Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Loveless marriage VS commitment to family

210 replies

hoven · 24/06/2023 11:21

AIBU to suggest that committing to stay in a marriage for your children is more important to show your children than showing them an 'example of a happy relationship'?

In marriages without abuse or toxicity of course

OP posts:
willWillSmithsmith · 24/06/2023 16:48

Anklespraying · 24/06/2023 16:41

That's hilarious.

I divorced my ex when the DS were teens but stayed in the house until they both left for uni as I paid the mortgage and bills anyway.

I bought my own place outright after and supported the DS through uni and still do assist if they need it.

I bought a power boat last year with the cash I don't spend on EX H. My pension fund is all mine to spend too. I have no interest in another relationship as I have a great time without one. Mediocre, I don't think so!

Very inspirational and similar to my attitude (once i no longer have to think of anyone but myself on a day to day basis).

A loveless marriage sounds awful because if there is no love of any kind then how can it really work? Love can come in many forms but the word loveless also conjures up no respect, no compatibility, no liking.

When you say loveless OP do you really mean all absence of any level of love or just romantic love?

Womencanlift · 24/06/2023 16:47

hoven · 24/06/2023 14:22

@BodyKeepingScore say that to those who have had abusive or toxic step families!

You are quite clearly projecting but to give you the opposite view from person experience, I am in a perfectly happy step family situation

If my parents had stayed together when they were quite clearly unhappy with each other then I would have considered them terrible parents and terrible role models.

Children of all ages can pick up on unhappy environments and living in that every day that will have a bigger detriment on them long term than families who split and are then happy afterwards

OP you seem quite firm on your views that divorce = everyone being unhappy. Fair enough if that’s your experience but it’s not everybody’s

Anklespraying · 24/06/2023 16:41

hoven · 24/06/2023 13:08

I think you are more likely to live a mediocre life a divorcee

That's hilarious.

I divorced my ex when the DS were teens but stayed in the house until they both left for uni as I paid the mortgage and bills anyway.

I bought my own place outright after and supported the DS through uni and still do assist if they need it.

I bought a power boat last year with the cash I don't spend on EX H. My pension fund is all mine to spend too. I have no interest in another relationship as I have a great time without one. Mediocre, I don't think so!

doodleygirl · 24/06/2023 16:37

OP you sound so sad and weary.

I wouldn’t want my children brought up in an unhappy marriage. When do they see you laugh, dance around the kitchen with your husband, hold his hand, sneak kisses and the kids go ewwwwe. This is what you deny your children when you are in a loveless marriage. They really deserve to know how much their parents love each other it is so fundamental to their sense of worth.

if you can’t do this you can all be so much happier out of the marriage.

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/06/2023 16:31

@hoven

a loveless marriage does not equal an unhappy life.

It depends how you define "loveless". If you mean "sexless" or with very little romance, then yes I think it is possible to come to an accomodation with someone for a bit, although often that is just buying time. It's fairly naive to think this will work forever: at some point one or the other of you will want to find the sex and romance you're not getting and the person who is left behind in this scenario will feel resentful and cheated. So it's theoretically possible but in practice I think quite unlikely this could be sustained indefinitely.

If you mean a marriage without respect or friendship or affection, never mind sex, then I would totally disagree. At its most fundamental, marriage should be a team which involves two people pulling in the same direction and sustaining one another and, (if there are kids involved) prioritising their children's needs.

With two people who disagree with each other on major points (values, politics, friends, ethics) or have wildly different emotional registers or needs or different lifestyle goals, it will become increasingly difficult to keep this project together. The logic in having two people legally yoked together if they are at odds on all the important things in life will eventually collapse in on itself and the tension between those two people will be unbearable for the children at the centre of it. And it sends a very damaging message to children that people need to reconcile wildly different perspectives "for the family". It tells them at some level that they shouldn't expect their needs to be met in the family.

StarSpangledSpaniel · 24/06/2023 16:29

I know that I could not commit to staying in a loveless marriage. And I cannot see how doing so would be of much psychological benefit to my children. It must be horrible for kids to see their parents live without love, or hope, and even worse to discover as a young adult they did this for your ‘benefit’. I’ve been in an unhappy relationship (pre children) and, for me, it meant an unhappy ( or just greyer) life. I think that when one is in a loveless relationship, it’s easy to forget the colour, energy and joy a strong relationship can bring to your life (not to mention the sex, I couldn’t easily give up that either). It is hard to imagine just how much more lovely the alternative might be, especially if there’s a scary path to walk.

DH’s parents divorced when their children were young. Their marriage and subsequent relationship was far from loveless. They rather adored each other, but were not suited to being married. The family still remained a family, they sometimes holidayed together, sometimes apart, DFIL had flat around the corner, he was involved in family life and close to his boys, they both had happy subsequent relationships, with people much better suited to them at that stage in their lives. None of their boys would ever suggest that the divorce wasn’t, at the end of the day, the right thing for everyone.

isthistheendtakeabreath · 24/06/2023 16:10

I agree OP and I would have put staying together as a family over my own happiness.....my soon to be ex husband however put himself first and chose not to

Eggham · 24/06/2023 16:02

Great post @AcrossthePond55

I am the one who ‘feels more’ in a MINO and it is torture. I have given DH an ultimatum that we need to properly work on the relationship (both of us, not just me) or we need to split.

It is no good for the children to be in this situation, they do sense the lack of love, just as you say. So ‘staying for the kids’ is a misnomer.

AcrossthePond55 · 24/06/2023 15:55

I think in a situation where both parties have ALL of the following they might be able to maintain a loveless marriage ('marriage in name only =MINO) in peace and maintain a modicum of sanity and 'peace of mind':

  • completely honest with each other
  • financially equal AND comfortable
  • can agree on how to handle family expenses
  • equal in 'lack of feeling' for each other (this is very important)
  • can agree on their 'non-marital' lifestyle (ie both agree on open marriage or celibacy), AND
  • have a big enough home to carve out separate spaces

But honestly, how often do all those circumstances fall in alignment? Almost never. And if they do at the moment of 'agreement', how long will that last? Probably not very long. It's a pipe dream. It usually transpires that one party feels more, is financially dependent, wants sexual freedom, doesn't carry their share of the household drudgery and child responsibilities, etc etc.

Someone may be able to deceive themselves into thinking they are happy, but that's usually the partner in the catbird seat. The partner who feels more, does more, or has less will invariably be unhappy. If someone divorces and is unhappy, at least that's something they can acknowledge and work on, whereas if someone stays in a MINO they must try to convince themselves that they are happy, or else they must confront the question "Why am I really here?". And 'for the children' will not make that person truly happy. They'll just be 'unhappy for a reason'.

And I believe that children can sense a 'lack of love' in their parents just as keenly as they can sense the love that a happily married couple have for each other. So even if a couple can rub along somewhat peacefully in a MINO they are teaching their children that it's just fine to 'settle' for someone they don't love in order to attain the goal of 'marriage and children' rather than to seek a real and meaningful love.

DH and I have been married over 35 years. We've had our good times and our bad times. But our children have always known that through good and bad we have a deep and abiding love for each other. I'm sure that neither of us would have been able to maintain a facade of love in a MINO. Nor would either of us have wanted to.

SchoolShenanigans · 24/06/2023 15:54

There's definitely a lot of grey space between a completely divorce and a happy marriage.

Lots of couples undoubtedly give up on marriages (and families) too easily. Those who have affairs, or who leave because "there no love anymore" as if love is something you just have or don't.

You have to work at love. It's something two people make an effort at, especially once you've had kids and life stresses. Relationships are HARD, any relationship including friendship. If you want it to last, you need to take the rough with the smooth.

But equally if someone's been unhappy for 5 years for example, and actually doesn't like or respect their partner, then I suspect all parties would be happier in the long run for the relationship to end.

Eggham · 24/06/2023 15:54

@GabriellaMontez Yes! I mean saying no one should divorce except those who are in marriages with ‘abuse or toxicity’ probably rules out the vast majority of divorces from discussion, especially if you include infidelity under the banner of ‘toxicity’, which I would.

GabriellaMontez · 24/06/2023 15:47

In marriages without abuse or toxicity of course

Given this statement, we already agree that sometimes it's best to separate.

How do you define toxicity? I often read about women on here who put up with 'silent treatment ' and other 'non physical abuse'. Plus all kinds of financial inequity.

Is it good, to demonstrate commitment to being treated badly?

TheaBrandt · 24/06/2023 15:46

As older children /teens the kids will go to their mates houses and see the difference in atmosphere ….

Ponderingwindow · 24/06/2023 15:28

If people can settle into a marriage of friendship and they have children, then I think staying together is better than seeking a romantic spark elsewhere. A successful marriage can be built on things other than sex and romance.

if you aren’t friends and aren’t working together, then I don’t know that just staying in the same house benefits the children.

Eggham · 24/06/2023 15:26

As someone facing the end of a marriage now, I’m finding the stories on this thread very moving, thank you.

Of course ideally we all want our kids to grow up in happy intact marriages. But if a marriage is unhappy it does tend to be toxic in some way and thus bad for the children ultimately, as well as the parents (who are people too!).

This is the nature of unhappy marriage - of course there are happy platonic marriages which are more like friendships - but these are still happy marriages. Genuinely unhappy marriages create a stifled, difficult atmosphere full of resentment, and are detrimental for everyone who lives in them. A ‘commitment’ to such a marriage isn’t a commitment to your children, but probably stems more from fear of the unknown.

sobeyondthehills · 24/06/2023 15:25

But at the start of the year, myself and my DP were on the verge of breaking up, there were a lot of issues going on. The atmosphere was horrible in our home, DS picked up alot on it, despite us keeping it to ourselves, he could tell, something was going on, with the way we interacted with each other, the way we talked to each other.

We have sorted the majority of the issues out now and have worked alot on our relationship and communication.

However, if we hadn't I would have had no problem at all in calling time on the relationship, not just for me but for DS, it was not a pleasant time and I would not want him living in that on a long term basis, I dont think that is modelling the right behaviour.

If either thing had happened, I would have been able to say, we worked hard at fixing things, and we sorted it and together or we worked hard at fixing things and we couldnt plug the gaps, we didnt want to paper the cracks, just to do things further down the line.

But, if we were to split up, I wouldnt consider a step family situation either, DP already has an older son, I think adding in another family would just confuse the situation alot more, but that is me at my time of life, right now.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 24/06/2023 15:14

Justfeckoffwiththeovulating · 24/06/2023 14:59

I left my long term relationship and for my children (not just for me) it was definitely the right thing.
They get to see their mother happy. Not walking on eggshells, not ready to argue, not pretending that she's not seething inside, not resentful, but happy.
Has this come with sacrifices, yes. But mostly for me. I have no financial security and am skint most of the time. The house is a mess and I'm permanently chasing my tail to keep up with full time work, life admin and being a present parent. We may have to sell the family home and I am retraining to get a better paid job. But ultimately, it was all worth it.
I don't want to date really and my marriage was sexless for five years so I'm not really missing that. But I dance around my kitchen with glee at being out of my relationship, I'm a great role model and a better parent than I was.
So what if we have to give up takeaways and holidays? They get a mum who feels genuinely optimistic about the future.

Love your story x

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 24/06/2023 15:13

MidsummerNightsDream · 24/06/2023 15:10

I’d have agreed with the OP until the decision was made for me by my exH. I thought we were okay. I was content. Then one day, he called time on the marriage. I desperately wanted it not to be happening. I had no experience of separation or divorce and I resisted it for months. I felt like a failure.

5 years on, happier than I’ve been in decades. On great terms with exH. Children very happy and settled and love spending time with both parents and our respective partners. I’ve been in a blissful relationship with a lovely man for 2 years now.

I was devastated and struggled with the stigmas (I think a lot of these were in my own head) that still surround separation and the failure of my marriage but I now believe that my exH made the right decision for us. It’s been and still is financially tougher than it was when I was married but I take pride in the fact that I have and still am working hard in every area of my life to keep our family life stable and happy. Ex does too. He has always been a fantastic father.

I don’t think there’s a black a white answer to this because when I was married, I was content (though I often felt anxious and stifled). I had absolutely no idea back then that the calm and happiness that I feel today was possible.

I suppose we cling to what we know and what makes us feel safe. To make a leap into the unknown is daunting - you don’t know where you’ll land. I think the little quote sums it up:

‘What if I fall?’
‘Oh but my darling,
What if you fly?’

I absolutely love your story, and this quote- I'm where you were now and it gives me lots of hope for future happiness! Xxxx

Cubsandmiel · 24/06/2023 15:13

hoven · 24/06/2023 12:51

So do you think divorce = happy?

In my particular case yes! 100%! We both met other people and are way happier

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 24/06/2023 15:12

@hoven that's an important perspective te child abuse. I tend to think that some of the same factors that cause instability that breaks up parents can also lead to abuse like poverty, mental health issues, substance abuse, domestic abuse, none of those factors are in the home child murder is very unlikely

willWillSmithsmith · 24/06/2023 15:11

If both parents can live happily together without any romance or expectations of intimacy then I guess it could work on a ‘flatmate’ basis but in the long term that’s not very likely. Resentments are bound to start showing if needs (in whatever capacity that is) are not being met. Resentment in a marriage will be far more damaging to children than two smaller but happier households.

MidsummerNightsDream · 24/06/2023 15:10

I’d have agreed with the OP until the decision was made for me by my exH. I thought we were okay. I was content. Then one day, he called time on the marriage. I desperately wanted it not to be happening. I had no experience of separation or divorce and I resisted it for months. I felt like a failure.

5 years on, happier than I’ve been in decades. On great terms with exH. Children very happy and settled and love spending time with both parents and our respective partners. I’ve been in a blissful relationship with a lovely man for 2 years now.

I was devastated and struggled with the stigmas (I think a lot of these were in my own head) that still surround separation and the failure of my marriage but I now believe that my exH made the right decision for us. It’s been and still is financially tougher than it was when I was married but I take pride in the fact that I have and still am working hard in every area of my life to keep our family life stable and happy. Ex does too. He has always been a fantastic father.

I don’t think there’s a black a white answer to this because when I was married, I was content (though I often felt anxious and stifled). I had absolutely no idea back then that the calm and happiness that I feel today was possible.

I suppose we cling to what we know and what makes us feel safe. To make a leap into the unknown is daunting - you don’t know where you’ll land. I think the little quote sums it up:

‘What if I fall?’
‘Oh but my darling,
What if you fly?’

Justfeckoffwiththeovulating · 24/06/2023 14:59

I left my long term relationship and for my children (not just for me) it was definitely the right thing.
They get to see their mother happy. Not walking on eggshells, not ready to argue, not pretending that she's not seething inside, not resentful, but happy.
Has this come with sacrifices, yes. But mostly for me. I have no financial security and am skint most of the time. The house is a mess and I'm permanently chasing my tail to keep up with full time work, life admin and being a present parent. We may have to sell the family home and I am retraining to get a better paid job. But ultimately, it was all worth it.
I don't want to date really and my marriage was sexless for five years so I'm not really missing that. But I dance around my kitchen with glee at being out of my relationship, I'm a great role model and a better parent than I was.
So what if we have to give up takeaways and holidays? They get a mum who feels genuinely optimistic about the future.

PonyPatter44 · 24/06/2023 14:57

hoven · 24/06/2023 14:36

Is your DD?

It was an interesting question, so I asked her.

She says yes. DP has done more for her than her biological father ever did. Bear in mind, though, that she didn't meet DP until she was 15, so its not like she had to deal with it as a young child.

ProfessorXtra · 24/06/2023 14:57

hoven · 24/06/2023 14:43

@jfshu a loveless marriage does not equal an unhappy life. The same way zero marriage does not equal happiness

Again comparing 2 different things.

A loveless marriage, isn't the same as not being married