Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone satisfied with the amount of maintenance they receive?

113 replies

MaxwellCat · 24/06/2023 18:42

Just wondering as I see so many threads where people are unhappy with the amount of maintenance they get but Is anyone satisfied with the amount ? Or is everyone unhappy with the amount they get? As someone that gets absolutely zero and never has I am often shocked when people are getting hundreds but still think it isn’t enough (I’m talking £500+) I don’t think anyone should be grateful and of course every nrp should be paying for their kids but just wondering if anyone feels satisfied with the amount they get?

OP posts:
IncomingTraffic · 25/06/2023 11:25

I think by the time it’s supporting a child through university, it’s about the obvious fact (to that young adult child) that only one parent is doing the supporting. Maybe it’s a good thing that they realise their father doesn’t contribute at that point.

The concept of child maintenance is a bit of a red herring there.

x2boys · 25/06/2023 11:23

BibbleandSqwauk · 25/06/2023 11:19

@x2boys but realistically most 18yo uni students do get help from their parents and stay in their home for the 22 weeks a year they're not in term time. Why should that fall solely to one of the two parents? Worse, when the RP has remarried, the step parents income is counted when the student is assessed for any grants etc, so they are expected to contribute but the nrp is not.

They are adults and as such should work part time its their choice to go to.uni.

BibbleandSqwauk · 25/06/2023 11:19

@x2boys but realistically most 18yo uni students do get help from their parents and stay in their home for the 22 weeks a year they're not in term time. Why should that fall solely to one of the two parents? Worse, when the RP has remarried, the step parents income is counted when the student is assessed for any grants etc, so they are expected to contribute but the nrp is not.

x2boys · 25/06/2023 10:10

LacieLane · 25/06/2023 09:48

And wait until the uni year's. Zilch!

My ex, more than happy, for my DP support me with my DC’s costs, flat deposits, drive them to and from, food during the drop off weekends, etc.
DC’s worked too, good for them in their independence.

Then ExDH demands tickets for the graduation, family photos....

But its your adults child,s choice to.go.to.uni ,why would you get maintenance for an adult ?
My sisters son is at uni he survivor off loans and part time work like most students
My sister sends him. ten pound a week for food and his Dad sends him 15 (they are divorced )

funinthesun19 · 25/06/2023 10:02

I receive £0.00 for 4 children.

I have to provide an over night bag with clothes etc if they stay over with him.
Has them only occasionally and never all at once.

I have to provide clothes etc for his holiday he’s taking them on.

If he buys some food etc, he asks for the money back.

Absolute waste of space.

Holly03 · 25/06/2023 09:54

For my ds I get 14.00 a month and covers nothing really but to be honest he never has in all these years so these payments have just started. My dd dad pays 160.00 a month and he complains about it, I never have. As it does help to contribute to her costs of buying new clothes, shoes and nursery etc. one month it paid for her new bed which I’m glad I can afford(used to be 200.00). The only time I’ve complained about it is when he has been abusive over it. Both children’s dads have nothing to do so are never mentioned and my son sees his money as extra pocket money for a game or towards a Lego set etc. both through the csa but dd dad pays into the bank and im actually glad he is reliable and pays every month on the same day, less chew as I know it will always be there on that day so I can budget for the things she needs. My sons dads is through the csa and is deducted so unreliable. I feel sorry for those who get nothing as even that little bit helps to budget

Makemyday99 · 25/06/2023 09:49

amiold · 25/06/2023 09:31

How does child know he had to have the money deducted though?

Mum told him, probably told him his Dad was a deadbeat who didn’t live him & refused to provide for him

LacieLane · 25/06/2023 09:48

And wait until the uni year's. Zilch!

My ex, more than happy, for my DP support me with my DC’s costs, flat deposits, drive them to and from, food during the drop off weekends, etc.
DC’s worked too, good for them in their independence.

Then ExDH demands tickets for the graduation, family photos....

Makemyday99 · 25/06/2023 09:46

newjobnewstartihope · 24/06/2023 23:24

@Makemyday99 could you display your male privilege any more ostentatiously?

I’m not male

amiold · 25/06/2023 09:31

caringcarer · 25/06/2023 09:16

I used to get £580 per month for 1 dc. This was 10 years ago. I was happy with the amount but unhappy it had to be ordered from his salary by CMS and he didn't want to provide for his DS. It impacted the relationship he had with his teen son who felt his Dad no longer loved him as he didn't want to provide for him. He rarely sees his Dad now, maybe twice a year.

How does child know he had to have the money deducted though?

x2boys · 25/06/2023 09:23

BOYBANDLOVER · 24/06/2023 22:15

considering i get zero and he doesn't buy anything for my son but expects visits, any one moaning about getting more should be bloody grateful they get anything.

ex and his new wife gets well over 8 thousand a month maybe more

she has 8 kids(all by different dads i want to point out, not one involved)
when they married(10 months ago) they took my exes surname and was legally adopted
ex has 2 with me so on paper he has 10 kids

there's 5 at home ages 11-18, she put up a 19 and 20 y old up for adoption so that makes 7(like i said all different dads),the youngest the 8th is 11 months, my exes so 8 kids by 8 different men

oldest 5 has a disability each and some multiple so are on high DLA each, my son gets this so i know how much it is
they get this x5

each DLA claim means disability element on UC per child, i get this as well so know how it works

2 adults are carers on carers allowance(hes down as a carer even though its not his DNA child) and gets a carers element on UC each so x2(as do i)

both adults get pip in their own right and the 17 and 18 y old claim carers for adults.
even though said child is disabled and gets high DLA
no idea why the system don't flag this up,
if your disabled enough to get high DLA and a adult needs to care for you how can you care for the same adult who disabled themselves enough to get high PIP, but that's how carers allowance work if you know how to play it

so thats
DLA high rate x5
PIP highest rate x2
CA x4
CE x2
UC for a couple over 25
UC child element x6(as children are disabled the cap is lifted)
CB x6
she also gets things for free off facebook and sells them on

as not one of these are eligible income legally i get zero.

he doesn't buy my son anything or give me anything privately, its all me
living of DLA,UC and CARERS ALLOWANCE as i cant work as son needs 24/7 care

my son, not me went very LC(NC for a while)as dads household is very chaotic and my son cant cope with visits and wont forgive him for walking out on him at 10 to then care-be a full time dad to 5 others

its not a co-parenting arrangement, my son is with me 24/7 its me being forced in to becoming a lone carer-parent overnight as dad left at 3am one night completely out of the blue for her and her kids and never came back

so when i read people moan they only get a few hundreds a month or he's not willing to pay this it gets my backup as there's many many of us that gets nothing

The DLA your ex,s wife receive,s is For HER disabled children its not their money its the CHILDRENS money !

caringcarer · 25/06/2023 09:16

I used to get £580 per month for 1 dc. This was 10 years ago. I was happy with the amount but unhappy it had to be ordered from his salary by CMS and he didn't want to provide for his DS. It impacted the relationship he had with his teen son who felt his Dad no longer loved him as he didn't want to provide for him. He rarely sees his Dad now, maybe twice a year.

BibbleandSqwauk · 25/06/2023 09:14

I've crossed keyboards with @taxpayer1 on many of these threads. No matter how many factual, objective details a poster gives about how their ex planned and wanted their kids such as the pp above who's ex paid for IVF etc he always tries to argue for a non existant alternative narrative. He cannot bear the idea that there actually ARE single mothers who do actually do all they say, work full time, give the lions share of their salary to support their kids with or without state help and have deadbeat exes. He's an apologist of the highest order.

In the end it's actually irrelevant - even if the child was an accidental pregnancy, even if the resident parent is a millionaire, the NRP should STILL pay and if necessary, use the freedom their NRP status gives them to work longer, more, harder jobs to adequately pay 50% of the child's costs. Not blood, not 50% of their salary, but 50% of costs (minus the % of time they spend with them, which is a pretty minimal 4 days a month in many cases). Back of the envelope figures tells me that I spend at least a third of my income (after mortgage, utlities etc) directly on my two children - so clothes, hobbies, food - teens now so they eat a lot, phone contracts (not expensive, hand me down handsets but still about £40 p/m for both together), laptops for school, allowance, school trips, uniforms and kit. I only receive CB, no other benefit. So lets say its a third, though its probably more, that's 33%. CMS is about 18%. So almost half. The actual FIGURE is irrelevant and leads to race the bottom conversations. If my ex paid 33% of his salary to his kids, it would almost double his contribution to a more comparable amount. We earn about the same so impact of paying that on him would be no different than it is on me.

UndercoverCop · 25/06/2023 09:11

I think sometimes it's not just the actual amount but the attitude that accompanies it.
So if someone pays the bare minimum according to CMS and will never chip in for unexpected extras, asks for the £5 back they spent on their contact day to buy a new t-shirt from Primark etc, or they hide their true income by being self employed and paying themselves a paltry salary and skimming more money elsewhere in cash.
DH and I haven't separated but I would be furious at any man deliberately trying to avoid genuinely supporting their own child to the best of their abilities.
If someone would full time but in a low paid job you will get less in maintenance as you would household income if you stayed together, but they're working hard and paying what they can. It's often those who earn more that are deceitful about it to short-change their children.

AnneElliott · 25/06/2023 09:04

I agrée with you @J0S. I'm not a single parent so no skin in the game here but I really can't believe we let dads Sean off and not pay for their kids! Or pay the bare minimum!

And yes people would judge a mum that didn't feed her kids but somehow it's ok for a bloke to give up his job and not pay for them at all? How many kids could we lift out of poverty if we actually made fathers financially responsible for their children?

I have 2 friends who are single mums so see how hard it is for them financially. I do wonder how the dads family can be happy with their behaviour- I'd be devastated if DS behaved like that and would definitely think I'd not brought him up right if he shirked his financial responsibilities.

LacieLane · 25/06/2023 09:01

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 24/06/2023 23:37

You are hugely missing the point here. It’s not about relying on a man and not being able to take care of your child independently. It’s about the fact that such a massive percentage of men pay little to nothing towards their children.

It doesn’t matter if I’m a millionaire. Their dad should still contribute towards them and not spend so much money elsewhere and only give pennies towards their child

I'm with you @ItsBritneyBitchhhh. And I would add, the tax payer having to pick up the tab.
Even though I was the one having to claim because my earnings were so much less than his (part time decided when I was with him) and even though I was so grateful in the support to get myself back on my feet and extend my hours back to full time, I was furious that my ExDH could walk away from his commitment to his DC’s and, even though he was financially stable, the tax payer would support me for his share.

I'm all for public services, support for those in need, but this was ridiculous. We had more money coming in as a separated couple than when we were together.
ExDH was delighted, his skiing holidays could go ahead!

Gettingbysomehow · 25/06/2023 08:56

I received nothing for the the whole of DS childhood and the CMS pathetically did nothing about it. He just led them on a merry dance.

IncomingTraffic · 25/06/2023 08:54

They think that the Public purse should pay for the kids that they made so they don’t have to.

Ironically, while calling themselves things like ‘taxpayer’. 🤣

umpeitpp · 25/06/2023 08:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

@YetMoreNewBeginnings so sorry to read this. I had a similar experience. Ex said he would be ‘over the moon if I said I was pregnant with his baby’ and that he was ‘desperate to be a dad’, it was ‘what he wanted most in life.’

He then became utterly vile as my pregnancy progressed.

Sadly for @taxpayer1 I don’t fit their narrative. Ex is a very higher earner. I out earn him still and look after our child with no assistance from him. Because he’s a lowlife and I am not.

IncomingTraffic · 25/06/2023 08:51

8% of his salary after tax that is.

umpeitpp · 25/06/2023 08:50

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 25/06/2023 08:31

Fucking hell wtf is wrong with you? Disgusting comment my GOD

@taxpayer1 there are always two sides, yes. We are not story telling here, though. Just saying men need to be accountable for half the costs of raising their child. As you can see from the thread, in time the net will close on lowlifes who don’t pay for their children. Things are changing.

umpeitpp · 25/06/2023 08:48

IncomingTraffic · 25/06/2023 08:46

It’s also hilarious - ‘what do you want? Half his salary. Blood?

8% of his salary is a long, long way from half.

Yes @Makemyday99 - how about they just pay their share, which is 50% of costs?

J0S · 25/06/2023 08:48

Some posters use deliberately misleading user names . Like MandyMumof3 when in fact they are a 35 single bloke living in their mums basement.

or HardworkingFather when they are an unemployed loser who pays nothing for their kids and spends their time on MN attacking divorced mums who who expect their kids father to support his own children.

Some people can’t understand that many single mums work hard full time AND that men still need to pay child support .

That it’s based on the non resident parent’s income NOT the resident parent’s .

They can’t understand that raising children and paying for childcare costs money.

They can’t understand that children cost more than the food they put in their mouths.

They think that the Public purse should pay for the kids that they made so they don’t have to.

I tend to take no notice of stupid, lazy and feckless people like that .

IncomingTraffic · 25/06/2023 08:46

It’s also hilarious - ‘what do you want? Half his salary. Blood?

8% of his salary is a long, long way from half.

umpeitpp · 25/06/2023 08:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

@Makemyday99 @IncomingTraffic this is genuinely hilarious. ‘Stop having them with useless men’ 😂

Not sure how educated you are @Makemyday99 or whether you have much life experience but you sound very naive to think men expose themselves as being useless and indeed are always useless prior to having a child. Have another think about it.