Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Loveless marriage VS commitment to family

210 replies

hoven · 24/06/2023 11:21

AIBU to suggest that committing to stay in a marriage for your children is more important to show your children than showing them an 'example of a happy relationship'?

In marriages without abuse or toxicity of course

OP posts:
Mothwingdust · 25/06/2023 09:14

It is actually true that most children murdered are killed by stepparents and not parents.

Each case for divorce is individual.

No one but you is actually experiencing your feelings you can write here and

try and explain. You could write the best description ever written but no one would be able to feel like you. Even if 20 women come on this forum and are also in dull though not toxic marriages and say I’m unhappy, bored, frustrated the way each one feels will be different.

jfshu · 25/06/2023 09:08

Sometimes your children may see you stressed from work, does that mean you are teaching your child to not prioritise their health over work? Work is always going to be stressful but you still have to do it.

I've actually left a job this year because it was making me unhappy and I felt devalued by the manager, managed to get a promotion externally and talked through it all with my eldest because I'm now being head hunted back to my remorseful old place so it's made for some useful teaching points around self worth!

No one is saying you have to 100% perfect and happy all the time, that is not life nor realistic to children, but when the light has gone out in a marriage that is more than just a down point in a marriage that has ups and downs.

MidsummerNightsDream · 25/06/2023 09:01

‘Quitting and making massive changes for your child just because you want to get laid is not the best option.’

Who/where are these people? I certainly don’t know them. Leaving a marriage is one of life’s biggest decisions. You’ve lost credibility with this comment, OP.

ProfessorXtra · 25/06/2023 08:37

whiteroseredrose · 25/06/2023 06:05

I understand where the OP is coming from, but there are so many shades of grey.

I come from a successful split. My parents split when I was 4 and both went on to have very happy second marriages. I didn't suffer because other than for a blip my parents got on well and prioritised my happiness. The big 'but' here is that I didn't have to house shuffle and my main carer, my mum, didn't have more children. I spent half of every holiday with my dad and didn't have to share my mum with any half siblings, or worse, step siblings.

From my mum's perspective she was bloody miserable living with her parents for 10 years until she met my stepdad.

In contrast, when I was a TA I dealt with several very unhappy children switching between parents either alternating weeks or splitting weeks. Tears at drop offs because they weren't seeing that parent for a few days. Blended families really not blending at all.

A childhood friend is on to her third husband. Her first husband (and father of her DD) was lovely but not massively ambitious, so she left. She married her second husband knowing that he actually didn't like her DD. That only lasted a few years and she's now onto her third. Her DD gets on ok with him. I don't think that divorce made that 'friend' happy the first time. She has done extremely well in her career and earns more than the Prime Minister, as does DH3 who was her boss. I think she is happy now, but I'm not sure about her DD.

There’s truth in this. But The outcome for the child is very dependent on how the adults handle it, rather than the divorce itself.

But then there plenty of unhappy children in homes where both parents live together and whose relationship with eachother is fine. Plenty of unhappy children in home where both parents are together but whose relationship is dead.

I don’t believe the only unhappy children are from families who divorce and the alternative handle it badly.

ProfessorXtra · 25/06/2023 08:29

hoven · 25/06/2023 07:05

Sometimes your children may see you stressed from work, does that mean you are teaching your child to not prioritise their health over work? Work is always going to be stressful but you still have to do it.

Same thing with relationships and marriage, they're not always easy but sometimes you need to do the right thing and commit to the choice you made. Quitting and making massive changes for your child just because you want to get laid is not the best option

Well if you are stressed every day because you are unhappy in your job, yes you are teaching kids a poor lesson.

If you think you will be miserable for the next 20 years in your job and it will impact every aspect of your life, including theirs. Yes, that’s a poor lesson to teach children. Sticking at something that makes you unhappy for years and years, isn’t a good lesson. Teaching kids that even if you are miserable you shouldn’t change anything, isn’t a good lesson.

If we are comparing your marriage to a job. Your marriage would be a job that’s having a bad phase. But on the whole you are happy with it and it’s not always bad. A job that you believe might get better at some point. There’s a pay off for having this job. In your marriage the pay off is that you can have 2 kids with the same man so you can still sit in judgement of those that have 2 kids by 2 dads.

So you are not at the stage most people are when they divorce. You think there might be hope. So you can’t actually judge people who do divorce because your aren’t in the same position. You think there’s still hope judging people who are 100 steps beyond that.

Maybe when you get to the point where you know there’s no hope, you might decide divorce is the only option. You have no idea how you will feel.

You posted because you are miserable and you wanted people to tell your are so great it was that you are sacrificing your happiness for your child. Expect you aren’t doing anything for your child. You are massively judgmental about women who have kids with more than one man. You want another child so staying so you can have one and not be a hypocrite. You are staying for you. Not for the child you have or a future child. But because having another child is your priority.

I don’t see how that makes you any better than someone who has 2 kids by 2 dads. And the judgemental attitude will also be damaging to your children growing up.

I stand by what I said. Within in 5 years of having a second child you will leave.

Panteranoir · 25/06/2023 07:24

Chastising people who leave an unhappy and loveless marriage to find a healthier way to live as 'wanting to get laid' is actually disgusting and risible. Especially from someone using their own husband as a sperm donor. You're clearly still getting laid as you so charmingly put it so what on earth maes you think that other people who are in loveless marriages are in sexless marriages and sex is their driver to leave?

You get one life OP.

This is it and you are wasting yours on a sad barren existence no matter how much you look down your nose at people making different choices.

No one will thank you for this.

hoven · 25/06/2023 07:05

Sometimes your children may see you stressed from work, does that mean you are teaching your child to not prioritise their health over work? Work is always going to be stressful but you still have to do it.

Same thing with relationships and marriage, they're not always easy but sometimes you need to do the right thing and commit to the choice you made. Quitting and making massive changes for your child just because you want to get laid is not the best option

OP posts:
whiteroseredrose · 25/06/2023 06:05

I understand where the OP is coming from, but there are so many shades of grey.

I come from a successful split. My parents split when I was 4 and both went on to have very happy second marriages. I didn't suffer because other than for a blip my parents got on well and prioritised my happiness. The big 'but' here is that I didn't have to house shuffle and my main carer, my mum, didn't have more children. I spent half of every holiday with my dad and didn't have to share my mum with any half siblings, or worse, step siblings.

From my mum's perspective she was bloody miserable living with her parents for 10 years until she met my stepdad.

In contrast, when I was a TA I dealt with several very unhappy children switching between parents either alternating weeks or splitting weeks. Tears at drop offs because they weren't seeing that parent for a few days. Blended families really not blending at all.

A childhood friend is on to her third husband. Her first husband (and father of her DD) was lovely but not massively ambitious, so she left. She married her second husband knowing that he actually didn't like her DD. That only lasted a few years and she's now onto her third. Her DD gets on ok with him. I don't think that divorce made that 'friend' happy the first time. She has done extremely well in her career and earns more than the Prime Minister, as does DH3 who was her boss. I think she is happy now, but I'm not sure about her DD.

MrsMikeDrop · 25/06/2023 04:13

Modaboutyou · 24/06/2023 22:25

My original point still stands, how terribly sad for your child to grow up in this situation. It will affect them more than you think (or want to give accept).

Agree. I also think that this is more about your comfort than doing it for the children. Probably for most of us actually, I think the excuse of "doing it for the kids" is mostly BS unless you're kids are clueless and don't know what's really going on. Spoiler alert, they see everything

Ellie6489 · 25/06/2023 00:53

I am in a loveless marriage (at least from my end) but I stay because my kids don't want us to split up. They would be so unhappy. They are thriving now and breaking up our family would change everything, and not for the better. So we make it work and it's alright. Not the best situation but I know it's what makes them happy and that's all that matters to me. He really is a great father and committed to our family.

I would definitely leave if our children were exposed to violent abuse. I would want to protect them at that point, whether they are happy with it or not. I try my hardest to make decisions that are best for them.

Panteranoir · 24/06/2023 23:43

Justfeckoffwiththeovulating · 24/06/2023 14:59

I left my long term relationship and for my children (not just for me) it was definitely the right thing.
They get to see their mother happy. Not walking on eggshells, not ready to argue, not pretending that she's not seething inside, not resentful, but happy.
Has this come with sacrifices, yes. But mostly for me. I have no financial security and am skint most of the time. The house is a mess and I'm permanently chasing my tail to keep up with full time work, life admin and being a present parent. We may have to sell the family home and I am retraining to get a better paid job. But ultimately, it was all worth it.
I don't want to date really and my marriage was sexless for five years so I'm not really missing that. But I dance around my kitchen with glee at being out of my relationship, I'm a great role model and a better parent than I was.
So what if we have to give up takeaways and holidays? They get a mum who feels genuinely optimistic about the future.

Good for you. You absolutely deserve to feel that happiness

Modaboutyou · 24/06/2023 22:25

hoven · 24/06/2023 19:42

@Modaboutyou if we split up they still won't see that! We are very respectful and get on ok

My original point still stands, how terribly sad for your child to grow up in this situation. It will affect them more than you think (or want to give accept).

MidsummerNightsDream · 24/06/2023 20:52

hoven · 24/06/2023 13:08

I think you are more likely to live a mediocre life a divorcee

I think that’s a bit mean and judgemental and also not true when I think about friends who have divorced over the years. Some love the single life and their freedom, others have found new love and are much happier than they were in their marriages. Anecdotal, I know but I definitely don’t get the impression that their lives are in any way ‘mediocre’. Quite the opposite.

To me, being in a marriage of convenience or staying for the children is far more likely to result in a ‘mediocre’ life. But I understand why people do. It’s the much easier, less scary option.

Womencanlift · 24/06/2023 20:36

Another one who is unsure what you want from this thread.

You are very judgemental and quite clearly not opening to learn from people’s lives experiences which is the point of a discussion forum

jfshu · 24/06/2023 20:31

You've made a decision but clearly are not very happy with it given this thread, your strong opinions clearly stem from a place of insecurity. It's your life, but you might want to reflect on why you are so judgemental and what the real problem is here, clue, it's not other people divorcing and being happy.

nothingcomestonothing · 24/06/2023 20:11

ProfessorXtra · 24/06/2023 19:58

In fact let’s just agree.

You aren’t staying for your child. You are staying because you want another child. You want one.

Theres no guarantee that your child will like or even enjoy having a sibling. You are staying for you. Not the vows. Not because it’s best.

I would actually bet money that within 5 years of having the second child, you split anyway. Once you have what you want, you won’t feel like it’s worth staying.

Nailed it.

OP I don't understand why you started this thread. You've already decided what to do, and you seem to have very fixed ideas about what various situations are or will be like, so I'm not sure anything anyone said would have penetrated anyway.

ProfessorXtra · 24/06/2023 20:04

hoven · 24/06/2023 19:58

Also who knows in a few year time we may be good again. I made the decision initially so I'm going to stick with it

If you think there’s a chance things can be good again, you aren’t in the same place as the majority of people who divorce.

Most people choose divorce once they know they absolutely can never make things better.

So until you get to that point, maybe hold off the judging people for not staying in their marriage. Because you don’t actually know what it’s like to be at the point you absolutely know there’s no way back from.

If you ever get to that place and you have your 2nd child. I think you will make a different decision.

Otherland · 24/06/2023 20:03

I agree with you, OP.

My life is infinitely harder now my ex has left. His choice. My kids absolutely hate having to leave living with me eow. We are two years on, and my eldest especially really hates the upheaval.

Financially, my life is extremely stressful. It is tough on my children. Our home is tiny, because it's all I can afford. We all hate our circumstances.

I would have stuck it out, but he didn't want to.

hoven · 24/06/2023 20:02

@AndIKnewYouMeantIt he's actually the best father I know. So I feel extremely proud of myself for choosing him

OP posts:
AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 24/06/2023 19:59

hoven · 24/06/2023 19:56

@AndIKnewYouMeantIt that will never be part of my value system.

Yeah, you don't get to claim moral high ground on this one, sorry. Using your DH as a sperm donor is foul.

ProfessorXtra · 24/06/2023 19:58

In fact let’s just agree.

You aren’t staying for your child. You are staying because you want another child. You want one.

Theres no guarantee that your child will like or even enjoy having a sibling. You are staying for you. Not the vows. Not because it’s best.

I would actually bet money that within 5 years of having the second child, you split anyway. Once you have what you want, you won’t feel like it’s worth staying.

hoven · 24/06/2023 19:58

Also who knows in a few year time we may be good again. I made the decision initially so I'm going to stick with it

OP posts:
hoven · 24/06/2023 19:56

@AndIKnewYouMeantIt that will never be part of my value system.

OP posts:
ProfessorXtra · 24/06/2023 19:56

hoven · 24/06/2023 19:53

Funerals, caring for parents and just having another close family member rather than feeling alone

What? A funeral is difficult to organise because you are grieving. It’s actually easier when one person does it.

You can’t care for parents who are dead and there’s no guarantee you would need care. Or that either will actually leave near enough to care for you.

Having a sibling doesn’t guarantee or even increase the odds of feeling alone.

We you child born in a loveless marriage?

hoven · 24/06/2023 19:53

ProfessorXtra · 24/06/2023 19:49

What load are siblings sharing when their parents are dead?

Funerals, caring for parents and just having another close family member rather than feeling alone

OP posts: