely, how you both still respect each other

Parkandpicnic · 24/06/2023 21:02

ColonelBrandonsPiano · 24/06/2023 20:13

I get a good amount of maintenance but it’s nothing like the standard of life my child would have if both parents are still together. The lifestyle of the paying parent is definitely a factor (as mentioned above) and children should have similar standards of living in both homes where possible.
If you wanted a certain standard of life for your child when you were together, really you should want to continue that as much as possible.
I work full time and I’m a higher rate tax payer but even with maintenance I can’t match the standard of living that my ex husband is able to provide. Holidays are only with him as our budget doesn’t stretch to it.

I didn’t expect my household (when I was single) to have the same standard of living as my ex as he earned more. He could take them for holidays abroad and I could take them on a caravan holiday. We were happy enough and I didn't have a problem with this. I’m now earning similar to what he was earning then and I certainly wouldn’t have been happy him taking a bigger than CMS chunk of my salary if the boot was on the other foot. Think the CMS rate is fair and have to be realistic that not going to afford the same standard of living as one household on a joint income

Curtainpoles · 24/06/2023 21:02

I get just under £500 a month for two children (worked out by the CMS calculator, but done via private arrangement), I'm happy with it. We coparent very amicably, I have the kids full time and he sees them one or two days a week at my house which I am happy with as he doesn't have the space to have them. If there are extra costs eg school trips we go half (if it's a cheap trip costing a tenner I don't bother asking, but he'll happily split the bigger trips) and he's also happy to contribute to things like uniform expenses / music lessons / after school activities - I just ask and he pays no questions asked.
We sometimes take the kids on day trips or out for dinner together and will generally split those costs 50/50.
I'm the higher earner and not entitled to any benefits other than child benefit - half of which I have to pay back as earning too much.
I feel very lucky that we get along so well - we split up before we got really bitter about things. Neither of us are bad people, just not good together, and he appreciates the care I give the children and I appreciate him for what he brings to the children's lives and how easy-going he is about things.

PriOn1 · 24/06/2023 20:57

Reasonably happy as it was a bit more than the required payment in the country where I live and was definitely enough to improve the standard of life we could afford… but I did point out, when the ex alluded to how generous he was being, that there’s a cap in this country and he would have had to pay a lot more in the UK because he earned so much.

Iamclearlyamug · 24/06/2023 20:39

I get 300 a month for DD11, we also pay half for uniform/activities/school trips.

We co-parent well and I'm happy with the amount

HappyasLarrynot · 24/06/2023 20:29

I’m not happy with what I get (50/week total for 3 teenagers) but my ex has always tried to get out of paying so something is better than nothing and the kids know how it works.
My DH’s ex should be happy with what she gets - very significantly more than she would be ‘entitled’ to if it went through CMS (and an amount that I’d be happy with for 3 kids not just 1) but she has regularly complained about it over the years.

HashBrownandBeans · 24/06/2023 20:19

I get nothing and that’s fine as we do a 55/45 split with our time.

ColonelBrandonsPiano · 24/06/2023 20:13

I get a good amount of maintenance but it’s nothing like the standard of life my child would have if both parents are still together. The lifestyle of the paying parent is definitely a factor (as mentioned above) and children should have similar standards of living in both homes where possible.
If you wanted a certain standard of life for your child when you were together, really you should want to continue that as much as possible.
I work full time and I’m a higher rate tax payer but even with maintenance I can’t match the standard of living that my ex husband is able to provide. Holidays are only with him as our budget doesn’t stretch to it.

Pasithean · 24/06/2023 20:03

Ilovemycar77 · 24/06/2023 18:58

I get £1.96 a week for my age 16 child and that only just started this week.
I left the T W A T when my child was 2 weeks old after catching him shagging another Woman in My car.
Apparently he hasn’t earnt anything for the last 15 years and has now only declared £368 yearly earnings which means CSA can award my child £1.96 a week.
So no, I am not satisfied. The CSA or CMS are not fit for purpose and neither are these lazy bar steward men who like to put their
d I c k s wherever they like without consequence!

you obviously let him 😳😳😳😳😳😳

Swipe left for the next trending thread