Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone satisfied with the amount of maintenance they receive?

113 replies

MaxwellCat · 24/06/2023 18:42

Just wondering as I see so many threads where people are unhappy with the amount of maintenance they get but Is anyone satisfied with the amount ? Or is everyone unhappy with the amount they get? As someone that gets absolutely zero and never has I am often shocked when people are getting hundreds but still think it isn’t enough (I’m talking £500+) I don’t think anyone should be grateful and of course every nrp should be paying for their kids but just wondering if anyone feels satisfied with the amount they get?

OP posts:
ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 25/06/2023 08:37

Beezknees · 25/06/2023 08:34

Taxpayer1 hates anyone who isn't a net contributer, or gets Universal Credit, or lives in housing association property, or asks for maintenance from their ex. I've seen them on other threads. Can you not tell by their username?

I hardly pay attention to usernames as my eyes immediately move past it and read their comments😅

Beezknees · 25/06/2023 08:36

I get £300 a month for one child. I'm actually happy with that. I'm not happy about the fact that he refuses to see DS but then acts like dad of the year because he pays maintenance. But hey ho.

Beezknees · 25/06/2023 08:34

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 25/06/2023 08:31

Fucking hell wtf is wrong with you? Disgusting comment my GOD

Taxpayer1 hates anyone who isn't a net contributer, or gets Universal Credit, or lives in housing association property, or asks for maintenance from their ex. I've seen them on other threads. Can you not tell by their username?

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 25/06/2023 08:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Fucking hell wtf is wrong with you? Disgusting comment my GOD

IncomingTraffic · 25/06/2023 08:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Wow, threads about child maintenance really bring out the MRA-sympathiser arguments, don’t they?

Pick a post that starts with a reminder that abuse starts in pregnancy and follow up with ‘there are two sides; you should be admitting how awful you are’.

Jesus wept.

taxpayer1 · 25/06/2023 07:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

IncomingTraffic · 25/06/2023 07:51

Makemyday99 · 24/06/2023 22:52

I understand that you want a decent contribution but do you expect something ridiculous like half his wages. Tbf you should be able to support your children alone, I would never had had children unless I could support them independently. Relying on a man is almost pointless

Why are you assuming I am aiming for half his wages? The CMS minimum is a long way from that.

The real question is: why should single mothers have to shoulder the financial, practical and emotional responsibilities of parenthood? Why shouldn’t their children enjoy the benefit of being properly financially supported by their fathers?

I DO support my son. If his father contributed in a meaningful way to the costs, then maybe some of my income could be used to take DS on holidays or we could have a car and go on better day trips - or many other things.

His father does earn more than me, but has plenty of money for buggering off to another city for a weekend whenever he fancies it. Maybe he should be contributing half of the £1300+ nursery fees, plus actually contributing to the 100% of the time I house and feed (and clothe) our child. Sure, he’d have less disposable income. But that’s the reality of parenthood. And it still wouldn’t be anything like half his income.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 25/06/2023 00:21

TokenGinger · 24/06/2023 23:19

Wow, this is really eye-opening to read.

I ask this question with absolutely no intended back-handed criticism, but did any of these men give any indication at all during the relationship that they had the capacity to be such dead beats? I hand on heart feel I could say, should DP and I ever separate, I know he'd always pay more than is necessary for our DC. But then I wonder how many of you could have said this about these men, who went on to prove otherwise? It's such a scary thought!

Firstly it should always be remembered that abuse often starts in pregnancy or shortly after. So people in that situation have no warning.

In my case my ex claims he was “trapped” by me. Never wanted children. Was devastated when it was twins. Apparently I should have known this according to him. I should have been aware and he’s baffled why I was so angry. He says he his best for as long as he could, but I made him snap one weekend when I was just “unbearably demanding”…

I mean, it might be the 17k he spent on us having fertility treatment that confused me. Or the fact that he once spent five solid hours researching which car seats were safest in his car, and at one point debated buying a different car. Maybe even the fact I came home from work one day and he’d taken a secret day of annual leave and had decorated our spare room into the most gorgeous nursery. I might be an idiot, but all of those things suggested to me he wanted to be a dad.

Everyone always thinks there must have been flags, but when he ended it while I was still in hospital after having my appendix out (that is had to stay an extra night was the aforementioned demanding) when they were 6 months old and then vowed to never pay a penny toward “your children” (his words) I was genuinely stunned.

Our girls are early 20s and I still find it incredible how he changed.

melj1213 · 25/06/2023 00:05

I don't get any child maintenance payments but it works for my circumstances with ExDH

ExDH and I share custody 50/50 and co-parent amicably so we have a very collaborative approach to parenting. DD spends alternating weeks with each of us and, since neither of us earns significantly more or less than the other, general day to day living costs balance out. We both buy DD clothes/books/toys and games etc that stay at our respective houses so again those costs balance out and are entirely relative to our own household budgets.

What we do instead is work out costs for DD outside of the basic household costs - extra curricular fees/uniform/equipment, school uniform, school lunch top ups, bus pass, trips, one off costs eg passport renewal etc - per year, split it 50/50, divide by 12 and then we each put an equal amount into an account for DD which we then use to pay for those joint costs. So, for example if we figured that the costs for DD was £2000 for the year then we'd take responsibility for £1000 each which is £83.33 a month so we'd just round up to put £100 each into the account every month so there's a little bit extra for a few treats, anything unexpected and/or to add to her savings account.

Then when DD needs something that is a joint cost we use the money from that account to fund it, if it's a recurring cost (eg DDs bus pass that is paid monthly) then we just set up a direct debit to take the money directly so neither of us have to do extra admin. This only works as we have a very open co-parenting relationship so we trust each other not to abuse the account and it saves us having to constantly negotiate 'I paid £40 for the school trip; you paid £30 for her dance class so you can pay the £15 for her new school jumper'

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 24/06/2023 23:41

Also @Makemyday99 let’s stop acting like these men are so obviously horrible men from the start and women are constantly ignoring red flags.

There are many situations where it’s been a happy marriage/relationship, been together for years with no issues of the dad contributing towards their children and the household. Once both parents split up, some men become SO bitter it’s ridiculous. They don’t care about impacting their child whilst trying to spite the other parents.

Do you have kids? If so, are you in similar situations to the rest of the women on this thread? I find your comments extremely tone deaf and almost insulting as if it’s women who have knowingly put themselves into this situation. Maybe you should focus your energy on the men who care so little as opposed to the women who are trying to do their absolute best to care for their children?

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 24/06/2023 23:38

This just made me realise, in Australia your earnings are what are in your tax return (which everyone has to do) so if a self employed man tried to hide it by funnelling it through dividends it would still show up. Not so much for those working cash in hand. And the ATO is making a concerted effort to catch anyone working cash in hand. (How successfully I have no idea). They even have an anonymous tip off form.

But what sucks is that your COMBINED income is used to determine child support.

So if I had 70% of care and my ex 30% but I earned and he didn't, I would have to pay him money.

I have 100% care so doesn't affect me that way, but he still get notified of my earnings every year. Which. I. Despise!

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 24/06/2023 23:37

Makemyday99 · 24/06/2023 22:52

I understand that you want a decent contribution but do you expect something ridiculous like half his wages. Tbf you should be able to support your children alone, I would never had had children unless I could support them independently. Relying on a man is almost pointless

You are hugely missing the point here. It’s not about relying on a man and not being able to take care of your child independently. It’s about the fact that such a massive percentage of men pay little to nothing towards their children.

It doesn’t matter if I’m a millionaire. Their dad should still contribute towards them and not spend so much money elsewhere and only give pennies towards their child

LacieLane · 24/06/2023 23:28

TokenGinger · 24/06/2023 23:19

Wow, this is really eye-opening to read.

I ask this question with absolutely no intended back-handed criticism, but did any of these men give any indication at all during the relationship that they had the capacity to be such dead beats? I hand on heart feel I could say, should DP and I ever separate, I know he'd always pay more than is necessary for our DC. But then I wonder how many of you could have said this about these men, who went on to prove otherwise? It's such a scary thought!

No, no indication at all. Professional man, we married late 20’s, so no ‘young and daft’ excuses even.

With two under three, he felt ‘left out’, couldn't share or compromise, carried on with his social life. Becam quite controlling, didn't like that I was more educated than him, that I had an opinion.

He had an affair and left, saying ‘family life is not for me’.

Tough eh...what if family life wasn't for me either....i did tongue in cheek say that to him and ask him if we should just sell the kids!

HRTQueen · 24/06/2023 23:27

Yes

I know I’m in a much better position than many (my dad paid nothing). I don’t feel I or ds should be grateful for the ex being a responsible dad but that shows how low the bar is

newjobnewstartihope · 24/06/2023 23:27

TokenGinger · 24/06/2023 23:19

Wow, this is really eye-opening to read.

I ask this question with absolutely no intended back-handed criticism, but did any of these men give any indication at all during the relationship that they had the capacity to be such dead beats? I hand on heart feel I could say, should DP and I ever separate, I know he'd always pay more than is necessary for our DC. But then I wonder how many of you could have said this about these men, who went on to prove otherwise? It's such a scary thought!

The amount of devoted responsible fathers I know of who have refused to pay maintenance or said they can't afford it is unbelievable
They really believe they are doing it so their ex doesn't benefit from 'their' money however as always it's the kids who miss out

saltandpepper86 · 24/06/2023 23:26

I am I get much more than I expected. I waited a few years to go through cms and turns out he had a big pay rise since we divorced.

newjobnewstartihope · 24/06/2023 23:24

@Makemyday99 could you display your male privilege any more ostentatiously?

TokenGinger · 24/06/2023 23:19

Wow, this is really eye-opening to read.

I ask this question with absolutely no intended back-handed criticism, but did any of these men give any indication at all during the relationship that they had the capacity to be such dead beats? I hand on heart feel I could say, should DP and I ever separate, I know he'd always pay more than is necessary for our DC. But then I wonder how many of you could have said this about these men, who went on to prove otherwise? It's such a scary thought!

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 24/06/2023 23:18

BOYBANDLOVER · 24/06/2023 22:15

considering i get zero and he doesn't buy anything for my son but expects visits, any one moaning about getting more should be bloody grateful they get anything.

ex and his new wife gets well over 8 thousand a month maybe more

she has 8 kids(all by different dads i want to point out, not one involved)
when they married(10 months ago) they took my exes surname and was legally adopted
ex has 2 with me so on paper he has 10 kids

there's 5 at home ages 11-18, she put up a 19 and 20 y old up for adoption so that makes 7(like i said all different dads),the youngest the 8th is 11 months, my exes so 8 kids by 8 different men

oldest 5 has a disability each and some multiple so are on high DLA each, my son gets this so i know how much it is
they get this x5

each DLA claim means disability element on UC per child, i get this as well so know how it works

2 adults are carers on carers allowance(hes down as a carer even though its not his DNA child) and gets a carers element on UC each so x2(as do i)

both adults get pip in their own right and the 17 and 18 y old claim carers for adults.
even though said child is disabled and gets high DLA
no idea why the system don't flag this up,
if your disabled enough to get high DLA and a adult needs to care for you how can you care for the same adult who disabled themselves enough to get high PIP, but that's how carers allowance work if you know how to play it

so thats
DLA high rate x5
PIP highest rate x2
CA x4
CE x2
UC for a couple over 25
UC child element x6(as children are disabled the cap is lifted)
CB x6
she also gets things for free off facebook and sells them on

as not one of these are eligible income legally i get zero.

he doesn't buy my son anything or give me anything privately, its all me
living of DLA,UC and CARERS ALLOWANCE as i cant work as son needs 24/7 care

my son, not me went very LC(NC for a while)as dads household is very chaotic and my son cant cope with visits and wont forgive him for walking out on him at 10 to then care-be a full time dad to 5 others

its not a co-parenting arrangement, my son is with me 24/7 its me being forced in to becoming a lone carer-parent overnight as dad left at 3am one night completely out of the blue for her and her kids and never came back

so when i read people moan they only get a few hundreds a month or he's not willing to pay this it gets my backup as there's many many of us that gets nothing

I completely understand what you’re saying but just because people like us get absolutely nothing, it doesn’t mean that people who think they’re entitled to more, shouldn’t complain about not getting enough.

My friend gets £100 a month for one child. She’s not happy as he’s self employed and has figured out ways to shift money around. We could say, ‘well at least you get £100 more than us’ but that’s not necessarily fair to say. Each case is different but I do understand your frustration. I have two kids, youngest with a rare genetic disorder and higher needs and get absolutely nothing from their dad

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 24/06/2023 23:15

I get nothing, and oddly quite happy with that. I've made it clear to both my DC that I solely fund our life and all of their extra curricular activities. What that really means about their father not paying for anything hasn't really registered with them yet as they're only teens, but when they are adults hopefully it will, and they'll see their father for the selfish arse he is.

The only time I've made a big point of it is when their father (and his very rich mother who is funding his life) asked them when they were flying to see him, with the full expectation that I would pay for their flights. I gave him a piece of my mind (and he's never made that suggestion again) and explained to my DSs that as I was paying for EVERYTHING there was no way I could also pay for their flights, and it was up to their father to fund it.

LacieLane · 24/06/2023 23:06

Nope! The amount my ex pays, through CMS is less than the cost of the DC’s school dinners....

He can claim and keep more money for his partners one child who lives with them ( 50%) than he pays towards his own two DC’s. Madness, the ‘step-child’ also has a dad earning £100,000 who he stays with. I can't fathom it.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 24/06/2023 23:04

CMS is shit though. I worked there for a very short time. They are not fit for purpose at all.

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 24/06/2023 23:03

To the poster who said they get £800 for two kids, I thought WOW that is amazing.

Then a poster said they get £1800 for two kids. My GOD that is just something else.

I have 2 kids and I get £0 because he apparently doesn’t have a job. Doesn’t claim UC either so I can’t even get £30 a month. Fucking bullshit really. Doesn’t answer your question ofc OP but I’m happy that so many people are actually happy with the amount that they receive

Mummysgonetobed · 24/06/2023 23:02

I am satisfied. £650 for 3 children who stay with dad 2 nights per week. He’ll also contribute for trips, uniform, after school stuff and any thing else I ask basically.
I can’t stand the man personally but he’s come through financially for the dc.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 24/06/2023 22:58

I’m satisfied with what I get - my girls are actually at Uni now but he’s still paying off his debt.

The military got involved so he had to pay what CMS said, pay his arrears (tiny bit at a time but eventually it’ll be paid off) and his bosses realised he wasn’t the lovely doting dad he portrayed himself as.

He begrudges every single penny of it. Even once deducted the cost of a packet of crisps from the following month when he bought them crisps when i wasn’t in when he returned them early and wasn’t expecting to have to give them lunch. That he’s been forced to pay despite trying desperately to avoid is the main satisfaction for me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread