Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Loveless marriage VS commitment to family

210 replies

hoven · 24/06/2023 11:21

AIBU to suggest that committing to stay in a marriage for your children is more important to show your children than showing them an 'example of a happy relationship'?

In marriages without abuse or toxicity of course

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 25/06/2023 15:50

continentallentil · 25/06/2023 15:02

You know OP, you are putting an awful lot of energy into persuading yourself you are right and the majority of society is wrong.

This does make me think you are trying to persuade yourself, rather than you actually believe what you are saying.

As long as you take good care of your kids, married or not, they will be fine. They may appreciate you staying together, or they may not respect you for it - there’s simply no way of knowing that, so whatever you do, don’t base your decision of some hypothetical feeling you think your kids may have in 20 years.

And don’t waste your time arguing on the internet and convincing yourself you have the moral high ground. You need to live your actual life.

I agree totally. And I think it's a shame when someone has to denigrate another person's actual lived experience to justify their own poor choices.

Many women leaving for sex, indeed! Sex may be a result of passion but passion doesn't always equal sex. Passion is a feeling born out of love. If for some reason my husband and I could no longer have sex I would still love him with the same passion that I do now. So when a woman says she is leaving because there's no 'passion' in their marriage, she's talking about the feeling not about sex.

Have at it @hoven . Just don't expect anyone to admire you for your decision to stay or for your children to bow down in gratitude. And I wonder what your husband's take on this is? Have you been honest with him? You're so anxious to proclaim the truth to us all but have you proclaimed it to him? Doesn't he have the right to decide whether or not he wants to live in a loveless marriage?

jfshu · 25/06/2023 15:50

@hoven are you certain your DH shares the same views and will tolerate a sexless, unromantic relationship until your children grown? And if he does, that he won't change his mind?

ProfessorXtra · 25/06/2023 15:45

hoven · 25/06/2023 15:42

Their childhood won't be miserable due to my lack of sex

Yea because that’s what the poster said. Yabu and you are being ridiculous

hoven · 25/06/2023 15:42

Womencanlift · 25/06/2023 15:32

And what would you do if when your child comes to you and said they had a miserable childhood because it was quite obvious you and their dad didn’t want to be in a marriage and should have split up?

Their childhood won't be miserable due to my lack of sex

OP posts:
Womencanlift · 25/06/2023 15:32

And what would you do if when your child comes to you and said they had a miserable childhood because it was quite obvious you and their dad didn’t want to be in a marriage and should have split up?

ProfessorXtra · 25/06/2023 15:18

hoven · 25/06/2023 14:59

What's your marital situation?

Why would that matter?

It’s clear you came here for some sort of kick. A need to prove that your choice makes you a better person and parent.

People who are happy with the choices they make, don’t do that. They don’t go seeking validation and certainly don’t seek to try and be superior to people who made a different choice.

You are staying because you dislike women who have kids to more than one man. But are desperate for another child. You know, deep down, this isn’t for your existing child. It’s for you. And you started a thread to tell people how you are making the right choice, they are wrong, how they must have put their sex life above their children and so and so forth.

That’s not the behaviour of someone confident they are doing the right thing for themselves or for their children.

jfshu · 25/06/2023 15:11

What's your marital situation?

Coming up to 20 years together; supportive, happy and still loving marriage with my high school sweetheart. But grew up in house with unhappily married parents, so if our relationship was to change, I know what would be best for us and our children, and they wouldn't necessarily be opposing options.

nothingcomestonothing · 25/06/2023 15:08

ProfessorXtra · 25/06/2023 14:46

You aren’t putting your child first.

You are putting your desire for another child first.

This.

OP you have said such unpleasant, goady, judgemental things to and about other women who have posted trying to help you. You keep trying to justify the poor decision you're making if you like, but you don't need to be such a dick about it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/06/2023 15:03

@hoven you keep parroting that “children come first” as if you were the only person to have thought of this.

But on further inspection it turns out your desire for another child is your real motive here.

It’s perfectly possible to separate in a way which prioritises the needs of your children. As plenty of people have pointed out here. The moral high ground is not reserved for people who doggedly cling to a miserable marriage like a rat to a sinking ship.

It is not ethical or sensible to sacrifice both yourself and your existing child to an unhappy relationship because you have some rigid idea that children need siblings. It’s incredibly selfish and self destructive.

Your beliefs are your beliefs and if you think staying in an unhappy relationship for your child is the right thing to do that’s one thing.

But remaining in a dysfunctional marriage to bring a second child into the mix takes it out of the realm of self defeating self denial and into the arena of doing exactly what you say you are trying to avoid: harming your existing child. If you do this you are in no position to insult the people you have asked for support by telling us that people only leave marriages for sex.

Your ethical position is highly questionable and you don’t get to make sanctimonious comments about people who divorce when your own actions are so profoundly self-centred.

continentallentil · 25/06/2023 15:02

You know OP, you are putting an awful lot of energy into persuading yourself you are right and the majority of society is wrong.

This does make me think you are trying to persuade yourself, rather than you actually believe what you are saying.

As long as you take good care of your kids, married or not, they will be fine. They may appreciate you staying together, or they may not respect you for it - there’s simply no way of knowing that, so whatever you do, don’t base your decision of some hypothetical feeling you think your kids may have in 20 years.

And don’t waste your time arguing on the internet and convincing yourself you have the moral high ground. You need to live your actual life.

hoven · 25/06/2023 14:59

jfshu · 25/06/2023 14:57

For this reason amongst numerous others I'm happy to accept a lack of passion.

But happy to accept having another child when you really shouldn't be having any more children, especially if you couldn't support them alone. I just find it SO hypocritical with how you chastised women on another thread for who they picked as fathers, and here you are with no financial independence, unhappily married and wanting to add a child to this situation? What will you do if he leaves you? Maybe lack of passion will be an issue for him eventually, it's not all in your control?

What's your marital situation?

OP posts:
jfshu · 25/06/2023 14:57

For this reason amongst numerous others I'm happy to accept a lack of passion.

But happy to accept having another child when you really shouldn't be having any more children, especially if you couldn't support them alone. I just find it SO hypocritical with how you chastised women on another thread for who they picked as fathers, and here you are with no financial independence, unhappily married and wanting to add a child to this situation? What will you do if he leaves you? Maybe lack of passion will be an issue for him eventually, it's not all in your control?

jfshu · 25/06/2023 14:53

@hoven and if you don't want to impact "hardworking taxpayers' money" don't add any more children to your already challenging set up!

jfshu · 25/06/2023 14:52

My relationship isn't unstable there is just no passion which is fine.

You said you will likely break up when the kid/s are grown, that is not a stable relationship. I'm afraid your thread is a case of people in glass houses shouldn't throw stones, you're pointing fingers at other people when your own actions are pretty questionable. Deep down you know that, or you wouldn't be protesting so much.

ProfessorXtra · 25/06/2023 14:46

hoven · 25/06/2023 14:45

Yes I am overlooking feelings of annoyance as children come first

You aren’t putting your child first.

You are putting your desire for another child first.

hoven · 25/06/2023 14:45

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/06/2023 14:42

@hoven

Yes apart from abuse, it is often to find a sexual relationship hence the excuse of "no passion"

I’m sorry this is just nonsense. You are fixated on the idea that this is about sex and missing out on the huge damage it does to people to be forced to remain legally bound to someone who doesn’t love or respect them.

Yes I am overlooking feelings of annoyance as children come first

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 25/06/2023 14:42

@hoven

Yes apart from abuse, it is often to find a sexual relationship hence the excuse of "no passion"

I’m sorry this is just nonsense. You are fixated on the idea that this is about sex and missing out on the huge damage it does to people to be forced to remain legally bound to someone who doesn’t love or respect them.

hoven · 25/06/2023 14:37

jfshu · 25/06/2023 14:31

@hoven I am really sorry your marriage is shit, but you are seriously projecting here and you must realise it. You think so little of yourself and are so selfishly desperate for another child that you are clinging onto a misguided belief that what you are doing is virtuous and for your child, but you are no different to the supposed women you believe are choosing sex over their children, you are choosing what YOU want, and bringing another child into an unstable and unhappy relationship is NEVER a morally good thing. Just be honest here.

My relationship isn't unstable there is just no passion which is fine.

I am priced out my area so would have to live in temporary housing until I could afford somewhere. I would also be claiming hardworking taxpayers money for benefits.
For this reason amongst numerous others I'm happy to accept a lack of passion. My child comes before my sexual desires and my desire to not depend on the system comes before wanting sex.

I started this thread as this is an anonymous forum and I don't have anyone else to discuss this point of view with in real life as it too controversial.

OP posts:
jfshu · 25/06/2023 14:31

@hoven I am really sorry your marriage is shit, but you are seriously projecting here and you must realise it. You think so little of yourself and are so selfishly desperate for another child that you are clinging onto a misguided belief that what you are doing is virtuous and for your child, but you are no different to the supposed women you believe are choosing sex over their children, you are choosing what YOU want, and bringing another child into an unstable and unhappy relationship is NEVER a morally good thing. Just be honest here.

hoven · 25/06/2023 14:28

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/06/2023 13:12

Quitting and making massive changes for your child just because you want to get laid is not the best option

This is actually insulting. A vanishingly small number of women leave a marriage because they “want to get laid”. Some men do, I grant you. The majority of the time when women leave marriages it is due to abuse, neglect or general suboptimal behaviour.

OP you seem to be trying to bolster your position and rise above your own palpable uncertainty with this thread and you are totally unwilling to listen to reasonable responses to the question you posed.

It’s totally understandable that you are anxious and apprehensive about something which would cause such upheaval and to be cautious about it.

What is unreasonable is rejecting all alternative suggestions out of hand and saying that “wanting to get laid” is the motivation for marriage breakdowns.

Yes apart from abuse, it is often to find a sexual relationship hence the excuse of "no passion"

OP posts:
hoven · 25/06/2023 14:27

AcrossthePond55 · 25/06/2023 13:57

@hoven

Do you really think that most people leave unhappy marriages because they 'want to get laid'? Seriously? I don't know a single woman who left because she wanted to 'get laid'. And tbf, the men I know who left, even for OW, were still 'getting laid' at home. Yes, there are people who leave because their spouse decides they don't want to have sex anymore, but those are few and far between. And even then they really aren't leaving to 'get laid', they are leaving to find love.

People leave because they are miserable. Not 'unhappy', miserable. There is nothing admirable in staying in a dead marriage. And definitely nothing admirable in staying in order to use a man you don't love as a sperm donor.

Having a sibling is no guarantee of someone to 'share the load'. My DH's brother never lifted a finger to help with their mother, DH did it all and as a result they no longer speak. My cousin's brother also didn't lift a finger to help but was happy to stick both hands in their mother's bank account before she died. They also no longer speak.

If you want to justify yourself to yourself, feel free. But don't use other people's decisions to seek happiness for themselves AND their children to do so.

Yes I do. Relationships are not perfect and can't actually make a person happy. Many people are miserable generally but project it onto their marriage. There would be less divorce if people assessed their lives holistically for happiness rather than relying on a marriage to make them happy.

Do they have hobbies, friends, are they fit and healthy with a flat belly, in a job they enjoy? If not they have bigger fish to fry rather than breaking up their families.

And yes a lot of people women included do divorce to find a sexual relationship. In effect putting their desires for sex above their children

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 25/06/2023 13:57

@hoven

Do you really think that most people leave unhappy marriages because they 'want to get laid'? Seriously? I don't know a single woman who left because she wanted to 'get laid'. And tbf, the men I know who left, even for OW, were still 'getting laid' at home. Yes, there are people who leave because their spouse decides they don't want to have sex anymore, but those are few and far between. And even then they really aren't leaving to 'get laid', they are leaving to find love.

People leave because they are miserable. Not 'unhappy', miserable. There is nothing admirable in staying in a dead marriage. And definitely nothing admirable in staying in order to use a man you don't love as a sperm donor.

Having a sibling is no guarantee of someone to 'share the load'. My DH's brother never lifted a finger to help with their mother, DH did it all and as a result they no longer speak. My cousin's brother also didn't lift a finger to help but was happy to stick both hands in their mother's bank account before she died. They also no longer speak.

If you want to justify yourself to yourself, feel free. But don't use other people's decisions to seek happiness for themselves AND their children to do so.

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/06/2023 13:12

Quitting and making massive changes for your child just because you want to get laid is not the best option

This is actually insulting. A vanishingly small number of women leave a marriage because they “want to get laid”. Some men do, I grant you. The majority of the time when women leave marriages it is due to abuse, neglect or general suboptimal behaviour.

OP you seem to be trying to bolster your position and rise above your own palpable uncertainty with this thread and you are totally unwilling to listen to reasonable responses to the question you posed.

It’s totally understandable that you are anxious and apprehensive about something which would cause such upheaval and to be cautious about it.

What is unreasonable is rejecting all alternative suggestions out of hand and saying that “wanting to get laid” is the motivation for marriage breakdowns.

nothingcomestonothing · 25/06/2023 10:00

hoven · 25/06/2023 07:05

Sometimes your children may see you stressed from work, does that mean you are teaching your child to not prioritise their health over work? Work is always going to be stressful but you still have to do it.

Same thing with relationships and marriage, they're not always easy but sometimes you need to do the right thing and commit to the choice you made. Quitting and making massive changes for your child just because you want to get laid is not the best option

Keep telling yourself you're doing it for your child OP, if it makes you feel better. But even by the little you've written it's clear this isn't about what's best for your child it's about you wanting another child, and looking down on women who have children with different fathers. So you're willing to use your DH as a sperm donor even though you don't want to be with him. Not sure that's the moral high ground you seem to think it is.

Your distain for others who've made other choices, and generously shared their experiences to try to help you, says a lot about you.

DaphneBlake101 · 25/06/2023 09:31

I think it's important to remember that a lot of the time, parents are not the sole example of a committed romantic relationship that children have. My parents divorced, I didn't see my father regularly, my mum had a few boyfriends when I was a child. She taught me that I should never settle and I apply that in every area of my life. My grandparents taught me a lot about being in a long term committed relationship and how that can involve compromise. Those are not mutually exclusive lessons.