Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Loveless marriage VS commitment to family

210 replies

hoven · 24/06/2023 11:21

AIBU to suggest that committing to stay in a marriage for your children is more important to show your children than showing them an 'example of a happy relationship'?

In marriages without abuse or toxicity of course

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FarmGirl78 · 25/06/2023 19:35

hoven · 25/06/2023 19:24

What can't you understand? I'm explaining why your ideas are reductionist ie dull relationship = sad life.

The overwhelming majority here are talking about loveless marriages, not specifically dull ones. A very large chunk (mainly ones who made the decision themselves rather than having it made for them) are saying that greater happiness came after separating. The consensus of opinion is that staying in a loveless marriage DOES NOT set a good example to your children, in fact quite the opposite. And that was the crux of your thread, wasn't it?

hoven · 25/06/2023 19:24

jfshu · 25/06/2023 18:55

@hoven WTF are you on about now?

What can't you understand? I'm explaining why your ideas are reductionist ie dull relationship = sad life.

OP posts:
FarmGirl78 · 25/06/2023 19:16

jfshu · 25/06/2023 18:55

@hoven WTF are you on about now?

Its just yet another switcheroo when she feels her point is losing ground. I call troll.

jfshu · 25/06/2023 18:55

@hoven WTF are you on about now?

hoven · 25/06/2023 18:53

How do those who disagree explain clinical depression in those with great marriages?

OP posts:
hoven · 25/06/2023 18:49

@FarmGirl78 happiness does not depend on your relationship. Many people are in great relationships but are clinically depressed. It's also possible to be in a dull relationship but happy overall due to other factors

OP posts:
FarmGirl78 · 25/06/2023 18:43

hoven · 25/06/2023 16:59

Exactly my point. Them divorcing could have changed the whole trajectory of you life by you not being able to go uni, potentially living in poverty and with your dc also unable to go and even achieving home ownership. Not to mention extra curricular activities and cultural capital they will be missing out on. That's a lot for your children to give up in exchange for giving up a dull but not toxic relationship to try to gain passion and sex

I'm not on about my children. I'm on about ME. I would rather have had 2 parents in separate 2/3 bedroom houses, and missed out on Uni, rather than the exec 4 bedroomed detached they had. I might have ended up with bigger student debt as my parents couldn't reach have contributed enough, I might have ended up living in a smaller house myself as an adult BUT SEEN AT LEAST ONE OF MY PARENTS HAPPY. I'm a product of exactly what scenario you're talking about, and I'm deeply unhappy my parents didn't separate.

OP, you're being so obtuse, argumentative and deliberately blinkered I really do hope your husband takes the decision out of your hands. Using him as a sperm donor for your own selfish wants is completely despicable.

So go ahead, put your own spin on this post and twist my words to suit your own narrative like you're doing with everyone who's disagreeing with you with very valid examples from their own lives.

jfshu · 25/06/2023 18:29

His values mean he is committed to his family above everything

Time will tell, but you sound very vulnerable and not very committed to improving the situation, one way or another.

Loopylalalou · 25/06/2023 18:26

ArcticSkewer · 24/06/2023 13:07

I'm more conceptually into the idea of cycles of life, so a partner for a stage of life not a life partner. Of course, that partner can also suit different cycles of life, but if they don't then that's fine too.

So that's what I would want to model.

I do see childrearing as a stage but not through to adulthood, just the younger stages. And if things don't work out, so be it

I agree. By loveless do you mean a lack of sex? There’s more ways to show commitment than a hump once a week. Being part of a team is more important to me at this busy stage in our lives, after nearly 31 years of marriage. It’s supporting each other and communicating and having common aims, and especially caring for your children.

Justfeckoffwiththeovulating · 25/06/2023 18:04

@rolvus I'm very lucky to have some equity in my property so my mortgage payments are lower but the reality is that we might still need to sell the 'family home'. That doesn't bother me that much, it's just a house. I don't meet affordability on my own.
We live frugally and I work full time. Get some UC but not equivalent to a full time other persons wage. I just find joy in the small things.
With my ex we could have gone to Disneyland and been miserable. So once you've lived through that you know that happiness can't be bought. Yes it's shit being skint at times but I know now that life is better when you're happy. If you're happy you can have 2p in your current account and still know that it's worth it.

When we split I promised that I would give my children one hour of play every day. I stick to that and I think they appreciate it more than stuff. We talk about when we used to eat out, or when we went to a theme park. They still do that stuff with their dad. They never say that they wish I'd stuck with their dad in order to go to centre parcs each year or have new clothes!

hoven · 25/06/2023 17:56

jfshu · 25/06/2023 17:54

@hoven you keep avoiding the question but I am really intrigued as to why you're so confident this is your decision alone, and that your DH will tolerate an unhappy marriage as long as you will?

His values mean he is committed to his family above everything

OP posts:
jfshu · 25/06/2023 17:54

@hoven you keep avoiding the question but I am really intrigued as to why you're so confident this is your decision alone, and that your DH will tolerate an unhappy marriage as long as you will?

rolvus · 25/06/2023 17:51

Justfeckoffwiththeovulating · 25/06/2023 17:42

@hoven why are you so determined to think that life as a single parent will be so awful for children. My children have infinitely better lives than when their father and I were together.
For example today they are going to a family bbq with their dad. Unlike when we were together, he would see it as a party and down four beers, (as I would be there to be the sensible one) he now has to be responsible for them and is a better father because of it. I've been to lunch with my family and got housework done. Now they will have a less stressed out, more present mum at home as I'm up together with stuff and have had time for myself. Later when I pick them up I will stay in my in laws for a bit and have a chat. They see their parents actually interact with eachother in a natural, friendly way, rather than make digs or passive aggressive comments all the time.
As for 'grow up in poverty' well I did with a single mum and it was bloody lovely. Much better than my other friends with 'moody' dads or grumpy stepdads to tiptoe around. Better than seeing domestic abuse or worse. One of my friends remembers crying each night as she knew her dad was going to come home and quiz her mum on where she had been that day and what she'd been up to. My kids have none of that worry. I am theirs and no one else, full time, and we have such a laugh. Eating pizza in bed, kitchen discos, days out, playing mario kart, walking to the woods in the summer evenings. My life is better than anything I could have ever imagined, can't imagine many in shit marriages could say that.

How do you afford it in the current climate? Are housing costs low where you live? I'd like to do as you describe, but can't afford to.

hoven · 25/06/2023 17:51

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4240051/

Most posters are claiming their divorce was a success. The above study details the significant risks occurring after divorce including higher rates of teenage pregnancy, lack of upward financial mobility and decreased social and emotional maturity

OP posts:
Justfeckoffwiththeovulating · 25/06/2023 17:48

@hoven yes. They said they don't like daddy and mummy arguing. They are much happier and doing better in school.

hoven · 25/06/2023 17:45

Justfeckoffwiththeovulating · 25/06/2023 17:42

@hoven why are you so determined to think that life as a single parent will be so awful for children. My children have infinitely better lives than when their father and I were together.
For example today they are going to a family bbq with their dad. Unlike when we were together, he would see it as a party and down four beers, (as I would be there to be the sensible one) he now has to be responsible for them and is a better father because of it. I've been to lunch with my family and got housework done. Now they will have a less stressed out, more present mum at home as I'm up together with stuff and have had time for myself. Later when I pick them up I will stay in my in laws for a bit and have a chat. They see their parents actually interact with eachother in a natural, friendly way, rather than make digs or passive aggressive comments all the time.
As for 'grow up in poverty' well I did with a single mum and it was bloody lovely. Much better than my other friends with 'moody' dads or grumpy stepdads to tiptoe around. Better than seeing domestic abuse or worse. One of my friends remembers crying each night as she knew her dad was going to come home and quiz her mum on where she had been that day and what she'd been up to. My kids have none of that worry. I am theirs and no one else, full time, and we have such a laugh. Eating pizza in bed, kitchen discos, days out, playing mario kart, walking to the woods in the summer evenings. My life is better than anything I could have ever imagined, can't imagine many in shit marriages could say that.

Have you asked them?

OP posts:
Justfeckoffwiththeovulating · 25/06/2023 17:42

@hoven why are you so determined to think that life as a single parent will be so awful for children. My children have infinitely better lives than when their father and I were together.
For example today they are going to a family bbq with their dad. Unlike when we were together, he would see it as a party and down four beers, (as I would be there to be the sensible one) he now has to be responsible for them and is a better father because of it. I've been to lunch with my family and got housework done. Now they will have a less stressed out, more present mum at home as I'm up together with stuff and have had time for myself. Later when I pick them up I will stay in my in laws for a bit and have a chat. They see their parents actually interact with eachother in a natural, friendly way, rather than make digs or passive aggressive comments all the time.
As for 'grow up in poverty' well I did with a single mum and it was bloody lovely. Much better than my other friends with 'moody' dads or grumpy stepdads to tiptoe around. Better than seeing domestic abuse or worse. One of my friends remembers crying each night as she knew her dad was going to come home and quiz her mum on where she had been that day and what she'd been up to. My kids have none of that worry. I am theirs and no one else, full time, and we have such a laugh. Eating pizza in bed, kitchen discos, days out, playing mario kart, walking to the woods in the summer evenings. My life is better than anything I could have ever imagined, can't imagine many in shit marriages could say that.

Mstxxx · 25/06/2023 17:16

hoven · 25/06/2023 17:01

We're there any financial implications or negatives effects on you living with a man you didn't get on with?

Financial wise - no. They divorced amicably so it was fair/even and my 'standard/quality of living' remained in the same in the immediate aftermath in terms of type of home, school etc. If anything, as I got older my mum and her husband were better off so my standard of living went up in terms of living in a better area, better opportunities, better holidays etc. My dad actually ended up moving abroad (which he would not have done if he stayed with my mum as she didn't want to do this) so it was nice to have a second home overseas to visit. My dad remarried as well later on to a nice lady.

It's harder to say for certain whether me not always getting on with him had any negative effects - it was mostly things like disagreeing as a teenager about typical teenager things. If my mum and dad had of stayed together, I presume my dad would have lectured me about those things if he was there to witness it instead of my mums husband so the outcome would be the same regardless of who it came from, if this makes sense. I probably would have argued a lot more with my dad if he was there as much as my mums husband, but it's just because my mums husband was in the line of fire at the time that I say that now.

I think the only one thing I did notice was that when my mum and dad were together, I rarely spoke. I would hide in my bedroom with books because the atmosphere was just so off it was almost unbearable. Once they were divorced it was like a weight lifted and I could have a better relationship and speak to each of them properly when they were seperated, as I no longer had the lingering feeling something was wrong.

Womencanlift · 25/06/2023 17:15

hoven · 25/06/2023 15:42

Their childhood won't be miserable due to my lack of sex

That is not what I said and you know it.

Either your reading comprehension is terrible, and not just from this post you have replied to but many others too, or you are here for a wind up.

hoven · 25/06/2023 17:01

Mstxxx · 25/06/2023 16:57

Just my personal experience but my mum and dad tried staying in a unromantic marriage for the sake of their kids when I was younger. No abuse or anything like that - they just weren't into each other romantically anymore and didn't really talk to each other unless necessary.

I was only around 5 at the time and I don't even know how I knew, because they never shouted at each other or argued. It was more like the air in the house was thick with tension, they didn't sleep in the same room or hug or kiss or laugh together and even at 5 years old that made me feel uncomfortable. They both just seemed lifeless and like robots going through the motions and I could sense it. My dad would go out to work all night and when he was gone my mum seemed happier and less tense, so I would wish he didn't come back. Not because of anything he did - just because the tension and weird non-lovey dovey vibe made me feel like I was on eggshells all the time.

When they announced they were finally getting divorced, I was only about 6 or 7 and honestly I just thought thank god. My mum got remarried to someone she actually has a romantic connection with, and even though me and her new husband didn't really get along all of the time - I can see my mum is happy (even as a child) and would prefer that 10x over than her and my dad together.

Again, no abuse or shouting or actual major issues. It's just hard to explain the vibe that it has and obviously I presume my mum and dad were unaware of the atmosphere it caused.

We're there any financial implications or negatives effects on you living with a man you didn't get on with?

OP posts:
hoven · 25/06/2023 16:59

FarmGirl78 · 25/06/2023 16:45

I'm 45 and my parents stayed together for us. There was no violence, arguements (not moreso than usual anyway),no abuse, shouting, nothing amiss. But I just knew they didn't love each other. I didn't see examples of love and happiness between a couple growing up, and that's caused some major issues for me. They're in their 70s now, and have strangely grown closer, but I so so wish they'd have separated and got divorced when I was a child. We'd have had less money, maybe not been able to afford to go to Uni, we'd have missed extended family occasions every now and again, but each of them would have had a chance at finding real happiness with someone else. It makes me so sad, I just think "What a waste of two lives".

Exactly my point. Them divorcing could have changed the whole trajectory of you life by you not being able to go uni, potentially living in poverty and with your dc also unable to go and even achieving home ownership. Not to mention extra curricular activities and cultural capital they will be missing out on. That's a lot for your children to give up in exchange for giving up a dull but not toxic relationship to try to gain passion and sex

OP posts:
Mstxxx · 25/06/2023 16:57

Just my personal experience but my mum and dad tried staying in a unromantic marriage for the sake of their kids when I was younger. No abuse or anything like that - they just weren't into each other romantically anymore and didn't really talk to each other unless necessary.

I was only around 5 at the time and I don't even know how I knew, because they never shouted at each other or argued. It was more like the air in the house was thick with tension, they didn't sleep in the same room or hug or kiss or laugh together and even at 5 years old that made me feel uncomfortable. They both just seemed lifeless and like robots going through the motions and I could sense it. My dad would go out to work all night and when he was gone my mum seemed happier and less tense, so I would wish he didn't come back. Not because of anything he did - just because the tension and weird non-lovey dovey vibe made me feel like I was on eggshells all the time.

When they announced they were finally getting divorced, I was only about 6 or 7 and honestly I just thought thank god. My mum got remarried to someone she actually has a romantic connection with, and even though me and her new husband didn't really get along all of the time - I can see my mum is happy (even as a child) and would prefer that 10x over than her and my dad together.

Again, no abuse or shouting or actual major issues. It's just hard to explain the vibe that it has and obviously I presume my mum and dad were unaware of the atmosphere it caused.

FarmGirl78 · 25/06/2023 16:56

hoven · 24/06/2023 13:02

Do you think it would have been the same happiness if you were a child?

For me, yes. It would have been difficult with less money etc, but seeing either of my parents happy would have been so lovely.

My Dad had a female work colleague he got on very well with, and on weekends or in school holidays if my Mum was working she'd come for days out with us (no issue, my Mum knew all about these times) and my Dad was just a different person around her. He was just......happy. I remember being about 10-11ish and just really wishing more than anything they would have an affair so he could be happy.

FarmGirl78 · 25/06/2023 16:47

hoven · 24/06/2023 12:51

So do you think divorce = happy?

I think it definitely means happier.

FarmGirl78 · 25/06/2023 16:45

I'm 45 and my parents stayed together for us. There was no violence, arguements (not moreso than usual anyway),no abuse, shouting, nothing amiss. But I just knew they didn't love each other. I didn't see examples of love and happiness between a couple growing up, and that's caused some major issues for me. They're in their 70s now, and have strangely grown closer, but I so so wish they'd have separated and got divorced when I was a child. We'd have had less money, maybe not been able to afford to go to Uni, we'd have missed extended family occasions every now and again, but each of them would have had a chance at finding real happiness with someone else. It makes me so sad, I just think "What a waste of two lives".