Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Loveless marriage VS commitment to family

210 replies

hoven · 24/06/2023 11:21

AIBU to suggest that committing to stay in a marriage for your children is more important to show your children than showing them an 'example of a happy relationship'?

In marriages without abuse or toxicity of course

OP posts:
Sparklesocks · 24/06/2023 13:40

As always making blanket statements like this never helps anyone, every situation is different and life is rarely black and white.
But so many MN posters seem to struggle with nuance.

hoven · 24/06/2023 13:37

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 24/06/2023 13:35

I'm interested to know why step or blended families aren't an option? If you're sure that this is the case I can see how you'd worry about being lonely and not having a companion

Majority of child murders are in blended families. And personally I would never do that to my child for a number of reasons.

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 24/06/2023 13:36

Tbh I think lots of women stay in marriages they don't feel are right. Hit menopause/retirement and think life it too short and the husbands feel blind sided

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/06/2023 13:36

hoven · 24/06/2023 13:08

I think you are more likely to live a mediocre life a divorcee

Also this is worth unpacking: it's by no means true that you will live a mediocre life after divorce. It depends on your financial position. If you work and have some money of your own there's every reason to think you will be in a much stronger position post divorce.

These days women tend to get reasonable settlements in divorces so unless you haven't worked at all or, God forbid, you haven't worked and aren't married, that doesn't reflect reality.

I know many women for whom divorce has been a new lease of life and the start of an exciting new chapter. Yes it's pretty unpleasant when its actually going on but as long as you've been reasonable sensible before and during the marriage about protection yourself it shouldn't be worse once it's finished.

hoven · 24/06/2023 13:36

cestlavielife · 24/06/2023 13:25

Step families are not an option for me.

Butcwhat about your dh?
He gets to decide his life too
What does your dh say sbout this?
Has he agreeed never to get involved with anyone else?

He won't divorce

OP posts:
Unexpectedlysinglemum · 24/06/2023 13:35

I'm interested to know why step or blended families aren't an option? If you're sure that this is the case I can see how you'd worry about being lonely and not having a companion

hoven · 24/06/2023 13:34

Nicecow · 24/06/2023 13:31

Besides the point, but who says "divorcee" anynore? Are you 100?

I am 100. Please don't be ageist

OP posts:
Unexpectedlysinglemum · 24/06/2023 13:34

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/06/2023 13:16

@hoven My ex and I separated when my DD was four (and divorced three years later). She is 12 now and is happy and well adjusted. I now have a great relationship with my ex and he and my current partner are friendly. We socialise together.

My DD is absolutely fine with this and is happy that her parents are friends (which we would certainly not have been if we had stayed married) and that her father and stepfather are on cordial terms.

It was difficult for a couple of years but I am absolutely certain that separating was the best outcome. We were unhappily married but are now good friends now the baggage of trying to force ourselves to align where we didn’t align has been removed. We have found people with whom we are better suited and it’s generally a more relaxed and happier environment for everyone.

I struggle to see how toughing out a miserable marriage in the face of deepening rifts and becoming angrier and more unhappy would have been preferable to what we have now.

I loved really this is helps me feel a lot more positive about splitting from my baby's father

hoven · 24/06/2023 13:32

@Nicecow I wouldn't want them to reach for the stars at the detriment of their children.

OP posts:
Landndialamrhf · 24/06/2023 13:32

I dunno, what do you think you’re showing them? Better to martyr yourself to an unhappy marriage and better to stick with a safe easy option than risk anything by getting a divorce?
marriages aren’t about love and You don’t or shouldn’t need love or care?
it’s ok to pretend you’re doing the right and good thing by sacrificing your happiness to stay in your marriage, without actually having to do any hard work to fix your marriage?

i don’t think you should divorce at the drop of a hat, you’ve committed to that person. But I also don’t think just settling into a loveless marriage shows any sort of commitment. You’re not following your marriage vows either way.

Nicecow · 24/06/2023 13:31

Besides the point, but who says "divorcee" anynore? Are you 100?

Nicecow · 24/06/2023 13:29

hoven · 24/06/2023 13:08

I think you are more likely to live a mediocre life a divorcee

I think you missed my point. You're basically teaching your children to settle. I want my children to reach for the stars, be brave, take risks and go for what they want in life. Not to settle for average, unless that's something they want of course. I want my children to be happy and live their best lives. What you're describing sounds no where close.

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/06/2023 13:27

@hoven

Step families are not an option for me.

Thats fine and I agree creating step families needs to be handled with extreme caution and respect. There’s huge potential to hurt children if this is not handled sensitively.

But that’s different from saying everyone who ever gets married should always stay together unless there’s abuse just because. That’s a very blunt instrument indeed which fails to reflect the reality of people’s lives.

It’s perfectly possible to separate in a healthy way and in many cases it’s in everyone’s best interests.

cestlavielife · 24/06/2023 13:25

Step families are not an option for me.

Butcwhat about your dh?
He gets to decide his life too
What does your dh say sbout this?
Has he agreeed never to get involved with anyone else?

cestlavielife · 24/06/2023 13:23

You mean sub suming your feelings?

Is ypur dh on the same page?

Have you sat down and agreed to stay in ssme house as friends?
You both equally care for house and dc?
You agree on whether you can date etc? And how?
If you both agree to the rules and decide maybe

If it s you seething underneath
Whike you maintain house for your dh and dc like a domestic servant
Then no

The dc will grow up
What then?

UndercoverCop · 24/06/2023 13:21

My friend's parents divorced when she was at university, she was blindsided. They seemed to get on really well weren't physically very demonstrative but there were never any rows or tensions she'd been aware of.
All came out eventually they'd agreed to stay together for her sake until she was grown. They made this agreement when they moved house just before she started secondary school. So whilst it had no negative impact on her childhood, as a young adult she was devastated firstly by the shock and then eventually finding out her parents had essentially lied to her for a decade.
I understand it more with elderly people, they get along, they've got a routine, they've reached an age where physical intimacy might not be in the cards anyway. They enjoy their home, joint friends, lifestyle, having the grandchildren to visit etc. So long as they genuinely do get on platonically

hoven · 24/06/2023 13:18

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/06/2023 13:16

@hoven My ex and I separated when my DD was four (and divorced three years later). She is 12 now and is happy and well adjusted. I now have a great relationship with my ex and he and my current partner are friendly. We socialise together.

My DD is absolutely fine with this and is happy that her parents are friends (which we would certainly not have been if we had stayed married) and that her father and stepfather are on cordial terms.

It was difficult for a couple of years but I am absolutely certain that separating was the best outcome. We were unhappily married but are now good friends now the baggage of trying to force ourselves to align where we didn’t align has been removed. We have found people with whom we are better suited and it’s generally a more relaxed and happier environment for everyone.

I struggle to see how toughing out a miserable marriage in the face of deepening rifts and becoming angrier and more unhappy would have been preferable to what we have now.

Step families are not an option for me.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 24/06/2023 13:16

@hoven My ex and I separated when my DD was four (and divorced three years later). She is 12 now and is happy and well adjusted. I now have a great relationship with my ex and he and my current partner are friendly. We socialise together.

My DD is absolutely fine with this and is happy that her parents are friends (which we would certainly not have been if we had stayed married) and that her father and stepfather are on cordial terms.

It was difficult for a couple of years but I am absolutely certain that separating was the best outcome. We were unhappily married but are now good friends now the baggage of trying to force ourselves to align where we didn’t align has been removed. We have found people with whom we are better suited and it’s generally a more relaxed and happier environment for everyone.

I struggle to see how toughing out a miserable marriage in the face of deepening rifts and becoming angrier and more unhappy would have been preferable to what we have now.

hoven · 24/06/2023 13:08

I think you are more likely to live a mediocre life a divorcee

OP posts:
Nicecow · 24/06/2023 13:07

Disagree. If your children know, then you're basically setting them up to accept a mediocre life. Why would you want that for your children?

ArcticSkewer · 24/06/2023 13:07

I'm more conceptually into the idea of cycles of life, so a partner for a stage of life not a life partner. Of course, that partner can also suit different cycles of life, but if they don't then that's fine too.

So that's what I would want to model.

I do see childrearing as a stage but not through to adulthood, just the younger stages. And if things don't work out, so be it

Outofthemoonlight · 24/06/2023 13:04

When my children were 8-10 years old I seriously considered divorce. For all the reasons posters will come up with I decided to stick it out.

No - don't. The fallout can be devastating. Twenty years later I so wish I'd have had the courage to walk.

hoven · 24/06/2023 13:02

SilverPeacock · 24/06/2023 13:00

As a product of this kind of situation I disagree. Both of my parents were much happier when they did eventually separate when I was an adult. I wish they had done it much earlier. There was no abuse or even arguments and they were civil to each other generally, but palpable sadness and loneliness. Not a happy house, with me and sibling going wtf?

Do you think it would have been the same happiness if you were a child?

OP posts:
Curseofthenation · 24/06/2023 13:02

I would do exactly what @Hankunamatata's friend did if my marriage was functional but loveless. Fortunately I'm in a very happy marriage and hopefully it never comes to that. If it did though, I'd rather keep my family under one roof and seek happiness in other ways and then divorce when my children are adults.

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/06/2023 13:00

hoven · 24/06/2023 12:46

And who is to say that happiness will be found after a divorce. There is a good chance you may be happier keeping your children together in your home and not uprooting them rather than divorcing, potentially moving into a smaller home away from what they know.

Of course unless there is abuse or a toxic relationship

It’s not a guarantee and obviously divorce is stressful and sometimes traumatic. No one should be under any illusion about that and it should be last resort.

But when a relationship is sufficiently toxic that people can’t bear to spend time with one another or talk to one another and have no affection or shared values it can’t enhance their lives to remain together in a legal and economic unit. And it’s a terrible example to set children. It basically tells them their happiness and self fulfilment will always come second to the needs of two people who hate one another because of an arbitrary legal construct.

Divorce is abrupt, short term pain and if handled badly can be awful for children. But if handled correctly it allows all concerned to reframe and reset their lives in a way which ultimately allows them to thrive.

Plodding along in teeth-clenching misery just to follow the rules is never going to be better than that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread