Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Loveless marriage VS commitment to family

210 replies

hoven · 24/06/2023 11:21

AIBU to suggest that committing to stay in a marriage for your children is more important to show your children than showing them an 'example of a happy relationship'?

In marriages without abuse or toxicity of course

OP posts:
ProfessorXtra · 24/06/2023 14:54

hoven · 24/06/2023 14:34

I think once you choose to have children yes you 100% have a commitment to them. Unless you think it's best to put your children in care to do anything you want to become "happy"

That commitment doesn't I clue staying in an unhappy marriage.

You are missing one huge problem- kids growing up in households where the parents are happy, know their parents aren't happy. That is toxicity all on its own. Often children in these households believe the 'staying for the children' line and it causes them guilt. The parents in the house start to resent each other, it's an awful atmosphere. An unhappy marriage is, more often than not, a toxic situation for kids to be in.

The whole 'staying together for the kids' is a lie people tell themselves. Happy kids don't grow up saying 'yeah my parents clearly were unhappy but we got to live in a huge house, that's what's important'. People who say this are staying for themselves because they choose to. But the 'staying for the kids' is a way to put a spin on it, appear selfless and victimise themselves. Its a choice to stay. And this choice is made for the adult, by the adult. Just the same as choosing divorce.

I don't think divorce is the ideal. And I don't believe anyone, especially with kids picks it lightly. And yes if patents can separate in a health way and live under the same roof, I think that's great. However it rarely works out like that. There's need to be clear responsibilities and both parties have to be completely on board.

When a relationship has got to the point you are considering divorce you are picking the lesser of 2 evils. Staying for will impact the kids. So will leaving.

I divorced. Moved to a smaller home. My eldest is an adult, well adjusted and happy. When we talk about divorce and marriage she believes me and her dad made the right choice. We aren't beasties. We are civil and work together if we need to for the kids.

My youngest is doing well at high school. Does well academically. Gets great reports on his behaviour, has friend and hobbies and is currently in the garden doing some pruning.

I am in no doubt that 2 separate happier households is better for my kids. The biggest problem with Divorce is when the adults put their needs, resentment, emotional lashing out in front of their children's well being. Which is the same as many couples who choose to 'stay together for the kids' do as well.

jfshu · 24/06/2023 14:53

(By most people I mean those seeking relationships and marriage, I appreciate there are lots of people not looking for that!)

jfshu · 24/06/2023 14:53

loveless marriage does not equal an unhappy life. The same way zero marriage does not equal happiness

I'm sure if we were to survey those in loveless marriages the large majority would be unhappy. Marriage isn't the emotionless, transactional tool required for having children that you're making it out to be. As well as having children, most people are seeking companionship; friendship, sex, emotional support, someone to share your life with, being stuck with someone who does not give you those things and not being able to seek them elsewhere would leave most miserable and resentful.

QueenVerilas · 24/06/2023 14:49

The only reason to stay is if leaving would be so disastrous financially and practically that you decide it’s staying is the least worst of two pretty shit options. If you can afford to leave, then go. It’s no life for any of you to stay.

Forevermermaid · 24/06/2023 14:46

That your children mean more to you then fleeting feelings. And that you chose to have children and get married so you won't put them at a detriment because you've changed your mind

Great.

Fancy letting my STB-EXH who this? You can let the OW know at the same time Wink

hoven · 24/06/2023 14:43

@jfshu a loveless marriage does not equal an unhappy life. The same way zero marriage does not equal happiness

OP posts:
IsThereAnEchoInHere · 24/06/2023 14:43

What does ’loveless’ mean?

Is it disrespect, name-calling, abuse, sexism?
Get out!

Or is it lack of sex, physical stuff?
Stay, Who cares?
I wouldn’t be impressed if my parents had divorced just so they could get a leg over.

jfshu · 24/06/2023 14:41

@hoven no I don't believe that for a second, the kids live with you, they are picking up far more than you're giving them credit for. It is very, very easy to feel how happy someone is.

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/06/2023 14:41

I also believe it will be better for society if people put their families before their feelings

How can that be? Think this through. If prioritising a social construct over feelings were the key to a better society, then movements like communism (which place the needs of "society" over those of the individual) should automatically work.

The whole reason why totalitarian states usually fail and why hardline approaches to lifestyle such as religious cults usually fail is because they don't take account of the needs of the individual. Eventually people bridle at the fact that their needs as human beings don't count. Pluralist societies in which the needs of the individual are given some weight are usually much more successful.

Also you seem to be conflating "the family" with "the marriage". The two things are not the same. You can put your family first while not being married, or by ending a marriage. Plenty of separated parents maintain dignified, cordial relationships with one another while prioritising their children's needs, and plenty of married people live in a state of near open warfare with one another. Marriage does not protect against toxic behaviour.

I think what you are getting at is that people need to put their children at the centre of all decisions as to whether to remain in or dissolve a marriage. Which is absolutely correct. But the corollary of that is not that remaining in a bad marriage is always the best solution. It's very frustrating that you seem to be incapable of seeing past this.

hoven · 24/06/2023 14:40

@cestlavielife maybe eventually after counselling/ shifting perspectives/ changes in circumstances meaning less stress

OP posts:
hoven · 24/06/2023 14:39

jfshu · 24/06/2023 14:38

@hoven but if a marriage is an unhappy one it is likely toxic, living with someone you used to love but now tolerate will hardly ever be a healthy, comfortable environment for each other, or the kids.

It could be. But many people can manage their emotions and keep themselves busy/ find happiness elsewhere

OP posts:
cestlavielife · 24/06/2023 14:39

hoven · 24/06/2023 14:32

Does divorcing to become a single parent make you happy? I know a lot of unhappy divorcees

But that s a daft argument
They were presumably unhappy in their marriage
(Or their spouse was)
Staying married would not have equated to happiness

jfshu · 24/06/2023 14:38

@hoven but if a marriage is an unhappy one it is likely toxic, living with someone you used to love but now tolerate will hardly ever be a healthy, comfortable environment for each other, or the kids.

hoven · 24/06/2023 14:36

PonyPatter44 · 24/06/2023 14:33

I was married for 18 years, and I was deeply unhappy for most of those years. When I left, I found myself better off financially and emotionally. My DD missed her dad, but he had never taken much of an interest in her, so not much changed really. I met my now partner about three years after the split, we moved in together months later, and even DD really likes him.

Am I happier post-divorce? Immeasurably.

Is your DD?

OP posts:
hoven · 24/06/2023 14:35

@BodyKeepingScore no in all my posts I said excluding a toxic marriage

OP posts:
BodyKeepingScore · 24/06/2023 14:34

hoven · 24/06/2023 14:30

Does this scream happy?

Nice article. I'm curious as to whether you think physical abuse is better/worse than emotional abuse?

hoven · 24/06/2023 14:34

BodyKeepingScore · 24/06/2023 14:29

@hoven I don't think that divorcing and becoming a single parent makes someone feel loved... you're being deliberately obtuse. What I'm saying is that you are modelling for your children that they should tolerate a loveless marriage, that their "obligations to others" is more important than how they feel. A lifetime is a long time to go without love or passion. Why would you want less than that for your children? Are they put on this earth to appease everyone around them or are they worthy of love and fulfilling relationships? Reading more of your replies I can't help but think you aren't genuine - surely you understand the message you're sending your children? You're either being disingenuous or you genuinely think that maintaining the veneer of a respectable marriage is more important than anyone in the household being happy.

I think once you choose to have children yes you 100% have a commitment to them. Unless you think it's best to put your children in care to do anything you want to become "happy"

OP posts:
PonyPatter44 · 24/06/2023 14:33

I was married for 18 years, and I was deeply unhappy for most of those years. When I left, I found myself better off financially and emotionally. My DD missed her dad, but he had never taken much of an interest in her, so not much changed really. I met my now partner about three years after the split, we moved in together months later, and even DD really likes him.

Am I happier post-divorce? Immeasurably.

SD1978 · 24/06/2023 14:33

Disagree. Proving you can martyr yourself for your children shows them nothing positive

BodyKeepingScore · 24/06/2023 14:32

hoven · 24/06/2023 14:22

@BodyKeepingScore say that to those who have had abusive or toxic step families!

Plenty of blood/birth families are abusive and toxic. So in your mind, staying in an already toxic loveless marriage is better than a possibly toxic blended family. Gotcha 🤣

hoven · 24/06/2023 14:32

Does divorcing to become a single parent make you happy? I know a lot of unhappy divorcees

OP posts:
BodyKeepingScore · 24/06/2023 14:30

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Was your mothers marriage a happy one? Because if not, essentially what you're saying is "I'm so so grateful she sacrificed a lifetime of love and happiness so that I wouldn't have to possibly adjust to a step parent."

hoven · 24/06/2023 14:30

Does this scream happy?

Loveless marriage VS commitment to family
Loveless marriage VS commitment to family
OP posts:
BodyKeepingScore · 24/06/2023 14:29

@hoven I don't think that divorcing and becoming a single parent makes someone feel loved... you're being deliberately obtuse. What I'm saying is that you are modelling for your children that they should tolerate a loveless marriage, that their "obligations to others" is more important than how they feel. A lifetime is a long time to go without love or passion. Why would you want less than that for your children? Are they put on this earth to appease everyone around them or are they worthy of love and fulfilling relationships? Reading more of your replies I can't help but think you aren't genuine - surely you understand the message you're sending your children? You're either being disingenuous or you genuinely think that maintaining the veneer of a respectable marriage is more important than anyone in the household being happy.

Yousee · 24/06/2023 14:28

Knocked off bike by truck - 33 years
Heart attack - 47 years
Cardiac arrest - 62 years
Murdered - 35 years

Just a run down of the last few funerals DH and I have attended in the last year.
Nobody is guaranteed decades of this life to waste being so unhappy, and I would hate do do it then see my children mimic me in their own unhappy lives.